A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Friday, May 14, 2021

A GOOD PLACE FOR A BELL

To continue from the last posting, this entry looks at the development of Pennsylvania in mostly the 1700s.  But before the turn into the eighteenth century an event in the seventeenth century is going to have a good deal of an effect on the new one.  And that would be the conversion of William Penn to Quakerism.  That happened in 1663.  The effect would be that Penn used his land grant to establish Pennsylvania so as to, in part, provide refuge for his fellow Quakers.  And that would initiate the initial migration to this granted area in North America.

          But Quakers would soon be joined by emigrating Germans and Scot Irish people.  Despite that, Quaker beliefs had profound influence on Penn and his original ideas of governance.  First, Quakers were considered radical Puritans, but unlike other radicals, they, in their beliefs, democratized the dispensing of God’s grace.  They believed that each person shared in God’s grace in some varied way so that each person has a special or unique value or worth. 

Therefore, according to this resulting aura in each person, each is unique with the potential to make his/her own contribution.  The belief further sees each person as equal, and it projects a responsibility for each to look after all others.  This includes for one to do what is necessary, and within one’s power and ability, to protect others from harm.  In addition, Quakers emphasize that people rely on their inner conscious experiences – one’s conscience serves as a basis for a moral life.[1]  One can observe the effects of such a belief system on the actions of Penn and of his cohorts.

One aspect of this bias can be detected, and mentioned in the previous posting, about how Penn interacted with indigenous people.  Despite his land grant, he initiated and completed a series of agreements with the local tribe leaders to attain tracts of land.  Some of the details of these additions are involved, but one can judge Penn’s actions as above board in every case.

Another aspect of this bias was how it attracted its early “fellow travelers” – they have been described as the dredges of society.  It was from those ranks that the first immigrants were recruited.  And it is those who, once on this side of the Atlantic, started what was to become a very industrious and successful colony.  To be measured, though, Quakers never accounted for more than ten percent of the immigrants that would populate this land mass.  Eventually, the immigrant population became anglicized (including Penn’s son).[2]

          One uncommon result of the Quaker influence, uncommon as compared to Massachusetts, Connecticut, and Virginia, was that religion’s anti formal education bias.  Unlike the other colonies, Pennsylvania delayed any establishment of an academy or higher educational facility.  To recall, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and Virginia each had one – Harvard, Yale, and William and Mary. 

In 1740, the Academy of Philadelphia was started, and that institution became first the College of Philadelphia and then the University of Pennsylvania.  Despite, or because of its later start, the institution took on an Enlightenment prone curriculum almost from its beginning.  Some of the famous names of Enlightened thinkers one can associate with the University of Pennsylvania include William and John Alison, John Ewing, Benjamin Rush, and, of course, Benjamin Franklin.[3]

And this short overview of the Pennsylvania colony should share some information as to the beginnings of Philadelphia and, by doing so, more information can be added as to Penn’s efforts in this settlement.  And one question the reader might ask, why did Charles II grant the initial lands that were to become Pennsylvania and Delaware to a Quaker.  Well, the grant was to satisfy a loan the king had with Penn’s father, Admiral Penn, mentioned earlier in this blog.  And part of the story includes a conflict with Maryland since the Penn grant overlaid with territory issued to Lord Baltimore and a resulting armed conflict, Cresap’s War, settled the dispute.

Shortly after that conflict, Penn organized a colonizing expedition.  Penn himself led this effort and upon landing (in New Castle, Delaware) set out to establish a peaceful change of government from Baltimore’s claims in which its people pledged allegiance to the new proprietor, Penn.  This led to the first structured government, previously described. 

Moving up the Delaware River, Penn, along with a group of fellow Quakers, then founded Philadelphia in order to secure religious freedom of the group.  Without going into the details, these developments had as a backdrop a complicated set of antagonism with local tribes.  These pitted settlers in Maryland against Susquehannocks and the settlement of nearby areas by other European immigrants, e.g., Dutch, Swedish, and English in what would become Delaware and New Jersey.

As for the general areas of what became Philadelphia, they drew the interest of European explorers all the way back to 1609 when Henry Hudson was actively seeking a Northwest Passage to the Far East.  Some years later the New Sweden Company engaged in fur trade activities.  This included the building of a fort.  A series of claims and establishment of business enterprises followed – including the establishment of New Sweden – but it had difficulties remaining viable.  But as far as establishing a permanent settlement, it was the Penn group that did so.

He, upon arriving at that area, found about fifty people – mostly subsistence farmers – making their livings there.  From the start, he foresaw a city as a safe zone for people of all faiths.  They would be able to practice their religions in freedom and be able to live peacefully together.  Penn personally appreciated this vision because he had experienced discrimination due to his Quakerism. 

He also was an early visionary who saw the Enlightened urban plan of a grid outlay that would mimic English rural towns rather than its crowded cities.  He also advocated spacious house plots which could have gardens and even orchards.  The first purchasers would be allotted plots along the river.  He planned for a commercial center, a state house, and some other key buildings.[4]

In this Philadelphia story, one does not see any diminution of federated values.  If anything, Penn encouraged those foundational elements that would enhance the institutional qualities that not only allowed it to influence how the various polities got started but encouraged people to think in terms of adopting federal values in how they saw governance should occur.  This included high degrees of tolerance for believers of other faiths and even accommodation of indigenous people. 

In short, the combination of Puritanical thinking and Enlightenment ideas and ideals, while contrary on many levels, did not contradict each other in this area of concern at least under the leadership of Penn.  Here is how the History Channel describes Pennsylvania’s origins:

 

Philadelphia, a city in Pennsylvania whose name means City of Brotherly Love, was originally settled by Native American tribes, particularly the Lenape hunter gathers, around 8000 B.C.

By the early 1600s, Dutch, English and Swedish merchants had established trading posts in the Delaware Valley area, and in 1681, Charles II of England granted a charter to William Penn for what would become the Pennsylvania colony.

Penn arrived in the new city of Philadelphia in 1682. A Quaker pacifist, Penn signed a peace treaty with Lenape chief Tamanend, establishing a tradition of tolerance and human rights.

But in 1684, the ship Isabella landed in Philadelphia carrying hundreds of enslaved Africans. Tensions over slavery, especially among local Quakers, resulted in the 1688 Germantown Petition Against Slavery, the first organized protest against slavery in the New World.

Penn’s colony thrived, and soon Philadelphia was the biggest shipbuilding center in the colonies. Among those attracted to the city was Benjamin Franklin, who in 1729, became the publisher of The Pennsylvania Gazette.

The Pennsylvania State House—later known as Independence Hall—held its first Assembly meeting there in 1735. State representatives ordered a large bell for the building in 1751 with a Biblical inscription: “Proclaim LIBERTY throughout all the Land unto all the inhabitants thereof.”[5]

 

Of course, Philadelphia would play a central role in the events leading up to the Revolution.



[2] Allen C. Guelzo, The American Mind, Part I – a transcript book – (Chantilly, VA:  The Teaching Company/The Great Courses, 2005). 

[3] Ibid.

[5] History.com Editors, “Philadelphia,” History Channel (March 8, 2019), accessed May 13, 2021, https://www.history.com/topics/us-states/philadelphia-pennsylvania .  

Tuesday, May 11, 2021

PENN PENS-IN INCLUSION

 

The next colonial tale this blog wishes to review is that of Pennsylvania, but as promised in the last posting, a short overview is helpful.  That would be a comparison between initial natural rights view and a federal view.  The reason for this insertion at this time is that the development of Pennsylvania took place mostly during the 1700s – it started its existence as a colony in 1681 when William Penn was issued the land grant by King Charles II.  And, the ensuing years, as this blog has already described, saw an increased influence of Enlightenment ideas.

          Along with those ideas, John Locke’s arguments were being considered by the American educated class.  Locke would pose serious questioning of prevailing either feudalistic notions, to the extent they existed in America, but also Puritanical rationales that promoted a more equitable social arrangement – as opposed to an Anglican/Roman vertical view that supports hierarchical church structures and power distributions.  Locke’s ideas, as he initially proposed them, promoted what would he called a “social contract” approach to the founding and development of polities.

          In formulative language, he described polities being initially created by free-standing individuals.  With complete freedom to act as each person wished, to formulate an authoritative entity for mutual benefits, each would surrender those rights – and only those rights – that allow for such an arrangement and retain all other rights.  This is a social contract.  And given the retention of each person’s bulk of rights – naturally endowed – this approach to government and politics can be called the natural rights approach or view.  These ideas were part of the array of Enlightenment ideas which also supported non-Lockean arguments.

Here is how Stanford Encyclopedia describes Lock’s contribution:

 

In the Two Treatises of Government, [Locke] defended the claim that men are by nature free and equal against claims that God had made all people naturally subject to a monarch. He argued that people have rights, such as the right to life, liberty, and property, that have a foundation independent of the laws of any particular society.  Locke used the claim that men are naturally free and equal as part of the justification for understanding legitimate political government as the result of a social contract where people in the state of nature conditionally transfer some of their rights to the government in order to better ensure the stable, comfortable enjoyment of their lives, liberty, and property.  Since governments exist by the consent of the people in order to protect the rights of the people and promote the public good, governments that fail to do so can be resisted and replaced with new governments.  Locke is thus also important for his defense of the right of revolution.  Locke also defends the principle of majority rule and the separation of legislative and executive powers. In the Letter Concerning Toleration, Locke denied that coercion should be used to bring people to (what the ruler believes is) the true religion and also denied that churches should have any coercive power over their members.  Locke elaborated on these themes in his later political writings, such as the Second Letter on Toleration and Third Letter on Toleration.[1]

 

What this blog has shared is that the ideas of Locke have been misinterpreted today – a philosophic point of contention – and have, therefore, helped lead the nation to the current polarized political landscape.  So, to help understand Pennsylvanian history and to help understand the current political debate, it is useful to review a set of distinctions between natural rights view and federal view.

          This review is organized by comparing the positions of these views in relation to a list of issues.  The issues are general conception amongst people, moral role of government, era of dominance in American history, and expectations of individuals.

 

·       General conception amongst people:  natural rights view sees that political order is equal to marketplace relationships (competing interests); federal view sees that political order is equal to a commonweal (undivided interests)

·       Moral role of government:  natural rights view is neutral to this issue, it provides protection for individual moral positions and its emphasis is on governmental procedures (e.g., due process rights); federal view provides structural prerequisites for self-rule by which local/communal moral positions vie in the consideration of proposed policy

·       Era of dominance:  natural rights view has been dominant in the last 70 plus years; federal view was dominant from the beginning of colonial existence to the late 19th century with strong influence, if not dominance, through the New Deal and World War II period

·       Expectation of individual:  natural rights view expects people to be respectful of others’ rights and behavior from a self-interest point of view; federal view expects active participation in creating a common environment and caring attitudes of fellow citizens and for the whole community.

 

So, with these general distinctions, one can better understand Pennsylvania evolvement.

          Pennsylvania (or Penn’s Woods) was granted to Penn late in the 1600s.  Actually, the territory is named for Penn’s father, Admiral Sir William Penn.  The family retained ownership of the grant until the American Revolution at which time the family was expelled.  The grant would eventually lead to two colonies, Pennsylvania and Delaware.

          Original settlers were mostly Penn’s fellow Quakers.  That religion was originally a radical form of Puritanism.  In addition to British Quakers, the area attracted large numbers of Germans and Scot Irish people.  One can detect that German influence by the number of towns or areas in Pennsylvania holding German or German derived names.  Roughly 30 percent of current Pennsylvanians claim German ancestry.[2]  And while initial relations with indigenous people, the Lenape, were cordial, eventual war broke out between settlers and local tribes (especially as extensions of the French and Indian War hostilities).

          The first efforts to establish a government was an extension of the land grant.  William Penn was the appointed governor, although he did not live there, and a 72-member council and larger general assembly constituted the colonies governance.  This did not work, and subsequent “frames of government” were written and put into effect in 1683, 1696, and 1701.  The last instrument was known as the Charter of Privileges and served as an organizing document until the American Revolution.  The next frame was to be a constitution, i.e., a compact-al instrument.

          Admittedly, Penn’s initial and subsequent “constitutions” were not occurrences in which a people gathered to hammer out an organizing document to arrange for a structure of governance and spelling out the other functions of government.  But Penn can be judged as being highly influenced by federal principles.  Here is a short overview of his handiwork:

 

[Upon visiting America in 1699], he put forward a plan to make a federation of all English colonies in America.  There have been claims that he also fought slavery, but that seems unlikely, as he owned and even traded slaves himself.  However, he did promote good treatment for slaves, and other Pennsylvania Quakers were among the earliest fighters against slavery.[3]

 

One can readily read that he was biased toward inclusion and, given his Puritanical view, was biased against hierarchical structures.       

          But in all of this, one should not lose sight that Pennsylvania was a business arrangement and, unfortunately, Penn was not above racists attitudes prevalent during his time (and one can argue, still exist today).  But he had a demonstrable federal bent.  He attempted inclusive policies and even sided at times against his commercial interests.  And to put a finer point on this portrayal, this blog has clearly indicated that the federal views that existed at the time limited their inclusiveness to white, European peoples and has given that version of federalism the name parochial/traditional federalism.

          This blog will at this point stop this story and pick it up in the next posting with the political developments that characterize that colony’s experience in the years leading up to the Revolution and independence.  What one generally sees in that history is the story of an industrious people and the development of the colonies’ first prominent urban center, Philadelphia.



[1] “Locke’s Political Philosophy,” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2005/2020), accessed May 10, 2021, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/locke-political/#:~:text=Locke%20used%20the%20claim%20that,better%20ensure%20the%20stable%2C%20comfortable .  What exactly Locke’s views mean is of great philosophic debate.  This blog, from time to time, has alluded to the fact that even Locke did not believe what has come to be seen his ideas to mean today.  This citation goes on to describe this point.  There are those who emphasize, even to the exclusion of other concerns, that Locke posed a position of natural rights.  This position argues everyone can do what he/she wishes as long as he/she does not interfere with the rights of others.  But there is another interpretation:  that is, once formulated under governance, individuals have certain duties and obligations under a principle of natural law.  Here, the door is opened to consider religious notions of what makes up natural law.  Be that as it may, the point is that a purely hedonistic view of rights would be averted if this latter view was adopted.

[2] See “Pennsylvania German Language,” Wikipedia (n.d.), accessed May 10, 2021, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pennsylvania_German_language .  Of note also has been the immigration of a good number of Dutch people.

[3] “Brief History of William Penn.” William Penn (n.d.), accessed June 8, 2020, https://www.ushistory.org/penn/bio.htm . 

Friday, May 7, 2021

VIRGINIA: A DIFFERENT BASIS, ONE SIMILAR RESULT

As one leaves the New England colonies, where the Puritan influence was so strong, and looks at the other colonies, say Virginia and Pennsylvania, one encounters some highly distinguishing social elements and some common ones as well.  What seems to prevail in all the colonies is a foundational understanding of governance and politics. 

That leads to a set the basic assumptions of how government should be set up and, therefore, reflects agreement about basic related values.  In addition, that similarity led to agreements about what government is and how it should function.  Generally, an overall description of this similarity can be characterized as federal thinking.

          A colony that predated settlement in New England is Virginia.  Thirteen years before the first settlement in Massachusetts was established in 1620, the Jamestown settlement of Virginia was established in 1607.  While there were three types of colonial arrangements – property colonies, charter colonies, royal colonies – given the inability to garner immediate profits, and in terms of the Crown, indifference, all the colonies devolved into being free standing entities establishing local governance.

          The initial businesses that set up the colonies, for the most part, were unsuccessful (the Virginia Company went bankrupt in 1622), but the role the colonies were to play in the prevailing mercantilist system was to provide natural resources to the mother country, England.  Given this overall aim, a lot of policy was accepted that might have been at least questioned otherwise.  That would include the introduction and furtherance of slavery.

          The first slaves were introduced in 1619 as they were brought to Jamestown.[1]  These unfortunates were to work on certain agricultural products – rice, sugar, tobacco, and eventually cotton.  These crops lend themselves to large land allotments and, given the geography of the area, the development of the plantation economy quickly came to be.

          Another difference between Virginia and New England was that Virginia was not settled by Puritans.  In that more southern area, Anglicans initially populated that colony.  This was offset a bit with a level of popularity for Puritanism among the first natural born generation of Virginians. 

Despite this variance, almost from the beginning, there was a similarity between the constituting documents written and enacted in New England and those that will guide the way in Virginia.  Donald Lutz reports on an initial Virginia document:

 

Under its initial charter, Virginia was run by a cumbersome double council.  A thirteen-member council in Virginia to carry out its will.  The system did not work, and the Virginia governor had to become a virtual dictator to maintain order.  The [Articles, Laws, and Orders, Divine, Politic, and Martial for the Colony of Virginia, 1610] was issued under martial law but still reflects the values that were generally accepted by the colonists.  It is equivalent to a code of law and may be fruitfully compared with the other codes of law [found among the colonies].  Religion plays an important role in this Virginia document, as it did in codes elsewhere, and the moral content looks similar to that of New England codes.  … The similarities with the Puritans may have been due to the predominance of “low church” members, who while remaining securely in the fold, shared many of the Puritan inclinations against pomp, status, and other vestiges of what was termed covert popery.[2]

 

This gave way to representative governance, defined by compact, shortly afterward.

          The general attitude of the English Crown to the developments in Virginia was to mostly ignore any problems.  This led to the company’s employees to organize themselves that led naturally to a federating model.  Naturally, one can attribute their already existing biases for representative governance due to England’s parliamentary tradition, but with the Crown being so far off and mostly indifferent, one can see federated bonding as a normal mode of advancing a structured polity.

          And this indifference would last for the greater part of the 1600s.  That is not to say certain actions by the Crown would have inconsequential effects.  It, for example, issued highly generous grants to its favored parties such as when it granted William Penn Pennsylvania in 1682, the Carolinas to the Carolina Properties in 1632, New York to the Duke of York in 1666, and so on.[3]  But as the colonies became viable and then lucrative – along with some uppity biases – the interest among British policy makers would change.

          And then there is the effect that growing Enlightened attitudes would have.  Here, there is a mixed bag.  On the one hand, the Enlightenment will undercut the authority of religious thinking (as previously explained in this blog), but on the other, it would also undermine aristocratic assumptions about people.  The whole notion that well off people are so advantaged due to some godly plan was seriously questioned. 

This led to republican leanings among Enlightened thinkers – among them one finds the “social contract” theorists.  It was a historical shift toward equality.  One imported set of ideas was those of John Locke.  While subsequent writers have attributed too much influence on this philosopher,[4] his promotion of a natural rights view and its introduction to America should be noted. 

To the extent that natural rights was considered and adopted, it presented a competing sense of what it meant to govern and engage in politics.  So, during the 1600s, Virginia was allowed to organize itself, initiate its basic economic arrangements, and proceed to establish a viable position within the mercantilist system that was one, global, and two, highly entrenched.  But before moving on to examine Pennsylvania’s development more closely, the next posting will give an overall comparison between the natural rights view and federal theory.



[1] Slavery had already been present in America; the first slaves were probably introduced on this side of the Atlantic as far back as the early 1500s with Christopher Columbus transporting them to Hispaniola.  See “America’s History of Slavery Long before Jamestown,” The History Channel (n.d.), accessed May 6, 2021, https://www.history.com/news/american-slavery-before-jamestown-1619#:~:text=The%20arrival%20of%20the%20first,as%20early%20as%20the%201500s.

[2] Donald S. Lutz (ed.), Colonial Origins of the American Constitution:  A Documentary History (Indianapolis, IN:  Liberty Fund,1998), 314.

[3] Allen C. Guelzo, The American Mind, Part I – a transcript book – (Chantilly, VA:  The Teaching Company/The Great Courses, 2005).

[4] See, for example, Garry Wills, Inventing America:  Jefferson’s Declaration of Independence (New York, NY:  Vintage Books, 1978/2018).  

Tuesday, May 4, 2021

FROM CAMBRIDGE TO NEW HAVEN

 

Whereas this blog took a turn toward Yale College two posting ago, it left the reader with little information as to the developments at Harvard during the 1600s.  This posting hopefully will modestly fill in the gaps in that story.  The main reason for looking elsewhere relates to the quality of leadership experienced on the Cambridge campus.

          This period saw subpar administrations beginning with Harvard’s first president, Henry Dunstar, who became embroiled in the religious turmoil between the scholastics and the Separatists – the strong Puritanical believers who took on the moniker, Baptists.  He was eventually forced to resign and was followed by a succession of men that were not able to bring under control the rowdy student body.  They were Charles Chauncey, Leonard Hoar, Urian Oakes, and John Rogers – these men were either physicians or clergymen.

          Finally, in 1684, almost fifty years after its founding, Harvard hired its first effective president with the curious name, Increase Mather.[1]  At the time of his acceptance of the position he was already well known as the pastor of the Old North Church of Boston where he secured the highest reputation among the second-generation New Englanders.  From the get-go, Mather’s appointment had some political intrigue since his ascendency staved off direct control of the college by the English government.

          One thing Mather accomplished was to upgrade the faculty.  Two additions to that group would prove of particular consequence; that would be the hires of William Brattle and John Leverett.  Brattle strongly insisted on Cartesian logic to attack skepticism – the belief that nothing is knowable.  Leverett proved to be more independent of religious ideas and ideals and eventually assumed the presidency of Harvard in 1707.  His more distinguishing posture led to his support of a new church.

          As Allen Guelzo describes it,

 

Leverett would … talk more about virtue than about redemption, more about reasonableness rather than mystery, and he put his entire support behind the organization of a new church in Boston, the Brattle Street Church, whose Manifesto of 1699 proclaimed the church Congregational, not by reason of Scripture, but by the Light of Nature.[2]

 

Eventually, a rift developed between Increase Mather and Leverett, as Mather attempted to block the ascendancy of Leverett to the presidency, but it proved too late.  This antagonism stemmed from the belief Leverett was drifting too far away from Calvinistic beliefs.  And this discordance would be picked up by Mather’s son, Cotton Mather. 

This drift, ironically, led like-minded advocates, headed by Cotton, to look to Connecticut to start a new college.  That would be New Haven, and this younger Mather convinced Elihu Yale to provide the bulk of the funds.  The irony continues, since it would be Yale College, through the work of its post-graduate tutor, Samuel Johnson, that would in time take the lead in promoting Enlightenment ideals and furthering the use of reason and the objectification of study that would lead the scholarship of that day.[3]

While surely other writers have commented on this next concern, what follows are the ideas of this blogger.  And that has to do with a source of contention between Enlightenment thinking and Puritanism.  Earlier, this blog introduced the acronym, TULIP.  The letters stand for the various beliefs Puritans claim.   The “U” stands for unconditional election which means one does not get to heaven through good works, but through being selected by God to be so rewarded.  This smacked as antithetical to Enlightenment ideas.

The Enlightenment not only rejected the notion that a person knows such a thing, but that belief undermined human capacities to reason.  Why a person is “saved” or not, must depend on more than the whimsical biases of some almighty power.  If that contention were true, it would need to be discovered as a tangible reality to be believed and since such a belief can have such far-reaching effects, it is of no small matter.  This writer believes that such disconnect underscored the ongoing discord between Enlightenment thinkers and the Puritans.

And another point, this writer wishes to highlight, that with objectified thinking having a Cartesian starting point of total ignorance, epistemological thinkers, since the days of the 1700s, have delved into what are the implications of Enlightenment thinking.  One such scholar was Eugene Meehan in the mid-twentieth century.  He provides the following list of criteria by which one can evaluate or ask questions of any theory, but given its thrust, they seem most applicable to scientifically derived theories. The list is:

 

•      Comprehension: Does a construct explain as many phenomena related to the area of concern as possible?

•      Power: Does a construct control the explanatory effort by being valid and complete in its component parts and in the relationships among those parts?

•      Precision: Does a construct specifically and precisely treat its concepts, making them clear in their use?

•      Consistency or Reliability: Does a construct explain its components and their relationships the same way time after time?

•      Isomorphism: Does a construct contain a one-to-one correspondence with that portion of reality it is trying to explain?

•      Compatibility: Does a construct align with other responsible explanations of the same phenomena?

•      Predictability: Does a construct predict conditions associated with the phenomena in question?

•      Control: Does a construct imply ways to control the phenomena in question?[4]

 

This is offered so that the reader can get a sense of what Enlightenment thinking has led to. 

 That is a highly disciplined way to look at, to measure, and to model what some aspect of reality is.  Of course, such knowledge, as it is accumulated, leads to application of it and the advent of engineering.  But a question to ask in terms of this blog’s story:  was this influence limited to the New England colonies?  The next posting will look at Virginia and Pennsylvania.



[1] Apparently, the name Increase was popular among Puritans during the time in question.

[2] Allen C. Guelzo, The American Mind, Part I – a transcript book – (Chantilly, VA:  The Teaching Company/The Great Courses, 2005), 40.

[3] See posting, “A Yale Turn,” of this blog.  It was published April 27, 2021.

[4] While this blogger cannot find from which of Meehan’s works this originates, the reader is directed to work of this now deceased academic.  That is Eugene J. Meehan, Contemporary Political Thought:  A Critical Study (Homewood, IL:  Dorsey Press, 1967).

Friday, April 30, 2021

SOME ENLIGHTENED BELIEFS

 

In this story of how federalism, a perception regarding the relationship between the individual and his/her government, has fared during the American experience, this blog has reached the foundation of a new colony, that of Connecticut.  The original motivation to establish that eventual colony and state was spearheaded by Puritans in three towns to separate themselves from the Anglican influence one found in Massachusetts.  That development is described in the last posting.

          It is of importance to this story since in one of the towns seeking separation was Hartford that would become the home of Yale.  There, Samuel Johnson would be influenced by the writings of Enlightenment thinkers and as a post-graduate student and tutor, led the way to institute a new curriculum called “The New Learning.” 

In the reading list of that curriculum were the works of Francis Bacon, John Locke, Isaac Newton, Robert Boyle, Copernicus, and that was only on the philosophic/science side of scholarly works.  On the literary side there were the stories of Shakespeare, Milton, and Addison.  These works and their ideas hit the “grapevine” of that time, i.e., the religious networks that, in this case, were centered in Yale College.  All this began roughly in the year 1718.

A historian who has studied this development and has reported certain central elements of it is James MacGregor Burns.[1] According to his reportage, the Enlightenment in Europe coincided with the Reformation and, as a result, the church came under critical review when it exercised its authority over questions regarding nature and government. 

Starting with Copernicus and his theorizing that the earth, contrary to religious dictum, was not the center of the universe, led to enormous energetic interest in the study of physical existence.  This encouraged a whole new approach to investigating nature that began with the Cartesian premise that nothing was known (except one’s own existence), and one needed to go out and hypothesize, observe, measure, and tentatively conclude what the basic elements of that reality are.[2]

 The second element Burns points out is how extensively this newer view took hold.  It stretched throughout Europe and even led to the overthrow of governments.  And once taking hold in America, it played a role in encouraging and emboldening a generation of leaders that would lead toward the independence of the colonies that would become the US. 

Third, he makes a definite connection between Enlightenment ideas and the direction American leaders would take.  These leaders will include John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, and James Madison.  Of particular concern were the philosophizing of certain social / economic / political qualities such as liberty and equality.  Here one can trace the original importation of the natural rights view as a legitimate philosophic tradition that owes a lot of its original arguments to John Locke, although, through the ensuing years that tradition has gone through extensive change, especially of late.

And fourth, Burns summarily sees the overwhelming effect of the Enlightenment as a “light” that made visible the realities of existence through the use of reason.  That light shone the way to go past the obstacles of traditional, faith-based thought that had stymied people’s ability to discover what humans have to contend with through the various turns in their lives.  This ranged from diseases, to movement, to meeting the wants and needs of people to survive and live better, more comfortable lives.

The aim of the Enlightenment here in America, as in Europe, was to apply reasoning to science, politics, and religion.  That reason, for example, encouraged religious tolerance; why engage in constant religious fights that in Europe led to the Thirty Years’ War (1618-1648) that ended due to exhaustion with no side winning?  It upgraded the arts as important pursuits.  It promoted a secular or, at least, a non-denominational moral approach that could replace theology.  And, probably most effective, was the introduction of science as a higher education discipline.

One form or result of a secular moral view was the upstart of deism – the belief in an uninvolved deity that might have created what is, but basically stands back and lets that creation do its thing.  Apparently, this belief became common among the leadership class of the American colonies. 

What became disfavored among the elite class were such beliefs in the ability to prophesize and the occurrence of miracles.  But of most importance was the influence the Enlightenment had on the leadership and on many of the common folk as to the reasonableness and prudence in adopting religious tolerance.  This and the other Enlightened views, through the slow process outlined above, took hold especially among the educated. 

It did not directly lead toward demanding independence but laid the foundation that would later make Americans less tolerant of English policies they found distasteful and that was not limited to the upper class.  It grew among the population in general.  So, as for the relevant history of the 1700s, one can see related influences taking hold, but did they eliminate federalist foundational beliefs?  This writer believes they did not, but instead were incorporated under the federated framework the Puritans had established.

Again, that influence can be best summarized as one of congregationalism.  This foundational form is counter to the vertical structure of such religions as Roman Catholicism and Anglicanism.  The formation of congregations is the result of local people bonding together to establish a church and it was through that mode that Puritanical churches were established in New England.  In turn, historians basically agree that this mode naturally led to the establishment of the colonial polities.  They also led to the early educational institutions such as Harvard and Yale.

Next, this story will review how Harvard reenters the story of the Enlightenment through mostly the work of Increase Mather.  His work will be the topic of the next posting as that posting aims to fill in some the information gaps regarding the development of the Enlightenment among Americans during the 1700s.



[1] James MacGregor Burns, Fire and Light:  How the Enlightenment Transformed Our World (New York, NY:  MacMillan, 2013).

[2] As the philosophy of science would later state (under the philosophizing of Karl Popper), all conclusions are subject to disproof.  This is known as the principle of falsification. 

Tuesday, April 27, 2021

A YALE TURN

With this posting, this blog moves on with its account of the historical development Americans experienced in their views of governance and politics.  The overall question being asked is:  can one ascribe the perceptual orientation Daniel Elazar identifies as federalism to Americans in the years from colonial times to World War II?  Until this point, this blog has described the thinking of the first generation of colonists. 

A lot of the early political/religious (often intertwined) thinking was done under the federalist system of a compact-al defined polity and had to do with how Puritanical they were going to be.  Were they going to follow a more scholastic/intellectual path that relied on logic or were they going to be readily swayed by a more emotionally based will?  As this ongoing tension evolved, a first, naturally born generation was being raised and developing its own views.  And to add to this mix, these newcomers were to experience the import of an intellectual movement.

This turn was emanating from Europe and before addressing its elements, one should keep in mind that in reporting such movements, various facts by historians and other experts are apt to vary.  Again, the aim here is to give the reader an overall sense of how Americans viewed their relationship between themselves, on an individual basis, and government and how that was being affected by the various forces these people were experiencing. 

One turn was a change of locality as to where the effects of this change were being most felt.  The early debate described above seemed to center on the concerns expressed on the campus of Harvard in Massachusetts.  That will shift to Yale and that story is intermingled with the development of Connecticut.  A passing knowledge of how it became a colony helps this story of Yale’s role and how political thinking was to change.

And, in that, a good place to start is with if not the first colonial constitution, then one of the first such documents.  The reader should keep in mind, by writing and abiding with such a foundational document, these colonists were exhibiting their reliance on federalism to define their governance and politics.  To history, this Connecticut document is known as the Fundamental Orders of Connecticut. 

The document fulfills a necessary function so that it be considered a legitimate constitution, i.e., it sets out how a formed government will be constituted – it establishes its structure of government.  Also, this document has the elements Donald Lutz outlines as being requisites for such a foundational instrument.  He identifies twelve elements of concern and here are the first three and the first sentence of the fourth.  He writes,

 

1.     Political covenants were derived in form and content from religious covenants used to found religious communities.

2.     A complete political covenant had the following elements:  (a) an oath calling on God as a witness or partner; (b) the creation of a people whose members are identified by those who signed the covenant; (c) the creation of a civil body politic, or government; (d) the specification of the shared goals and values, a shared meaning, that defined (self-defined) the basis for the people living together; and (e) the creation and description of institutions for collective decision making.

3.     The people covenant form evolved rather quickly into the political compact form.  A political compact is identical to a political covenant except for the absence of an oath [calling on God’s role] in a compact.  The elimination of the oath resulted in the force of the document, and therefore the basis of political obligation, resting entirely on the consent of those signing it.  The move from political covenant to political compact is thus a shift to de facto popular sovereignty.

4.     The political compact eventually evolved into what we now recognize as the American form of constitutionalism. …[1]

 

 The Fundamental Orders fulfill these elements and serve as a starting point, and that document’s beginning paragraph should be studied to garner these people’s basic view.  By doing so, the reader can bring life to what Lutz point out.

          Here is this writer’s “translation” of that document’s first paragraph (recall, that the original is written in the idiom of its time).

 

For as much as it has pleased the Almighty God, the wise disposition of his divine prudence to Order and dispose of things that we the inhabitants and residents of Windsor, Hartford and Wethersfield are now cohabiting and dwelling in and upon the River of Connecticut and the lands thereunto adjoining; and well knowing where a people are gathered together the word of God requires that to maintain the peace and union of such a people there should be an orderly and decent government established  according to God, to order and dispose of the affairs of the people at all seasons as occasion shall require; do therefore associate and cojoin ourselves to be as one public state or commonwealth; and do, for ourselves and our successors and such as shall be adjoined to us at any time hereafter, enter into combination and confederation together, to maintain and pursue the liberty and purity of the gospel of our Lord Jesus which we now profess, as also the discipline of the Churches, which according to the truth of the said gospel is now practiced amongst us; as also in our civil affairs to be guided and governed  according to such laws, rules, orders and degrees as shall be made, ordered and decreed, as follows …[2]

 To state the obvious, the religious influence is center and prominent.  It reflects a Puritanical view and as one reads on, the principle of self-commitment to belong and meet responsibilities is more than hinted at as the “governor” describes his responsibilities. 

To state the obvious, the religious influence is center and prominent.  It reflects a Puritanical view and as one reads on, the principle of self-commitment to belong and meet responsibilities is more than hinted at as the “governor” describes his responsibilities. 

The question this blog asks:  will the Enlightenment, as it is interpreted on this side of the Atlantic, going to challenge this perception, enhance it, or merely accommodate to this already cultural element one finds as the Enlightenment makes its initial inroads?  Again, this newer constitution, which is issued in 1639, serves as a piece of evidence of what was held as espoused values and goals when it comes to governance. 

And how did Connecticut come to be?  That story is a bit confusing and not essential to know in its details to achieve the intentions of this blog.  The steps somewhat begin with the Massachusetts General Court issuing permission for the cities identified in the document to set up this entity that will be known as Connecticut.  The document was the product of a commission set up to deal with a dispute in which the cities being united helped in their cause.  The story includes Massachusetts’ governor, John Winthrop.

All of these matters led to the creation – and the writing of a constitution – of a new colony.  Close (less than forty miles) to one of those original cities, a university would be established.  That would be Hartford and the university was Yale in New Haven.  The date of its establishment was 1701.  Its role in introducing the Enlightenment is also a bit messy, but certain key facts are clear.

            Apparently, in 1714, Jeremiah Dummer generously donated a library to the newer university.  At the school was an industrious post-graduate student, Samuel Johnson.  He took it upon himself to study the books of the library and, by doing so, was exposed to ideas that went contrary to his Puritanical understanding of things. 

He is quoted as seeing this discovery as overwhelming to a “low state of mind.”[3]  As a result, Johnson introduces a curriculum shift at Yale that he called “The New Learning.”  With that, the reader is invited to the next posting that will pick up this Connecticut tale that will eventually lead them back to Harvard.



[1] Donald S. Lutz, “Introductory Essay,” Colonial Origins of the American Constitution:  A Documentary History, edited by Donald S. Lutz (Indianapolis, IN:  Liberty Fund, 1998), xxxv-xxxvi. 

[2] Ibid, 211.  As the text indicates, the depiction here is a version of what is found in this source.  Lutz provides the document in its original spellings.  Of note, this writer visited the Wikipedia entry for the Fundamental Orders of Connecticut.  That entry describes summarily the document, as a constitution, setting up “[g]overnment [as being] based on the rights of an individual, and the orders spell out some of those rights, as well as how they are ensured by the government.”  The reader is asked:  does the language this document use indicate that individualism is its main thrust?  This writer believes it does not and feels that this categorization serves to support the view that the current prominent view of governance and politics being that of the natural rights view.  See “Fundamental Orders of Connecticut,” Wikipedia (n.d.), accessed April 26, 2021, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_Orders_of_Connecticut#:~:text=The%20Fundamental%20Orders%20were%20adopted,the%20open%20ocean%20for%20trading.

[3] Donald S. Lutz, Stephen L. Schechter, and Richard Bernstein, Roots of the Republic:  American Founding Documents Interpreted (Madison, WS:  Madison House), 24.