A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Friday, August 25, 2023

VIABILITY OF THE LIBERATED FEDERALISM, VI

 

This posting will address another concern of Eugene Meehan’s criteria as they are applied to the social construct, the liberated federalism model.[1]  This blog has been applying that criteria to describe the viability of that construct.  The sixth Meehan criterion asks:  does the construct align with other responsible models explaining the same phenomena?  That is, does it have compatibility? 

There is nothing in this proposed model that either contradicts the parochial/traditional federalism model or the political systems model and its offshoot models that have, to some degree, been previously reviewed in this blog.  What follows is a description of how liberated federalism is compatible.

          From this perspective, the model offered here can be seen as an open-ended one in which all of these models and theories are called into play by the activities of the deliberative process which the model in question highlights.  The federalist model of government is a more encompassing one.  These other models – those that have emanated from the political systems model – are mid-range models that describe and attempt to explain how political actors work their processes for a given context. 

As such, the mid-range models are useful in understanding political conditions, given specific political challenges, and in devising effective strategies.  As stated in an earlier posting, the model that has the closest overlapping content to liberated federalism is group theory.  Roy C. Macridis writes:

 

… [T]hey [group theorists] tell us that in order to understand how groups behave and how they interact, we must study the political system, the overall behavior patterns, the values and beliefs held by the actors, the formal organization of authority, the degree of legitimacy, etc., etc.  Without realizing it, they reverse their theoretical position.  They start with groups only to admit the primacy of the political phenomenon and suggest that in order to explain group behavior we must start with what group behavior purported to explain – the political system![2]

 

In a similar way, if the liberated federalism model were presented for purposes of generating hypotheses which would lead to empirical studies, this criticism would similarly be a serious one in terms of the model’s usefulness.  But that is not its purpose.

          The model is presented as a foundational construct for the study of American government and civics and, therefore, the Macridis statement is seen as having a functional quality because these are exactly the types of concerns that one wants secondary students to tackle in their study of government and civics.

          The literature about groups has been concerned mostly with the actions of interest groups, i.e., groups that have the on-going role of bringing demands to the political perspective of group behavior.[3]  While this type of group concern is not excluded from the liberated federalism model, it, liberated federalism, is not limited to that concern.  Besides, the emphasis is not limited to questions of effectiveness, although also included, but the emphasis is also heavily concerned with the communal interaction of entities with arrangements/associations and the moral quality of their actions.

          Therefore, the judgment here is that for pedagogical reasons, liberated federalism is not only compatible but also solicits a functional role for systems-based models in guiding civics instruction at the secondary level.  The next criterion to be addressed is predictability.



[1] That is, this posting continues the blog’s review of Eugene Meehan’s criteria by which to evaluate social science theories and models.  For readers wishing to read the previous postings relating these viability claims that the blog is making, they can read the last five postings found in the online site http://gravitascivics.blogspot.com/.  As for Meehan’s criteria, see Eugene J. Meehan, Contemporary Political Thought:  A Critical Study (Homewood, IL:  Dorsey Press, 1967).  To date the blog has reviewed comprehensiveness, power, precision, consistency/reliability, and isomorphism.

[2] Roy C. Macridis, “Groups and Group Theory” in Comparative Politics:  Notes and Readings, edited by Roy C. Macridis and Bernard E. Brown (Chicago, IL:  The Dorsey Press, 1986), 281-287, 286.

[3] Current academic political thinking concerning group theory has a mixed opinion as to its viability.  See “Political Group Analysis,” Encyclopedia.com (n.d.), accessed August 23, 2023, https://www.encyclopedia.com/social-sciences/applied-and-social-sciences-magazines/political-group-analysis AND for a more positive view, see Robert A. Heineman, Steven A. Peterson, and Thomas H. Rasmussen, American Government (New York, NY:  McGraw-Hill, Inc., 1995).

Tuesday, August 22, 2023

VIABILITY OF THE LIBERATED FEDERALISM, V

 

After presenting and describing the application of Eugene Meehan’s criteria for appraising social science theories and models,[1] the last posting addressed the challenge of diversity and how it affects the isomorphism of the liberated federalism model.  For readers who want to read those accounts, they are directed to the online site, http://gravitascivics.blogspot.com/,[2] and review the last four postings.

          Given the complexity that the last posting reported, it does not complete this account’s comments concerning diversity and isomorphism.  In addition, there is the need to describe how excessive individualism, an ongoing malady of American life, [3] influences the diversity issue and demands yet another type of toleration within the nation’s collective social make-up.

 

This country is not only a pluralism of groups but also a pluralism of individuals, its regime of toleration is focused, as we have seen on personal choices and lifestyles rather than on common ways of life.  It is perhaps the most individualist society in human history … “we are free to do our own thing.”[4]

 

But “doing your own thing” takes financial resources which many immigrant groups, in many cases, have in short supply.

          The poorer groups often lead the nation to be the noisiest – in most cases, legitimately so – about maintaining their cultural identity by engaging in political processes.  As the groups establish themselves, they become Americanized because the political processes have their effects.  The debate in the nation is whether to insist on a single, nativist approach (“Make America Great Again”), one in which a hegemony of dominant culture prevails, or one that tolerates or even encourages diverse cultural lifestyles.

Walzer gives one element of this debate a positive spin, he writes:

 

… [D]emocratic politics itself, where all the members of all the groups are (in principle) equal citizens who have not only to argue with one another but they also somehow, to come to an agreement.  What they learn in the course of the necessary negotiations and compromises is probably more important than anything they might get from studying the canon.  We need to think about how this practical, democratic learning can be advanced.[5]

 

In the process of learning the lessons, great benefits are gained by immigrants belonging to associations:  “Individuals are stronger, more confident, more savvy, when they are participants in a common life, when they are responsible to and for other people.”[6] 

In so claiming, Walzer agrees with one of the main points of this account, that federating themselves with others, in the long run, benefits these people’s interests by doing so.  That is, communal allegiances in associations and neighborhoods would do much to stem the tide of divorces, single parent homes, child abuse, abandonment, decline in membership in unions, homelessness and increase the future fates of churches, parent-teacher organizations, and philanthropic societies.

A federalist model, then, has a definite correspondence to these segments of reality.  The judgment here is that that demonstrates how granular the model can be and, therefore, demonstrates its isomorphism.  The next posting will address the model’s compatibility.



[1] Namely by reviewing comprehensiveness, power, precision, and reliability.  See Eugene J. Meehan, Contemporary Political Thought:  A Critical Study (Homewood, IL:  Dorsey Press, 1967).

[2] Use the archives feature.  If readers want to read the blog’s presentation of the liberated federalism model, they should start with the posting, “From Natural Rights to Liberated Federalism” (June 2, 2023).

[3] Jean M. Twenge, Generations:  The Real Differences between Gen Z, Millennials, Gen X, Boomers, and Silents – and What They Mean for America’s Future (New York, NY:  Atria Books, 2023).  It should be noted that individualism is not all bad.  It has its positive elements, but here the concern is with excessive individualism.

[4] Michael Walzer, On Toleration (New Haven, CT:  Yale University Press, 1997), 100.

[5] Ibid., 97.

[6] Ibid., 97.

Friday, August 18, 2023

VIABILITY OF THE LIBERATED FEDERALISM, IV

 

To date this blog has, in its viability statement concerning the construct, liberated federalism, reviewed four of Eugene Meehan’s criteria by which to determine the usefulness of social science models or theories.  The four are comprehensiveness, power, precision, and reliability.  For readers who want to read those accounts, they are directed to the online site, http://gravitascivics.blogspot.com/[1] and review the last three postings.

          This posting addresses the next Meehan criterion, isomorphism.  It asks:  does a construct contain a one-to-one correspondence with that portion of reality it is trying to describe and explain?  One can view the liberated federalism model as a problem-solving, decision-making model applicable to a political event or situation.  In Robert L. Solso’s 1995 edition of his book, Cognitive Psychology, one finds the following:

 

Studies of decision making show that problem solutions are influenced by memory factors (availability hypothesis), reference frames that affect problem formulation, failure to consider how similar an event is to its population, and underestimating the mathematical significance of a possible event …

Cross-cultural differences have been observed in syllogistic reasoning, with people from highly industrialized countries proving arguments in terms of representational propositions, and people from less industrialized countries basing proofs more on sensory impressions.[2]

         

As for the liberated federalism model, memory and other reference frames are accounted for in the model at the individual (entity) level by reference to knowledge resources.  At the arrangement/association level, the deliberative process refers to a review of held collective ideals and political and other theoretical knowledge or beliefs.  What scientific inquiry might investigate are the processes of congealing opposing commitments to diverse ideals and theoretical knowledge or biases by different entity members, especially among leaders.

It is surely an area that should be of prime concern when formulating compact-al agreements.  Parties cannot always foresee these types of basic disagreements, but looking for them in advance can ease their appearance and their resolution in a productive fashion.  A good review of personality and other distinctive characterizations of themselves and others so involved can prove to be beneficial in the long run.  One can think of this as akin to choosing a marital partner and is surely highlighted by the liberated federalism model.

In terms of cross-cultural differences – an issue of vibrant concern in diverse population societies – conscious awareness of differences in reasoning patterns among minority or immigrant groups can again ease the accommodations of their differences.  One should not underestimate the challenges such differences cause.[3]  Michael Walzer writes about different pluralistic models which characterize the various nations and empires that have had to deal with diversity.

The United States began with what Walzer calls a consociation arrangement among the several states.  A consociation is an arrangement of several communities through negotiations, a constitutional arrangement or union between or among themselves.

Diversity was based on geographic and economic factors and the nation’s compact originally was designed to federally unite this level of diversity.  A civil war and the nationalization that has occurred via common struggles, such as the development of a national economy, two world wars, a cold war, and a pervasive national media, have changed the nature of the nation’s diversity.[4]

The current, rising diversity is more a result of having an array of ethnic representation within the population.  This type of pluralist model Walzer calls immigrant societies.  Since this type of diversity is not segregated to the degree that various areas of the nation sustained (up to the civil rights movement in the twentieth century), the nation’s view of how to establish a federalist union needed changing – a process still in progress.

This does not mean that geographic and even accompanying cultural distinctions no longer exist in the United States; they do exist and enjoy a level of multiculturalism which has been culturally established in recent decades.  But to add to the complexity within the diverse geographic regions of the nation, there is diversity within and among the nation’s separate ethnic groups, according to Walzer.  For example, there is much diversity among the Latin groups as immigrants from various Latin countries have increased.

How this diversity matches up with liberated federalism’s elements – its isomorphism – will be addressed in the next posting.  Obviously, this question of how the model matches on a one-to-one basis with the realities of American society is a bit complex and deserves a more extended treatment.



[1] Use the archives feature.  If readers want to read the blog’s presentation of the liberated federalism model, they should start with the posting, “From Natural Rights to Liberated Federalism” (June 2, 2023).

[2] Robert L. Solso, Cognitive Psychology (Boston, MA:  Allyn and Bacon, 1995), 437.

[3] Dwitio Prayoto, “Public Administration and the Challenges of Managing Diversity,” Linked In (May 1, 2023), accessed August 16, 2023, https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/public-administration-challenges-managing-diversity-dwitio-prayoto#:~:text=One%20of%20the%20most%20significant%20challenges%20of%20managing%20diversity%20is,with%20individuals%20from%20different%20cultures AND Michael Walzer, On Toleration (New Haven, CT:  Yale University Press, 1997).

[4] Juliana Menasce Horrowitz, “Americans See Advantages and Challenges in Country’s Growing Racial and Ethnic Diversity,” Pew Research Center (May 8, 2019), accessed August 16, 2023, https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2019/05/08/americans-see-advantages-and-challenges-in-countrys-growing-racial-and-ethnic-diversity/.

Tuesday, August 15, 2023

VIABILITY OF THE LIBERATED FEDERALISM, III

 

Continuing this blog’s viability statement regarding the construct, liberated federalism, this posting will review Eugene Meehan’s[1] third criterion, precision, and the fourth criterion, reliability.  The blog has already addressed Meehan’s concern for comprehensiveness and power (see the two previous postings at http://gravitascivics.blogspot.com/[2]).  Precision is a criterion that asks:  does a construct specifically and precisely treat its concepts, making them clear in their use?  The concern is whether a construct is clearly usable in its uses.

          As applied to liberated federalism, this blog, preceding the actual description of the model with a presentation of its elements, presented the model’s key concepts.  They were identified and explained as to their meaning and significance.  In addition to the explanation of the individual concepts, the relations among them were explored.  This was carried through in the description of the model itself.

          Certain concepts, such as equality, were introduced more than once since they have significance within the different components of the model.  For example, equality is important within the relation between entities outside the domain of the arrangement as well as within it.  These distinctions were added to the description in the attempt to be as clear as possible.

          So, carrying this example further, if the concern of a study is how cohesion among members of a minority group and members of that group who hold positions within a government bureaucracy, such a condition would be addressed if that condition affects the concern under study.  This sort of clarity is carried forth with all its elements – its concepts and claims.

          The fourth Meehan criterion is reliability or consistency and asks:  does a construct explain its components and their relationships the same way time after time?  Can it be used reliably across various studies or different elements of a particular study?  The proposed model attempts to generalize the factors that are present in any moral, political decision-making, but maintain their meaning in its different applications.

          Not every important decision-making event in politics and government is moral or effective.  If one accepts the stated assumption that only moral decision-making furthers, in the long term, the self-interests of all parties involved, then the model serves as an ideal standard by which all political and governmental decisions can be analyzed and even judged.

          It also serves to identify the viable factors involved with such decision-making and can, therefore, provide a springboard for asking insightful questions of any similar or related activity within and without government.  As a standard, the relationship between or among the factors can be judged to be reliable in all political situations. 

As a model that designates the factors necessary for effective decision making for a given association, the primary emphasis is that they be coordinated and contextualized as communal efforts, i.e., federalist unions are best equipped to gain political objectives, particularly in the long run.  As with the previous notes on the other Meehan criteria, use of the model will serve to see if these claims are in effect true.

The following posting will address the next Meehan criterion, isomorphism.



[1] Philip Selznick, The Moral Commonwealth:  Social Theory and the Promise of Community (Berkeley, CA:  University of California Press, 1992).

[2] Use the archives feature.  If readers want to read the blog’s presentation of the liberated federalism model, they should start with the posting, “From Natural Rights to Liberated Federalism” (June 2, 2023).

Friday, August 11, 2023

VIABILITY OF THE LIBERATED FEDERALISM, II

 

With the last posting, this blog began a viability statement regarding the construct, liberated federalism.  That construct has been described and explained in a number of postings starting with “From Natural Rights to Liberated Federalism” (June 2, 2023).  Readers are invited to use the archive feature of the blog (via Google:  http://gravitascivics.blogspot.com/) and review the postings dedicated to that presentation. 

Using Eugene Meehan’s criteria to evaluate social science constructs, this blog, in the last posting, utilized Meehan’s first criterion, comprehension; this posting will apply his second, control.  By using or implementing control, a reviewer asks:  does a construct control the explanatory effort by being valid and complete in its component parts and in relationships between and among those parts?

That is, does it have power?  Since this is a proposed adoption of this model, the power level of the model will only become apparent through its use.  The model, as the foundational construct, has to be used in the building of curricular content.  Through that function, teachers and curriculum material designers of American government and civics will determine the effectiveness of this model by measuring the success that resultant materials have in teaching those subject areas.

From a theoretical point of view, the judgment of this synthesis is that it viably presents the factors, roles, and necessary structures that are essential to creating a communal democracy with federalist values.  Further, it claims that these elements can be synthesized into a product that teachers can transmit in practice to the extent that the natural rights perspective and the political systems construct have been able to do and is currently dominant in American schools.

The model is based on the ideas and relationships of such writers as Michael Sandel,[1] Daniel Elazar,[2] and Donald Lutz.[3]  The model also reflects the synthesis of communal, moral theorizing offered by Philip Selznick.[4]  Selznick describes his effort in the following way:

 

Although this work reflects my experience as a sociologist, I take an ecumenical view of that discipline … “[S]ocial theory,” as used in the subtitle here, includes political, legal, and moral theory.

            Like Emile Durkheim, I believe sociology is preeminently a “moral science” … Of course, many specific studies – many lines of inquiry – are mainly descriptive and explanatory … The closer we come, however, to what is central in the discipline, the more important is evaluation …

            Hence, the distinctive feature of a moral or humanist science is its commitment to normative theory, that is, to theories that evaluate as well as explain.  In political science, constitutional theory is normative or evaluative, in that it speaks to the difference between superior and inferior constitutional systems, which may be strong or weak as ways of achieving the rule of law.  Normative theory is value-centered.  It identifies values, including latent or emergent values, and studies the conditions affecting their fulfillment or frustration … [W]e consider what is genuinely valuable – and affects the fate of values – in the social worlds we study, including our own, whether or not it conforms to our preferences.[5]

 

In short, the elements of the proposed model, including the interrelationships it indicates, are based on the writings of distinguished experts and their own and reviewed research in the social sciences.

          In addition, the model is not limited to descriptive and explanatory theory, but to normative theory as well.  The needs of students – young citizens – being introduced to the structures, processes, and functions of government are more demanding than a neutral descriptive account can provide.  The application of moral standards to authority, the same source from which they receive the rules, regulations, and laws these youths are expected to obey, is inevitable.

          Whether the standards are based on short term consideration or longer-term ones are dependent on socializing agents.  Communitarian agents are what encourage longer term perspectives and permit political perspectives that are less conflictual and, according to Selznick, based on consensus.  But one should keep in mind that conflict will always be an element of political life and the liberated federalist model does not short-change that reality.

          And to see beyond that reality, to see beyond a political context in which the individual is scheming to attain the marginal advantage, the person must be socialized to standards which promote “a healthy social environment [where] this separateness [of the individual] is mitigated and obscured.”[6]

          And this posting leaves readers with the parting Selznick quote,

 

Nothing, I say, can be desired by men more excellent for their self-preservation than that all with all should so agree that they compose the minds of all into one mind, and the bodies of all one body, and all endeavour at the same time as much as possible to preserve their being, and all seek at the same time what is useful to them all as a body.  From which it follows that men who are governed by reason … desire nothing for themselves which they do not also desire for the rest of mankind, and therefore they are just, faithful, and honourable.[7]

 

In an ideal frame of mind, nothing could be more powerful and possible than these claims by Selznick.

          Next, this blog will address precision.



[1] Michael J. Sandel, Democracy’s Discontent:  America in Search of a Public Philosophy (Cambridge, MA:  The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1996).

[2] Daniel J. Elazar, American Federalism:  A View from the States (New York, NY:  Thomas Y. Crowell Company, 1966 AND “Federal Models of (Civil) Authority,” Journal of Church and State, 33 (Spring), 231-254.

[3] Donald S. Lutz, The Origins of American Constitutionalism (Baton Rouge, LA:  Louisiana State University Press, 1988).

[4] Philip Selznick, The Moral Commonwealth:  Social Theory and the Promise of Community (Berkeley, CA:  University of California Press, 1992).

[5] Ibid., xii-xiii.

[6] Ibid., 208.

[7] Ibid., 209.

Tuesday, August 8, 2023

VIABILITY OF THE LIBERATED FEDERALISM, I

 

As the last posting stated, this posting will begin a viability statement of the construct, liberated federalism model.  In doing so, this blog will utilize the ideas of Eugene Meehan and his criteria to review the perceived merits of any model or theory. Meehan’s criteria are comprehension, power, precision, consistency or reliability, isomorphism, compatibility, predictability, and control.[1]  In addition, this blogger will apply two extra criteria:  abstraction level and motivation.  Each of these will be defined as the blog addresses its concerns.

          Meehan’s criteria begin by asking whether the construct explains as many phenomena as possible, which are classified under its concepts and generalizations – i.e., its comprehension.  Comprehension asks:  does a construct explain as many phenomena related to the area of concern as possible?  Or does the construct have scope? 

Since the liberated federalism model does not limit itself to one kind of arrangement between politically active parties or any political specific condition, only that it be challenging, the construct is judged to be applicable to any political situation that a secondary school course would care to address in governmental studies.

          Usually, political situations involve groups with collective desires or demands.  Viewing politics as a group phenomenon is one way to address the scope of this model.  Another term that can be used to describe a group, arrangement, or association is an interest group.  Group theory has been basically used to study interest group behavior.[2]  This theory has been utilized in a good deal of political research through the years, leaving one with a broad literature. 

Such a theory or model uses the following variables:  leadership, cohesion, structure, group size, type of interest group, access, lobbying, and influence.  But the model presented here transcends group theory in that it does not limit its view to interest groups found outside of government.  It also includes groups within government as well.

          In addition, this model is not solely concerned with trying to explain group behavior, but with trying to place moral or critical review as to the actions and decisions that these groups or arrangements make.  As such, the scope of this model takes in more relevant concerns than does the behaviorally leaning models that were reviewed as this blog addressed political systems approaches.

          From the past, Roy Macridis offers the following insight:

 

… [G]roup theorists anchor man’s life into perennial group conflict which by their very nature groups can never transcend.  Not only our lives remain intolerably and unredeemably [sic] “nasty and brutish,” but our theoretical universe in terms of which we can explain behavior becomes unduly restricted.  Interest is the propelling force and man is forever destined to live in an environment that mirrors interest.  It may be argued that group is “realistic” and, furthermore, that the group is a far more useful concept analytically than [Karl Marx’s] “class.”  I doubt it very much – first, because group analysis as I have noted has normative implications and second and more important, because the concepts of “interests” and “group” are fuzzy analytically, perhaps just as much as that of the “class.”[3]

 

While making the concept, group, more generic – than using terms arrangement and association – perhaps it is “fuzzy” for behavioral study.  The liberated federalist model extends its instructional usefulness by including more types of conditions where people arrange themselves for political purposes.  In addition, the model incorporates the normative element that Macridis calls for above.

            As compared with the political systems approach, this federalist model offers flexibility, making it more applicable to all political behavior and any political environment within the American polity.  That is not to say it could not be applicable to other governmental setups, but the modest aim here is to address the American system.

          With its concerns for moral decision-making and action, it more suitably allows appropriate political analysis at the secondary level.  The model is an ideal against which students can measure what political actions have taken place in each case study and make judgments as to what should have taken place given the moral positions of the actors and the moral precepts of a federalist value position.

          So much for this blogger’s concerns about scope. The next posting will address the model’s treatment of power a la Meehan.



[1] Eugene J. Meehan, Contemporary Political Thought:  A Critical Study (Homewood, IL:  Dorsey Press, 1967).

[2] Robert A. Heineman, Steven A. Peterson, Thomas H. Rasmussen, American Government (New York, NY:  McGraw-Hill, Incorporated, 1995) AND Douglas J. Ahler, “The Group Theory of Parties:  Identity Politics, Party Stereotypes, and Polarization in the 21st Century,” De Gruyter (June 9, 2018), accessed August 5, 2023, https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/for-2018-0002/html?lang=en.

[3] Roy C. Macridis, “Groups and Group Theory,” in Comparative Politics:  Readings and Notes, edited by Roy C. Macridis and Bernard E. Brown (Chicago, IL:  The Dorsey Press, 1986), 281-282.