A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Friday, July 26, 2019

COMPETING HISTORIES


One of the background bits of information undergirding a lot of what this blog has to say is the ongoing “debate” between establishment educators and academic educators.  A simple rundown of what divides them can take the following form:  the establishment favors a natural rights point of view and academia favors critical theory. 
The natural rights view summarily supports individuals holding basic rights and that they can behave to exercise those rights as long as such behavior does not interfere with others enjoying their basic rights.  Critical theory believes society is ruled and controlled by monied interests and the resulting political/economic system is set up and sustained to advance those interests. 
Each side strives to move education toward recognizing the governmental/political, national perspective they respectively harbor, to pursue policies it sees as ideal, and delegitimize the related beliefs of the other side.  This leads to a different set of policy preferences:
·        For establishment educators, policy should support and be directed toward preparing students for the competitive environment that categorizes the economy. 
·        For critical theorists, policy should encourage the citizenry toward overthrowing the exploitive society – this can be done peacefully – so it can advance to a general state of equality in which all will equally share in the economy’s benefits.
As a short expression of these opposing ideas, one can simply state what each side’s trump value is:  natural rights holds liberty – or what the literature calls natural liberty or equal condition – and critical theory holds equality – or what the literature calls equal results.  As a point of context, the current political landscape seems to indicate that the electorate is swinging toward one camp or the other by abandoning what is usually called the “political center.”  Another way to describe this:  both sides are getting closer to the extremes – nationalism and socialism.
As for this posting, the aim is to see how each side treats educational history in the US.  If either can have its view of the past as the general view, this would lead, among the electorate, to agreements over many assumptions one makes in promoting one set of policies as opposed to the other set.  This writer believes that that would be an important achievement by either side as it would “grease” the way toward being successful in many policy debates.
But before explaining that, here is a contextual point that needs to be mentioned.  One should not view education as a consumer service.  Instead, one should see it as a discipline; in order to succeed, it demands that a reasonable amount of effort be exerted by students.  This account mentions this because of its varied implications.  When reformers consider changes in education, they need to remember that this basic relationship – between students and subject matter – should dictate important parameters as to what should be considered.
Often, those who discuss reform, be they establishment advocates or critical theorists, do not take this fact into consideration.  How an educational system is run, therefore, goes a long way in determining whether the resulting service is reasonable in its demands in the expected efforts called upon by students, parents, or other involved adults, such as teachers and school administrators.  With those ground rules, what do these opposing sides view as being the educational history of the nation?  Here is a short answer.
Naturally, both sides have differing historical accounts they favor.  So, how can one see these dual views separately and in comparison, to each other?  A central concern of critical theorists can be used to begin this review.  That is:  why, to begin with, does an exploitive nation, such as the US, have a public-school system?  Here are the two opposing answers to this basic question.
The establishment believes that on the face of it, public schooling allows the masses to become educated and, through that experience, can improve their competitive posture.  In turn, this, with hard work, can lead to ever higher levels of rewards that lucrative careers can accrue.  In short, education can lead to equal opportunity assuming the educational system works sufficiently well. 
This assumption is one of many that critical theorists question.  Critical theorists do not accept that the above overall aim is true.  They argue that an alternate motivation was at play when the rich agreed to sign up and support a public-school system, an essential element in instituting such a system.  
On the critical theory side, one can summarize its view by stating that public schooling came about due to how rich people saw a vast population.  That population, mostly poor, would have little to no motivation to favor, uphold, or otherwise support the existing, exploitive polity and its economic system.  Given their lack of any meaningful stake in what was, the masses were left to their own devises to not only be antagonistic toward that system, but also, through lawlessness and outright rebellion, undermine it.
Chief among the upper class’s concerns, were behaviors that aimed at destruction.  Yes, religion could be counted on to stave off some of these beliefs or feelings, but on a day to day basis, a more instituted effort could be made to promote a message of how good the system was and, better still, that message could be imparted early in life. 
Not only could such a schooling institution do these things, but it could also socialize people to except such exploitive practices as forcing the working class to submit to the factory system, in which manufacturers forced workers to earn a subsistence wage.  By the way, schools used the factory model to physically structure their operations.[1] 
The promotors of public schooling could and finally did sell this essential message to the rich.  It has been further supported, critical theorists would say, with the underfunding that public schooling has struggled through the years since its inception.  Of course, because of funding formulas across the country, one can readily see the results of such funding when one compares the physical resources schools in lucrative areas have compared to say inner city schools where struggling people live.
That, in a few sentences, summarizes why critical theorists argue the rich – in this nation and in just about all nations that have public education systems – supported initiating and funding such expensive operations among the states of the US.  Of course, lately the rich are thinking of ways to lighten that financial burden.  Critical theorists are apt to see such “reforms” in this light, and one can easily see why the critical theorists might question the motivation behind moves toward some alternate school models such as charter schools.[2] 
On the other side, natural rights advocates favor a different history.  They might see some of the above counterproductive practices – e.g., the factory system model for structurally arranging schools – but usually chalk those up to how people generally saw education at a given time.  They instead look and emphasize those actors and movements that strove to make education available to the public. 
And they proudly point out those cases where people of modest means have been successful in an array of professional careers.  For example, the head of Amazon went to high school in the Miami-Dade school system. 
In addition, they like to tout the efforts of such historical characters as Horace Mann who in the 1800s “believed passionately in the value of public schools and common education for the children of Massachusetts and defended his proposal in flowery … terms.”[3]  But, one should note an issue that bogged down a harmonious beginning to the public-school system. 
Among the populous, initial efforts found a lot of disagreement over any normative elements being included in the resulting public-school curriculum.  What one needs to keep in mind, initial efforts at public schooling emanated from a time when there was broad concern over any educational effort especially those involving moral content. 
Most insisted any resulting curriculum should include moral content based on sectarian foundations.  But, the founders of the public system faced a public strongly divided – for one thing, Roman Catholics who objected to the Protestant bias started their own generally affordable system.[4] 
Despite this divergence, American schooling evolved into a homogenous product.  Here is Toni Massaro’s summary:
Despite this resistance, compulsory schooling came to dominate the educational landscape during the 1900s.  By 1918, every state had adopted a compulsory school act.  In the 1920s, Cremin reports, “over ninety percent of American children between the ages of seven and thirteen were reported as enrolled in school,” and the vast majority of them were enrolled in public elementary and secondary schools.  Moreover, the content of this education became reasonably, though never completely, coherent.[5]
This writer argues that the resulting curriculum up until roughly the 1960s had a strong moral component.  Cremin lists various moral strains which categorized the content among the various state systems that include:  New Testament values, Poor Richard’s Almanac wisdom, and Federalist Papers’ political messaging.  This writer feels this ended in the sixties and that a more natural rights bias has become dominant and has instilled a less communal content-based curriculum that generally avoids dealing with moral questions.
Part of adopting federation theory to guide educational efforts, especially in civics, is a call for a communal curricular base that actively deals with moral questions, but on a secular basis.  This blog has argued that the federalist view can and should be seen as a compromise between both the natural rights view and critical theory.  Again, the nation seems to be edging toward the extremes of these views and that, in turn, can result in dire consequences.


[1] Here’s the analogy:  The raw material was students, they were submitted to timed sessions, they were molded and passed on the assembly line of different workers/teachers and were submitted at the end of the assembly line as finished – educated – products.  In addition, production areas, the classroom, were to be arranged in neat rows to better keep oversight on how well the material was progressing.

[2] These semi-public, semi-private schools are often seen as just means of draining public resources away from regular public schools to provide cheaper semi-private schools to affluent families that usually do not have the oversight to which regular schools are subjected.

[3] Toni M. Massaro, Constitutional Literacy (Durham, NC:  Duke University Press 1993), 12.

[4] For an account of this division, see Robert Gutierrez, “Some Initial Rancor over Education,” Gravitas:  A Voice for Civics, December 1, 2017, accessed July 25, 2019, https://gravitascivics.blogspot.com/2017/12/some-initial-rancor-over-education.html .

[5]  Toni M. Massaro, Constitutional Literacy, 14.

Tuesday, July 23, 2019

MORE INFORMATION ON OPIOID CRISIS


In the past, this blog has shared lists of factoids and insights this writer links to the opioid crisis.  His interest in that concern has not waned.  His reading into the topic has led him to Beth Macy’s book, Dopesick.[1]  Using Macy’s work, this posting adds to the previous listings.  Below, it also informs the reader how to find the initial listings.
          First item:  One depressing factoid is that America’s life expectancy, between highest fifth in terms of wealth and the lowest fifth, widened between the years 1980 and 2010 by 13%.  The Appalachian poor account for a significant portion of that widening due to the incidence drug taking (much of it being opioids).  “[O]verdose mortality rates [are] 65 percent higher than in the rest of the nation.”[2]
          Second item:  Part of the marketed advantages, according to its producer, of OxyContin was its longer period of pain relief.  Purdue Pharma claimed its relief lasted three times longer than the claimed relief time – four hours – of most other pain pills.  In addition to that reported advantage, the company claimed that since the drug had a slow-release time, it would frustrate those who used the drug to elicit a euphoric rush and, therefore, discourages its use for that purpose.  This latter advantage has proved to be untrue.
          Third item:  The use of poppy derived opium can be traced back to Neolithic humans.  Apparently, the two aims have been all along to induce a high and/or to get cured of some malady.  Jumping to a much more recent time, but considered some time ago, were the years before and during the Civil War.  It is during that time the use of morphine became common.
Fourth item:  An early proponent of morphine, an opioid, was Dr. Alexander Wood, the inventor of the hypodermic needle.  Wood touted that one use for his needle could be injecting morphine which was to avoid the drug’s addictive quality that resulted from either swallowing or smoking it.  His promotion was made in the mid-1800s.  Of course, his claim proved to be untrue as its application to Civil War veterans demonstrated; many of them – 100,000 – became addicted.
Fifth item:  The Macy book should be read if for no other reason than to become informed of the work done by Dr. Art Van Zee and Catholic nun, Sister Beth Davis, in their work to combat the marketing efforts of pharmaceutical companies to promote the distribution and use of opioids.  They should be considered for one of those awards that are handed out in Washington to outstanding citizens by a president or the heads of Congress.  Van Zee has won over a dozen national awards.
Sixth item:  On a cultural level, Macy provides an insight into the Appalachian people.  “In an Appalachian culture that prides itself on self-reliance and a feisty dose of fatalism, peddling pills was now the modern-day moonshining.  Some passed the trade secrets down to their kids because, after all, how else could they afford to eat and pay their bills?”[3]  Macy, with this last reference about being able to afford food, is reflecting the devasting effects caused by the elimination of jobs in that region due to the cessation of coal mining or manufacturing jobs.
Seventh item:  The Appalachian coal region can be credited with bucking a trend.  Many postings in this blog have repeatedly claimed that the nation has abandoned, as a dominant view, the federated view of citizenry.  That is, as was the case before World War II, Americans were easily apt to involve themselves in communal efforts to address local problems.  But since that war, they have not been so disposed.
It also describes, as an exception, how after many years suffering from an opioid addiction problem, the city of Portsmouth, Ohio of late has begun to seriously address this addiction.  The lack of initiatives generally can be regarded as an enabling factor in the spread and severity of that epidemic.
But here is another case countering the general trend.  It turns out that miners in Appalachian localities had portions of their pay directed to build a clinic way back in 1973.  In addition, these communities of miners have initiated fund raising efforts – like bake sales and talent shows – that have actively solicited money from their neighbors to meet the needs of drug affected families.  Of note, these efforts were organized by three nuns who were, in turn, inspired in their youth by the War on Poverty programs initiated by the efforts of LBJ’s administration.
Eighth item:  An added factoid regarding the elements of an addiction is that an opioid addiction, like alcoholism, lasts a lifetime.  Relapses are common and active treatment, to be effective, needs to last ten years.  While 40-60% of treated addicts experience remission – when assisted with appropriate medication – relapsing among them is a problem.  In the meantime, 4% of opioid addicts die annually from overdoses.  Given that the death rate is 68,500, in 2018, over 1.7 million Americans are addicted today.
Ninth item:  And for this posting, the last factoid it offers is to report that, as with the addiction problems after the Civil War, recognition of opioid addiction on such drugs as Oxi-Contin was slow to develop.
For readers who are new to this blog or to those who have not kept up with the blog’s description of how factoids and insights are used for classroom purposes, the following is offered.  Factoids are “bundled” facts that can be utilized in conducting an inquiry over an issue or societal problem.  Insights are statements of some cause and effect relationship between or among factors.  In both cases, these statements are useful in constructing arguments.[4]
Also, this writer has accumulated a list of factoids and insights relating to the opioid crisis.  That can be found online and has the following URL:  https://onedrive.live.com/view.aspx?resid=CED163627385DD3C!11635&ithint=file%2cdocx&app=Word&authkey=!AFhwqIF3ZhONVK8 .  He will, within the next few days, add the above factoids and insights identified to this online site.


[1] Beth Macy, Dopesick:  Dealers, Doctors, and the Drug Company that Addicted America (New York, NY:  Riverhead Books, 2018).

[2] Ibid., 16 (Kindle edition).

[3] Ibid., 42 (Kindle edition).

[4] See Stephen Toulmin, The Uses of Argument (London:  Cambridge University Press, 1969) AND Robert Gutierrez, “The Structure of an Argument or Two,” Gravitas:  A Voice for Civics, May 15, 2015, accessed July 22, 2019, https://gravitascivics.blogspot.com/2015/05/the-structure-of-argument-or-two.html .

Friday, July 19, 2019

COMPLICATING PUBLIC INFLUENCE


Does the American government do what Americans want it to do?  In an earlier entry, “Is the Love Real?” (January 12, 2016), this blog reported findings from research conducted by Paul Burstein.[1]  That researcher looked at how much the American federal government followed what Americans wanted it to do in terms of 60 issues.  Here is what that posting reported:
Of the sixty policy proposals, public opinion polls were silent on 40% of them.  Of the 60% that had polling information, Congress seems to abide by public sentiment 50% of the time.  As for the “silent” 40%, there is no reaction to whether the proposals should be considered, much less as to whether the policy proposal should be adopted or discarded or adopted in a modified fashion.  As for soliciting the attention of interest groups, they responded to only three of the 60 proposals.  Again, the indifference is sufficiently palpable.
But should one be surprised?  Most of what government does is of little concern to most Americans.  Should an Interstate plan call for this or that routing option or should it implement a certain maintenance schedule?  Who cares unless one owns property in the affected area?  In short, this question of how reflective governmental policy is of citizen desires is not that easy to answer.
In Burstein’s account, he goes go on to cite opposing findings among social scientists.  James A. Stimson published his findings in 1995 that argue not only does public opinion influence policy decisions, but there is nothing else that matters.  Some other researchers agree, but still other ones disagree.  Agreeing, in an earlier, 1993, article, is Robert Erikson (who this writer found himself in his class back in the late 1960s on the campus of Florida State University – surely, he does not remember the encounter). 
Yet, citing a review article by Jeff Manza and Clem Brooks, Burstein informs the reader that political sociologists don’t agree.  They don’t just disagree; they don’t even consider this factor in their research.  Actually, Burstein doesn’t clarify whether political sociologists ignore this factor due to their opinion that it does not fall within their theoretical concerns or that they find, through their research, it doesn’t matter.
Burstein summarizes both camps with the following:
… on balance, there is great support for the view that public opinion consistently influences policy, sometimes very strongly, not only in the United States, but in other countries as well, over time and on a wide range of issues … [According to Soroka and Wlezien] “in major policy domains … the people ultimately decide” what policy will be, especially on issues the public cares about.[2]
This finding is not limited to the United States, but to advanced countries in general and that includes, surprisingly, the Russian Federation as well. 
          Elsewhere in this blog, a recurring message has been that Americans in general have decreased their level of engagement with politics and governance.  This lack of involvement serves to encourage this writer to write this blog; he feels it indicates that his fellow citizens are not sufficiently exhibiting federalist values, of acting in accordance with the obligations of a partnership – it’s like missing the board meetings of a company.
          So, reading that governments do follow public wishes in general, maybe citizens not engaging in an ongoing fashion is not that important.  This then needs to be further looked at and this blog will do so in the future.  A question for now is:  what specifically should be asked of how this influence is determined and measured?  While there is general agreement with this more generalized sense that public opinion matters, a more telling question might be:  how do they influence public policy?
          Researchers have turned their related concerns to an array of circumstances in which that influence is exerted.  That is, they are looking at intervening factors affecting this relationship.  For example, do political power holders effectively manipulate the perceptions of the public?  When this blog picks up this topic again, it will look at the process of advocacy.  Burstein offers information in that concern.
          Whatever that research reports, hopefully the reader agrees that this notion of public influence enjoys a central place in why and how civics teachers should teach their subject matter.  This writer can report that the textbooks used in their central role in determining what is taught say little over this concern.


[1] Paul Burstein, American Public Opinion, Advocacy, and Policy in Congress:  What the Public Wants and What It Gets (New York, NY:  Cambridge University Press, (2014).

[2] Ibid., loc. 224 (Kindle edition).

Tuesday, July 16, 2019

POWERING AS A CONDUIT


This blog, as a recurring concern, attempts to share ideas regarding power.  Politics revolves around the use of power; this social mechanism is central to any understanding of politics.  And this blog, in its treatment of power, relies on Robert Dahl’s definition, power is a condition in which one party, person or collective, convinces some other party or parties to do something they would not do otherwise.[1]  In addition, to further this perspective of power, this blog has also relied on the work of John French and Bertram Raven’s “bases of power.”[2]
          As stated earlier (posting, “What Power,” November 28, 2017), French and Raven identify five bases:  coercion, reward, legitimate, expert, and referent power.  That posting pointed out the problems associated, first, with coercive power – its likelihood of engendering resentment and a desire to extract revenge – and second, with the other bases, of generating feelings of being manipulated. 
At times this can not only engender motivations to not comply openly or under some subversion, but if compliance is elicited, for it to be done with low levels of competency.  All these negative consequences usually result in the power holder policing the “compliance” in any subsequent acts.  Policing can further engender negative feelings and, to the degree it does, it generates costs – sometimes, significant costs.
Finally, the earlier posting offered “three faces” of power offered by Joseph S. Nye.  Using Nye’s words:
First Face:  [Party] A uses threats or rewards to change [Party] B’s behavior against B’s initial preferences and strategies.  B knows this and feels the effect of A’s power.
Second Face:  [Party] A controls the agenda of actions in a way that limits [Party] B’s choices of strategy.  B may or may not know this and be aware of A’s power.
Third Face:  [Party] A helps to create and shape [Party] B’s basic beliefs, perceptions, and preferences.  B is unlikely to be aware of this or to realize the effect of A’s power.[3]
As described, progressing from one face to the next, certain attributes take hold and chief among them is that the subject is less likely to know he/she is being subjected to a power interaction.  And before one castigates all of this as something evil or sinister, one should remember that parents exert power all the time and smart parents strive to use the above “Third Face” strategy.
          Nye goes on to write of the importance of social networks in the implementation of power.  Networks function in various ways.  Two functions of importance are their role in communication and in furthering the legitimacy of power holders.  People understand the importance of communication – after all, how does one know what he/she is expected to do if he/she is not told – but might find legitimacy a more subtle quality.
          Beyond legitimacy as a bases of power, legitimacy refers to how the power holder is viewed.  One can disagree with a specific power play, but that does not in itself debase the legitimacy of the power holder.  What bolsters that legitimacy are many factors, among them is the existence of institutional networks that provide the foundations upon which the society resides.  And in this, Nye situates the above “faces.” 
He writes:
Another reason not to collapse all three faces of power into the first is that doing so diminishes attention to networks, which are an important type of structural power in the twenty-first century.  Networks are becoming increasingly important in an information age, and positioning in social networks can be an important power resource.  For example, in a hub-and-spokes network, power can derive from being the hub of communications.  If you communicate with your friends through me, that gives me power.[4]
So, beyond legitimacy, the faces enhance all the bases of power by creating functional roles if extended and institutionalized, the power becomes indispensable or perceived as such.
          And upon further reflection – and based on ample case studies – when holes develop in these networks, when direct communication is hindered or ruptured, the ability to provide bridges in those gaps can result in newer or novel bases for power relations.  Used in this fashion, the possibility of forming federated relations becomes possible.
          That is, such formulations can allow for third face strategies to take hold.  They can target information flows that encourage or permit innovation, cooperation, and collaboration, to further institutionalize more communal power relations.  How?  By “plugging” network holes.  This is what Kenneth Boulding called “integrative power.” 
In turn, this helps establish power friendly, social landscapes that, in turn – according to relevant research – furthers the use of empathy and social intelligence.  And when that happens, would-be power holders are more effective in their attempts to solicit compliance than when they rely on force, deception, or terror. [5]
          Examples of theorists Nye cites in backing this view include Hannah Arendt – “power springs up among men when they act together” – and John Ikenberry – “American power after World War II rested on a network of institutions that constrained the United States but were open to others and thus increased America’s power to act with others.”[6]  While it is a stretch to categorize such efforts as being federated ones, it does encourage one to see it as taking steps in that direction.


[1] Robert Dahl, Who Governs:  Democracy and Power in an American City (New Haven, CT:  Yale University Press, 1961).

[2] John R. P. French, Jr. and Bertram Raven, “The Bases of Power,” in Current Perspectives in Social Psychology, ed. Edwin P. Hollander and Raymond G. Hunt (New York, NY:  Oxford University Press, 1967), 504-512.

[3] Joseph S. Nye, Jr.,  The Future of Power (New York, NY:  PublicAffairs), 14.

[4] Ibid., 17.

[5] Ibid.

[6] Ibid., 18

Friday, July 12, 2019

FINDING MANAGEABLE CHANGE FACTORS


Change, what an elusive event.  Yes, life is full of change, for example, one doesn’t wear the same style of clothing each day.  But significant change, change that reflects changes in values, attitudes, and/or beliefs happen very seldom.  Perhaps the reader can think of his/her own past and try to think of such a fundamental change.  This writer can probably number on one hand the times he has experienced such changes in his life.  He admits, among friends, that he did go through two changes in his basic outlook concerning values.
          One might ponder this general state of affairs when considering change over some relatively important institutional norm.  While this writer finds it difficult to admit, most Americans do not find civics education as that important.  But if one were to suggest a line of instruction that most Americans might deem were un-American, that might engage their interest.  The writer is reminded of how the fear of communism stirred in the 1950s and 1960s a popular change.
          He remembers how due to this fear, through the leadership of conservative politicians, but was easily supported among the electorate, the state of Florida instituted a new course of study.  That is, to earn a diploma, a Florida high school student had to pass an American-vs.-Communism course.  The thing is, teachers were forced – in most cases without objection – to teach the course but with little supervision.  Yes, at university, they had to take a special course to prepare them for this assignment, but seemingly that is where supervision of the effort ended.
This writer was one of those affected teachers and he taught the course from a more open-ended approach and steered it away from being a propaganda exercise.  The textbook he was assigned to teach the course was published by Time-Life and that publisher was noted for having, through their publications like Time magazine, a conservative bent.  But it still ascribed to general, objective journalistic standards and, in the opinion of this writer, the textbook was very informative and did not approach the subject in a propagandistic way. 
Using for the most part a discovery approach, this writer feels he provided a useful course of study.  In any event, he enjoyed teaching it, believes his students did not find it a waste of time, and hopefully they learned something about another system of governance with its faults and perhaps some advantages.  He did not sugar coat the more brutal aspects of that totalitarian system.
The point here is, given the goals of the conservative politicians, what was provided in the state’s classrooms was a far cry from those goals.  If anything, young Floridians were exposed to a curriculum choice far from any cartoonish take on the attributes of soviet governance which, given their rhetoric, was probably the goal.  Change is difficult.
In that, a current book sheds light on the change process.  Headed by Leslie R. Crutchfield, a team of researchers took it upon themselves to find what the elements of successful and unsuccessful national movements are – movements that called for meaningful change.[1]  This is a very important area of concern unless one thinks the nation has already achieved perfection.  Chances are the reader does not.
This posting will serve as merely an introduction to this study.  It identifies some overarching factors that affect change, mostly those that serve as the background context to change efforts and in which a change agent has little to no control.  That is, it asks:  what are the elements of a social/political/economic landscape in which a change effort is attempted?
Admittedly, the Crutchfield book does not spend much ink in addressing these contextual factors.  They are mentioned toward the beginning of the book and then the text goes on to highlight those factors that are subject to being manipulated.  But they – the contextual factors – are important and the right mix of them can doom a change effort no matter how well the other factors are addressed.
They are luck, misfortune, timing, and changing cultural attitudes.  Just to mention the strength of one of these, cultural attitudes, one can easily cite the above historical example.  That would be the effort of the conservative politicians that succeeded in getting the Americanism-vs.-Communism course added to the Florida state curriculum, but not much else.  They could not have foreseen what the growing effect of the Vietnam War would have on the psyche of Americans. 
As the legitimacy of that war became questioned – to ever increasing levels – the whole anticommunism bias, even in conservative Florida, could not continue to be unquestioned.  In short, if those in power were lying about Vietnam, what else are they lying about?  For those who had high hopes for the new course of study, they did not count on this type of fundamental questioning, especially among the young.
Nor could they have done much about it.  The political landscape was changed by exterior forces way beyond the control of Floridians – be they part of the power structure or not.  What occurred was a societal/political shift over a relatively short span of time.  Within ten years, the whole communism fear idea changed drastically.  But Vietnam is an extreme case, one that probably only happens once or twice within the course of lifetime.  What of other changes, ones that happen not as quickly perhaps but still within the memory of a lifetime?
These are the change examples the Crutchfield team studied.  She writes:
But we also recognized that significant societal shifts do not occur at random … [Like reduction in smoking, increase in gun ownership, acceptance of same-sex marriage] … These changes occurred because of the relentless advocacy of vast networks of individuals and organizations, campaigning in the face of seemingly insurmountable obstacles and often against entrenched, powerful opponents.  In spite of it all, they prevailed.[2]
It is these examples that future postings will address.  That is, not from the inter-personal dynamic perspectives, but from a stage where one can observe the more political interactions among the various players in such change efforts.  The research of the Crutchfield team offers telling stories from which political strategies can be derived – savvy strategies that have been successful and imprudent strategies that have proven not to work.


[1] Leslie R. Crutchfield, How Change Happens:  Why Some Social Movements Succeed While Others Don’t (Hoboken, NJ:  John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2018).

[2] Ibid., 4 (Kindle edition).

Tuesday, July 9, 2019

WHOM TO BELIEVE?


On more than one occasion, this blog has cited Lawrence Lessig.  He, in 2011, came out with a book that had a dire message.  That is that the nation’s republic is endangered.  “But the feeling I am talking about today is different:  not that we, as a people, have lost anything of our potential, but that we, as a republic, have.”[1] 
          As most good writers do, he proceeds, in his book, to provide evidence for his major argument.  This posting picks up on this message.  The reader might reflect:  does Lessig, after these many years, still have a point?  What would indicate that he does?  After all, the nation is still functioning, its major institutions are still operating, and social life still progresses with a general air of cooperation. 
When this writer leaves the front door of his abode, he does not expect to meet chaos out there.  Yet, is there an accompany air of everything not being the way they should be?  And if so, isn’t that just part of living.  In the conscious decades he has lived – from the fifties to today – each set of years seems to have had its set of “doomsday” concerns. 
The complacency of the fifties, the rebelliousness of the sixties, the malaise of the seventies, the “Me-ness” of the eighties and nineties, the global challenges of the “ought” years (punctuated by the 9/11 attack), and now the set of unprecedented politics one observes emanating from the nation’s capital seem to be an unending movie.  But is there something more fundamental today that was pre-envisioned by Lessig at the beginning of the current decade?
What one hears today on the media is that the nation is having an attack on its basic institutions.  Perhaps, one should give Lessig more of a listen.  He begins by citing an institution that has been questioned all along, that of the markets.  It’s not so much that the markets themselves are corrupt, but what transpires within them is prudently questioned.  At the time of Lessig’s book, a question bandied about was:  are cell phones safe? 
Americans were subject to reports from industry studies that they were.  There were other independent studies that said they were not; that they emitted harmful, cancer inducing “rays.”  Well, with the advent of earplugs, that worry seems to have passed.  Yet, while the controversy progressed – and what probably encouraged the industry to develop a solution – average consumers were apt – or at least in sufficient numbers – to believe independent studies.
Why? Well, they, the independent studies, were likelier unaffected by the profit motive.  Afterall, the cell business by 2011 had grown to be a multi-billion-dollar concern.  People hesitant to use the product because of independent studies would have translated into significant loses.  In addition, industry studies were likely to be held with suspicion.  If money is at stake, people recognize that and are biased to believe those who have no or little skin in the game over those who do.
To place more context to this, one should consider Lessig’s words:
Across all three domains we tested, the mere suggestion of a link between financial incentives and a particular outcome significantly influenced the participants’ trust and confidence in the underlying actor or institution.  Doctors’ advice was judged to be less trustworthy if the procedure they recommended was tied to a financial incentive.  Politicians were judged to be less trustworthy if they supported a policy consistent with the agenda of contributing lobbyists.  Researchers for consumer products were judged less trustworthy if their work was funded by an agency that had a financial stake in the outcome.  And most surprisingly to us, these variations in the hypotheticals we presented also significantly influenced the participants’ judgments of their own doctors, politicians, and consumer goods.  Even the suggestion of one bad apple was enough to spoil the barrel.[2]
But, unfortunately, it is not that simple all the time.  What if one side has no profit angle – they can call it either way with little to no financial consequences – but they discover a relevant fact or issue that the general population does not want to hear or if they hear, do not want to believe?  Here, what Lessig says in his book, can take on a more relevant quality.  It can gather a relevancy not only for a tendency to undermine general trust levels among the population but to interfere with devising and implementing extremely important policies.
And if the issue under consideration, promises to have a one-way – i.e., unfixable – consequence(s), one can easily understand the importance of this development.  Presently, there are various issues vying for one’s attention; all of them important especially for those directly involved.  But there is one that affects every person not only here in the US but across the planet.  Of course, that is climate change.
Among the general population, there has been a reluctance to accept warnings related to climate change.  Was the earlier reporting by the media, that questioned the veracity of certain institutions, undermining current warnings or is it that a specific institution, the scientific community, is just issuing a message average Americans do not want to hear?  In this, a recent conversation with a relative comes to mind.
Are climate and/or weather developments indicating that there is a change in climate occurring and, if so, is it the product of human activities?  When this topic has come up before, this relative has questioned whether climate change is a real thing.  In a more recent conversation, his message is:  okay, it can be climate change, but any widespread fix – for example, abandoning gasoline powered automobiles – would result in enormous, negative consequences for millions of workers and destroy the economy. 
Perhaps, that’s progress toward accepting the dire messages the scientific community has been communicating concerning climate.  But it still does not take in the whole story.  One can, and this writer failed to do, point out that a shift to renewable energy sources means the creation of millions of jobs.  Net effect is unknown to this writer, but still this positive consequence can be communicated when the issue arises. But the issue here is:  why do Americans even question the legitimacy of the scientific community? 
Is it, as Lessig warned some years ago, there is an erosion of trust over the actions and statements of the nation’s institutions and that does reflect a dangerous development?  This writer believes that there is for civics teachers no greater issue than whether Americans are questioning their institutions; they should address this issue in their classrooms.  Of course, the first instructional aim would be to have students know, understand, and appreciate what institutions are and how they function in the maintenance of the republic.
A people establish institutions to rely on established ways to accomplish societal aims and those ways, in their manifestations, are associated with certain organizations or groupings.  Some of these are within government and some are not.  The two institutions under current attack are the press and the intelligence community.  There is also the above-mentioned target, the scientific community.  These are important institutions and they are protected by law, even constitutional law when it comes to the press. 
Yes, any human endeavor can be improved, but when one of these entities is labelled the “enemy of the people,” one should investigate not only the institution, but those who are issuing such a claim.  This blog avoids stating political messages, but this issue gets at the basic notion of citizenship and the ability to federate with the elements of the polity. 
Institutions, due to their central role in not only allowing a federalist political environment, but of maintaining any form of legitimate governance, need to be believed and deserve to be protected.  Civics classrooms should not avoid this undermining development that offends the basic elements of a viable republic.  Perhaps a way to refer to a healthy treatment of institutions is for Americans to see them with a critical, but sanctifying eye.


[1] Lawrence Lessig, (2011).  Republic Lost:  How Money Corrupts Congress – and a Plan to Stop It (New York, NY:  Twelve, 2011), 1.

[2] Ibid., 29.  Emphasis in the original.