A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Friday, February 14, 2014

FINAL GASPS?

It's sad and interesting at the same time. Make no mistake about it; unless some drastic changes take place, we are seeing the death of an institution. If not its death, then its ability to be at all functional, to be viable. That institution is the American public school system. It has several strikes against it, some being systemic. For one, probably most important, it is an institution whose basic foundation goes against the grain of the prevailing economic system – a condition it has suffered since its inception. But this government run institution was able to maneuver around the capitalist environment for over one hundred and fifty years. But the times have been “a'changin” and not in the way the Dylan song referred to back in the sixties. Today, capitalist forces are playing full court offense against any organization run by non-entrepreneurs and the public school system is dead in their sights.

That's the societal level danger that public schools are facing. Now let's look at the institution itself and we do see dire dysfunctions. And in looking at this terminal process, I believe it's best to look at it through a functional approach. Specifically, the public school system is having drastic problems meeting two – at least – essential functions any institution or organization needs to meet: production and adaptability. In terms of schools, production is measured in terms of good citizenship, knowledgeable graduates, and graduation rates. Others add to these measures. They talk of schools helping in lowering crime rates, decreasing unwanted pregnancy rates, bolstering health outcomes, and the like. Some of these are legitimate; they reflect success in meeting the functions I identified above. But we need to be careful. Schools can't do it all. But they should educate in terms of preparing youngsters to be good citizens and employable. Unfortunately, the institution is not “getting it done.” A look at one of these identified measures tells enough of the story.

Graduation rates are appalling. According to Ed H. Moore,1 CEO of the Independent Colleges and Universities of Florida, three million students find school too burdensome and decide to walk away before graduation – a dropout rate of 8,300 per day. This is magnified in our urban school districts where seventeen of them have an over 50 percent dropout rate (41 percent in our 50 largest urban areas). Even when we feel we can boast – Florida just celebrated a graduation rate of 75 percent – we are still facing one in four students not graduating. For them, the one in four, we are talking about an almost certain life filled with money problems, probably marital problems, probably legal problems, etc., etc. For example, 75 percent of all crimes are committed by dropouts. We know that 90 percent of the jobs in our technically based economy demand that employees have at least a high school diploma. I think it's safe to conclude that our schools are not being productive enough.

As for adaptability, our schools don't seem to be changing fast enough. A lot of sociological (and political science) literature has been dedicated to the need for institutions and organizations to adapt to changes to their internal and external conditions. One such writer is Samuel P. Huntington.2 Here is what he points out in terms of what adaptability concerns any institution or organization needs to address in order to remain healthy and even survive into the future. The most obvious concern is change and the rate of that change. Institutions in static environments naturally have an easier job at adapting – there's little need to adapt. But, of course, we are not static. We are dynamic and the rate of dynamism is increasing. This is led by technology. But even in trying to adapt to what is now old technology, such as TV, schools still have not been able to adjust to excessive TV viewing – and its socializing effects – with which most students engage. So here comes the digital world: I phones, texting, YouTube, computer games, on and on, with all their effects. All of these developments have had their negative effects on our ability to teach kids. Yes, there are the positive effects of computers; we'll see how extensive they are. But as of now, the overall effect has been to present schools and teachers with daunting challenges.

We can further analyze this function. As it turns out, according to Huntington, the age of an institution positively relates with the ability of that institution to adapt. The older, the more experienced an institution is, the more likely it is to adapt to new challenges. Huntington identifies three ways to view age.

One is chronological. Here, public schools began somewhere near the middle of the nineteenth century (first system started in Massachusetts in 1821). Since then, the institution has adapted to many changes with varying degrees of success, probably none more challenging than desegregation with which schools are still dealing. While no one would judge the institution a beacon of light when it comes to adaptation, it still kept on functioning in relation to both the demands of the economy and to our social expectations. Some of us can remember when schools were viewed as reasonably successful – perhaps a false image to begin with but an image that perhaps gave the leaders of this institution, years ago, a false sense of invulnerability. Perhaps this level of “success” has been enough to instill an aura of invincibility among the leaders of the institution. If so, then adaptation takes on, for them, a lower level of priority. This is probably not the case now, but I do believe it was the case initially. Be that as it may, this institution today is not adapting successfully and everyone seems to know it. I feel fairly sure that most administrators of our school districts are appreciating the existential challenges they are facing as these newer changes have made themselves known.

A second way to view age is generational. That is, is its personnel turning over with the “right” types of people filling its important roles? This usually applies to leadership roles, but in terms of school, a more important personnel issue has been replacing the talented women who used to see education as that rare area of employment that society deemed acceptable for women to pursue. Of course, that all changed since the sixties and the rise of the women's lib movement. Now, all those highly talented women do what men have been able to do all along; that is, seek employment that is self-satisfying and more lucrative. And guess what? For far too many of them, teaching is not that field. And so, an internal change to the institution has been the lack of sufficiently skilled personnel to meet higher demands.

A third way to view age is the functions themselves. Here is where I believe the most challenging changes have taken place. Huntington writes:
Usually an organization is created to perform one particular function. When that function is no longer needed, the organization faces a major crisis: it either finds a new function or reconciles itself to a lingering death. An organization that has adapted itself to changes in its environment and has survived one or more changes in its principal functions is more highly institutionalized than one that has not. Functional adaptability, not functional specificity, is the true measure of a highly developed organization. Institutionalization makes the organization more than simply an instrument to achieve certain purposes.3
This passage hits on an important area of concern that affects schools. The assumption had been, back in the fifties, that schools functioned. They produced; they met their functional niche in our society. But since this demand for education is never satiated – there's always a new generation of youngsters who need to be educated – public officials were ill advised to dump new functions on this institution. And yet that's exactly what they began to do, even though evidence began to mount that indicated the institution was not meeting its initial, specific function.

And so it goes. We are watching the death of what was once a venerated institution. Our public schools are being attacked from all quarters. I even saw a clip where the in-house Fox liberal, Juan Williams, argued for choice – vouchers and charter schools. I will make a prediction: a form of public schools will survive and those schools will resemble public schools in developing countries where only the abject poor attend. These schools will literally be warehouses in which to store poor kids during the day. People with any means will send their kids to publicly subsidized schools that are run by business people, not educators. They will provide what the parents of those students want. In most cases, that is not education, but credentials. It will be only the minority of these schools that will actually educate students. We will have higher graduation rates, but we will not have more education or better citizenry.

1Moore, Ed H. (2014). Let's not endorse and enable failure: Dropping out at 16 is being sentenced to poverty. Tallahassee Democrat, February 11, p. 5.

2Huntington, S. P. (1968). Political order in changing societies. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

3Ibid., p. 15.

Monday, February 10, 2014

CRYING LESSONS

A few postings ago, I addressed the seemingly liberal tone of this blog. I tried to make a distinction that put this bias in context. I made the case that the blog is not so much liberal as it is more collectivist – as opposed to being individualist – in its treatment of governmental and political affairs, especially as they apply to civics instruction. I pointed out that since major corporations favor conservative policies and they, in turn, foster an individualist bias of their own, my concerns against the effects of corporatist policies cast many of my claims in a liberal posture: by promoting a more collectivist agenda, my arguments tend to favor what has come to be associated with liberal causes. Let me quickly make a clarifying, definitional distinction. By liberal, I mean what has come to be called liberal. In the referred-to posting I used, instead of liberal, the term progressive. In any case, I will admit my own political leaning to be liberal, but probably one that favors the center more than the extreme. I am definitely a collectivist, at least compared to what is in vogue today, but definitely not an extreme one. I am a federalist, in the more philosophic sense.

In the previous posting, to which I am referring, I claimed that there can be positions that are both conservative and collectivist. This posting is dedicated to one such position – one with which I agree. That is, we, as a society, have ignored and treated the most federalist of all unions shabbily. The family has come under severe attack and we are reaping the unfortunate consequences of such treatment. We shouldn't be surprised. With the prominence of the natural rights perspective in our political and social relations, we have found promoting the values necessary to support the family to be intrusive and, in some context, old fashioned. Yet the universal need for strong family structures is true today, is true here, as in any other time and place.

This concern for the family has been a long standing conservative position. I find their approach a bit holier than thou, but I believe they truly feel and believe in the importance of families from a practical, as well as a spiritual point of view. My interest, particularly as it relates to this posting, is on the practical. For you see, those negative consequences I alluded to above have more to do with the fate of our youngsters. All of this came to mind as I read a report by Kay S. Hymowitz.1 The report reminded me of a time when I happened to mention to my class at Miami Beach High how single parents, especially single moms, were the head of an inordinate number of poverty ridden households. Well, that message hit a tender spot for one of my students who proceeded to take me to task. You see, I was accurate, but unintentionally, I hurt the feelings of a daughter of a single mother. Apparently, they, mother and teenaged daughter, happened to be doing just fine and she took exception to how I depicted such families. I stuttered an apology, and tried to approach the subject more sensitively.

The point is, liberals have been shy about addressing this issue. But the facts are what they are and they include the persistent high incidence of poverty and immobility, both social and financial, among families headed by single mothers. Why is this the case – it's not so bad in other advanced nations. In these other countries, they have much more generous public assistance policies, but is that it? According to Hymowitz, there's more to it than that.

As for the differences that exist between us and these other nations, single parenthood, it turns out, is quite different in the US. Let me mention some of these distinctions: in the US, young women become mothers at younger ages and they live in communities where there are higher incidents of single motherhood. This develops, unfortunately, a sort of norm for such arrangements. Offspring arrive as a result of a lack of using contraception and pregnancy encourages the coupling of young adults that have little going for them besides sexual attraction. These are people who are, for the most part, strangers and who find little to hold them together after the attraction wanes. They have a child, but that isn't enough. It seems that only about a third of such relationships survive through an offspring's fifth birthday. Then we have the following conditions: “multipartner fertility,” disaffected biological fathers – as mothers attach themselves to new partners or fathers begin families with other women – and dysfunctional stepfathers. “There's substantial research showing that stepfathers are sometimes worse than none at all.”2 I might be wrong here, but this last point, I think, was the hidden message my student was communicating to me as she objected to my comments so many years ago.

What to do? First, a sober perspective of the situation is essential. We have to hold people accountable and just writing off irresponsible behavior will not do. I know we want to avoid the old days when young girls would just disappear to have out of wedlock babies. But public policy on this front cannot continue to be absent. Can government dictate dating habits? Of course not. But laws and the enforcement of them seem to be reasonable. If a person is responsible for the birth of a child, that person needs to be held, to the best of his/her ability, responsible for taking care of that child. That includes not only mothers, but biological fathers, whether they live with the child or not. And, of probably more importance, our common language should support that people be held to those responsibilities. It should shame those who shirk their responsibilities. And there seems to be hope in that regard. According to Hymowitz, there seems to be a higher level of realization that having a baby outside a meaningful relationship is not a good idea, especially if you're a teenager. As for welfare programs, we should keep them, but we should devise policies that take into account and rectify the disincentives that such government largess promotes. As Hymowitz points out, we might be providing for today's disadvantaged children at the expense of those in the future. As for this last point, I wish I could be more creative and give you a solid way to run productive welfare programs, but whatever expertise I might have lies elsewhere – in civics education.

And as for civics, the chief aim would be to bolster the more responsible language I mentioned above and with it such thinking that would lead to better decisions. This issue should have a place in a civics curriculum. The treatment should take on directly the basic idea that such dysfunctional choices, as having children outside of meaningful relations, have social as well as personal consequences. Instruction should get at the mode of thinking that has led to a certain level of indifference toward this issue. That is the line of thinking that holds we can do what we want to do as long as we don't hurt others – a la the natural rights construct. We should bring this view under severe criticism. Instruction should ask quite seriously: what constitutes hurting others; where's does the line lie between hurting someone and not hurting someone else? Does having children with an attractive person – a person for which one hardly knows or has any binding affinity – constitute moral or prudent behavior? Of course, such a message and questions ensconced in a more general curriculum that repeatedly deals with substantive moral questions would have a greater impact. No, no guarantees, but a general moral tone that encourages more responsible thinking and considerations can become one of those cultural expectations that do have a positive impact. We know that what we teach in schools has an effect. We also should know that what we don't address in school, if it relates to those predisposed desires we all share, in effect, gives related behaviors a green light.

1Hymowitz, K. S. (2014). How single motherhood hurts kids. The New York Times, February 9, Sunday Review section, p. 5.

2Ibid.

Friday, February 7, 2014

A TRUER COMPARISON

Recently in the national media there was a certain discussion about whether current calls for increasing taxes on the rich, the one percent, are comparable to what the Nazis did to the Jews in the late 1930s. Specifically, there was a reference to Kristallnacht – the Night of Broken Glass – when the Nazis launched a coordinated attack on Jewish establishments throughout Germany and parts of Austria. The attacks were conducted during the night and were characterized by the resulting broken glass from Jewish businesses and synagogues. Besides being a tasteless comparison, I believe a better comparison would have been to the French Revolution. I must admit, I never read the A Tale of Two Cities – I saw the movie. And as in the case of Les Miserables, the story graphically depicts the plight of the lower classes in pre-revolutionary France as being extremely desperate. The system, in terms of both the government and non-government, was totally dedicated to the benefit of the upper classes – royalty and the aristocracy. This exploitation continued until the lower classes had had enough and those in power, both in and out of government, paid a heavy price. Many actions of the Revolutionary government, headed by the Jacobins, went overboard – we all have seen renderings of the guillotines – but that amount of built up hatred toward their one percent found its release. You see, and I'm just speculating, the reference to Kristallnacht, instead of the French Revolution, was favored because in the case of the Nazis, their tyranny was based on a more unreasonable motivation. They were expressing an extreme form of tribalism in an industrial nation. While we can condemn the excesses of the Revolution, we can more readily understand its origins. Now, I'm not saying the French Revolution is an equitable comparison with what is going on today – it's not – but it did pit those who lacked economic resources and all that that entails with those who had extreme wealth. We're not there yet, but we are drifting in that direction, a direction where a very few own just about all there is.

That is, income and wealth mal-distribution are legitimate issues for government to address. If we listen to the political right, there seems to be a lack of understanding of this whole concern. They talk as if any mention of it is an exercise in class warfare, whereas dealing with it might very well avoid real class warfare. The right likes to support its contention with a variety of evidence – some true, some out of context, and some just plain inaccurate.

Citing our founding fathers, specifically Thomas Jefferson and James Madison, is among this evidence. In the case of Madison, we have his writings including a source I have cited in past postings: Federalist Paper Number 10. For example, there is the following:
As long as the reason of man continues fallible, and he is at liberty to exercise it, different opinions will be formed. As long as the connection subsists between his reason and his self-love, his opinions and his passions will have a reciprocal influence on each other; and the former will be objects to which the latter will attach themselves. The diversity in the faculties of men, from which the rights of property originate, is not less an insuperable obstacle to a uniformity of interests. The protection of these faculties is the first object of government. From the protection of different and unequal faculties of acquiring property, the possession of different degrees and kinds of property immediately results; and from the influence of these on the sentiments and views of the respective proprietors, ensues a division of the society into different interests and parties.
The italicized sentence above – not italicized in the original – is of particular favor among conservatives.1 It speaks to their desire to convince us that there is no communal bias in our constitution. After all, Madison didn't get the moniker, Father of the Constitution, for no reason and any bias he were to express is, therefore, a fundamental constitutional principle. But of course, all of this is taken out of context.

Remember, Madison didn't write the Constitution all by himself. The Constitution itself, even, is not in effect because it was written by those who attended the Constitutional Convention. It is in effect because the members of the separate Ratifying Conventions in the several states voted for it. And there is ample evidence that the collective wisdom of those founding fathers was highly in favor of a communal view of government and society. After all, federalism is not an individualistic view; it is a congregational view of government. It is a compromise between individualism and communalism. And if one reads the Constitution with this more nuanced eye, it makes a whole heck of a lot more sense.

Let's look at what a present day expert has to say about Madison:
[Madison] believed that the preservation of people's “different and unequal faculties of acquiring property” was “the first object of government,” but that a too-powerful government could undermine that goal. He was, therefore, more concerned with abuses of legislative and executive power than of unregulated commercial power.2
Jeffrey Rosen, CEO of the National Constitution Center, in this cited article, goes on to argue that a shortsighted aspect of Madison's concern was the potential power of national, private interests such as transnational corporations. Madison, though, when one takes in the whole sense of this paper, is concerned with excessive power in the hands of any one actor or group of actors. Madison just did not see the potential of transnational corporations that exist today – hence, his oversight. Rosen, particularly, is focused on the ability of the likes of Google and Facebook to gather and sell our private information. My concern, here, is that a reliance on Madison's thoughts concerning the rights of private concerns when it comes to wealth distribution in our times is a reliance on ideas taken out of context.

First of all, the history of government up to that time was not one of a power exercised to represent or advance the interests of the non-elites. Government, in the minds of Madison and Jefferson, was a force to represent the interests of the rich or the landed or both. There were no public welfare programs; there were no public health facilities, and there were no jobs programs or employment training efforts paid by the public treasury. The abuse came about when government was used to protect and advance the interests of the well-heeled. This is a practice not foreign to us today. It was that type of abuse that the founding generation was concerned with unless we're talking about those who benefited. It was that type of abuse, to unrelenting degrees of exploitation, that led to the French Revolution and our republic was to be a model of governance that would be able to avoid such abuse.

And let me add another word. A recurring charge by the right is that those who favor welfare or higher taxes on the rich or who favor programs such as Social Security, Medicare, or the Affordable Healthcare Act are seeking policies that aim at “equal results” – that is, they want a socialist regime to take hold. In the main, this is not true.3 What those who support these policies are serious about providing is not equal results, but equal opportunity. These are policies that address those conditions that stand in the way of less advantaged people having a real shot at the American Dream. Those who oppose them are either against equal opportunity or they have an unrealistic view of what it takes to provide it for the majority of those in the lower classes. And what is asked for will not result in anything like what faced the deposed elites of Jacobin France. What is asked for is a fair tax policy, one that asks more from those who get more for the betterment of all.

2Rosen, J. (2014). Madison's privacy blind spot. The New York Times, January 19, Sunday Review section, p. 5. This article argues that the Constitution has a deficiency and therefore needs amending. That is, it should have the expressed power to limit the power of private entities to gather and distribute private information of individuals similar to the constitutional prohibition against government to do so.

3I write “in the main” because there are socialists in this country, but they comprise a very small minority among those on the left.

Monday, February 3, 2014

A BETTER WAY?

I have during the history of this blog ascribed to our constitution an almost sacred quality. That is, as the basic compact between all Americans, it is a solemn agreement in which we federate ourselves with each other. But, for all that “sacredness,” it can be changed. Not easily, but we can either add some provision or we can delete some provision. My purpose here is not to go over the long and arduous process by which changes can be made, but to write about how a civics teacher can instruct students about the purpose of amendments to the Constitution.

The teacher can present students with proposed amendments and have students analyze them, determine the purpose of a given proposed amendment, evaluate it, and perhaps alter it to conform with what the students believe would be a better amendment. I would begin with a bit of advice I heard a long time ago (I think I heard this when I was high school). The advice is: when confronted with a proposed change to the Constitution, first say no and then look into it. That is, be disposed to reject our constitution; history has shown it works pretty well as it is. But from time to time, either structural and/or procedural governmental problems develop or problems with citizenship or voting rights arise, or it could be a problem with the relationship between the states. There are probably other sorts of problems that only a change to the Constitution will fix, but these are the types of problems that call for an amendment. And people engage in proposing new amendments all the time. Currently, there is a so-called 28th Amendment movement calling for a provision which mandates that the members of Congress be equally subject to the laws they pass. Without exemption, those who pass laws might be more careful about the effects those laws might have on the rest of us – or so the thinking goes. So, in this posting, I will present two proposed amendments that are aimed at addressing current problems. They are examples of the type of proposals teachers can present to students. I will add that they are not proposals I would necessarily vote for, but I think an argument can be made for both of them.

Before presenting these proposals, let me remind you that I am not a constitutional scholar or constitutional lawyer, so the language I am using should not be seen as being adequate to the task. I am also not claiming they are optimal in terms of what they are suggesting as to the structural changes they would implement – as a matter of fact, what they suggest could be part of what students could determine is wrong with them. But despite all that, here they are:
Proposed amendment one,
1 - Upon the recorded agreement by twenty percent of the combined number of electors – known as voters – from the various state voter registries for a proposed national law, both houses of Congress (the House of Representatives and the Senate) shall take up the proposed measure, as written and presented, for a vote of approval or disapproval within six months of its presentation to each body. If the proposed law is agreed upon by the houses of Congress and signed into law by the President, the proposal shall be statutory law.
2 - State legislatures shall enact legislation empowering appropriate state officials to provide federal government officials with voter related information necessary to administer this provision.
3 - This provision will be administered by the federal Department of State.
4 - Congress shall enact necessary legislation to implement this provision.

As suggested above, students will be asked to analyze this proposal and determine what current problem(s) this proposal is meant to address. I will share with you that the ongoing inability in Congress to pass any meaningful legislation spurred the idea of this amendment. What do you think? Is the current intransigence we see in Congress bad enough to call for such an amendment? And if so, is this the solution? Will it cause other problems? Is it too expensive a solution? These are the types of questions students can tackle and to which they can derive answers.

Proposed amendment two:
1 - The power to administer national elections is vested in a national election commission. The commission is comprised of seven members. The commission is to:
administer federal government's duties related to the election determining the members of the Congress, the President, and the Vice President;
determine the boundaries of the Congressional districts; and
administer a non-partisan informational and promotional program to encourage active participation on the part of the citizenry.
2 - The electoral commission is comprised of members who serve seven year terms and will serve as long as they maintain lawful status. The terms of members will be established as staggered with one new member selected every year. Each member is selected by one of various bodies consisting of the House of Representatives, the Senate, the President, the Supreme Court, the chief officer of the Department of State, the chief officer of the Department of Justice, and the active members of the sitting electoral commission.
3 - Members of the election commission are limited to one full term of seven years. Those initial members whose terms are fewer than seven years can be reappointed for one full term.
4 - Congress shall pass necessary legislation to administer this provision.

For this second proposed amendment, a useful line of questioning could be initiated if the teacher asks: whose power will be affected if this change were put into effect? For example, by a national body determining the composition of Congressional boundaries, state legislatures will be deprived of a very coveted power. They exercise this power every ten years after the national census. Many believe that the current inability to get things done in Washington is to a significant degree caused by how these boundaries are drawn. This was demonstrated in the 2012 election when the Democrats garnered a million more votes than Republicans in House elections, but still couldn't get control of that body. Hence, we still have divided government and we still have stymied policy makers. And another line of questioning might be about how much power a given executive administration has, under the provisions of the amendment, to determine who shall serve on the commission. Perhaps the administration should have only one choice in a given cycle and have the commission made up of five members instead of seven and have five year terms. This change to the change would have meaningful implications.

This exercise of thinking up proposed amendments is great fun. Try it. Just remember to first say no to each proposal that occurs to you.

Friday, January 31, 2014

SMALL STATE BLUES

In the last posting of this blog, I reviewed James Madison's ideas concerning the political sins committed in small territorial republics. In short, he argued that in a small republic the common good is less likely to be achieved because in a small political arena the chances are that one or very few factions – interest groups – would have inordinate influence over government policy makers. Why? Because relative to the wealth of the republic, these interest group(s) would own or have control over a significant amount of that wealth and/or other political resources. As I mentioned in that posting, Madison had first-hand knowledge of what he argued since he belonged to the elite group that controlled the politics of his home state, Virginia. He was the owner of a plantation. So were Washington, Jefferson, and Monroe, to name a few. Of course, all four of these examples later became presidents of the national republic. But even if we agree with Madison's argument based on conditions of over two hundred years ago, does his view still hold today?

In this context, I found a report on the politics of West Virginia very interesting. In that small republic, apparently their politics are not controlled by a gaggle of plantation owners, but instead their politics are highly influenced by the coal and chemical industries. This arrangement came to national attention lately when a chemical company's storage tank developed a hole which in turn caused a highly toxic chemical to ooze into that West Virginian area's drinking water. This resulted in 300,000 people being deprived of usable water for days. The effects of the contamination continued to affect the folks in the area as they remained suspect of the water since it continued to smell. Since then, it still has not been determined how extensive the toxicity of the water supply is and, to date, 400 people have been reported ill as a result of the spill.1

Is this just an anomaly, a case of an accident, or is it closer to being the result of an industry being too cushy with the state government – a la Madison? Or stated another way, has the chemical company been allowed to run its affairs in a purely self-serving way; that is, to further or protect its financial interests? What is it?

Let's look at the record as it applies to both the coal mining and chemical industries. In the mining industry, worldwide, thousands die annually. In this country, the incidence of fatal accidents has become significantly fewer although through the twentieth century there were some memorable events. For example, in 1968 there was the Farmington, W. Va. mining disaster that killed 78 miners. I highlight this incident because among those who lost their lives was Senator Joe Manchin's uncle and five classmates. Today Manchin is a strong defender of the coal and chemical industries. As it turns out, West Virginia has been afflicted with five major incidents involving the coal and chemical industries in eight years.2

Apparently this latest incident is not an anomaly:
“This crisis is about much more than a renegade chemical company,” said Bob Kincaid, board president of Coal River Mountain Watch, an organization based in Raleigh County in the state's southern coal fields that fights mountaintop-removal mining. “It's about an entire state subjected day after day for more than a century to a laundry list of poisons by renegade companies. This particular poisoning happened to catch the world's attention, but for us, it's another day in the Appalachian Sacrifice Zone.”

The question is, [w]ill the nation continue to turn a blind eye to the mounting toll of the aging extraction industry on the health and livelihoods of central Appalachians or take action against the growing, untenable costs of mining, cleaning, transporting and burning dirty coal?3
But the question remains, how has the state government of West Virginia acted in relation to these conditions?

According to The New York Times article, cited here, the following list of actions has characterized the state government's response to the related health and safety issues:
  • There are no state laws that regulate the storage location of chemicals such as those that leaked from the tanks in question. Therefore, these tanks, situated dangerously close to the Elk River, the major fresh water supply of the area, were legally placed. A distinction between production facilities and storage facilities exists in state law but there are no regulations addressing storage.
  • Federal law, in which West Virginia's representatives have had influential roles determining its content, requires reporting chemical storage facilities, but does not call for inspection of them.
  • State officials did not deem the spilled chemical into the Elk River as deserving a legal designation as “extremely hazardous” despite the fact the company that owned the tanks had described them as “immediate (acute) hazards.”
  • In 2010, the state government sued the Environmental Protection Agency over its water pollution standards as they applied to the coal industry. This position was recently bolstered by the current governor when he was quoted as saying, “ never back down from the E. P. A.”
  • West Virginia has a unique provision in its environmental laws which states that any new regulation written by its environmental agency has to get a majority vote in both houses of its legislature before taking effect. This is a significant extra hurdle that pending regulations have to overcome before taking effect. The legislature has the authority to change any details, including striking any provision of any regulation.
  • The state has allowed the oil company, Halliburton, to keep confidential the chemicals it uses in its fracturing activities despite state regulations to the contrary.
  • The state's environmental regulatory department recently began allowing an increase in the allowable amounts of aluminum, a toxic mining pollutant, into the state's waterways. This pollutant, beyond being toxic to fish, is expensive to remove.
  • State officials have filed lawsuits against PPG Industries at the request of PPG. The aim was to outmaneuver lawsuits by environmental groups. State lawsuits call for much more lenient decisions toward PPG's water pollution activities than would have been called for if the environmental groups' lawsuits would have been successful.
  • Current efforts to update the Toxic Substances Control Act – of 1976 vintage – are being pushed by the state of West Virginia's representation in Congress. The update has been judged by the Natural Resources Defense Council's representative as toothless. It doesn't even legislate the disclosure of information or further regulate the toxic substance that oozed into the Elk River.
  • The state's environmental regulatory department, which employs 800 people, has a separate office to regulate the coal industry. According to one knowledgeable observer, “Dow Chemical and a car wash are regulated in the same office. Mining gets a separate office.”4 Since the observer refused to be identified for fear of retribution, the implication is that the arrangement exists to give coal companies favorable treatment.

Is this a cherry-picked list of complaints? Perhaps; I'm not an expert. But given the state's apparent support of the coal and chemical industries, perhaps this favoritism is allowed and even encouraged if it results in providing benefits to the people of West Virginia. Well, according to the Times, West Virginia is 49th out of 50 states in median household income (it was 46th in 1969). The coal industry today hires about 4 percent of the labor force. And yet Manchin was quoted as saying, “[i]f it weren't for the resources we had here, you wouldn't have the middle class.” Whether the “we” is the national middle class or that of West Virginia, it is Senator Manchin's job to represent the interests of all the people in his state. Are the politics of this small republic advancing the interests of these people? Or is it as Madison warned: advancing and protecting the interests of its few major factions?

1Breslin, S. (2014). West Virginia chemical spill worse than initially reported. The Weather Channel, January 28, http://www.weather.com/news/science/environment/west-virginia-chemical-spill-latest-20140128. 
 
2Gabriel, T., Wines, M., and Davenport, C. (2014). In a state wary of regulations, a chemical spill changes little. The New York Times, January 19, pp. 1 and 16 (“front page” section). Most of the facts reported in this posting were derived from this article.

3Biggers, J. (2014). How dirty coal foretold West Virginia's disaster. Aljazeera America, January 14, http://america.aljazeera.com/opinions/2014/1/west-virginia-chemicalspillcoalminingcleanwater.html .

4Op. cit., Gabriel, Wines, and Davenport, p. 16.

Monday, January 27, 2014

DOES THE MADISONIAN SOLUTION WORK?

“Hope for the best, prepare for the worst” is an adage I find particularly insightful. This, to a great deal, is how I see our constitution. The founding fathers, I believe, were motivated by a variety of reasons. Among them was a federalist hope to forge a nation that could congregate to meet the opportunities and challenges of the future. But they also had a healthy respect for the reality that times do change. While they laid down a blueprint with a set of goals and a structural plan for government, they made those goals broad enough and the structure and implied processes open enough to allow us, their inheritors, the ability to work out our responses to those opportunities and challenges we would meet along the way. That was the hope and as far as the foibles of being human, the structure was to address the worst: the inevitable attempts by some to exploit the situations to come.

How? They made it so that interests would find themselves pitted against those counter- interests in the competition for society's benefits. The worst would be met with a governmental mechanism which would derive the best – or at least the workable – by having people's countervailing interests vie for what would be wanted. Yes, they would compete in markets, but they also would compete before public policy makers and public policy implementers. Oh yes; they also would compete before the courts that interpret those policies.

This approach at meeting the worst is intentional. The “father of the Constitution,” James Madison, explained the thinking in Federalist Papers, Number 10. There Madison points out that in small republics, there are a limited number of interests or factions. Usually one or a very few number of factions who control the most number of financial assets can pretty well run the politics of the republic. Of course, Madison, being a Virginian, saw how the plantation owners controlled just about every aspect of southern life. These elites sponsor and support those policies that benefit them at the expense of the common good. But if the republic is large, then there are many wealthy factions whose wealth and power are derived from a variety of sources. And when one of them sets out on a strategy that offends the others, then the others will respond. These others will apply pressure on policymakers to get government to reign in that overly selfish faction. In the case of the thirteen newly formed states, you had the northern small farmers; the middle states had the tradesmen and farmers, and the South had those plantation owners. And to really put diversity into the mix, the North had a burgeoning industrial faction. Here, already along the Atlantic seaboard, a fine array of economic interests existed and promised to develop much further.

This theory of balanced governance was somewhat contrary to what was accepted as truth: republics needed to be small territorially. The political philosophers of the time followed ideas of such thinkers as Charles-Louis Montesquieu. They argued that for a republic to maintain the loyalty of its citizens – that is, for the citizenry to not engage in unbridled, self-serving strategies that would be to the detriment of all – they would need to be psychologically attached to their fellow citizens. This would be promoted by a small territory in that such a jurisdiction would be populated by the personal relations that smallness allows. In such a republic, citizens would be disposed to not act in an overly selfish way. In larger republics, the people would lose many of the personal relations that marked the social realities of a small area. And without such relations, citizens would follow their selfish natures and act in too self-serving ways. Therefore, to be in a large republic is to be in a republic with a short-lived future.

But the hypothetical relation between small size and longevity of republics offered by these philosophers proved to be wrong. We experienced how wrong they were between the years of the Revolutionary War and the writing of the 1787 constitution. During those years, we were a confederation of small republics – thirteen of them. We found the “worst” prevailed just fine. We found serious class warfare break out culminating with Shay's Rebellion; we saw the republics engage in shortsighted policies against their sister republics; we saw a serious reluctance to pay for the mutual benefiting policies such as maintaining the national military. Things were a mess and getting worse; hence, the call for a constitutional convention. But, in the public mind, the assumption was: in order for republics to last, they needed to rule over small territories.

Madison gave the public discourse another view – the one outlined above. And so, the “expanded republic” was born. But does the expansion of a republic really handle abuse as Madison foresaw? Well, we have had a Civil War; we have had the growth of corporate power which many believe is killing our republic, and we have increasing inequality that belies any claim to having equality. These are troubling developments. Where are the rise of countering factions to reign in those who are acting in an abusive way which has led to these troubles? I have wondered, for example, as we experience climate change and the resulting droughts and increased incidents and viciousness of tornadoes, why those victimized don't organize themselves and begin an organized campaign against those responsible for changing our climate – I'm told by the bulk of scientists – the fossil fuel producers. That would be the Madisonian solution. What's going on or what's not going on?

One, those who benefit from abusive behavior have invested in propaganda efforts to do two things: de-legitimize the evidence that connects their behavior to the harmful effects being felt and de-legitimize government inserting itself in addressing any area of concern – emphasizing the notion that the government that governs less, governs best. Two, the propaganda has worked and affected people to not engage in the necessary political activity that might result in the needed pressure to change things. We have such movements as the Tea Party that mistakenly argues that the founding fathers hated government. Three, business entities understand the danger of setting costly precedents that will negatively affect other monied interests in the future. If you can make corporations, for example, pay for external costs – such as pollution – what will that mean to other corporations who are responsible for external costs? Four, there are the honest concerns over the costs that will result from changing the established practices of business entities, including costs to consumers. What will it cost all of us, for example, if we stop or significantly cut back on using fossil fuels? It won't be cheap. You might be able to think of other hindrances blocking other factions from doing the Madisonian thing. But there are cases in which we are starting to see affected parties being motivated to counter the actions of the abusers or alleged abusers.

You see, in our example, climate change is beginning to step on very big toes. The concern for Coca-Cola might have begun in 2004. That's when the soft drink maker lost its contract in India. There, drought has caused water shortages: “[w]hen we look at our most essential ingredients, we see those events [droughts] as threats”1 stated a Coca-Cola executive. Joining Coke in its concerns over climate change are the World Bank, led by its president, Jim Young Kim, and Nike. Whether these toes are big enough is a question we will have answered. There are many ways to act against corporate power, especially if you represent another corporate power. For example, you can sponsor alternative energy technologies. Each of these entities has its own affected interests. They, in this case, might find it beneficial to push for the development of other fuels, but fossil fuel interests are not alone in advancing their interests. China and India, the new large economies emerging from lesser developed status, are highly dependent on fossil fuels to “fuel” their growth.

And so we have a Madisonian conflict, one in which vested interests will engage in the politics of energy. Who will win is an interesting question and one in which we all have our own interests at stake. I wish I could report that the public will play a meaningful role. But our history suggests that an active citizenry is stirred sufficiently to act only when enough of them experience direct results of existing conditions. I and many of my cohorts were involved with the politics of Vietnam. By and large, despite our democratic rhetoric, we simply did not want to get drafted and end up being a statistic on the battlefield for a cause in which we did not believe. Madison didn't promise us an easy political future, just one that plans for the “worst.” Here's hoping that he was right when it comes to the big questions such as climate change.

1Davenport, C. (2014). Threat to bottom line spurs action on climate. The New York Times, January 23, http://nytimes.newspaperdirect.com/epaper/viewer.aspx . The facts concerning the politics of fossil fuel producers vs. other entities such as Coca-Cola, which are reported in this posting, were derived from this article.

Friday, January 24, 2014

EQUALITY BEFORE THE COURT

There are times when our government gets close and personal with us. I cannot think of any time when this is more true than when our government drafts us into military service or when the government, either at the federal or state level, charges us with a crime. Now-a-days we have put the draft into hiatus and most of us are never charged with a crime. I remember when as a young man, I was in a car accident and was charged with causing it. I was directed to go to court and I remember the document stating the State of Florida vs. Robert Gutierrez. The actual charge was driving too fast for the conditions. I remember my emotional discomfort when I saw in black and white that I was pitted against the State of Florida. I think that hurt more than the $25 fine – and that was despite the fact I was a poor college student at the time and was facing expensive costs caused by the damage. As bad as it is to be charged, how much worse is it when a person can't afford legal representation? This wasn't an issue in my case, but for serious accusations it is an issue of significant consequence. It is our constitutional right to have representation by a licensed lawyer. So, as the familiar refrain states, if you can't afford one, one will be appointed for you.

Who assigns an indigent defendant a lawyer? A judge does. Problem solved? Not really. Take the case of George Stinney from the 1940s (a story much in the news these days); he was a fourteen year old boy who was charged, tried, and executed for the murder of two white girls – Stinney was an African American youngster. His incarceration lasted 81 days, there was no physical evidence of his guilt, the trial lasted two hours, and there was no appeal filed by his court-appointed lawyer. The only “evidence” there was was the fact that Stinney was seen with the two girls on the day of the murders and that he had “confessed.” There was no written account or a recording of the confession. There was only the testimony of the police officers stating the young boy confessed to the crimes. While this is an extreme case from a highly segregated South, it is not unique. How unjust the criminal procedure can be has been amply portrayed in our popular media. We hear of a sufficient number of convictions that have been overturned by DNA testing. My understanding is that nationally there are over 4,000 such cases to date. How many of those were cases initially defended by court-appointed lawyers, I don't know. But the point here is that the system is flawed enough and that we need to address this area of concern. If we are serious about our claims of honoring equality – we have stamps on which the word is boldly printed – then we need to do what we can to minimize the chances of an injustice occurring within our legal system. We need to keep very clear in our minds what an injustice of this type means to those victimized. It means, in terms of a faulty verdict, that a person is condemned for a crime he or she did not commit and that that means a person is doomed to years of imprisonment or even an undeserved execution – a horrible consequence to consider. Yet we seem to tolerate an unacceptable level of probability that such a result happens and happens all too often. So if something – some change in policy – can minimize this probability, we are constitutionally obliged to pursue it.

Under this light, I found that there is an experiment being conducted in Texas that deserves mention. There, in Comal County, it has been determined that court-appointed lawyers are a source of serious systemic injustices.
“The fundamental problem is that [court-appointed] lawyers in this country are oftentimes beholden to judges for appointments,” said Norman Lefstein [a Texas official] … “The allegiance of the lawyer is not principally to client, where it ought to be.”

The other problem is that clients have no meaningful control over this important professional relationship. It is hard to trust a lawyer you have not chosen and generally cannot fire.1
These Texas officials addressed these concerns by developing a conservative approach to the problem. That is, they have begun issuing vouchers to defendants so that they can purchase legal representation of their own choosing. The idea for this policy originally was presented in a law-reviewed article. The authors of this article are Stephen Schulhofer and David Friedman. I believe that the proposal appealed to conservative policy makers because of its reliance on a market solution. It has been criticized by respectable experts – for example, Judge Richard A. Posner, a federal appeal judge, fears that defendants could paralyze a local legal system if they all begin to demand the same lawyer or a select few number of lawyers. I personally don't see this as a possibility since a lawyer can beg off a case if he or she is overloaded with existing clients. A Comal official claims that implementation of the policy can be regulated in such ways that the main concerns can be addressed. One official stated that this will not be a purely free market. It will be monitored and regulated. It is believed by the officials who are implementing the policy that there will be practical limitations so that the system will continue to function under reasonable conditions.

I will not claim I know enough to pass judgment on this option, but I believe that consideration for it is justified. My main message here is that this is an ideal “federalist” issue and has the makings of a powerful civics lesson. It focuses on a condition that, as it is now experienced around the country, puts in question any claim that our justice system is run by the principle of equality. In addition, here is a proposed policy option that, at least in terms of its stated rationale, is meant to level the legal playing field. If it works, it will put substance into the promise of the fifty year old Supreme Court decision, Gideon v. Wainwright, which ruled that every poor defendant is entitled to legal representation. Whether giving these defendants the ability to choose their attorneys will rectify the systemic problems such defendants face, only time will tell.

In any event, for civics instructors this issue is a promising one, one that directly relates to our national goal of instituting meaningful equality, one that is suitable to analyzing actual and proposed solutions, and one that reflects real, active concerns with ample local examples. It has the promise of engaging students on a meaningful national problem.

1Liptak, A. (2013). Need-blind justice. The New York Times, January 5, Sunday Review section, p. 4. The facts related in this posting regarding this Texas experiment are contained in this source.