A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Friday, June 3, 2022

JUDGING PAROCHIAL FEDERALISM, XIX

 

An advocate of parochial federalism continues his/her presentation[1] …

Demographic Teacher Information (cont.)

          Given the raw demographic information which offered data that pointed to high levels of dissatisfaction among teachers and were shared in the last posting, the implication is that social studies teachers and teachers in general, would be amenable to reasonable curricular change.  That change could emphasize duty and responsibility as well as individual rights.

          Duty and responsibility can be extended to issues of school performance and  whether students are citizens of their school communities.  If so, what are their duties and responsibilities as they use up the resources assigned to the schools?  Surely included in any such determinations would be for students to apply themselves seriously to their academic lessons.

          Such a change would be entailed with the adoption of the parochial / traditional federalist construct and would emphasize, along with duty and responsibility, an outlook that would bolster a communal orientation.  This orientation is exactly what seems to be needed given the general concerns the data seems to be indicating and not limited to cheering for the school colors at a football game (usually an expression of one’s ego), but as an extension of identity as a member of a community.

In terms of a construct to address these concerns, it would need to have a moral component, as the parochial federalist construct would include.  One aspect of such curricular content would be what is currently called character education.  Marilyn Price-Mitchell writes,

While teachers are hired to develop children’s skills and abilities in academics like reading, writing, history, geography, and math, there is a lot more going on in the classroom than meets the eye.

Opportunities abound for students to develop hope, fairness, humor, valor, appreciation, and many other personal strengths that lead to fulfilling lives. For many teachers, this is a natural extension of the job they do on behalf of children.

Building character strengths is the mutual responsibility of families, schools, and communities.[2]

 

This concern for federalist/communal messaging is not new.  Back in 1991, James S. Leming stated that in a Gallop poll, the “development of character” ranked highly with fifty percent support rating among teachers as a useful goal in education.[3]  The teachers also indicated that students should be thinking critically and constructively about society.  And these teachers pre-dated more recent calls for students to think critically and constructively about their communities and the broader nation.[4]

Of course, the application of Socratic dialogue techniques has been promoted regarding traditional American republican values, as called for in the described methodology that social studies literature recurrently prescribe.  It calls for students to think critically and constructively about timeless issues that face the maintenance of the nation’s republic.[5] 

In addition, teachers in a recent study had a distinct orientation toward citizenship transmission.  That is, the transmission of the nation’s founding values – such as republican values and civic virtue – seems a most appropriate goal for the application of this orientation.  Asiye Toker Gokce found in a survey of young student teachers,

According to the results, the participants indicated that students should acquire 20 values at schools. These values are listed as virtue, respectfulness, affection, conformity, sympathy, patriotism, humanism, equality, justice, tolerance, responsibility, democracy, modernism, devotion, diligence, freedom, discipline, entrepreneurship, friendship, and cooperation.[6]

 

One can generally find such values, to varying degrees, as supportive of parochial federalist orientation toward citizenship.  Again, citing the Leming article from above, the transmission of those nation’s founding values is seen as relevant and vibrant in promoting the partnership federalism represents.  But are actual teachers sufficiently so disposed?  The next posting will address this question.



[1] This presentation begins with the posting, “A Parochial Subject Matter” (March 11, 2022).  The reader is reminded that the claims made in this posting do not necessarily reflect the beliefs or knowledge of this blogger.  Instead, the posting is a representation of what an advocate of parochial federalism might present.  This is done to present a dialectic position of that construct.

[2] Marilyn Price-Mitchell, “Character Education:  What Good Teachers Do Best,” Roots of Action (n.d.), accessed June 1, 2022, https://www.rootsofaction.com/character-education/ .

[3] James S. Leming, “Teacher Characteristics and Social Studies Education,” in Handbook of Research on Social Studies Teaching and Learning, ed. James P. Shaver (New York, NY: MacMillan Publishing Company, 1991), 222-236.

[4] For recent such references, see National Council for the Social Studies, Preparing Students for College, Career, and Civic Life, C3.  Of particular relevance, this document promotes what it calls an “inquiry arc.”

[5] Ibid., for example.

[6] Asiye Toker Gokce, “Core Values in Education from the Perspective of Future Educators,” cited through Sage Journals, May 8, 2021, accessed June 1, 2022, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/21582440211014485 .

Tuesday, May 31, 2022

JUDGING PAROCHIAL FEDERALISM, XVIII

 

An advocate of parochial federalism continues his/her presentation[1] …

Teachers

With the parochial/traditional federalism’s account of the school – as a commonplace of curriculum development – completed, this blog will now address another commonplace, the teacher.[2]  Factors concerning teachers as they relate to the proposed curricular change that this presentation offers will be addressed in this posting and, at least, the next.  Specifically, these postings will provide answers for the following questions:

 

·      What relevant demographic information about teachers will affect the implementation of a parochial federalist construct? 

·      How do teachers associate with the broader citizenry that would, in turn, affect that implementation?

 

This posting focuses on the basic demographic data the literature reveals.

Teachers play a vital role in social studies classrooms.  Back in 1991, Stephen J. Thornton describes this role as one of gatekeeper:  “As gatekeepers, teachers make the day-to-day decisions concerning both the subject matter and those experiences to which students have access and the nature of that subject matter and those experiences.”[3] 

This notion is vibrantly supported by a more recent position paper by the National Council of the Social Studies:  “They [teachers] encourage students to be thoughtful, critical, and deliberate when examining issues both past and present.  Teachers want students to participate actively in a vibrant democracy.”[4]  With this context, it would be crucial for the implementation of any curricular change to have a willing teacher corps to carry out the prescribed elements of that change.

Demographic Teacher Information

          Of the roughly one and half million social studies teachers currently manning America’s schools, the following demographic information has been extracted:

 

·      48.4% of all Social Studies Teachers are women, while 51.6% are men.

·      The average age of an employed Social Studies Teacher is 42 years old.

·      The most common ethnicity of Social Studies Teachers is White (76.5%), followed by Hispanic or Latino (10.5%) and Black or African American (7.5%).

·      The majority of Social Studies Teachers are [sic] located in NY [as in New York state], New York [as in the city] and IL, Chicago.

·      Social Studies Teachers are paid an average annual salary of $49,265.

·      Social Studies Teachers average starting salary is $36,000.

·      In 2021, women earned 96% of what men earned. [These percentages are assumed to be among social studies teachers.]

·      The top 10% of highest-paid Social Studies Teachers earn as much as $65,000 or more.

·      11% of all Social Studies Teachers are LGBT.

·      Social Studies Teachers are more likely to work at Education companies in comparison to Private companies.[5]

 

Of interest here is the age-related information. 

It reflects a favorable state in that this more mature corps – which represents the average ages within the American workforce – offers advantages for two reasons.  One, these teachers are more cognizant of a time when the society was less entrenched in a natural rights culture (a culture that has gained vibrancy since its establishment as dominant in the years after World War II), and two, older teachers would be more dissatisfied with current school conditions because of their more extended exposure to those conditions – the “enough is enough” syndrome.

Evidence is that teachers have long been less and less satisfied with their work.  Of course, the pandemic has exasperated this trend.  But even before COVID, the teacher corps was finding it more and more difficult to find the job fulfilling.[6]  And what specific complaints do teachers have?  A recent study concluded:

 

Results indicate that a lack of resources, overcrowded classes and lack of discipline among learners were serious sources of dissatisfaction among teachers. Administrative issues, lack of recognition by principals and parents for good work done also caused dissatisfaction among teachers in this study. It was also indicative that job dissatisfaction caused disengagement of some teachers with a consequent lack of focus on professional activities and being negative in their job. The study concludes that teacher satisfaction is germane for the sustainability of social transformation.[7]

 

The general impression derived from the data is that teachers, including social studies teachers, are highly dissatisfied with the general malaise affecting education that has been commented on in this blog from time to time. 

And with that tale of woe, this posting ends.  The next one will look at the implications these complaints would have on teachers being asked to change their curricular approach to a parochial federalism-based one in the teaching of civics.



[1] This presentation begins with the posting, “A Parochial Subject Matter” (March 11, 2022).  The reader is reminded that the claims made in this posting do not necessarily reflect the beliefs or knowledge of this blogger.  Instead, the posting is a representation of what an advocate of parochial federalism might present.  This is done to present a dialectic position of that construct.

[2] William H. Schubert, Curriculum:  Perspective, Paradigm, and Possibility (New York, NY:  MacMillan Publishing Company, 1986).  The meaning of this term has been shared in previous postings and refers to the political interests of students that curriculum developers should consider in their plans.

[3] Stephen J. Thornton, “Teacher as Curricular-Instructional Gatekeeper in Social Studies, in Handbook of Research on Social Studies Teaching and Learning, edited by James P. Shaver (New York, NY:  MacMillan Publishing Company, 1991), 237-248, 237.

[5] “Social Studies Teacher Demographics and Statistics in the US,” Zippia:  The Career Experts (n.d., reports information from 2019), accessed May 29, 2022, https://www.zippia.com/social-studies-teacher-jobs/demographics/ .

[6] Madeline Will, “Teacher Job Satisfaction Hits an All-Time Low,” Education Week (April 14, 2022), accessed May 29, 2022, https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/teacher-job-satisfaction-hits-an-all-time-low/2022/04 .

[7] Chinedu Okeke and Pamela Mtyuda, “Teacher Job Dissatisfaction:  Implications for Teacher Sustainability and Social Transformation,’ Journal of Teacher Education and Sustainability, 19, 1 (January 2017), accessed May 29, 2022, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/318168100_Teacher_Job_Dissatisfaction_Implications_for_Teacher_Sustainability_and_Social_Transformation

Friday, May 27, 2022

JUDGING PAROCHIAL FEDERALISM, XVII

 

Before starting this posting, a word regarding Uvalde is offered.  Profound sorrow is felt over this senseless event.

An advocate of parochial federalism continues his/her presentation[1] …

Student Pedagogical Interests [2]

          This posting will complete this blog’s review of the parochial/federalist view regarding the first curricular commonplace, the student, by focusing on students’ pedagogical interests.  Curricular decisions must be made with a realistic approach concerning the learning conditions and contexts which characterize American classrooms and therefore affect students.  This dialectic argument advocates changes in curriculum toward federalist ideals and such moves make certain assumptions about the nature of learners relevant to those changes.

That would include changes in the educational substance and processes that are associated with any resulting prescriptions.  In large measure, those conditions take on the form of assumptions and are related to the abilities and aptitudes of American adolescents in their study of historical material, since the parochial federalist construct calls for a high degree of analysis of historical information. 

That is, information contained in accounts that transpired in earlier days and over the documents associated with those events would be the material students would be called upon to study.        This posting addresses those assumptions and questions about whether the proposed change is viable in today’s classrooms. 

Specifically, this posting will look at two issues – posed as questions:

 

·      Are students in the middle and high school years sufficiently sophisticated to analyze the historical material?

·      Are these students cognitively matured enough to deal with the issues and perform the skills necessary to meaningfully benefit from a study of the issues associated with parochial/traditional federalism?

 

Given the current condition in society, i.e., the prevalence of the natural rights perspective, many of the descriptions which will emanate from the parochial federalist approach might seem to students to be bizarre or counter-intuitive to what they have come to expect.  In many ways, federalist inspired content would take on a different language and point to unexpected concerns.

          Some time ago, John B. Poster shared some insightful descriptors about how young people view history.  He delineates several notions of time when studying a cultural contextual subject:  that would be social time, literary time, personal time, physical (clock) time, and historical time.  Historical time “[requires a] sense of existing in the past as well as the present, a feeling of being in history rather than standing apart from it.”[3] 

This interaction might and does get thwarted by cultural biases, as those in Western societies with their market orientation of current consumptive-centered views.  Under such a prevailing, general view, commentators are prone to become practical in the study of history (or any other subject). 

When one comes to history and being practical, one often cites the following reasons for such study:  understanding the world, becoming a more rounded person, understanding one’s identity, becoming inspired, learning from mistakes, and developing transferable skills (such as analyzing social information).[4]  In each of these, the interests of the learner, exclusively, seems to be the motivation for such concerns.

Yet history, while assisting with these sorts of aims, can more fundamentally tempt or challenge its readers and students to question their basic views of life, their existence, and their modes of living in their most basic sense.  And these other concerns expand from the individual to more socially motivated interests.  When tied with the transformational time of life – adolescence – a realistic, substantive, and even introspective approach to this study can be of great benefit to those young people and the general society.

This makes the challenges of teaching history or historical material more difficult, but not impossible.  Several studies (Bradley Commission on History in School,[5] William J. Friedman,[6] and E. C. Oakden and Mary Sturt[7]) establish the recognition of the ability of eight- and nine-year-old youngsters to cognitively figure estimates of the amount of time that has transpired since events have taken place, to separate events in chronological order, and to connect dates with specific individuals and events.

More recently, these topics are beginning to be seen as having a placating role over contentious issues even for younger students.  Here is a more recent view expressing a concern over the state of social attention that American schools are affording to younger students.

 

There’s long been concern about American students’ lack of history and civics knowledge.  On national tests, 85% of eighth graders score below proficient in U.S. history, as do about 75% in geography and civics.  Now there’s also handwringing about whether it’s possible to teach these subjects in an even-handed way.  But a more basic problem is that many students reach middle and high school without enough background knowledge to grasp much history at all, let alone understand it in all its complexity – especially if they haven’t been able to pick up historical knowledge at home.  In the current polarized climate, that leaves them vulnerable to oversimplified versions of the country’s past.[8]

 

This cited article further calls for more meaningful questioning, even at lower grades, so that teachers can direct study more meaningfully to reveal consequential issues (an example in the article cites the Boston Tea Party and suggests questions about how colonists should have reacted to this illegal incident).

          Not only does Natalie Wexler, the author of the above quote, believe elementary students should tackle such questions, but that a more probing history is recommended for a kindergarten curriculum.  Of course, reasonableness should guide what is doable for such young students.  But the point here is that if higher geared, more revealing questioning can be utilized with these younger students, then those types of questions are quite suitable for adolescents in secondary schools.

          Jean Piaget, back in the 1960s, argued that children can make a wide range of logical relationships including causal and temporal relations at an early age.  And the literature supporting this claim is quite extensive.[9]  With these skills, students of the middle and high school years can facilitate the acquisition of historical knowledge with the use of narratives or scripts (story lines).[10]  Narratives allow people to interrelate with historical events and events from one’s own life and they also allow a holistic sense of the time studied.

          But isn’t the concern here not history but civics?  The parochial/traditional federalist construct favors – not to the exclusion of other forms of research – historical inquiry in the study of federalist issues.  In turn, in building those narratives or checking their veracity, documentary evidence becomes important.  There is evidence – cited here – that a course of study that primarily depends on that type of evidence is viable.

With nine- and ten-year-old students, despite being less knowledgeable of dates and comprehensive information, they acquired, with appropriate historical lessons, clearer views of studied periods – of their people – and a more meaningful understanding of the problems faced by those people.

 

Historical contributions to civics education can be as simple as providing narratives and sources that demonstrate people in the past had an impact on the world in which they lived. The past is filled with people who are not given the agency in traditional textbooks that they possessed in life. [11]

 

And for a more substantive instructional strategy, the reader is encouraged to see this blogger’s book, Toward a Federated Nation, where his “historical dialogue-to-action” (HD-to-A) instructional model is described and explained.[12] 

Overall, there is ample evidence to suggest that students at the middle and high school levels are cognitively capable (actually, better suited) to pursue a study of American government or civics using history and utilizing the parochial federalist construct to guide such study.  With the above cited evidence, the conclusion can be drawn that students at the secondary level are sophisticated enough to analyze the historical material used in conjunction with that construct. 

That is, they are cognitively mature enough to analyze and reflect on the issues which federalism holds as important.  And with that, the reader is set to review the next commonplace, the teacher.



[1] This presentation begins with the posting, “A Parochial Subject Matter” (March 11, 2022).  The reader is reminded that the claims made in this posting do not necessarily reflect the beliefs or knowledge of this blogger.  Instead, the posting is a representation of what an advocate of parochial federalism might present.  This is done to present a dialectic position of that construct.

[2] William H. Schubert, Curriculum:  Perspective, Paradigm, and Possibility (New York, NY:  MacMillan Publishing Company, 1986).  The meaning of this term has been shared in previous postings and refers to the political interests of students that curriculum developers should consider in their plans.

[3] John B. Poster, “The Birth of the Past:  Children’s Perception of Historical Time,” The Historical Teacher, 6, 4 (August 1973), 587-598, 589.

[4] For example, Nord Anglia, “Why Is It Important to Study History?,” Nord Anglia (April, 29, 2020), accessed May 25, 2022, https://www.nordangliaeducation.com/news/2020/04/29/why-is-it-important-to-study-history .

[5] “Resolution of the Commission Steps toward Excellence in the School History Curriculum,” Bradley Commission on History in Schools (Westlake, OH:  Author, 1988).

[6] William J. Friedman, “Development of Time Concepts in Children,” in Advances in Child Development and Behavior, editors Hayne Reese and Lewis Lipsitt, 12 (New York, NY:  Academic Press, 1978), 267-298.

[7] E. C. Oakden and Mary Sturt, “The Development of Knowledge of Time in Children,” British Journal of Psychology, 12 (1922), 309-336.

[8] Natalie Wexler, “Why We Need to Start Teaching History in Kindergarten,” Forbes (July 5, 2021), accessed May 25, 2022, https://www.forbes.com/sites/nataliewexler/2021/07/05/why-we-need-to-start-teaching-history-in-kindergarten/?sh=63078e1b1e8f .

[9] Along with Wexler, examples include Robin Fivush and Elizabeth Slackman, “The Acquistion and Development of Scripts,” in Event Knowledge:  Structure and Function in Development, edited by K. Nelson (Hillsdale, NJ:  Lawrence Erlbaum, 1986), 71-96 AND Friedman, “Development of Time Concepts in Children,” in Advances in Child Development and Behavior AND L. Harner, “Talking about the Past and Future,” in The Development of Time, edited by William J. Friedman (New York, NY:  Academic Press, 1982), 141-169 AND Roy N. Smith and Peter Tomilson, “The Development of Children’s Construction of Historical Duration:  A New Approach and Some Findings,” Educational Research, 19 (1977), 163-170.

[10] Here one finds another extensive literature.  See, for example, Charles L. Newhall, “Witnessing Historical Thinking:  Teaching Students to Construct Historical Narratives, Common Place, 12, 3 (April 2012), accessed May 25, 2022, http://commonplace.online/article/witnessing-historical-thinking/ .

[11] “Civics Education,” The Inclusive Historian’s Handbook (January 15, 2021), accessed May 25, 2022, https://inclusivehistorian.com/civics-education/#:~:text=Historical%20contributions%20to%20civics%20education,that%20they%20possessed%20in%20life. AND to feature how long this insight has been recognized, see David W. Blake, “Observing Children Learning History,” The History Teacher, 14 (1981), 533-549.

[12] Robert Gutierrez, Toward a Federated Nation:  Implementing National Civics Standards (Tallahassee, FL:  Gravitas/Civics Books, 2020).  Available through Amazon.

 

Tuesday, May 24, 2022

JUDGING PAROCHIAL FEDERALISM, XVI

 

An advocate of parochial federalism continues his/her presentation[1] …

Student Political Interests [2] (cont.)

          With a backdrop of an objectified, general approach by which to consider political issues – one that counts on such methods as cost-benefit analysis – and one that avoids normative questioning, what remains for students to consider as they grow old enough to enter the political fray?  One focus or related concern:  American institutional support for political debate has become weak when the need for that debate has become more important.

          That is, as the citizenry has become more dependent on governmental services in a more complex, post-industrial society, institutions such as political parties have not collaterally met the task of providing the arena(s) for such debate.  Instead, single-issue interests, such as political action committees (organizations that pool political assets of members to fight for some vested interest), have maintained their activities although the general landscape has changed since the final years of the last century. 

Today, those pacts are caught up in an overarching polarized political environment where these pacts find themselves, out of necessity, embroiled in alliances – one of two grand alliances.  But their functions are still the same.

          By financially supporting candidates, they gain access not so much to debate the issues, but to inform the beholding politicians of their promotions on the specific issue(s) that interest them.  Oftentimes such issues are little known or understood by the general public.  What discussion exists is not in the content of the general good but is constrained by the concerns associated with the particular issues in question.  Even the introduction of social media has not changed this basic dynamic.

            Those who served to coalesce demands through the processes of compromise, such as leaders of political clubs, parties, and even political “machines” (which in these days take the form of a national polarized side – the left or the right – the liberals/progressives or the conservative/nationalists) have had their roles changed.  Now, the coalescing happens out of emotional leaguing as opposed to thought-out debate.  As such, it takes on an Us-Them characterization.[3]

The current national arena is characterized by these two sides coalescing an array of interest groups of broad breadth.  Why? Because the opposition is similarly arranged, and one interest cannot face that broad alliance singularly and have any chance of success.  This blogger, in his pending book (From Immaturity to Polarized Politics), expends quite a few pages describing these phenomena and relies heavily on the modeling proposed by E. E. Schattschneider.[4] 

Until recent years, negative opinion polls concerning politicians, the political process, and low voter turnouts serve as evidenced of the general dislike that Americans are feeling.  The Pew Center regularly issues a report on this sort of concern.  Here is a sample of what it has reported:

Though the public is unhappy with government generally, Americans are largely divided on key measures of their ability to influence how it runs, including the impact of voting on government and the ability of motivated individuals to influence the way government works.

When asked which statement comes closer to their own views, most Americans (58%) say that “voting gives people like me some say about how government runs things,” while fewer (39%) say “voting by people like me doesn’t really affect how government runs things.”

The public is somewhat more skeptical when it comes to the ability of ordinary citizens to influence the government in Washington. Half (50%) say ordinary citizens can do a lot to influence the government in Washington, if they are willing to make the effort, while about as many (47%) say there’s not much ordinary citizens can do to influence the government.[5]

While this general view of a despondent electorate prevails (a true republic would have a much higher rate of influence over public policy), it should be pointed out that in 2020, the electorate voted at an over 60% turnout – very high by American standards.  Perhaps intensified polarized politics is revving up emotions and encouraging a higher rate of participation.

          But even with this relative uptick, generally, Americans are noted for their indifference.  The current negativity, regardless of how many go out and vote, in the form of alienation and withdrawal (and if engaged, being done out of anger and disgust) toward politics is a far cry from the reported rapport Americans felt among the founding generation in the eighteenth century.[6]

          If government is to again issue policies perceived to advance the common good and earn a more positive reaction from the populace, citizens must develop a better awareness.  Of what?  Of the basic sources of their discontent and become convinced that political work needs to be done to recreate the necessary political institutions that lead to general welfare policies. 

Such a realization must begin in the nation’s social studies classrooms, particularly in government or civics courses.  This is particularly important for the typical student who will most likely not be represented directly by high priced lobbyists or political action committees that make influential contributions to politicians on the behalf of those lobbyists and committees.

          For citizens to regain control, a resocialization of the republican values that wrestled control from the British in 1776 must take place.  Such a socialization is the nation’s historical heritage.  One element of such a campaign would be to reestablish the political theory that informed and motivated Americans not only at the beginning, but through most of its history, the parochial/traditional federalist construct.[7]

          This blog will next address its last position concerning the commonplace of curriculum development, the student, before it turns to the next commonplace, that being teachers.  The last position of the student commonplace is “pedagogic student interest.”



[1] This presentation begins with the posting, “A Parochial Subject Matter” (March 11, 2022).  The reader is reminded that the claims made in this posting do not necessarily reflect the beliefs or knowledge of this blogger.  Instead, the posting is a representation of what an advocate of parochial federalism might present.  This is done to present a dialectic position of that construct.

[2] William H. Schubert, Curriculum:  Perspective, Paradigm, and Possibility (New York, NY:  MacMillan Publishing Company, 1986).  The meaning of this term has been shared in previous postings and refers to the political interests of students that curriculum developers should consider in their plans.

[3] Frank Schweitzer, Tamas Krivachy, and David Garcia, “An Agent-Based Model of Opinion Polarized Driven by Emotions, Hindawi (April 10, 2020).

[4] E. E. Schattschneider, The Semi-Sovereign People:  A Realist’s View of Democracy in America (New York, NY:  Hole, Rinehart and Winston, 1960).

[5] “8. Perceptions of the Public’s Voice in Government and Politics,” Pew Research Center (November 23, 2015), accessed May 22, 2022, https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2015/11/23/8-perceptions-of-the-publics-voice-in-government-and-politics/ .

[6] Gordon S. Wood, Creation of the American Republic 1776-1787 (Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 1969/1968).  This conclusion is questioned.  Critical scholars have cited evidence that perhaps this sort of rapport might have been limited to the privileged segments of the population.  But even with these advocates, a certain level of agreement exists with the general support the Revolution enjoyed, for example, which was needed for that effort to have succeeded.  See Ray Raphael, A People’s History of the American Revolution:  How Common People Shaped the Fights for Independence (New York, NY:  Perennial, 2001).

[7] Daniel Elazar contends that that theory, federalism, is still held in prominence.  See Daniel J. Elazar, Exploring Federalism (Tuscaloosa, AL:  The University of Alabama Press, 1987).