A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Friday, January 30, 2015

MAGRUDER ON SOCIAL SECURITY

With this posting, I finish my review of Magruder’s American Government textbook.[1]  The effort has been to pass judgment on whether Magruder’s is more reflective of natural rights values and principles in its portrayal of governance and politics or whether it conveys more of a federalist bias.  This blog contends that the prevailing mental construct guiding the choice of content in our government and civics classrooms is the natural rights construct.  The blog promotes the federalist theory construct for that purpose.  I pick on Magruder’s because it is the overwhelming choice of American high schools as the text that teachers use in teaching American government.  As I have repeated often in this blog, one cannot overestimate how reliant teachers are on the textbook they use when determining the content of their courses.

In this final posting on this concern, I have chosen to focus on how Magruder’s treats Social Security.  Why?  I do so because I feel Social Security is the most federalist of programs at the national level.  Federalism, as I have described it, does put an emphasis on local governance and politics.  It is at that level that individual citizens can get involved and make a difference with policy choices.  But at the national level, the stakes are higher and draw the interest of more well-funded factions which renders the average individual at a prohibitive disadvantage.  Social Security is no exception to this general relationship.  But the way Social Security is structured makes it especially “federal.”  Let me explain.

Especially in its retirement program, we have one segment of the population providing for another.  Those young enough to work pay their FICA[2] tax and that, in turn, is used to pay for the benefits of the older generation that is now retired.  When the young grow older and retire, they will get the benefit from those who are younger and are working.  In other words, the program is an intergenerational compact and that structural provision binds the interests of all federated citizens closer together – a higher sense of partnership among us all.  My problem with how we view it is that few of us seem to understand this basic relationship.  Instead, we hear retired folks claim they are entitled to the benefit because they paid into it all their working years, as if those payments correspond to a forced savings program.  Few understand that those who live a normal life span will probably receive more in benefits than not only they paid in but also more than what would be normal interest returns on those amounts.  A healthy view of Social Security is to view it as a by-product of ourselves being federated with each other and providing a program that enhances the common welfare.  Social Security, for example, allows younger workers to go about their lives without being so concerned for the financial status of their parents.  And Social Security has but eliminated what used to be a chronic problem:  poverty among the elderly.  I know the program has certain financial challenges on the horizon and my purpose here is not to discuss that.  My only purpose is to highlight the program as an essentially federalist approach to a vexing problem:  how do you take care of those of us who can no longer work due to age?

So how does Magruder’s handle this program?  Here’s what it has to report:  on page 289, it informs students that Congressional members are covered by Social Security; on page 44, it explains that Social Security is designated as an independent agency and is not situated structurally under one of the “Cabinet” departments; on page 460, it defines the program as a social insurance program and  that it is funded by a social insurance tax; on page 461, it points out that the FICA tax is a regressive tax in that it is a “flat” tax – everyone pays at the same percentage of income rate; and on page 469, the text explains that expenditures of the program are “uncontrollable” in that they are entitlements and the monies are automatically issued.  This, of course, is not exactly true – a point the book makes – in that ultimately, expenditures can be controlled because Congress can change the law and, in turn, determine how much the program would pay in benefits.  Of course, this course of action would be highly unpopular and suicidal – career wise – for any politician who attempted or promoted such a change. 

In sum, in all that describing and explaining of Social Security, one does not have the federalist foundation of the program described, much less explained and, due to such instruction, little is done to inform and encourage a more federalist understanding of Social Security.  This, of course, enables in part the misunderstanding of the program alluded to above.

So, overall, Magruder’s does little to promote a federalist perspective.  I would argue that, instead, it promotes a natural rights view.  You are encouraged to look at the textbook yourselves and see if you agree.  If you get your hands on one, easily obtained at any public high school, have a list of governmental departments or agencies in mind; thumb back to the index and look up how that part of the government is explained.  You can do the same thing for a particular program such as Social Security or Medicare.  Am I advocating to get rid of Magruder’s?  Definitely not.  I believe the book to be a good reference book and that’s how it should function in the classroom.  Whether one uses a federalist theory approach or not, this text can be used as a “go-to” source for structural information about our government.  But it should not be used to determine what the content of a government course should be.



[1] McClenaghan, W. A.  (2013).  Magruder’s American Government (Florida Teacher’s Edition).  Boston, MA:  Prentice Hall/Pearson.

[2] FICA stands for Federal Insurance Contributions Act.

Tuesday, January 27, 2015

MAGRUDER ON PRACTICAL CONCERNS OF CITIZENSHIP

I am in the midst of reviewing a selection of inserts found in the American government textbook, Magruder’s American Government.[1]  Because this text is the overwhelming choice of government educators around the country and due to the reliance teachers place on textbooks, a look at Magruder’s is a good way to find out what content is being taught in those government classes.  To date, I have reviewed three of those inserts:  “letters to the editor,” “political campaigns,” and “volunteering.”  The series of inserts is meant to give practical advice to students who might be interested in involving themselves.  In general, the tone of these inserts cannot be interpreted as any hard sell on engaging in these activities – there is mention in one of them of obligation to be engaged, but that is as close to “selling” citizen participation as these inserts get.  In the main, they take on the tone of addressing a student who might already be inclined to an activity such as writing a letter to an editor.  I have indicated that judged by federalist standards, the inserts fall far short of being adequate; instead, they work quite nicely if one adheres to natural rights values.[2]

The remaining inserts I have looked at are:  “political roots and attitudes,” “voting,” and “writing to public officials.”  The most interesting of these is “political roots and attitudes,” the most useful and practical is “writing to public officials,” and the most disturbing is “voting.”  None of them, with the exception of one, give what I deem incorrect information, and they all are straightforward efforts to convey information.  None are an attempt to encourage the activity highlighted.

I found the “political roots” insert interesting in that it has students construct an opinion poll questionnaire on one of three issues: national debt, environment, and the economy.  While not making any effort to review what opinions are currently talked about concerning these issues, the insert seems to assume the student has some previously held beliefs and biases.  The concern is more about how to determine what classmates might feel about the chosen issue.  The information does not include any list of dos and don’ts concerning how to write an opinion questionnaire, other than to be neutral, but perhaps a teacher using the inserts can “springboard” into having students research the techniques that professionals use in such efforts.

The one disturbing bit of “information” found in any of the three inserts is in the “voting” insert.  There, voting is described as a privilege, not a right.  While voting is not a natural right, it is a civil right – a right created by law.  When one considers the sacrifices African-Americans and women and, in some countries, non-propertied workmen made to get those laws allowing them to vote,  referring to voting as a privilege is a bit disheartening.  Hopefully, there is no sinister motive in using this language.

The insert dedicated to writing to a public official is the most useful.  It gives good advice about how to structure any letter or email that a constituent might write so as to be more effective.  In so doing, the tone immediately becomes more encouraging.  It even mentions how politicians are more influenced by a voter, considering the effort such an activity might entail.  Given that a voter is willing to go to that length, he or she is probably someone who is willing to encourage others to hold similar opinions to those expressed in the letter or email.  Each of them, in turn, might be persuaded to vote in a certain way and as a result, that might affect the politician’s future success in keeping his/her job.

Overall, though, the effects of these inserts mirror those previously reviewed.  In terms of encouraging communal participation or social capital – the societal quality characterized by having an active, public-spirited citizenry, egalitarian political relations, and a social environment of trust and cooperation – the inserts are woefully lacking.

In my next posting, I will look at Magruder’s treatment of the Social Security program.  Earlier, I identified the program as one that is fundamentally based on federalist principles, at least as those principles are defined in this blog.  As such, a text’s treatment of the program, I feel, would give good insight as to how the material reflects either federalist or natural rights values and principles.



[1] McClenaghan, W. A.  (2013).  Magruder’s American Government (Florida Teacher’s Edition).  Boston, MA:  Prentice Hall/Pearson.

[2] For those of you who are new to this blog, the blog has dedicated a lot of space to explaining the difference between federalist values and natural rights values.

Friday, January 23, 2015

MAGRUDER ON WORKING ON AN ELECTION CAMPAIGN

Note:  In case you missed my last two postings, let me inform you that I am posting on Tuesdays, as opposed to my previous posting day, Mondays, and Fridays.

The last few postings have been about taking a look at the most widely used American government textbook and seeing how it treats certain concerns.  Specifically, I have been seeing if the textbook has a natural rights perspective with a heavy self-centered approach or, instead, a more communal approach – one reflecting a federalist bias.  This blog has been dedicated in part to promoting a federalist view and it has claimed that this is not what the prevailing approach has been in civics instruction.  In order to back up this claim, I decided that a closer look at the most widely used textbook would give us good evidence as to whether I am correct in this assessment.  Overall, for most teachers, the textbook determines the content of what he/she teaches.  Magruder’s American Government[1] is by far the most frequently chosen text for American government classes across the US. 

Due to limited space, I have in this review of Magruder’s tried to narrow in on key questions.  I have asked:  (1) What is the assumed motivation of a student that would encourage him/her to read the material? (2)  Does the material bolster/promote participation in pursuing collective goals or does the text encourage a more individualistic/self-interest posture? (3) Does the material advance social capital,[2] especially among high school students?  Most of the text – the overwhelming amount – is taken up with “slice and dice” descriptions of the different elements of the political system.  Earlier, I stated it takes on a scientific bias of assuming that by reducing elements of reality, looking at smaller and smaller elements, one can reach clear explanations of why things are the way they are – in this case, in terms of government and politics.  All one has to do is add up the different explanations of the varied elements and have a picture of the whole.  But as I previously pointed out, while this approach might lead to some level of explanation, it usually does not lead to understanding.  Most social reality, it turns out, is greater than the sum of its parts. 

Interspersed throughout the book are eleven inserts, collectively entitled “Citizenship 101.”  These inserts seem to come closest to addressing the federalist concerns I mentioned above.  To date, I reviewed the inserts “Writing Letters to the Editor” and “Volunteering.”  My judgment of these two is that both fail to inspire much that would be supportive of social capital or communal interests.  They make attempts to address what a citizen might do to get more involved with government and politics, but, at best, the attempts are judged to be lukewarm both in terms of information and tone.  With this posting, I want to review the book’s treatment of “Working on a Political Campaign.”[3]

In this insert, it is hard to determine what motivation is assumed on the part of the student.  The tone is light-hearted, but there is no describing what campaign workers experience.  I sense the author of the insert assumes a student who would read it is already wanting to work on a campaign – any campaign.  I write any campaign because in the steps the insert lists, the first step is “Get to know the candidate.”  This is before any consideration is given as to why one would work on a campaign.  Then, curiously enough, the second step is “Choose a Candidate.”  I fail to see the logic of this progression.  The last two steps are straightforward:  “Find out about volunteer opportunities” and “Choose a task.”  The steps, though, are perfunctory with little information or enthusiasm over what type of activity the steps entail.  Let me share the text for “Find out about volunteer opportunities”:
Political campaigns offer a wide range of volunteer opportunities.  A candidate may be looking for people to go door-to-door to seek support.  The campaign may need people to host or even just attend events.  Most campaigns need people to make phone calls or send out mailings of campaign literature.  Campaigns also appreciate financial contributions.[4]
Don’t you feel yourself wanting to run out and get involved?  Don’t you get a good sense of what it means to work on a campaign?  Don’t you just feel tingly over the possibility of doing something so exciting as working to get someone elected, someone you believe will help lead us to make a better community, city, state, nation?  Sorry; it’s just that campaign work is a chance to learn some important lessons about politics and an opportunity to work with like-minded people who might turn out to be life-long friends.  As with the book’s treatment of volunteering, couldn’t there be some case studies of young people working on a campaign or quotes from campaign professionals about what all is analyzed during a campaign?  To be honest, the text does have in its regular text information about voters and voter behavior.  There is a section dedicated to explaining why people don’t vote.  All of this can be useful in campaign work, but the tie-in is not built into the explanations.  There is a question in a section review (page 178) that asks:  “How do factors such as income and level of education impact rates of voter participation? … Why do you think this is the case?”  Magruder’s claims these are critical thinking questions.  How about using the text information and ask:  From what you know about why people don’t vote, how can a political campaign encourage reluctant people to vote?  Which political party would be more inclined to encourage high voter turnout?   This last question would have students look up and analyze: who votes, which party is likely to win low turnout elections; which party is likely to win high turnout elections?  Let me add another question:  Is it good for us to have high turnout elections?  Why/why not?  This is critical thinking. 

As with the other inserts already reviewed, I believe Magruder’s could do a lot more with the topics it has highlighted in these inserts.  In terms of motivation, the text basically takes the posture that students either have the motivation to work on a campaign or they don’t.  By using only minimal language of encouragement to get involved or to promote social capital, one is left with not much motivation or excitement emanating from Magruder’s.



[1] McClenaghan, W. A.  (2013).  Magruder’s American Government (Florida Teacher’s Edition).  Boston, MA:  Prentice Hall/Pearson.

[2] Social capital is a societal quality characterized by having an active, public-spirited citizenry, egalitarian political relations, and a social environment of trust and cooperation.

[3] Op cit,, McClenaghan, p. 141.

[4] Ibid.

Tuesday, January 20, 2015

MAGRUDER ON VOLUNTEERING

Note:  With this posting, I begin a schedule that has me posting on Tuesdays (as opposed to Mondays) and Fridays.  Oh yes; the Perry referred to in my last posting is, of course, Perry Como.

Let me continue my current focus in this blog; that is, taking a closer look at the content of the most popular government textbook, Magruder’s American Government,[1] and see if that material either leans toward advancing a disposition to self-interests or communal interests.  Does it present government as a social institution established to protect and advance individuals, much like the individual student, or does it present government as that organized effort to protect and advance the common good, the common welfare?  Of course, this is not an either/or question.  The textbook can advance both the individual and the community, but can we detect a bias since oftentimes the interests of the community are at odds with the interests of the individual and vice-versa?  In the last posting, I looked at one of eleven sporadically placed inserts.  Its title was “Writing a Letter to the Editor.”  With this posting, I will look at what might be considered a more directly related topic to community welfare or, as I called it in the last posting, advancing social capital.[2]  That is “Volunteering.”[3]

Again, the context of these inserts is that they take up a page each, though the actual amount of written information is less than the amount of information the text provides in its regular pages.  This one, dedicated to volunteering, begins with a call to volunteer by President George W. Bush.  A few organizations are mentioned as well as federal government’s efforts to facilitate volunteering such as USA Freedom Corps – the organization acts as an information distribution service and as a connector between non-governmental organizations and citizens interested in volunteering.  The insert informs the reader that while 20% of young people engage in some sort of volunteering, the overall number of people volunteering has dropped off.  The description does mention several sorts of activities that volunteers perform such as tutoring and maintaining hiking trails.  All of this information is presented in a matter of fact tone without any real effort to sell this “obligation” to the reader.  The information includes – following its usual format in these inserts – a list of steps that an interested party should follow in order to hook up with some volunteering effort.  They are:  make a list of interested activities, seek out opportunities of potential organizations that might put to work those interests, and make contact by emailing or calling.  As for seeking out opportunities, apparently teachers are a source of information to help a student find an appropriate organization or a student can research using the Internet to find that opportunity.  In making contact, the student is warned that he/she might need a resume or have references.

Of course, any reaction I might have as to the efficacy of this insert is purely an opinion.  But the insert could have done a lot more in selling this “opportunity.”  It could have presented case studies of actual volunteers.  It definitely is a topic that should have been given a lot more space.  Part of the information mentions how the system depends on volunteers to provide services that are important, but are not mandated by law or covered by a government program.  Perhaps a discussion on whether government should or should not provide some of these services might have been suggested or called for.  In any event, the whole topic, in my opinion, was treated as something quite inconsequential.  While the text benefits from having something about volunteering, it does not warrant the judgment, “well done.”  As a promotor of federalist values, I believe Magruder’s effort on this topic does not reach even the level of adequate.



[1] McClenaghan, W. A.  (2013).  Magruder’s American Government (Florida Teacher’s Edition).  Boston, MA:  Prentice Hall/Pearson.

[2] Social capital is a societal quality characterized by having an active, public-spirited citizenry, egalitarian political relations, and a social environment of trust and cooperation.

[3] Op cit., McClenaghan.  The insert, “Volunteering,” can be found on page 19.

Friday, January 16, 2015

“WE GET LETTERS”

I want to look more closely at those elements of content in the Magruder’s American Government textbook that I judged to address social capital.  Social capital is a societal quality characterized by having an active, public-spirited citizenry, egalitarian political relations, and a social environment of trust and cooperation.[1]  A civics curriculum (and that includes government classes) which is guided by the federalist theory in its content choices should strive to support, promote, and enable social capital generally, but specifically among high school students.  In my last posting, I made the claim that one content topic that a federalist theory-minded course should include is material regarding community development.  On that score, Magruder’s falls short.  I did mention that one potentially saving element in the text is sporadic inserts that, if treated appropriately, could support social capital.  I indicated that with this posting I would begin to take a closer look.  I want to begin with the insert topic of “Writing a Letter to the Editor.”  The institutionalized practice of local newspapers to dedicate space, usually on their editorial pages, to letters from their readership is a way to encourage and promote average citizens to voice their opinions, knowledge, and beliefs about current public issues.  It promotes active, public-spirited citizenry.

So, how does Magruder’s treat this topic?  My concern here is to detect a bias toward a communal orientation versus a self-interest orientation.  The insert begins with a sample letter to an editor. Let me reproduce the letter here:
Editor:
Regarding the article on additional budget cuts to public education (“Government Proposes Slashing School Funding,” May 9), I believe that every penny spent is a necessary investment in the future of this community.  As a junior at Westfield High School, I know that these cuts would place students’ futures in greater jeopardy.  Last year 15 percent of the teaching staff and 10 percent of all elective courses were eliminated due to severe reductions in funding.  These cuts ultimately impacted the quality of our education, and that is a sacrifice this town should not be willing to make again.
-Thomas Grey, St. Clairsville[2]
This letter couldn’t be a better example of lobbying.  Take a public policy that negatively affects your interests, manipulate the pitch so as to provide a general welfare angle, and use language that denotes a concern for the community.  Interesting, I think, is the fact that textbook funds come out of the same pot of money as those affecting the budget cuts referred to in the letter.  Couldn’t another example be thought of?  Anyway, I believe this example to be well within the guidance of the natural rights construct – a construct that promotes self-interest.

And here, following this sample letter, is the introduction:  when writing a letter to the editor choose a topic that affects you and your community.  The rest of the insert lists steps you should take in writing your letter:  briefly summarize the issue, explain your position, make a suggestion, and identify yourself.  Given this advice, there would never be letters from middle class citizens about the plight of the poor or what we should do about undocumented citizens or the space program.  These issues are too far removed from a typical individual or community.  In short, in terms of writing to the editor, I believe Magruder’s is far less than a promoter of community development and basically presents the topic as just another way to help students get what individually advances their self-interests.

Note:  Since the inception of this blog, my postings have been on Mondays and Fridays.  Starting with my next postings, due to other activities, my posting days will be Tuesdays and Fridays.



[1] Putnam, Robert D. (2000). Bowling alone: The collapse and revival of American community. New York: Simon & Schuster.

[2] McClenaghan, W. A.  (2013).  Magruder’s American Government (Florida Teacher’s Edition).  Boston, MA:  Prentice Hall/Pearson, p. 631.

Monday, January 12, 2015

MAGRUDER ON COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT

If you have been following this blog over the last two postings, you know I am reviewing the senior high school textbook, Magruder’s American Government.[1]  The purpose is to see how much the content of the book enables or encourages those attitudes and skills supportive of social capital.  The term social capital I derive from Robert Putnam’s writings.  He uses the term to mean a societal quality characterized by having an active, public-spirited citizenry, egalitarian political relations, and a social environment of trust and cooperation.[2]  In the last posting, I shared the textbook’s table of contents.  From that listing, we can judge the book to be heavy on conveying the structure of the central government, who and what  influences Washington – factions, political parties, etc. – and how influence upon that government takes place.  From the table of contents, we did not denote any emphasis on how individuals or local groups can be successful or viable to any degree in bolstering communal interests.  But this only begs a closer look.  I therefore will begin with this posting looking at whether the text in its finer points addresses these more public-spirited topics.

I will look at whether the book has anything to say about communities, community development, neighborhoods, charities, or non-profit organizations.  I feel that these are the types of topics one would associate with social capital.  Using the index of the book, this is what I found.  There is no listing for community(ies), community development, neighborhood(s), or charity(ies).  There is no listing for non-profit organization(s), but there is one for non-governmental organizations (NGOs).  When I looked up NGOs, the text mentions that the United Nations works with NGOs in administrating a number of its programs around the world.  While commendable, this type of information is not what bolsters social capital among your average high school student population.  In short, in terms of community, Magruder’s has little to nothing to say.

But what the text does have are inserts sporadically placed throughout the book which are entitled Citizenship 101.  Each insert is dedicated to a different topic; they are:  debates, evaluating leadership, juries, letters to the editor, political campaigns, political roots and attitudes, polls, television news programs, using the internet, volunteering, and writing to public officials.  Each insert takes up about half a page (the entry might take up the entire page, but a lot of the space is taken up with a photo or words, leaving a good deal of empty space).  Given the font size and spacing of its usual text material, the information in these inserts would take up a good deal less than half a page if it were presented as part of the usual text.  The format is the same for all of them.  It begins with a quote, then an introduction to the topic, a list of things to do in order to perform some action in relation to the topic follows.  For example, the list for evaluating leadership has three steps:  “decide what factors are most important to you;” “match the skills to the job;” “compare their qualifications.”  For each step, there is a short “how to” explanation to help the student accomplish the step.  I am disappointed that these entries are given such small emphasis, but some of the topics I do believe are related to social capital.  They are:  letters to the editor, political campaigns, political roots and attitudes, volunteering, voting, and writing to public officials.

Is the treatment of these topics really written in such a way as to bolster or enable social capital – a federalist theory aim – or are they written to promote self-interest agendas as those would be more in line with a natural rights perspective?  My next posting begins to take a closer look at the six topics I have highlighted.  Before I do this let me point out that no matter what we find, these entries are a very small part of this book.  That by itself conveys the notion that what is contained is not that important.



[1]McClenaghan, W. A.  (2013).  Magruder’s American Government (Florida Teacher’s Edition).  Boston, MA:  Prentice Hall/Pearson.

[2] Putnam, Robert D. (2000). Bowling alone: The collapse and revival of American community. New York: Simon & Schuster.

Friday, January 9, 2015

FOCUS

As I indicated in my last posting, I want to present a content analysis of the government textbook, Magruder’s American Government.[1]  The book will be from here on referred to as Magruder’s – that’s what we in the business call it.  Again, my purpose is to see how much the book encourages a student in one direction or the other between thinking in a collectivist fashion or an individualist fashion.  This will not be anything like an extensive review; one, I believe, is not needed.  For my purposes, by asking a few questions about a few topics of content, we can get a good sense of where the book’s emphasis is along this dimension.  The questions guiding this analysis are:  what is the assumed motivation of a student in his or her reading of the book’s content?  Is it to further the student’s role within collectives or is it to advance his/her knowledge of what is useful to advance personal political/governmental ambitions?[2]  Does the book cover the needs of organizations or other arrangements or does it focus on what the individual needs to know to advance private concerns?  The content choices are developing community (better known as community development), placing a demand on government, influencing local governmental policy, and describing or explaining a governmental agency – such as Social Security.  I have chosen these topics because they relate directly to social capital.  In turn, social capital refers to a societal quality which is characterized by having an active, public-spirited citizenry, egalitarian political relations, and a social environment of trust and cooperation.


Let me start by sharing the book’s table of contents.  Remember, we are interested, as I pointed out in my last posting, in how much the author of the book, William A. McClenaghan, dissects the subject matter.  Here are the chapter titles and number of pages in each chapter:
Chapter 1 – Principles of Government, 26 pages
Chapter 2 – Origins of Government, 38 pages
Chapter 3 – The Constitution, 26 pages
Chapter 4 – Federalism, 28 pages
Chapter 5 – Political Parties, 30 pages
Chapter 6 – Voters and Voter Behavior, 32 pages
Chapter 7 – The Electoral Process, 30 pages
Chapter 8 – Mass Media and Public Opinion, 28 pages
Chapter 9 – Interest Groups, 26 pages
Chapter 10 – Congress, 28 pages
Chapter 11 – Powers of Congress, 34 pages
Chapter 12 – Congress in Action, 34 pages
Chapter 13 – The Presidency, 36 pages
Chapter 14 – The Presidency in Action, 26 pages
Chapter 15 – Government at Work:  The Bureaucracy, 30 pages
Chapter 16 – Financing Government, 26 pages
Chapter 17 – Foreign Policy and National Defense, 38 pages
Chapter 18 – The Federal Court System, 26 pages
Chapter 19 – Civil Liberties:  First Amendment Freedoms, 32 pages
Chapter 20 – Civil Liberties:  Protecting Individual Rights, 34 pages
Chapter 21 – Civil Liberties:  Justice Under Law, 34 pages
Chapter 22 – Comparative Political Systems, 32 pages
Chapter 23 – Comparative Economic Systems, 30 pages
Chapter 24 – (Florida edition) Governing Florida and the States, 34 pages
Chapter 25 – (Florida edition) Florida’s Local Government and Finance, 31 pages

There are 180 days in the school year.  Many weeks of the school year are not made up of five days.  For example, Thanksgiving week is only three days.  Many schools operate under the assumption that every course taught can follow the same format in that tests are assigned a specific day of the week so as not to overload a student with too many tests on the same day.  So your test day in biology would be on a Monday, social studies on a Friday, language arts on a Wednesday, and so on.  The natural approach is to divide your course by units that last a week and attempt to cover a chapter per unit.  That means a chapter needs to be covered – given the practical constraints of the calendar – in a week’s time.  Now put yourself in the shoes of the average high school student – a person who cares next to nothing about the topics covered in Magruder.  And then there is the fact that government is one of six courses you are taking.  Government in Florida is offered usually in the senior year and some of your other courses might include pre-calculus, physics, and world literature.  So figure in applying to colleges and the general exhaustion of being at this type of schooling for twelve or more years.  And for the teacher, this is the challenge if you choose to accept it:  teach American government in such a way as to promote social capital using the above content.

My first reaction to the above list of chapters is that the above content puts almost all of its emphasis on the structure and working of the central government and how it is influenced – only two chapters, at the end of the text, are dedicated to local government and most of that attention is at the state level.  Social capital is promoted by participation in governmental affairs.  For most of us, effective participation is limited to involvement with local government – usually city or county government, not national government.  Why?  Most of us do not have the resources to affect national policy, but we do have the resources to influence local politics and policy formation.  So if the goal is to promote participation which in turn encourages social capital, shouldn’t the emphasis in our government education be directed to the local level?  That’s what makes sense to me.  The above distribution of attention, on the other hand, I judge to be geared not to participation, but observation.  If successful, the above content seems to me to be geared to informing the average citizen so that he or she will be knowledgeable enough to view the national news, understand it, and perhaps vote for national policy makers from a knowledge base that can translate personal preferences to those voting decisions.

What I will outline in the next few postings are exceptions to this general observation of Magruder’s.  Let me emphasize that the exceptions are just that; they make up few entries in the textbook and are easily lost and ignored, given the overall challenge of “teaching” an almost 800 page textbook in fewer than 36 weeks.  In the next posting, I will specifically address the topic of community development.



[1] McClenaghan, W. A.  (2013).  Magruder’s American Government (Florida Teacher’s Edition).  Boston, MA:  Prentice Hall/Pearson.

[2] By political/governmental ambition I do not necessarily mean a pursuit of a career in politics or government.  I am referring to any desire one might have in which government action is necessary to fulfill.  This can extend from filling in a pothole to receiving a Social Security payment.  Of course, it also includes getting a government job.