Would you judge a person by the size of his/her
pancreas? Silly question? Then why do so many of us judge others by the
color of their skin – just as silly. If
you were to determine what the size of each person’s pancreas was and then
categorize them according to size, say three sized categories – small, medium,
and large – and then correlate the sizes to other factors such as crime
figures, attendance in college, Nobel prizes, etc., for each correlation one of
the sized categories would correlate the highest and one would be the lowest.
Is there a cause and effect relationship
among those correlations or are they just happenstance occurrences? Most of us would say they are
happenstance. But suppose for some weird
reason(s), people began believing that there was a cause and effect relationship
and began treating the negatively or positively affected group in some unusual
way. Would that treatment enhance the belief or assuage it? It would probably enhance it.
So the belief is not one based on
biological factors – the genetic factor(s) that cause people to have the size
pancreas they have – but the social construct (the shared, made up belief) that
says pancreas size (PS) leads to the behaviors one sees and with which one must
deal.
Yes, all of
this is silly. But it reflects a serious problem. For example, the most glaring example is the
historical treatment of African-Americans.
That treatment has led to the conditions that exist today, not the
biological factors that cause the different shades of skin color we see. Here, there is a people who were taken
against their will from their homes and enslaved. Then there were generations upon generations
of people enslaved and deemed to be inferior in every way possible.
Upon liberation from slavery, they
were subjected to horrendous social conditions and messages that continued the
negative stereotypes. And yet those
people today can claim, beyond all the negative treatment, advancement. Most African-Americans live middle class
lives, just like the rest of us. This is
due to their diligence, hard work, and continued hope that things would/will
get better.
One such
person made it to the highest office in the land. But this negative social construct persists
and among some, the effects can still be seen in promoting the
counterproductive behaviors – on both sides of the racial divide – that further
the negativity. In a shorthand way, this
brief piece is an attempt to describe what is meant by saying that race is a
social construct, a social construct educators have the responsibility to set
straight.
No comments:
Post a Comment