A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Tuesday, May 9, 2023

JUDGING CRITICAL THEORY, XVI

 

An advocate of critical theory continues his/her presentation[1] …

 

With the last posting describing one school of thought under the general construct critical theory – that being reconstructionism – this posting will describe the second school, reconceptualization.  Of the two, reconstructionism has a more collectivist orientation, while reconceptualization leans more toward an individualistic perspective.  Yes, the two share many aims, but the latter emphasizes addressing more directly questions of consciousness.

          How do the two, more specifically, share in the goals and claims they make?  Here is a list of overarching, common attributes:

 

·       they both have an organic and holistic view of people and society,

·       they have a constructional view of knowledge as explained by this blogger in his explanation of constructs,[2]

·       they place an emphasis on personal experiential knowledge,

·       they recognize the power of pre-conscious knowledge,

·       they use the humanities as a source of knowledge (more so with reconceptualization),

·       they place in priority personal liberty with responsibility and higher levels of consciousness (driving one’s consciousness toward self-actualization – again, more so with reconceptualization),

·       they value diversity and pluralism as both a means and ends,

·       they advocate a need to reconstruct social and political processes, and

·       they set forth a new language.

 

But here is how reconceptualization differs from reconstructionism.  During the later years of the twentieth century, life and culture changed drastically from the Great Depression years of the 1930s.  And in those later years, reconceptualization picked up steam.  For one, it applied more recent curricular approaches and adopted its language to a new set of sensitivities and insights (for example, using terms such as “deconstruct”).

          It also employed different categories of consciousness such as gender, race, and sexual orientation as well as socio-economic class, this last category being what reconstruction featured in its arguments.  Reconceptualization advocates point out how these other groups have their own views concerning oppression and oppressive conditions – some are like class-based ideas and views of realities and others differ.  That is, in particular they often vary from class-based views in their consciousnesses regarding oppression.

          Other points of difference include:

 

·       in terms of curriculum, reconceptualization does not hold it as a final product but as an experience, preferring the verb form of curriculum, currere,

·       its advocates rely to a greater degree on psychoanalytic (preconscious) study in analyzing pedagogic conditions and needs,

·       and these advocates are leery of scientific efforts at “discovering” targeted explanations and instead depend on more holistic, as opposed to analytic, understanding.

 

On this last point, reconceptualization advocates see science, as it is mostly practiced, to be overly aimed at problem-solving and tends to support bureaucratic, shallow efforts.  As such, it is a research approach that seriously tends to obfuscate efforts at forming enriched understandings or meanings.  In this, with his problem-posing form of study, the late Paulo Freire can be considered more of a reconceptualization educator who promoted holistic research. 

Irrespective of what their critics claim regarding their approach, reconceptualization advocates argue that their work is value free and not meant or aimed at indoctrinating their audiences, be they students or social activists.  They also boast of broadening their perspective by freely incorporating a larger array of literature such as poems, novels, short stories, and plays – do not be surprised if one finds in their work references to visual arts as well.

          Other points of distinction with reconstructionism are that reconceptualization often relies heavily on existentialism[3] and phenomenology.[4]  It is more focused on individual development as it often centers on self-actualization.  There, the theoretical ideas of Abraham Maslow are recurringly employed.

          This blog has observed that reconceptualization tends to be more in line with the natural rights view than what reconstructionism has been and probably not more so than when its advocates rely on perceptional claims of Carl Rogers and Arthur Combs.  These advocates, while still maintaining the moral and theoretical differences with the natural rights view, do take on a more individualistic view than the more traditional reconstructionist approach.  More concretely, they tend to cater to individuals’ whims and biases.

          Beyond these differences, critical pedagogy overall has had significant influence on higher education in both the US and Europe.  Starting in the 1960s (coinciding with the protests against the Vietnam conflict), its corps of supporters have engaged in various healthy – sometimes unhealthy – debates over various concerns.  Those concerns include community, diversity, social justice, and a host of other concerns over perceived instances of oppression.  Often their discourses relate these concerns to establishing or maintaining societal health.

          For those readers who follow the news of late, they can verify that these issues are or are becoming more central to the national discourse.  Various “red” states are taking a more proactive approach to counter the efforts of critical theorists and have taken on the ill-defined term “anti-woke” to summarize the concerns and antagonism for what critical advocates tend to favor.  And some of this has been affecting civics curricular efforts including the banning of books and other media.



[1] This posting heavily relies on the work of William Schubert.  See William H. Schubert, Curriculum:  Perspective, Paradigm, and Possibility (New York, NY:  MacMillan Publishing Company, 1986).

[2] This blogger has in several postings given a definition for the term, construct. For example, posting dated November 22 or 23, 2010, “A Default Construct,” and can be found in Blog Book First Hundred, accessed May 6, 2023, BLOG BOOK FIRST HUNDRED - Google Docs, 67.  It gives a shortened definition.

[3] General belief in individual existence – investigative effort to determine what is the nature of being, particularly as it applies to individual human beings, as one experiences reality in this ultimately indeterminable world – and in total freedom and responsibility.

Existentialists point out that people are constantly faced with choices in which there are no known laws, ethical standards, or traditions to show the way. This makes life a state of being that inevitably produces anxiety.

[4] Study of consciousness as it relates to being. Founded by Edmund Husserl and Martin Heidegger; it can be a somewhat opaque philosophy. For the purposes here, though, the interest is in its contributions to how one’s mental acts, consciousness, handle   the very nature of things in the practical world. It therefore is an alternative to empirical sciences.

Friday, May 5, 2023

JUDGING CRITICAL THEORY, XV

 

[Note:  This posting is subject to further editing.]

This blog, as a parting observation in the last posting, pointed out that critical theory has developed into two schools of thought.  The one is reconstructionism and the other is reconceptualization. [1]  Both share certain ideas and claims, but they do vary enough to be considered separately.  This posting will address reconstructionism and the next will describe reconceptualization.

          Some credit John Dewey with the founding of reconstructionism and its heyday was during the 1930s – years that coincided with the Great Depression.  As it applied to education – which was Dewey’s main concern – it was/is based on the belief that learning should mostly emanate from one’s experiences.  Further, those recollections of experiences should be reorganized – that is, reconstructed – so that they provide students with added meaning and direction in facing current conditions and subsequent experiences.

          Paulo Freire, whose work was just reviewed in this blog, illustrates how this prescription can be implemented through school instruction.  That would be one approach, but as one reviews how this school of thought has been considered by others, there has been various approaches derived from reconstructionist ideas.  There are those who promote social reforms.  And these other efforts are targeted at those conditions that have rendered the working class being exploited by oppressive conditions.  Low wages, long oppressive hours, unsafe working conditions, child labor were among the conditions they would strive to change in the 1930s and beyond.

          There were those among the reconstructionist groups who encouraged teachers to work in organizing others to join socialist or communist labor movements.  They tended to argue that teachers should teach their students what they deemed to be the follies of capitalism.  And there were those who pushed for teachers to do all these roles, but they added that such actions, even in the days of hostile labor strikes and demonstrations, should be performed without resorting to violence – they believed it was not necessary.[2]

          The overall educational aim was to enhance the ability of students to change themselves so as to allow them to generate the insights necessary to understand their conditions – as being oppressed – and be motivated to work toward the transformation of society.  National figures leading this movement included George Counts and Harold Rugg.  They expressed the belief that education could and should be a medium by which to create and promote a new social order.

          The curriculum for which they advocated conceived of education as a force to institute a new spirit for education, one that could be applied to the whole curriculum.  Yes, that curriculum would still teach the basics – reading, writing, math – and the academic disciplines – in the social studies that would be history, government, geography, economics – but to present them in such a way that it would promote this new social order.  In so doing, it would be characterized by a social/communal, as opposed to an individualist, focus.  That is, it would emphasize cooperation, not competition.

          Inherent with such an approach is its ideal vision of society.  That would be an organic (interdependent) view that calls for an interdisciplinary mode of research.  It would disfavor epistemology based on specialization that one associates with positivist/scientific studies that schools generally teach even today.  That is, in seeking reconstruction, one puts aside the use of detached disciplines – which the advocates of the natural rights view favor – and apply multidisciplinary lessons.

But what should be pursued should be done within the context of self-actualization or a proactive effort to have students discover who they really are.  What prevails, though, is something else, i.e., a younger generation – not exclusive to today’s youth – that is overly influenced by cultural and other forces – encapsulated in the prevailing discourses of the day and that affect them at subconscious levels.  Consider today the force of pop culture.[3] 

And added to that general aim in content is the utilization of instructional processes critical pedagogues call praxis.[4]  That praxis should be conducted through sensitivity and penetrating criticism where students actively evaluate what they experience.  And one can add that in relation to social studies – particularly civics – this approach, even if one does not ascribe to it, does offer a good deal of useful ideas. 

Advocates argue that the nation could stand for a good dose of “social self-realization” that could be assisted by adopting various instructional suggestions from the critical approach.  Yet, this school of thought did not enjoy much currency in the US in the thirties or since.  There was the adoption of texts written by Harold Rugg back in those years, but they ran into controversy during the fifties and were removed.

 Why were they removed?  Business groups found them offensive.  This blogger can share a bit of firsthand information on this score.  No, he did not teach in the fifties but does have a copy of one of those books – America’s March toward Democracy – and judges it to be fairly mainstream.  As evidence, here is a passage taken from the beginnings of the book:

 

...[F]or at least two centuries and a half [before the Revolution] there was a more widespread spirit of individual liberty in America than in the Old World of Europe and Asia. By that we mean that the Americans were much freer to live and work as they pleased. The chief factor introducing this spirit was the frontier. … On the frontier men and women were forced to depend upon themselves for their living. There was no one else to rely upon for help. … We say that there grew up a spirit of self-reliance, of initiative, of democracy. And this frontier spirit of individual liberty played a most fit important part in changing the American government to the needs of the changing American civilization.[5]

 

A passage resembling the Communist Manifesto?  Not really.

          It reminds this blogger of the natural rights construct which guides what is taught in history and civics classes today.  In the introduction to the book, Rugg does claim that the text aims to encourage problem-solving activities, and a review of its content – way short of reading every page – this blogger does not find any open-ended problems students are called upon to solve.

          Reconstructionism’s advocates on college campuses during the ensuing years did verge on being radicals – at least some of them.  During the Cold War – especially during the “McCarthyism years” – they were actively hassled and subject to various punishments by the authorities – denial of tenure, FBI investigations, criminal prosecutions, etc.[6] 

More recently, while more success has been experienced by reconceptualization followers, one can find reconstructionist ideas filtering onto published works in professional journals – at least in terms of the topics being addressed.  And with this noting of reconceptualization, the other school of thought, this blogger brings this posting to an end and points out that that school of thought will be the topic of the next posting.



[1] William H. Schubert, Curriculum: Perspective, Paradigm, and Possibility (New York, NY: MacMillan Publishing Company, 1986). Most of the descriptive comments in this and the next posting rely heavily on ideas presented by Schubert.

[2] See Progressive Education and Social Reconstruction, Encyclopedia.com. Website: http://www.encyclopedia.com/doc/1/g2-3468301130.htlm .

[3] “Popular Culture,” Central Community College (n.d.), accessed May 3, 2023, https://libguides.cccneb.edu/popculture#:~:text=As%20the%20name%20implies%2C%20popular,conduct%20themselves%20and%20so%20on.

[4] See “Judging Critical Theory, VII,” Gravitas:  A Voice for Civics, April, 7, 2023.

[5] Harold Rugg, America's March Toward Democracy (Boston, MA: Ginn and Company, 1937), 8-9.

[6] Ellen Schrecker, “Political Tests for Professors:  Academic Freedom during the McCarthy Years,” The University Loyalty Oath (October 7, 1999), accessed May 3, 2023, https://www.lib.berkeley.edu/uchistory/archives_exhibits/loyaltyoath/symposium//schrecker.html.

Tuesday, May 2, 2023

JUDGING CRITICAL THEORY, XIV

 

[Note:  This posting is subject to further editing.]

With a good look at Paulo Freire’s ideas concerning education – that of a critical pedagogue – one can now take a closer look at what critical theory promotes.  One word about Freire – to contextualize his contribution – the nation he represented was Brazil.  While Brazil has become highly advanced, it is still classified as a developing nation since it still does not provide adequate healthcare and clean water to all of its population.[1]  So, one should keep that factor in mind when considering his arguments.

          This and the next posting will get more closely at the diversity of ideas or focuses critical theorists hold.  One commentator that points to this variety, as he describes and explains the construct, is William Schubert. [2]  He does emphasize that critical theorists do agree on certain principles. 

He mentions agreement on the need for praxis as Freire mostly describes it as striving for the transformation of a society (instead of working toward marginal changes).  In their understanding of praxis, they see it as an action to attain emancipation and empowerment – their terms – of the oppressed.  In part they achieve this by questioning the structures of the power arrangements in each nation.  And looming over all of this is a value system that prizes equality of results – or as they term it, social justice – as a trump value.

Praxis views knowledge in a particular way.  That is, it is derived from constructive processes which investigate the social realities that the oppressed experience.  And the approach students are to take utilizes a multidisciplinary approach (history, political, economic, and social sciences) applied to reality as it evolves in given places and times – as opposed to universal conditions.

Regarding “learning,” knowledge is perceived differently.  Here it is the product of deconstructing existing claims – the product of oppressor discourses – and reconstructing them in more real contexts as perceived by the oppressed.  Obviously, this view of knowledge is that it is the product or created by the mind constructing it.  As such, it rejects reductionist research protocols.[3]

In its purity, this view of knowledge counters the positivist view which is what natural rights advocates promote.  In its total form, a positivist approach favors the impartation of knowledge through the efforts of experts with sanctioning credentials.  Instead, critical theorists argue that knowledge should be the product of self-derived knowledge taken from personal and intimate relationships and their related experiences.

And on this point, critical theorists do not accept the claims of positivists that being that positivists objectify their subject matter and strip their biases from their findings.  According to critical theorists, positivists are equally affected by their personal biases as demonstrated by the long history of faulty claims proffered by these experts. 

This critique holds that positivists see the function of scientifically derived social knowledge is not to better interpersonal relationships, but to be applied to clinical relationships by social technicians or to advance the interests those who fund such research as multi-national corporations.  And this can be said of not only the conclusions they derive from their research but also the questions they pose.

Bottom line is that the results of this sort of “studies” are a false consciousness.  In its stead, would be a liberating education, an education that helps people achieve emancipation from the inherently debilitating condition or state of affairs.  Through the years, this line of thinking has gone through changes including the evolution of two schools of thought:  reconstructionism and reconceptualization.

Reconstructionism has remained truer to its Marxist origins – not to deny it has its differences with that source – while reconceptualization has open itself to the influence of a variety of sources including existentialism, psychoanalysis, and a stronger aversion to pure scientific research.  Next posting will delve into these ideas and how they have affected the whole critical theorists’ view of civic issues.



[1] Mar Z. Luna, “10 Most Developed Countries in Central and South America,” Homeschool Spanish Academy (October 13, 2022), accessed April 29, 2023, https://www.spanish.academy/blog/10-most-developed-countries-in-central-and-south-america/.

[2] William H. Schubert, Curriculum: Perspective, Paradigm, and Possibility (New York, NY: MacMillan Publishing Company, 1986).  Most of the descriptive comments in this and the next posting relies heavily on ideas presented by Schubert.

[3] According to this blogger’s understanding, not all critical theorists totally reject the contributions of positivist studies one associates with scientific approaches.  All of them do question its value as being the sole source of knowledge.  It should be noted that Freire does not dismiss the social sciences but argues their application in a multidisciplinary way.

Friday, April 28, 2023

JUDGING CRITICAL THEORY, XIII

 

[Note:  This posting is subject to further editing.]

In the attempt to share with readers how critical theory is expressed in the educational community, this blog has described Paulo Freire’s educational approach.  To begin, this application is called critical pedagogy and the purpose of relating Freire’s contribution is to provide a working sense of what it takes to be a critical pedagogue.  He provides, if not a pure version of critical theory, an insightful view of what critical pedagogues mean by people being liberated.

          To be honest, this blog’s effort has not been an extensive presentation of Freire’s argument but a basic one.  Enough of one so that an interested teacher can begin experimenting with Freire’s more practical prescriptions and if readers are interested, his book, Pedagogy of the Oppressed, can offer a more complete exposition of his views.  It addresses the challenges teachers will face if they initiate his ideas in the classroom.

          Mixed in with Freire’s critical thoughts are natural rights beliefs – the approaches, to a noticeable degree – blend one with the other.  What one can clearly discern, though, is that Freire does not have a natural rights sense of liberty, one based on individualism.  The critical bent leans toward a communal sense of liberty and, in this mode, Freire writes of cycles where teachers and students perform each other’s roles in the classroom.  The same, in a different fashion, pertains to the oppressed and liberated oppressors where both strive toward attaining their humanity.

          And here is a general principle of this construct:  Those involved must, in communion, exert their effort to accomplish the transformation from a reality of oppression to one of liberation.  They must accomplish it; it cannot be done for them, and it cannot be done alone.  In this, Freire strays from other critical theorists.

          The usual writers of that construct and in the fashion of Marxists, speak and write of collectives not communal arrangements, unless the two are equated.  This blogger feels the two are distinct.  A collective subsumes or mostly subsumes the individualism of those involved for the sake of the collective.  Communal retains individualism in terms of a person’s self-dignity.  Why?  Because the common good is or will be compromised if that dignity is sacrificed.

          Writing in this vein, Christopher Ferry writes of the need for teachers to trust students, for them to accept them for who they are, including their limitations, while working with them to transform them and their reality toward liberation.[1]  In terms of this distinction, one can appreciate an overlap between Freire’s ideas and the ideas of federation theory.

          If and when others step in and attempt to instill or create a liberation for those who are oppressed – the “savior” role – that in effect objectifies those who are to benefit from such attempts and, therefore, end in failure.  The process, in its very nature, demands dialogue and trust among those involved.  Yes, there is a role for empirically derived knowledge, but from the life experiences of those involved. 

These are the themes the previous postings pointed out which are essential to true school reform even if one finds fault with Freire’s overall message.  One does not need to be a critical theorist or critical pedagogue to appreciate, for example, the function of discourses.  And the dialogues or discourses are to be on-going that strive to expose the slew of myths the oppressors promote, e.g., that entrepreneurial opportunities exist in abundance. 

Along with these exposures is discovering and informing those involved of various strategies such as existing policies or practices that divide the oppressed.  So, leftists or liberals often attempt to uncover quick paths to success or power which by-pass hard earned partnerships among the oppressed – short cuts to some.  Results of such efforts are unaccomplished goals or new forms of oppression or other parties inflicting other forms of exploitation who, through their discourses, promise “liberation.”

And then, according to Freire, there are governmental programs – e.g., welfare – that artificially anesthetize the oppressed and tend to further divide them.  What critical pedagogy strives for is not cradle to grave assistance.  Along with its condemnation of undue concentration of wealth, this form of enlightenment sees wealth as power and that power is exercised, in part, to deny opportunities for the oppressed.

So, what determines liberation.  Liberation exists in societies where no small percentage of the population – the elites – can dictate or unreasonably influence the laws of the land and/or how the laws are enforced.  According to Freire, true equality includes all segments of the population having equal say in what those laws are, how they are administered, and how they are interpreted.



[1] See Christopher Ferry, “When the Distressed Teach the Oppressed:  Toward an Understanding of Communion and Commitment” (n.d.) accessed June 11, 2021, https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/268749403.pdf,

Tuesday, April 25, 2023

JUDGING CRITICAL THEORY, XII

 

[Note:  This posting is subject to further editing.]

An advocate of critical theory continues his/her presentation …

Of late this blog has been reviewing the elements of critical theory.  In doing so, the blog has claimed that this leftist view has posed the most prominent challenge to the natural rights construct.  Natural rights view is currently dominant and mostly guides what civics classrooms present students in way of content.[1]  The challenging view, critical theory, has been around for ninety years in various forms, and is finally having some actual influence in the US and is generating reaction from certain conservative parties – e.g., consider Governor Ron DeSantis’ efforts in Florida.

          Even non-advocates of this view might consider a number of their arguments worth their consideration.  For one, many would sign up for instituting interactive instructional strategies as opposed to what one usually finds in classrooms, what critical theorists call a “banking” strategy.  In this, critical educators fall in line with progressive pedagogues who, for example, promote both open ended research and community involvement activities. 

What differentiates critical strategies from more mainstream progressive ones is that critical educators target their efforts almost exclusively to what they consider exploitive conditions.  In terms of clarifying this distinction, consider what critical educators claim their approach strives to accomplish:

         

The students – no longer docile listeners – are now critical co-investigators in dialogue with the teacher. The teacher presents the material to the students for their consideration, and re-considers her earlier considerations as the students express their own [a two-way influence]. The role of the problem-posing educator is to create, together with the students, the conditions under which knowledge at the level of the doxa [opinion] is superseded by true knowledge, at the level of the logos [reason].

Whereas banking education[2] anesthetizes and inhibits creative power, problem-posing education involves a constant unveiling of reality. The former attempts to maintain the submersion of consciousness; the latter strives for the emergence of consciousness and critical intervention in reality. [3]

 

To distinguish themselves, as indicated by this quote, critical pedagogues claim they engage in “problem-posing.”

And as indicated earlier in the blog, the problems posed and studied arise from the oppressive realities that confront the students.  Included in this approach is to encourage students to form a solidarity with their classmates – fellow oppressed comrades.  Being action-oriented, this approach has a dual aim:  transforming the oppressive nature of the situation and having students become fully humanized as they interact with each other and deal with their plight.

          And central, according to critical pedagogues, is discourses – the powerful dialogues in which people engage.  Transformation toward liberation relies on words that communicate what the real world is and is to function in people becoming truly human.  It surely does not rest on sentimentality or as a tool to manipulate others.  Instead, it communicates humility, not arrogance.  Among its messaging, it states a faith in humankind, not an unrealistic faith, but one that comprehends and deals with the foibles and short sightedness people tend to employ. 

As part of this mode of communicating, the discourses should promote horizontal arrangements – a real equality – instead of vertical arrangements in social as well as political relationships.  To use common parlance, the process should lead to honest partnerships where true respect for others and their views are held.

          For part of the highlighted reality is an area’s history – its background – which includes how the structural realities of an area were formed and maintained.  In the current frame, what exists is that background’s product and includes the views entertained by the oppressed and the oppressors.  So, a major aspect of the transforming process is for the current generation to decode the situations that people experience.  And the educative effort is geared to see the real nature of how and why they became and are oppressed sans the manipulative language the non-liberated oppressor employs.

Paulo Freire describes the oppressor discourses as language that utilizes oppressive generative themes.  These themes deserve a bit of explanation.  “In the process of decoding, this analysis of meaning corresponds to the stage we call the ‘description of the situation,’ and facilitates the discovery of the interaction among the parts of the disjointed whole.”[4]  The aim is to discover the dialectic forces impinging on people’s well-being – the hows and whys in which they do so.

And even if one is tempted to get boughed down on the particulars – the specific people or things in situations – the focus needs to be on the whole – the abstract composite one confronts.  That is what is known as generative themes, and if oppressive, they are oppressive generative themes.  In that mode, liberating education has students and others inquire into people’s thinking about the realities they face, and their corresponding action – their praxis.  They need to replace the oppressive generative themes with liberating ones.

The oppressed need to leave behind their self-image as objects.  In its stead, they become subjects who are drivers of what becomes real.  That is, these students are to become drivers of what is to be; they, through their study and action, discover (1) their felt needs, (2) the abstractions embedded in the codification of the language that has veiled their reality, and (3) commence to communicate the totality of that reality.

As indicated in previous postings, this process is ongoing.  Its general gist is for those involved – which might include liberated, former oppressors – to introspectively inquire as to the reasons why they have been seeing reality as they have.  If possible, this can be assisted by the services of experts from the disciplines of psychology and sociology.  With this sort of help, an interdisciplinary approach should be maintained.

          Freire, on this score, writes,

 

Once the thematic demarcation is completed, each specialist presents to the interdisciplinary team a project for the “breakdown” of his theme. In breaking down the theme, the specialist looks for the fundamental nuclei which, comprising learning units and establishing a sequence, give a general view of the theme. As each specific project is discussed, the other specialists make suggestions.[5]

 

And with that Freire discusses another element of critical pedagogy, that being interdisciplinary analysis.  The resulting studies take on a thematic form that originates from the people and are directed at them as challenges they need to resolve.  Again, as earlier in this blog it was stated, what one sees here are processes of study-praxis-study, recurring cycles.  They continue in this mode as people stake out different futures.

          To update this account, let this posting add another quote from the Freire Institute recently retrieved from the internet:

 

People can be passive recipients of knowledge — whatever the content — or they can engage in a ‘problem-posing’ approach in which they become active participants. As part of this approach, it is essential that people link knowledge to action so that they actively work to change their societies at a local level and beyond.[6]

 

And that is why this posting is entitled “Problem-Posting.”



[1] For this blogger’s more extensive argument concerning this point see Robert Gutierrez, From Immaturity to Polarized Politics:  Obstacles in Achieving a Federated Nation (Tallahassee, FL:  Gravitas Civics Books, 2022), available through Amazon.

[2] Banking education was explained in the previous posting. It basically refers to didactic teaching.

[3] Paulo Freire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed (New York, NY: Continuum Publishing Company, 1999), 62, emphasis in the original.

[4] Ibid., 86.

[5] Ibid., 101.  These teams, this blogger assumes, are organized at a national level for the recurring types of problems students identify with their self-analyzing efforts in the classroom.