A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Monday, March 17, 2014

BIG BROTHER ON A CELL

A new technology challenge is before us. And the implications are far reaching. It presents dangers and it also provides a crucial tool in rendering life saving results. Before I describe it, let me just mention that those who control it today might not be the ones who will control it exclusively in the future. The new technology is a simulator, a fake cell phone tower. Its capacity was described in a Tallahassee Democrat report as follows: “government investigators and private individuals can locate, interfere with and intercept communications from cellphones and other wireless devices.”1 Apparently, this capability has been in the hands of the FBI since 1995. The most recent twist is that the technology is available to local police forces.

Has this sharing been done in the open? Has it been announced with fanfare and gratitude celebrated in our local media? Not quite. The technology and its dispersing to local authorities came to light as a result of a 2008 rape case in which the accused rapist was identified as a result of the simulator's use. The problem was that its use was not authorized with a warrant or permission. The simulator was used to identify the person of interest and the officers, investigating the case, went to the person's domicile and they, in effect, broke in and found the suspect and personal items of the victim. But since they lacked the warrant or permission, the resulting conviction was thrown out and the court ordered a new trial. Now the question is whether the obtained evidence can be used in a new trial. But that's not the issue here.

My concern here is what this technology means to our sense of a mutual fate. How does a policy shrouded in secrecy help or hinder our ability to feel we are all in this together? And according to American Civil Liberties Union statements, the secrecy could be motivated to avoid complications with Fourth Amendment protections of privacy. Needless to say, government's ability to know what we say on a phone is quite invasive into our private affairs and can be used by unscrupulous politicians to advance their aims illegitimately. The point is if evidence is gathered by the use of this technology and a less than ideal investigative process – such as with the cited rape case – is followed, perhaps a lack of knowledge of its existence could save cases that would otherwise be lost on appeals. Also, if law enforcement capabilities are secret, would-be criminals will not be able to make arrangements to counter the entailed procedures. At present, 29 law enforcement agencies have use of the simulator technology. We now know all of these facts not due to officials informing the public, but because of the attention that the appeal on the above rape case drew and the request for information appeals that ensued by the news media outlets. So, there are two dangers: one, government having unconstitutional access to our private affairs and, two, unscrupulous agents – who some day might include private individuals or groups – having information that can be used to commit crimes, political or otherwise, that could victimize any one of us.

What about the positive uses? According to law enforcement officials, due to the ability to track and decipher cell phones, lives have been saved. The Florida Department of Law Enforcement official said that its uses of the simulator are always done with a warrant unless there is an emergency situation such as a murder, kidnapping, sexual assault, or other violent situation. According to a police spokesperson, in these extreme cases, lives have been saved due to the use of simulators. As it turns out, to use or not to use this technology is a classic case of weighing security versus liberty. Which way should we go? Obviously, this is a discussion we should have.

But how can you discuss something if you don't know that that something exists? And further, the negative effects of secrecy are compounded when the technology comes to light. We should assume that eventually such capabilities will be generally known – information is like water; it is bound to find those cracks that exist and work its way out of any enclosure. This is especially true in a relatively open society. When it is found out, then its attempted cover-up just adds to our collective sense of mistrust. In this case, should we be wary of public officials knowing too much about our affairs? Can we trust them if they are gathering personal information in ways that we have not been informed about, much less given our consent? Mistrust undermines federal unions. Yes, there are legitimate instances for secrecy – nuclear secrets come to mind – but, in general, we should limit access to public policy information in only the most sensitive situations – where lives are at stake if the information were known. The general goal should be to open up as much as possible even if political costs are involved. After all, we are all united for the common good as participating partners. Partners need to know what's going on.

1Portman, J. (2014). Invasive or essential? Tallahassee Democrat, March 16, pp. 1A and 4A. Quotation on p. 1A. The facts related in this posting are derived from this article.

Friday, March 14, 2014

FEDERALIST COURSE OF STUDY

Since the beginning of the this blog, I have been promoting a newer curricular view, one based on a mental construct I have dubbed liberated federalism. The curricular area in question has been civics or government. I have dedicated many postings to going over the different elements of this mental construct and you are invited to hit the archive feature and see past postings or visit the website, gravitasarchives.blogspot.com to review those descriptions and explanations. This other site has a listing of ninety – to date – postings that I have deleted from the site you are on now. Just to give you some context, this blog began on September 6, 2010. While I have commented extensively about the theoretical content of the construct, I have not written about how a civics or government course, based on a liberated federalist view, would be organized; that is, how the units of study would be arranged in such a course. In this posting, I will address this topic.

There are several options for how such a course could be arranged and these options call for different preparations of which curricular workers, school administrators, and teachers need to be aware. Let me start by confessing that I don't see a vast change over to a federalist approach as being imminent. It's not even on anyone's radar. The most I could hope for is that a teacher here and there is taken by liberated federalism and decides: “You know, I feel that this construct could be helpful in my class. It is a useful way to look at governance and politics and I'm going to incorporate federalist concerns into my lesson plans.” That teacher would begin to notice that many of the generally discussed issues of the day have a federalist side to them. He or she might be motivated to insert questions or research topics that reflect federalist concerns. In many of my postings, I write my pieces with this type of teacher in mind. That is, I address some contemporary issue and describe and explain it from the federalist perspective. Now I must add a clarifying statement – it's one that regular readers of this blog will find familiar. But for new readers, by stating that civics material should be guided by liberated federalism, I am not using the term federalism as it is usually used. Usually, people who refer to federalism are talking about the structural arrangement between the central and state governments. While this is an aspect of federalism, on a more theoretical level, federalism refers to people coming together for a purpose and agreeing to remain united, under the auspices of a covenant or compact, no matter what any individual member might do. In this blog, in short, I usually become aware of some problem or event that endangers the federal union of which we are all a part – the good old USA. I try to explain what the situation is and then I try to make the connection to federalist thought explicit. By doing so, I am justifying the inclusion of the issue or event by an educator into his/her plans – class time is a limited resource and should not be taken up by whimsical concerns a teacher or some student might have. Perhaps this – a sporadic teacher taking up the cause – is the extent to which I can realistically hope that federalist ideas might make it into our classrooms. But let me be idealistic and project more thought-out curricular options.

Option one: Maintain existing course structures and use federalist issues to illustrate how our system of governance operates throughout the course. The advantage of this option is that classroom teachers could not only use standard civics and government textbooks, but could also probably finesse any needed accommodations with curriculum policy of the school district and/or state department of education – not that such a level of supervision is common enough to engender such a concern. What might be changed with this option is the questions that students would be asked to answer. Most textbook questions are written by curriculum workers who are influenced by natural rights thinking. There, the emphasis would be on functional concerns: what is the function of a particular element of the system (e. g., department, agency, voter, political party, etc.)? How well has this element performed its function? What recurring problems does this element face in performing its functions? What changes/reforms are being considered regarding this element? These types of questions lack normative concerns other than a concern for efficiency in meeting various governmental functions by the government itself or by some person or group that deals with government.

A liberated federalist approach would ask more normative questions: how is this element meant to advance social capital; that is, a society characterized by having an active, public-spirited citizenry, egalitarian political relations, and a social environment of trust and cooperation? What are the relationships among the different players within a particular element – promoting mutual interests or promoting competitive interests? What is the social environment within which an element functions? Is it one of trust, cooperation or of acrimony, deception? I can add many more questions, but I believe you get the drift. Of course, the exact questions would depend on the federalist issues under discussion and/or analysis.

Option two: Forget the textbook and the structure that the textbook outlines for the course and develop a course entirely on federalist priorities. Here is where I am a bit in a quandary. If you give up on the existing structure, you have to invent one. Here's my first try. Begin with each element of a federal union from the most basic to the most complicated. From the individual – the most basic, but still complicated – to international arrangements such as the UN. Let me present a list of these elements and an accompanying federalist issue for each upon which a unit of study could focus:
  • The individual – short term interests vs. long term interests
  • The family – the effects of divorce
  • The neighborhood – responsibilities toward problem children
  • A small business – treatment of employees
  • A labor association (such as a union) – efficiency practices or product quality
  • A large corporation – product safety
  • A local government (either city or county) – zoning or racial/ethnic divisions
  • Law enforcement agency – judicial rights applicable to an accused
  • White House – federalist meaning of leadership
  • Congress – the extent that money is influential
  • The courts – the role of interpreting a federalist compact
  • Society during wartime – special demands on citizenship
  • International association – levels of interdependence between nations
That makes thirteen units to be covered in an eighteen week semester at the high school level. Middle school civics courses last the entire academic year, so the list can be longer or each item can demand more time (or a combination of the two). The point is that a purely federalist approach gives low priority toward “teaching” the structure of government, per se, and a higher concern for the federalist character of our government and our society. I assume the structure becomes instrumental in dealing with these issues and that students will learn the structure as a matter of course. By taking this approach, units of study would incorporate the type of questions I listed above. But in this option, the overall aim is to have students know, understand, and appreciate the bonding among citizens that our form of government demands and how the related political activity under analysis advances or detracts from those demands. Many of my postings relate to situations in which I believe some people are not living up to the compact that forms our federated union. These are offered, in part, to help any teacher who wants to walk on the federalist side.

Monday, March 10, 2014

PRAYING WE DON'T REPEAT A MISTAKE

Do you agree that you have the right to practice your religion no matter what the majority of your neighbors' religious beliefs are? Do you think the state has the right to promote religious beliefs with which you might not agree – how about those with which you agree? The history of our constitutional thought has led us to at least voice the opinion that there should be a separation between church and state. Not all of us seem to agree with this, but generally, if asked, Americans think the best policy for government is is to stay away from attacking or promoting any religious belief or activity. This tradition began way back and is a product of a history of violence between religious zealots and their political spokespersons, including kings, dukes, and powerful noblemen. In the western world, the Treaty of Westphalia began a long string of compromises that finally led to our more modern view. A lot of blood bought us our more accommodating and tolerant view of others' religions. Should we hold vigilance against any back-tracking and/or look the other way when those who want to push their views about the supernatural among not only their fellow believers but the rest of us seem to be getting their way?

In Florida – a recurring site for so many of our current troubling news – we have a program that tests our commitment to this modern view. The governmental program provides vouchers to families so that they can send their children to private schools. The glitch is that these public funds, for over 80% of the 60,000 youngsters involved, go to religious schools. The goal is not subtle; it's to promote religious morals among the impressionable students. The reason this is a current issue is that the state legislature is considering expanding the $300 million program. Under the control of conservative Republicans, the bill will probably successfully make its way through the Legislature and be signed by Governor Rick Scott.

Given our constitution's First Amendment with its sanction against the establishment of religion by the state, how can such a program be legal? There are two cases that seem to give such a program the green light. The first is Zelman vs. Simmons-Harris in which the Supreme Court found such a program – one existing in Cleveland – to be constitutional. In doing so, the Court established a five element test for such programs. They ruled the Cleveland program okay because it met the following requirements: (1) program has to have a legitimate secular purpose, (2) needs to provide assistance to parents, with no funds going directly to schools, (3) must have a “broad class” of beneficiaries – as opposed to a specific group(s), (4) the vouchers must not be reserved for a particular religion and, therefore, favor any one faith, and (5) the program must be offered where there are sufficient non-religious options. A second case, Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization vs. Winn, limits who can bring suits against such programs. This case was thrown out because it was brought by taxpayers, per se, and they did not have standing – any one taxpayer does not have enough skin in the game to claim enough harm. In the case of Cleveland, the program was initially geared to help low income parents get their kids into schools other than the low preforming public schools and, therefore, judged to be secular in its intent.

But in Florida, we see the proponents tip their hands with the new proposal before the Legislature. They want the expansion of the state's program to include parents with incomes over $60,000 a year. The median household income in Florida in 2012 was $47,000. So one can question this expansion's “valid secular” purpose. As Pasco County pastor, Alfred Johnson, proclaimed, “[t]hese programs are bringing an angle that the public schools cannot …”.1 A delegation of parents, students, and teachers appeared at a legislative hearing that discussed the proposed expansion. They are reported to have “praised the existing program as a lifeline for families seeking an alternative to public schools, either to escape crowded schools or to attend a school that emphasizes religious values.”2

Individually, I am offended by this program. But that's me. I can't claim that it sends us back to those days when believers of different faiths fought over religious disagreements. It does, though, begin a process that could potentially lead to more virulent relations among the faithful. It also spends tax money of those who do not believe in any religion; I can't see where these people would not see the program as promoting religion – the program simply does that no matter how secular the original purpose of such a program is. This can be questioned in terms of justice. It serves to undermine and corrupt a governance based on equal protection. Atheists are not being equally protected by such a program especially when the law is intended to “bringing an angle that the public schools cannot.” In short, the program is dangerous and we all, including the religious, should be wary of its effect on our level of tolerance for those who do or don't agree with us when it comes to other worldly beliefs.

1Fineout, G. (2014). Private school voucher bill moves ahead. The Tallahassee Democrat, March 9, p. 15A. The facts of the Florida program reported in this posting are derived from this Associated Press article. Emphasis added.

2Ibid.

Friday, March 7, 2014

VIEWS OF EQUITY THROUGH GOOD TIMES

I have made the case in this blog that the prominent view of politics among our citizens is the natural rights perspective. To summarize this view, it is a highly individualistic perspective in which we believe governmental action should be kept to a minimum. The emphasis is on the right to choose and do those actions we, individually, see as best for us as long as we do not interfere with anyone else enjoying the same latitude in his/her choices. Under such a view, we promote competitive relations usually under the auspices of a free market. The view is highly associated with capitalism. We have adopted this view to such a degree that we have begun to call it the “American way,” as if this bias has always been the way we see politics and, in general, social arrangements. While American culture has been from its very beginning a relatively individualistic one, to the degree this view has “taken over” is a product of the last fifty to sixty years – since the end of World War II. In terms of more specific policies, this view has encouraged reduced governmental regulations – which have increased, but mostly as a result of the globalization of the economy and the resulting worldwide markets. It has also encouraged a weakening of labor unions and of the role of government in determining labor relations between workers and employers. Overall, the strength of labor laws has been weakened. Oversight of markets became much looser. All of this gained impetus in the years leading up to 2008.

Then came the financial crisis that led to the worst economic recession since the Great Depression of the 1930s. This development brought into question, among informed circles, the prudence of a view that promotes such a hands-off approach by government in relation to economic activity. As a result, the Congress passed the Dodd-Frank Act to reimpose regulations on the buying and selling of securities. But what of the general public and its views regarding how free economic actors should be? Have the American people, in general, been able to turn on a dime and seek another view to replace the extremely laissez-fare attitude that had become so prevalent?

According to Leslie McCall,1 the public had reached the highest point of support for laissez-fare in 2008 – at least as measured by available survey data on our tolerance of inequities, a by-product of a laissez-fare economy. But this high point was not reached in a straight line over the years and analysis of this progression provides evidence that suggests a period of time in which the whole view came into question not during a time of economic distress, but in a time when economic conditions were good and improving. She points out that during the nineties, when the nation was enjoying a healthy economic uptick, that there was an increase in questioning the results of this uninhibited economic policy. That is, people began to question the level of inequality that was increasing since the seventies. Robert Y. Shapiro, reporting on McCall's research, writes
… there is an unfairness suggested in the more-pronounced beliefs in the 1990s, in which rising income inequality is seen as benefitting mainly the rich and not producing prosperity for all. … [This time of improved economic conditions] signifies opportunity, so that what has changed in the public's mind … is that rising income inequality can affect individuals' perceptions of opportunity.2
Shapiro points out that this finding goes contrary to what was previously understood to be the relation between economic conditions and the public's view of opportunity. That is, it was believed that good economic conditions would correlate with a higher sense of opportunity and therefore a higher level of tolerance toward or, at least, ambivalence over degrees of inequality in regard to opportunity – that such views would hold off calls from the public for a redistributive policy response to meet existing inequality. Instead, and one needs to remember that inequality grew in the 1990s, McCall finds that the improving economic conditions coexisted with a more prevalent belief that there was no longer a rich segment of the population that deserved its riches. What seems to have come under question was whether the contemporary rich should be “celebrated” for ushering in equitable growth – a tide lifting all boats. The general public seems to have begun establishing a general view of the rich as undeserving “who are implicated in producing a form of inequality that is perceived to either symbolize or directly contribute to limited opportunities”.3

What I see is a tension among the populous or among different segments of the population. That tension is between what has become more and more obvious, the extreme inequality of income between the very rich and the rest of us, and the prevailing political view of the natural rights perspective. When the financial crisis hit, I would argue that the popular view was still under the influence of the heightened support for the more individualistic perspective. What complicated the distinction between views of individualism and a more collective, government friendly view were a few economic and social conditions. One, the crisis and the resulting recession did not reach Great Depression levels of misery. Yes, the recession was severe, but we did not have the bread lines and other extreme deprivations that the American society suffered during the Depression years. Two, despite its salutary effect, the bailing out of the Wall Street banks and the auto industry united the dismay of both extreme right-wingers and many on the left, an anti-corporatist faction of the political spectrum. Both of these factors muddied the waters concerning the justification for strong governmental response in regard to the economic dangers facing the nation. There resulted no clear lesson as to the need for a strong government presence in the operations of the economy. Therefore, in 2008, the public which became enamored by the more laissez-fare policies of the George Bush Administration did not find it easy to give up on those biases through the time when the dam burst and the economy fell into the Great Recession.

Since then, we have had the Occupy Wall Street movement which has brought to the fore the inequality issue in a much clearer perspective. It has become common knowledge of how unequal income has become. We are even becoming aware of how unequal wealth is. While the defenders of the inequity have tried to steer the language of the discussion in terms of “either/or” – either we have an economy that rewards those who run businesses and create jobs or we don't – many more Americans are becoming aware that the question has more to do with the extremity of the disparity than whether we should reward the successful. What I find worth taking away from McCall's research is how expectations, especially during better economic times, are affected. Increased economic activity does not help in hindering our perception of how opportunities are affected by a mal-distribution of income and wealth. Perhaps, as the economy improves, we will not forget about this issue of inequality and begin to demand, from the rich, behaviors and policies that will lead us to the judgment that they are, in effect, deserving.

1McCall, L. (2013). The undeserving rich: American beliefs about inequality, opportunity, and redistribution. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press. The presentation of the study in this posting is based on a book review by Robert Y. Shapiro which appears in Political Science Quarterly, Winter 2013-14, 128 (4), pp. 750-753.

2Ibid, Shapiro, p. 752.

3Ibid.

Monday, March 3, 2014

HOT STUFF

This blog has been dedicated, in part, to promoting a mental construct that can function as a guide in determining what substantive content should be included in our civics curriculum. I will not rehash all that has been written about this promotion, but rather say that a central part of my effort has been to make the case that any construct that attempts to guide civics instruction will, by necessity, have a moral position. After all, the reason we offer civics to begin with is to encourage good citizenship. The “good” presupposes a sense for the good and therefore reflects what the creators of the curriculum consider to be moral.

The prevailing construct that guides our civics efforts has a moral posture and I have identified that moral outlook as the natural rights perspective. That moral stand holds liberty as its trump value. What I have been promoting, the liberated federalism construct, has its trump value, societal well being. This federalist value consists of a commitment toward securing the survival of the society and advancing toward those aims and goals that the society has identified for itself.

Let me focus on the first concern, societal survival. As for further explaining societal survival, when I state that that is central to the construct's value scheme, I am not saying other orientations don't concern themselves with this value. The question is one of focus or priority. The value for survival doesn't seem to be highlighted in other constructs. You see, especially among people who have never had to face survival head on, it tends to be easier to promote other priorities such as liberty or equality or religious precepts or whatever a given, other orientation might emphasize. Or the concern over survival might be taken for granted, not worth mentioning because, of course, everyone wants to survive. Finally, some might think that given our level of advancement in terms of technology or our military prowess, we are collectively well protected against any force or enemy that might bring our existential existence into question. But is this true?

In a recently released book, Elizabeth Kolbert,1 points out how our advanced technologies and economy are producing the conditions that are very well bringing our safety into perilous danger and yet our dominant values seem to be standing in the way of our meeting this challenge. Here are but some of the particulars concerning this threat. The planet is warming up. Because of the excessive heat we are generating, our water cycles are being affected. The extra warmth leads to higher humidity – globally 4 percent higher – which results in larger rain storms with accompanying floods and mudslides. The top layers of the ocean are becoming hotter, again leading to larger and more destructive storms. With the excess heat, the oceans have become more acidic. This excess acid is threatening an array of ocean life such as coral reefs. Whole ecosystems are endangered. Land areas are not immune to the deleterious effects. Heat quickens evaporation, leaving drier conditions. Longer droughts take place; dry conditions cause more and larger fires. Dryness causes lower food yields as we have seen with wheat, corn, rice, and other crops. As we have all heard, the melting ice caps in both polar regions have caused ocean levels to rise. In addition, we are beginning to experience resulting shifts in the usual paths of our major jet streams. More conducive to this abnormality has been the Northern Hemisphere jet stream. This results in not only unusual, higher temperatures, but also lower temperatures in areas that have arctic conditions pushed to more southern areas, giving those areas closer to arctic temperatures during the winter months. Sound familiar? A warmer planet doesn't always mean hotter temperatures, but it does mean more extreme weather conditions. And all of this leads to changes not just in weather, but also to the fauna and flora of the earth. For example, macro organisms which cause diseases might be more prevalent as the number of their carriers, such as mosquitoes, ticks, and others, increase.

These changes don't sound ominous just for today's weather reports; they are promising to be highly consequential in the years ahead. Kolberg warns us that we are in the beginning phase of a “mass extinction event.” This will be the sixth in the history of the planet since life first appeared 3.8 billion years ago. The last such event, 66 million years ago, caused the extinction of 75 percent of all living organisms, from those so small we would not have been able to see them to those of mammoth proportions. And yes, this all refers to conditions threatening societal survival.

As opposed to previous mass extinction events, this one is being caused not by some meteor, but by one of the planet's living forms – by humans – more specifically, by humans from the “advanced” societies, including us. As an issue, this whole condition falls under the federalist concern over survival in the most direct way.

1Gore, A. (2014). Without a trace. The New York Times, February 16, Book Review section, pp. 1 and 22. This is a review of Kolbert's new book: Kolbert, E. (2014). The sixth extinction: An unnatural history. New York, NY: Henry Holt and Compnay.

Friday, February 28, 2014

EL PRESIDENTE?

Recently, we have been “warned.” President Obama has told us: “I've got a pen and I've got a phone.” That is, if Congress, because of its inability to act, can't address the pressing issues before us, then he will act through executive orders. The cry from the opposition party is that the President is acting in dictatorial fashion and his actions will be illegitimate and unconstitutional. Is this right? Whether it is or not is a matter of reviewing each of his actions and analyzing it – not my purpose here. My purpose is to add some context to this whole question and establish some ground rules as to the notion of an imperial presidency.

My first introduction to this term, at least as it was being applied to contemporary conditions, was its use in describing the presidency of Richard Nixon. Symbolically, the concern was illustrated when he ordered the uniforms of the White House guards changed to resemble, to some, nineteenth century imperial uniforms and, to others, marching band uniforms. The get-ups were described as “palace guard” uniforms. Apparently, Nixon was inspired by uniforms he saw in Europe. But the move fed the general impression, mostly fostered by his opposition, that this sartorial move simply reflected the President's desire to institute an imperial presidency. The newer uniforms didn't last very long. As for my awareness, I probably already had been introduced to the concept of a strong presidency in my political science classes.

In the political science literature, there was – probably still is – a strong bit of reporting and explaining about the difference between what is called the “strong presidency” theory and the “weak presidency” theory. Weak presidency refers to the view that holds that our Constitution created the presidency to be of very limited powers. In effect, the powers of the office solely derive from his/her duty to carry out the wishes of Congress. The president, under this theory, simply awaits what Congress wishes, in the forms of the laws it passes, and merely carries out those wishes in a fashion that is as true to the intentions of lawmakers as possible. The use of the veto by the executive – the ability of the executive to say no to a particular bill – should be reserved for only the most extreme cases in which the Congress has passed an obviously unconstitutional bill or in which the bill would cause untold damage to the nation or to the security of the nation, especially in terms of foreign relations. This view of the presidency was very much in line with traditional federalist thinking and, as I have pointed out, in vogue long into the history of the republic. If that be the case, then one would expect the use of the veto to have been very limited during the years in which the traditional federalist view was dominant. From the presidency of Washington through that of Chester Arthur (1789-1885), there were 206 vetoes – including regular vetoes and pocket vetoes. Ninety-three of them were issued by only one president, Ulysses S. Grant. I cut it off after Arthur because the next president, Grover Cleveland, issued 584 vetoes. One needs to remember that Cleveland is the only president to have served two non-consecutive terms – he won one election, lost one, and then won one. In his first term, he issued 414. What is interesting about this turn, from Arthur to Cleveland, is that since then we have had a significantly higher frequency of vetoes by the executive branch. The all time record holder is Franklin D. Roosevelt with a total of 635. Then again, FDR served quite a bit longer than any other president, but ironically was graced with a Congress controlled by his own party. In any case, I believe the numbers support the general notion that early in our national history, our bias toward the presidency was to see the office as subordinate to Congress. Slowly, but unrelentingly, our acceptance and then our expectations for an active president grew and with that we had a change of heart. Consequently, the institution of the presidency has become the dominant branch. This shift began, ever so modestly, with the dramatic administration of Andrew Jackson (he issued 12 vetoes; significantly more than all six previous presidencies which totaled 9 vetoes). In contemporary times, since the Truman administration, the average number of vetoes per presidency is 66 1/4 vetoes. The highest numbers were recorded during the Truman (250 in eight years), Eisenhower (181 in eight years), and Reagan (78 in eight years) administrations. Of note, the Ford administration issued 66 in roughly two years and five months. In our current Obama administration, there have been, in five years, TWO. Perhaps the current president wants to reintroduce the weak presidency theory?

Of course, opposing the weak presidency theory is the strong presidency theory. Here, the idea is for the president to challenge Congress in order to implement the president's agenda and where Congress does not act, to take the initiative and act. The first annunciation of this theory was given to us by Andrew Jackson. He not only challenged Congress; he also challenged the Supreme Court by refusing to refrain from a policy the Court had ruled unconstitutional1 – a challenging strategy against the Court not followed by any succeeding president with the exception of FDR with his “court packing” scheme. In terms of relations with Congress, the question is: what are the initiating powers of the president to develop and carry out policy not authorized by Congress? For example, Theodore Roosevelt wanted to spend monies already allocated to send a fleet of our navy ships, the White Fleet, around the world – a showing-off gesture to promote our military prowess. Some said Congress had not authorized the expenditure. TR simply responded to the critique: “try and get it back,” referring to the money. Instead of a subservient role, the strong presidency theory calls for a cooperative relation between Congress and the president in determining what national policy will be. Sometimes, that cooperation reflects a coordination, and sometimes it is better characterized as a competition for power and influence. It is this sense of competition, many argue, that is more closely in line with the intention of the Constitution. It reflects the Madisonian ideal of having the branches of government compete so that excessive power would not fall on any one of them – “absolute power corrupts absolutely.”

As for the charge of whether the Obama administration is trying to reintroduce a weak presidency, not so, say his critics. I was watching a C-SPAN broadcast the other day of a Congressional hearing in which constitutional scholars were invited to testify as to whether the Obama administration was usurping too much power. With only two vetoes, the focus was not on stopping legislation, but on the President and his administration's execution of the laws. The charge is that through the actions of the President and his interpretations of the law, he is not executing the law as written. By behaving in this way, the President does not have the legitimate power to do what he is doing. An often cited example is his administering the Affordable Care Act in which he has delayed the implementation of certain mandates written into the law. I will not pretend to know enough about the law to determine whether he is guilty of using unsupportable power to delay those mandates, but there are certain guidelines by which to determine if that is the case.

Fortunately or unfortunately, laws at any level – national, state, or local – usually cannot be written with such specificity so as to spell out exactly how the law will be administered in its execution. Also, laws don't always come to the executive fully funded. That is, for every law that authorizes something to be done, such as the ACA, there needs to be an accompanying, but separate, law that appropriates the funds from the Treasury to pay for it. Often, that amount is not equal to the task. Hence, this usually gives the administration power in determining what parts of the laws to implement. This is the case unless the law specifically identifies a priority in spending choices. When the President states that he has a phone and a pen to carry out executive orders, in order to be legal, the authority to do so comes from the lack of specificity in the law or from a lack of funding provisions. Oh yes; there are times when the law specifically calls on the executive to determine the actual method by which the law goes into effect.

Take the issue of whether the administration will enforce anti-marijuana laws in Colorado where the recreational use of it has become legal under state law, but not federal law. The Obama administration has announced that it will not enforce those federal laws; that is, it will not spend its limited funds on policing statewide law breaking. Now, unlike a law, such executive decisions are easily reversed by subsequent administrations by the equally simple use of a pen and phone by a new president. Any executive action, which is a product of a law's lack of specificity or lack of funding, is in force only during the life of that administration, assuming the President doesn't change his/her mind and get rid of the order him/herself. The moment a newer administration decides to rescind it, it is no longer in effect.

Therefore, as a tool in implementing an “imperial” presidency or a “dictatorship,” executive action is a relatively weak one. The veto is much more effective and this president has been quite weak in its use.

Note: My use of the term, el presidente, is not meant as a slur of the Latino/a culture – heck; I'm a Latino. I just think it sounds more imperial, doesn't it?

1This had to do with the removal of the Cherokee – native American tribe – from the East to territories out West.

Monday, February 24, 2014

I DO, DO I?

I have in this blog referred to marriage as the fundamental federalist union. Here, two adults choose to form a union under the auspices of a covenant or compact. They promise to be by each other's side come hell or high water. And this includes all sorts of situations no matter what either one does. At least, that is the model. We, through the years, have compromised this ideal. I have to admit that the realities characterizing too many actual marriages fall far short of the ideal. Many of our popular dramas we love to watch are about how spouses, most often the husband, cheat on their partners in one way or another. Be that as it may, the importance of the family and the marriage upon which this institution is based need to be examined. It is a subject our youngsters in school should explore, because the role that marriages play in promoting a healthy society cannot be overestimated.

Yet our institution of the family is lacking sufficient success – current rates of divorce have leveled off at 45% since 1980. Consequently, we are under the burden of social effects that are detrimentally keeping us from accomplishing significant goals. Such as what? Such as a society with low crime rates, with an educated populace, with a labor force that can readily meet the demands of our modern economy, with a people who are able to seek and attain those personal ambitions they set for themselves. The simple truth is that marriages not only serve the spouses involved, but also set the stage for the creation of the next generation with all of its promise for the future.

So a central question in analyzing this institution would be: why would people want to get married? Why would they want to set up their lives, committed in the most intimate ways, with one other person? What are they looking for when they say, “I do”? And in this, as it turns out, there has been a significant amount of research, mostly by sociologists.

Eli J. Finkel1 provides a bit of an overview of recent findings one can find in this academic literature. He approaches this complex concern from the perspective of two domains: economic and psychological. One is the varying economic demands that people faced through the years of our nation's existence – how the particular set of demands of any era shape the expectations of prospective couples. The other domain is the psychological developmental stages that people go through as they have or don't have their perceived needs met.

As for economic demands, Finkel identifies three broad models he sees characterizing how Americans have viewed marriage over the nation's history: the institutional marriage (up to about 1850), the “companionate” marriage (1850-1965), and the self-expressive marriage (1965 to the present). Basically, as Americans were able to more readily meet the economic necessities facing them, this in turn helped Americans meet their needs. As they became more proficient economically, their motivational expectations developed into different psychological views as to what constitutes a workable marriage – a marriage that provides satisfaction of the expectations one has for getting married in the first place.

In general, there is a development among populations that progresses from the oldest, more austere times to the more prosperous times of today. And it happens that a respected psychological model on motivation helps us understand this development. That model is Abraham Maslow's “hierarchy of needs.” The model postulates that as one is able to satisfy a set of lower needs, one is confronted by a higher set of needs. The general trend is from the lowest level – survival needs (mostly biological needs for food, shelter, safety, and touch) – to mid-range needs – social needs of comradeship and love – to finally the highest level needs – personally directed needs of esteem and self-actualization. It's not that we lose our lower needs as we ascend this hierarchy; we continue to seek food and shelter, but our conscious emphasis falls on the higher and in many ways more complex needs.

Using these domains, Finkel identifies the three eras I listed above, each with its own view of what marriage should provide spouses. Let us review the implications of all this by explaining each marital model. The institutional marriage model was in vogue when the primary economic needs of Americans were to provide food and shelter. Sure enough, marriage decisions in the earliest years – pre-1850 – centered around concerns over providing the lowest level needs of food, shelter, and protection against violence. These were the primary considerations in determining whether one was to marry or not and to whom. Love? In an institutional marriage, one could hope for it, but the emphasis was on the more immediate survival considerations that were central to most people during those years.

With a more secure and prosperous economy, one could allow oneself to be more concerned with loving someone and with being loved. With basic needs for the most part met, in a “companionate” marriage, one can begin to look for and focus on companionship that reflects emotional attachment to one's perspective spouse. At the same time, men, especially, found employment outside the homestead – a movement from rural employment to urban labor. The sexes, in vast numbers, began to live in distinct social environments: the home versus a factory, mine, business shop, or office. The expectation became that love would keep these mates together, as opposed to those mutual concerns over making a farm a success.

In our last era, the self-expressive marriage model became prominent at least in people's minds. Since 1965, people have lived in significantly richer times. For those who have benefited from this largess, people have reasons to formulate a new set of psychological expectations. The cultural media outlets tend to promote these types of expectations since they are more likely to describe and focus on people from upper income households. And so, a different marriage model becomes prevalent: the self-expressive marriage. This has taken hold among most people since 1965. Under this model, the new emphasis becomes one's own individual needs: esteem and self-actualization, Maslow's highest levels. Marriage mates, who are now safely ensconced in lucrative careers, are not so dependent on companionship, but instead are apt to look for that person who will help or at least allow one to bolster one's self importance and/or one's self-meaning. But a word of caution concerning this view: I can't help but describe this as an outlook that encourages a more narcissistic view. If one does not define self-importance as being determined by service to others, the outlook is one of selfishness and, by definition, not one that bolsters the sacrifices that living with someone else demands – hence a 45% divorce rate. This is especially true if both partners see marriage with the same set of self-centered expectations. Unfortunately, in an age when the dominant social and political construct is the natural rights perspective, the likelihood that either or both spouses will see marriage as a means to advance a more self-serving agenda is much more likely.

Given the importance of the family and the relationship it has with the institution of marriage, there is a need to address all of these concerns in civics classes. Marriages have a crucial role in securing a healthy dose of social capital in our or any society. To quote a previous posting:
The problem of incivility [a central concern of civics education] can be defined as a lack of social capital. The social scientist [Robert D.] Putnam … defines social capital as a societal quality characterized by having an active, public-spirited citizenry, egalitarian political relations, and a social environment of trust and cooperation.2
If upon looking around today, you sense we have too few of these listed qualities, perhaps one of the reasons has to do with marital expectations that encourage selfish behavior that is non-conducive to healthy family relations.

Finkel reinforces the notion that we have higher divorce rates, especially among the lower income population (as reflected by lower educational attainment levels). He argues that lack of income makes self-expressing expectations more or less unaffordable. These types of findings lead Finkel to postulate that while divorce rates are high, those who can meet the expectations of current societal conditions tend to find themselves in very rewarding and self-enhancing unions. My take is that there are qualitative issues that these marriages must address, irrespective of their educational or income levels, and federalist thought might guide us toward looking at what those are. Does the marriage encourage healthy perspectives that frame the relationship in accordance with those qualities that advance social capital in whatever minimal amount that relationship can contribute? Does it, for example, promote trust between the spouses and between the couple and their social environment? Or does it encourage a self-serving posture that invites anti-social relations between them and/or among their social relations? All these are factors that contribute to the happiness a particular marriage enjoys and can determine its ability to not only survive but also be fulfilling.

As for couples that cannot literally afford higher expectations, whether in terms of finances, time, or energy (self-actualizing relations do take significant amounts of effort), Finkel suggests: “they might consider adjusting their expectations, perhaps by focusing on cultivating an affectionate bond [mid-range Maslow needs] without trying to facilitate each other's self-actualization.”3 For whatever level a particular person finds him/herself in, an understanding of the psychological forces that are in effect would, I believe, increase the chances for that person's eventual marriage to work. We all have a vested interest in upping the probabilities of successful marriages. These probabilities can be affected by what we address in school, particularly in civics classes.

1Finkel, E. J. (2014). The all-or-nothing marriage. The New York Times, February 16, Sunday Review section, pp. 1 and 6. The reported factual information in this posting is derived from this article.

2See posting More Formal Evidence of Incivility, November 1, 2010.

3Op cit., Finkel, p. 6.