A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Friday, July 15, 2016

FROM A CHALLENGING SETTING, A CHALLENGE

In a recent article that gives an overall account of how effective our current efforts in civics education are, Kathleen Hall Jamieson forms a set of conclusions. These conclusions are:
1) neither the federal government nor the states have made high-quality civics education a priority; 2) social studies textbooks may not adequately convey the knowledge or facilitate the development of the skills required of an informed, engaged citizenry; 3) consequential differences in access and outcomes between upper- and lower-class students persist; 4) cutbacks in funding for schools make implementation of changes in any area of the curriculum difficult; and 5) the polarized political climate increases the likelihood that curricular changes will be cast as advancing a partisan agenda.[1]
I have in this blog discussed many of these states of affairs, but one I have not addressed is number 5, the effect our current polarization has had and which directly draws attention to the challenges of changing our curricular offerings.

Let us say you are a parent, a teacher, a school official, or a national leader who is convinced that our civics offerings have to change.  There are, of course, many political obstacles facing you.  The most obvious obstacle is that those whose power is dependent on the status quo and, therefore, will view any meaningful change as threatening, will likely be against you.  But let us further say that a proposed change becomes popular – oh, perhaps federalist ideals become the “in-thing” – and it is politically advantageous to adopt and attempt to implement the sort of curricular changes that are promoted in this blog.  Does that guarantee a successful change?  No, it does not.

Why not?  The main problem is that what is being proposed includes not only changing textbooks – which, by the way, I don’t suggest doing – but also changing how people basically do their jobs at the school site.  What is being promoted in this blog, can be implemented to varying levels of change.  It could simply mean that teachers consider different concerns when they prepare their lessons.  For the teacher who simply follows the textbook, this level could be challenging.  As I have explained in earlier postings, the prevalent textbooks in the field are based on a natural rights perspective in the content and format they employ.  For the teachers who follow the content, page after page, of the assigned textbook, all of a sudden they are being asked to impose a different perspective on that content.  Whether those professionals are prepared for such a task is more a catch as catch can type of situation.  Some are sophisticated enough; some are not.  Therefore, in-service training, an expensive and time consuming proposition, would have to be part of the change effort.  But further, I would consider that what is being proposed is transformational in nature; that is, it calls on teachers to change not only their objective view of the subject matter, but more likely, a normative shift as well.  This could be assisted by, to the degree it exists, the popular call for such a change.  But popular whims come and go.  Early in my career, I experienced the popular concern over the Soviet threat as spurred on by their launch of Sputnik.  By the time I was teaching, just a few years into that period, the fear of Sputnik had been effectively quieted and with that, all calls for changes in education ceased to be heard.

A heightened level of implementation would call for a school to change how it was run.  A federalist approach to schooling would count on a shared and collaborative approach to organizing, planning, and teaching among teachers, teachers and administrators, and among administrators.  To just comment on one of these collaborative settings, that of teachers, let me report that from my experience, teachers are very much cloistered when it comes to their view of their classroom, not their school.  The classroom is viewed, by most teachers, as their domain.  As such, they are highly sensitive to the, in their eyes, illegitimate meddling by other teachers or abrasive administrators.  I write “abrasive” not due to any personality traits, but by the very nature of what these other people attempt to do.  Therefore, what is needed in order to effectuate the type of change being sought is a change of heart – not just of what is believed to be true, but what is believed and felt should be true.

Now let’s get real.  As Jamieson points out, we are in very divisive times.  I believe that one reason for this condition is our overall view of government and politics, that of the natural rights construct.  This has been explained previously in this blog.  Our current presidential race demonstrates sufficient evidence of this partisan divide which has also characterized our inability to meet many of our national, political needs and demands.  Negotiations and compromise have almost become impossible to achieve even when it is mutually advantageous for all sides to agree.  To agree would hand success to the opposite side and, if one is of the opposition party, would help improve conditions which reflects well on the party in power.  Again, a change that might threaten such partisan environment will not be welcomed and will be judged suspiciously.  It will be evaluated by the standards set by any supportive ideology either side might hold.  Federalist thought will probably be interpreted by the left as a belief system supporting parochial, bigoted life views which it is not.  The right would see it as a challenge to individual prerogatives and heightened governmental intrusions which is true to a limited degree.  As proposed in this blog, the liberated federalism construct – the proposed construct – has been presented as a synthesis between natural rights and critical theory.  As such, there are aspects of this proposed construct that are seen positively by either side of the political divide, but more important in a partisan environment, are seen as antithetical to cherished beliefs.  Consequently, under our current conditions, any attempt to shift our curricular content toward a federated view will be a long one in which careful and prescient planning needs to be done if it is to be successful.



[1] Jamieson, K. H.  (2013).  The challenges facing civic education.  Daedalus:  Journal of the American Academy of Arts & Sciences, Spring, 142 (2), pp. 74-75.

Tuesday, July 12, 2016

INITIAL POWER FACTORS

In the literature of politics, probably the most often cited definition of power is provided by Robert Dahl.[1]  That definition takes the following form:  power is a condition in which one party, person or collective, convinces some other party or parties to do something they would not do otherwise.  This is the definition I have used in this blog.  I have also cited Harold Lasswell’s context for power:  who gets what, when, how, and when.[2]  I have added, with little humor, “and how much.”  Of course, since political science is a social science, one should not confuse this use of the term with how an electrician or a physicist uses it.  They, it turns out, can measure this physical entity; political scientists cannot measure its social counterpart.  Is this important in our attempts to understand politics?  I would say it is.

Power has been considered more or less the central concept in political science.  It’s akin to what the concept, energy, is in physics.  Again, they can measure accurately and precisely their main variable.  Insofar as we cannot in political science or in the study of civics, we are highly limited in our predictive “powers.”  And after all, is it not the main reason for having a science in the first place to be able to predict and, in turn, control?  Perhaps it’s just as well we can’t measure this essential quality of politics.  If it were possible, those who could would have an untold advantage over the rest of us.  Please don’t think that there have not been attempts to measure it; there have, but to no avail.

In this posting, I want to consider some of the conceptual thinking that has gone into this aspect of politics and reported by Joseph S. Nye, Jr.[3]  Starting with the basic structure of Dahl’s definition, he basically explains that the definition is wanting.  It glosses over certain components of a power relation that, it turns out, are essential to delve into in order to understand power’s scope and domain in a given relationship between parties.  By the scope, Nye is referring to the who – the who, who is administering the power (the powerful) and the who, who is the subject of the power exercise.  By the domain, he is pointing to the substantive issues or social/physical conditions over which the exercise of power is performed or attempted.  So, in the obvious case of a government instituting a policy on desegregation in schools, the who is those citizens and school officials who will change their practices in order to comply with the new policy and the domain is the educational practices involved.  But when we look more closely at the scope and domain we find factors, if you will, that are very telling about the situation which not only reveal important social dynamics, but get at what is exactly powerful about what is happening.

Running through this view is the notion that someone with power is able to get what he/she wants by getting others to do things.  But the power lies in the fact that to some degree, the other person(s) are not disposed to do that something.  Here lies the murkiness that prohibits clear measuring.  Simply stated, we don’t know, in a given situation, how disposed a person is.  But that aside, there are other shortcomings.  When a party is getting others to do something, this is done through mechanisms.  The supposed power holder(s) need resources so as to be able to “convince” the subject to be a subject.  In an attempt to simplify this, let me point to three types of motivators that solicit a subject’s compliance.  They are to avoid punishment, to seek reward, or to satisfy an attraction – let’s call these coercive power, reward power, and attraction power.[4]  And in this, we can designate two overall categories of power:  hard power – mostly referring to coercive power which depends on either authority or destructive capacity such as with military resources – and soft power – mostly referring to capacities to change the subject’s mind so that he/she/they want to do the powerful person’s bidding either through rewards or through a sense of righteousness, knowledge, personal, or some other appeal.  In all of this, the subject need not know who is exerting power in order for power to be administered – many times the powerful would rather remain anonymous.  This might assist future exertions of power.  Of course, there can be combinations of these approaches.  The point is, though, that any definition of power should at least allude to these factors; they are that central to the meaning of the term in how it is used in political/civic analysis.

This leads to seeing or defining power from two perspectives.  We can define it in terms of resources or we can define it in terms of behavioral outcomes (what the subject is either expected to do or actually does).  In each perspective, there is a necessary process.  Either resources (e. g., military assets) have to convert into a viable strategy before desired behavioral outcomes are accomplished or the means are chosen by which desired wishes are skillfully accomplished through actions initiated by the powerful.  Actually, in either case we are saying the same thing:  a goal or aim is sought by implementing a course of action that successfully converts desired outcomes into behavioral outcomes.  And this leads to an array of variables (factors) that have to be accounted for in the development of that/those strategies.

That is a topic for another day.  But let’s make a stab at a definition:  power is a social relation in which one party or parties get another party or parties to do something due to some strategy which sufficiently eliminates or diminishes any reluctance by the use of coercive, reward, and/or attraction resources.  While these factors still elude exact measurement, it might lead to better estimations.



[1] Dahl, R.  (1961).  Who governs:  Democracy and power in an American city.  New Haven, CT:  Yale University Press.

[2] Lasswell, H. and Kaplan, A.  (1950).  Power and society:  A framework for political inquiry.  New Haven, CT:  Yale University Press.

[3] Nye, J. S. Jr.  (2011).  The future of power.  New York, NY:  PublicAffairs.

[4] These types are derived from French, J. R. P., Jr. and Raven, B.  (1967).  The bases of power.  In E. P. Hollander and R. G. Hunt (Eds.) Current perspectives in social psychology (pp. 504-512).  New York, NY:  Oxford University Press.  These writers identify five types:  coercive, reward, legitimate, referent, and expert.

Friday, July 8, 2016

INTELLIGENCE IS CHANGEABLE

I have previously in this blog, based on the work of Carol S. Dweck,[1] made a distinction:  a student in school can place emphasis on learning for its own sake or learning in order to be able to perform in some endeavor.  Yes, a student can have both motivations, but the concern is whether or not a student places priority on one or the other or excludes one or the other.  According to Dweck and her research, if a student emphasizes performance or out and out excludes learning for its own sake, there are resulting problems with students advancing in their learning progression.  Let me explain why.

Among students, there seem to be two overarching held theories as to learning and intelligence.  One theory sees intelligence as an entity.  Students who see intelligence in this way consider it as a given amount; one is born with that amount and the more one has, the easier it is to learn new material.  This view can be described as fixed, more or less concrete, and internal.  You have what you have and that’s it.  The other theory sees intelligence as incremental.  This incremental theory describes intelligence as malleable, willfully changeable, and dynamic.  In other words, a person can become more intelligent.  While one can hold the two motivational types identified above, one cannot logically hold these two views of intelligence simultaneously.  Intelligence is either fixed or changeable; it can’t be both.  One can hold one view at one time and, later, be convinced of the other.  But it seems to me that this is one of those basic beliefs one holds, either consciously or subconsciously and as such, the belief can affect what learning activities one is likely to pursue.  It also affects how one judges others.  If a person sees intelligence as unchangeable, he or she is apt to hold those who exhibit low levels of intelligence as being highly limited in any efforts they might expend on improving their positions in life.  Can one change one’s view of intelligence?  To the degree a person’s view of intelligence is an unconscious belief, it would probably take either many indirect experiences to convince one of changing this view or direct instruction that is aimed at changing that view.

In assessing these views individually, let’s look at the “entity” view first.  If a person holds this view, one is prone to seek those settings, including learning experiences, that allow the individual to demonstrate, i.e., “show off,” one’s smartness.  Therefore, this view leads to a bias for performance opportunities.  In seeking these settings or experiences, the person is apt to further diminish whatever motivation he or she might have had for learning for its own sake – at least, that is what Dweck’s work indicates.  Why?  Because actual learning experiences are challenging by their very nature and, as such, a person’s engagement in them might not produce the opportunity to show off.  On the other hand, those persons – students, in the case of Dweck’s work – who see intelligence as incremental, seek learning experiences that do not necessarily offer opportunities to demonstrate mastery or their “smartness.”
We found a clear and significant relation between the students’ theories of intelligence and their goal choices:   The more students held an entity theory of intelligence, the more likely they were to choose a performance goal, whereas the more they held an incremental theory, the more likely they were to choose the learning goal.[2]
This finding was similarly found among college students.  The research found that such biases affect the type of learning experiences toward which a student strives.   If he or she is an “entity” student, he or she will strive for good grades and other demonstrable exhibitions of his/her knowledge or abilities.  An “incremental” student, on the other hand, will strive for challenges that offer opportunities to learn, but at the same time offer the possibilities of failure.  For incremental students, these possibilities are just an inherent attribute of the learning process. 

Practically, for those students who do not see the possibility to change intelligence, they tend to be more conservative, more reserved, in their learning strategies.  These “entity” students are more concerned with removing obstacles to doing well in their performance efforts rather than with seeking challenging opportunities.  Dweck theorizes that for them the motivation is to avoid those conditions which might demonstrate to themselves or others that their “entity” might be deficient or less then others’ “entities.”  This is not good; we want people to take on challenges and this, in turn, is enabled – even promoted – by the other view of intelligence, the incremental view.  That view would be one that is bent on learning for its own sake.  If one believes one can change how intelligent one is, one is apt to seek those experiences that offer the opportunity to do so.  This can be in the form of remedial work, advanced work, or whatever is reasonably calibrated to the sophistication of a particular individual and promises to provide a learning result.

How readily are we to be dissuaded from one view to the other view?  In a set of studies Dweck conducted, it seems that subjects who were given written material – written for a general audience – that described intelligence in a more incremental way, seemed to opt for learning, as opposed to performing, instructional experiences.  This indicates that we are open to being instructed to viewing intelligence as malleable and susceptible to being improved or increased.

I might add that the incremental view is more democratic and more amenable to federalist thinking.  It is gratifying to know that this reported research exists and that it bolsters a more democratic view of this very human quality:  intelligence.



[1] Dweck, C. S.  (2000).  Self-theories:  Their role in motivation, personality, and development.  Philadelphia:  Psychology Press.

[2] Ibid., p. 21.

Tuesday, July 5, 2016

LIMITS ON RELATIVITY

When I began my college education, quite a few years ago, I took a course titled Social Science I.  The course had a strong anthropological bent to it.  One of the organizing concepts of the course was cultural relativism.  Simply stated, the instructive message was for us to view other cultures as equal to ours.  The qualities of a culture are the product of historical happenstance in the sense that cultures are the products of developmental processes and that any one culture, except for the accidents of the past, could have a trait of any other.  A subtext was that one cannot judge one culture as being more morally sound than any other.  Therefore, bolstering one’s culture as superior is dysfunctional in terms of understanding the cultural traits of other people and in terms of justice.  Thinking one’s culture is superior in any sense is what we call ethnocentrism. 

This idea is a bit touchy.  People have a natural bias toward their own culture.  My take was:  okay, I have a bias for my culture, for my way of life, but that bias needs to be set as a preference – more of an aesthetic preference.  But, as the years subsequent to those early college days have taught me, this whole way of viewing culture has some shortcomings.  While the notion of cultural relativism had a profound effect on me – it seemed to make so much sense – as I pursued my interest in civics education, I began to qualify my beliefs concerning this realm of interest.

Let me point out that this blog’s content has been heavily influenced by a cultural concern.  I have addressed our cultural bent on governmental and political beliefs and how they have evolved from our colonial days to the present.  I have argued that our history has been characterized by the dominance of two cultural/political constructs:  traditional federalism and natural rights.  I have further argued that we, in making a cultural decision, should adopt a newer version of federalism – liberated federalism – to guide our selection of content in our civics curriculum.  This argument is based on an assumption; that is, that there is a preferred cultural content when it comes to deciding what content our youngsters should be exposed to in their tax-funded public school classrooms.  Some might argue that such a policy defies the implied principle of cultural relativism.  I would like to address this concern.

To begin, I in no way have recommended that any cultural tradition is less than any other.  What I have implied is that for our national polity, in order to meet certain challenges – low political knowledge, low levels of political engagement, criminality, and relatively high levels of incivility – certain cultural elements should be at least considered by young students.  Those elements would be introduced in the form of issues that civics instruction would have students tackle.  I have dedicated space in this blog to describe this approach, but I want to further explain why I have chosen this strategy and how it is not an example of ethnocentrism.

The term, “We the people,” means something; it means that there is an entity made up of human beings who are tied together.  What ties them together is a set of ideas and ideals.  This phrase is the first words of our compact, the United States Constitution.  Constitutions are the ideals of a political culture meeting the realities of a polity.  It is not a claim that the ideals contained are the best or superior ideals for everyone, but it is what we believe is best for us.  In that spirit, we adopted that constitution and what it contains.  Our collective lives have evaluated its content and we, after 240 years of national existence, still believe it is best.  As for immigrants who come here from other traditions, we don’t expect them to relinquish their beliefs and ideals unless they counter those that are essential to our constitutional structure.  The federalism I promote in this blog takes a step further.  It does not judge beliefs, but it expects behaviors that promote federalist values.  In this blog, I offered a federalist moral code.  But for my purposes here, let me address this whole concern from another perspective.

Inherent in the moral code I proposed is the trump value of societal welfare or the common good.  I have stated that this value is experienced in two domains:  societal survival and societal advancement.  What do I mean by societal advancement?  Is this progress by Western standards?
The idea of “progress” is suspect for those who are committed to cultural relativism, for whom each culture defines its own goals and ethics, which cannot be evaluated against the goals and ethics of another culture.  Some anthropologists view progress as an idea the West is trying to impose on other cultures.  At the extreme, cultural relativists and cultural pluralists may argue that Westerners have no right to criticize institutions such as female genital mutilation, suttee (the Hindu practice of widows joining their dead husbands on the funeral pyre, whether they want to or not), or even slavery.

But after a half century of the communication revolution, progress in the Western sense has become a virtually universal aspiration.  The idea of progress – of a longer, healthier, less burdensome, more fulfilling life – is not confined to the West; it is also explicit in Confucianism and in the creeds of a number of non-Western, non-Confucian high-achieving minorities ….[1]
The author of these words, Lawrence E. Harrison, goes on to point out preferences that he claims and that I agree are universal or near universal.  They are:  life is better than death; health is better than sickness; liberty is better than slavery; prosperity is better than poverty; education is better than ignorance; and justice is better than injustice.  While there might be disagreement about the exact definition of terms (e. g., the term justice) the overall sense is fairly understood and accepted.  The argument can be further extended to state that certain cultural traits advance progress along these concerns and others hinder or defy these concerns.  I would count the values that support these preferred states as operational values (although liberty and justice are identified as instrumental values in the moral code I offered in a previous posting).  As such, one can make value judgments as to the content of cultural traditions.  These judgments are not wholesale denunciations of any particular tradition, but a more specific focus as to particular cultural biases, attitudes, behavior patterns, and values.  Under a liberated federalist approach, they are legitimate areas of inquiry in which students would be asked to pass judgement on counter federalist practices.  So, for example, if there is a cultural bias against females advancing their education – say, seeking a college degree – and the practice of certain cultural biases prohibits such education among certain segments of the population, this would be a legitimate subject for a civics course to address.  It should not be forgotten that federalism invites pluralism, a centered pluralism – “from many, one.”  If this is ethnocentrism, which I believe it is not, then so be it.




[1] Harrison, L. E.  (2000).  Introduction:  Why culture matters.  In L. E. Harrison and S. P. Huntington (Eds), Culture matters:  How values shape human progress (pp. xvii-xxxiv).  New York, NY:  Basic Books, p. xxvi.  Emphasis added.

Friday, July 1, 2016

SUPERSTRUCTURE DANCE

A part of Marxian theory, a part with which I wish I didn’t agree, is his notion of the superstructure.  I am not a purist or raw version believer; I believe in what I understand Marx himself believed.  That is, the economy functions as a sort of a base for the society and over it, metaphorically, is a superstructure made up of the major institutions of that society.  The raw view sees the superstructure being dictated by the base; it follows the demands of the economy.  In the more modest view, the one with which I agree, the base sets the parameters for the superstructure.  The individual institutions are highly influenced by the values and beliefs constituting the economic system.  So, while the economic system does not dictate all the activities in which these other institutions engage, it does set boundaries and help define what is judged acceptable.  This more modest view also allows for the possibility that the institutions have some limited effects on the economic base.  In the last thirty years, you have seen the effect that the economic system has had on the superstructure.

Of course, our basic economic system operates under the controlling influence of capitalism, the ism that is based on private property, property rights, and markets.  Throughout the history of capitalism, the economy has had varying degrees of control over the other institutions.  Here is my take on this variance.  We have, during the reign of capitalism, been drawn to its dictates as an object is attracted to earth.  We might at various times be “shot” away from it by some force, but as the force expends its energy, we fall back to the capitalist way of thinking and resume acting much as an object falls back to earth.  And what is the force that propels us away from capitalism?  Well, ironically enough, it’s the result of going through a period of radical capitalism.  When we approach an unbridled form of capitalist, economic activity – unbridled markets – certain social effects arise due to a magnification of dysfunctional levels of greed.  This is characterized by more and more economic behaviors pursuing profits irrespective of what consequences arise from such strategies.  History tells us that what results are a maldistribution of wealth, high debt levels, and a general disregard for those caught on the short end of the wealth and income “stick.”  In the twentieth century, we had such a time during the 1920s, so raucous a time it was nicknamed the “Roaring Twenties.”  Of course, the result – the force – that propelled the society away from this radicalism was the Great Depression of the 1930s, in which most economists blame the excesses of the previous decade for its eventuality.  Of course, the resulting depression, historians agree, was instrumental in the rise of Hitler and Mussolini and the tragedy of World War II.

As a result of this historical evolution – perhaps, revolution – there was an extensive attempt to bridle in raw capitalism.  Western countries went through a period of Keynesian economics noted for a set of policies that placed meaningful regulations and restrictions on pure capitalism.  What we learn and then seem to forget is that markets don’t necessarily self-correct and they need to be regulated.  In addition to regulatory policies, particularly on the financial industry, there was a plethora of welfare and recovery programs to better distribute income.  This included minimum wage and work programs.  Some have survived but have been diminished.  They have been diminished as part of an overall creep, once again during the thirty years preceding our latest financial crisis, toward the rawer or radicalized capitalist thinking – that gravitational pull has once again had its detrimental effects, resulting in the Great Recession of 2008.  As we study this latest version, though, two historical factors should be kept in mind.

One, the latest manifestation has had a strong supportive mental disposition that is quite conducive to the capitalist mindset; that is, the ascendency of the natural rights construct has become part and parcel of our social thinking.  Natural rights, with its emphasis on individual value determination and lack of substantive moral precepts, makes ignoring the more social aspects of a healthy society easier to accomplish.  Let me share Michael J. Sandel’s thoughts:
[With market triumphalism] some of the good things in life are corrupted or degraded if turned into commodities.  So to decide where the market belongs, and where it should be kept at a distance, we have to decide how to value the goods in question – health, education, family life, nature, art, civic duties, and so on.  These are moral and political questions, not merely economic ones.  To resolve them, we have to debate, case by case, the moral meaning of these goods and the proper way of valuing them.

These examples illustrate a broader point:  some of the good things in life are corrupted or degraded if turned into commodities…

This is a debate we didn’t have during the era of market triumphalism.[1]
 Naturally, all that sort of valuing, lack of valuing, and calculations accelerated our gravitational pull toward radical capitalism.  As I alluded to above, this radicalism can be traced to the thirty years prior to the 2008 financial crisis.  The difference, though, was that this latest version, at the point of the debacle, despite our natural rights bias, was met with a more active government reaction than was the case in the 1930s.[2]  This was more of an accidental happenstance; the more progressive party was in power.  During this version, the critical implosion was stymied, and while many suffered, the catastrophe did not reach the drastic levels of the earlier depression. 

So the question this time is:  how forceful was the force?  To what extent did the economic downturn generate the levels of suffering that would result in the reactive forces to propel us away from those gravitational forces of capitalist thought and policy?  A lot of what is going on politically is about this very question.  While many have jobs, nowadays, their jobs are not paying very well and many families are still dealing with the consequences of the recession.  This includes deleveraging from steep debt obligations.  I have lost count of the number of ads I’ve seen that refer to some strategy by which to handle poor credit ratings.  It is my belief that the push away from raw capitalist biases was not strong enough among many citizens as they maintain a healthy belief in markets, while for others, socialist solutions – a la Sanders – do not seem as foreign as they once did.  What has resulted is a confused period in which no one vision, as Keynesian economics was, has emerged to point a way out of our collective woes.

Two, the predictable response of nationalism is less strident this time around, but has made its presence known nonetheless.  The Brexit and Trump – and to some extent Sanders – phenomena can be viewed this way.  No, these are not totalitarian versions of either nationalism or socialism that befell Europe during the 1930s, but it is enough to undermine the dreams of the post-World War II leaders for global semi-governance.  Those dreams were activated so as to lessen the probabilities of another global conflict that inflicted untold suffering and destruction.  Given the potential destructive power of today’s weaponry, this is no small matter.  In this context, the Brexit vote seems worrisome.  Perhaps the decision that Britain is to leave the European Union is not a done deal and the parties can reconsider the vote.

To get back to Marx, all of these social understandings – those emanating from the superstructure – hopefully can influence the base; that together, between our economic and political institutions, we can devise those policies that allow us to establish a workable level of protections from unbridled capitalism.  Such a move would make our political-social-economic realities less worrisome and, hopefully, more promising for a brighter future.  Can we learn from our historical past, a past that was not so long ago?



[1] Sandel, M. J.  (2012).  What Money Can’t Buy:  The Moral Limits of Markets.  New York, NY:  Farrar, Straus, and Giroux, p. 10.

[2] By way of a reminder, the initial event that led to the onset of the Depression was the Stock Market collapse on October 29, 1929.  FDR’s administration began on March 4, 1933.  The interim years allowed the collapse in the economy to take a strong hold.

Tuesday, June 28, 2016

WHO’S THE CULPRIT?

This topic is going to come up:  the national debt.  It seems that every election cycle and campaign dedicate at least some interest to the question (or the problem) of the national debt.  Big numbers are involved and, as such, can easily be manipulated and the average citizen can be left mystified as to the seriousness and effect the debt can have on their individual lives.  The party that cries the most about the debt is the Republican one as it tries to paint the Democrats as irresponsible spendthrifts.  In the eyes of most voters, this view is enhanced with the image of the Dems as being the party that favors welfare, bureaucracy, and foreign aid.  These citizens, listening to this campaign rhetoric, seem to have little understanding of what the government spends and many see such budget items as foreign aid gobbling up much more money – in absolute as well as percentage terms – than is actually the case.  And yet when one actually does see the numbers, those pertaining to who is responsible for the increases in the national debt, one gets a very different picture.

In this posting, I want to review the record of the last five administrations.  But before I share these numbers, let me point out one important fact.  The increase in the debt is not just a product of the government spending more or even of tax rates going up or down.  Yes, of course, these are definite factors.  But another important factor has to do with how well the economy is doing.  Why?  Because, if the economy takes a nose dive as it did in 2008, businesses make less profit and workers lose their jobs.  As a consequence of less profit and wages, tax revenues plummet and the government takes in less money – a lot less money.  But it is precisely at those times that governmental support services and other welfare demands increase.  Of course, this means more money going out of government and less coming in.  Consequently, deficits increase and the overall debt goes up.  Again, tax rate policy, such as the Bush tax cuts, and government spending such as the military buildup under Reagan, take their tolls as the numbers below demonstrate.  But one should not forget other sources of debt when one considers what the appropriate levels of spending and taxing should be.

Here are the numbers for the last five presidents:
Ronald Reagan (R) – January, 1981 to January, 1989 – inherited a total federal debt of $848 billion and left office with a total federal debt of $2,698 billion, an increase of 218%.
George H. W. Bush (R) – January, 1989 to January, 1993 – inherited a total federal debt of $2,698 billion and left office with a total federal debt of $4,188 billion, an increase of 55%.
Bill Clinton (D) – January, 1993 to January, 2001 – inherited a total federal debt of $4,188 billion and left office with a total federal debt of $5,728 billion, an increase of 37%.
George W. Bush – January, 2001 to January, 2009 – inherited a total federal debt of $5,728 billion and left office with a total federal debt of $10,627 billion, an increase of 86%.
Barack Obama – January, 2009 to a scheduled departure in January, 2017 – inherited a total federal debt of $10,627 billion and is currently presiding over a debt of just over $16,000 billion, an estimated increase of 60%.[1]

What can a civics teacher do with these numbers?  Well, one thing a teacher can do is test the popular hypothesis of which party is more responsible for the debt.  This would need more information.  For example, which party controlled Congress during the different administrations?  It’s Congress that sets up the final budget and votes it into law.  Another question I think is very important is how able we Americans are to handle increased debt.  So, for example, what was the GDP (gross domestic product, the total dollar value of goods and services produced in a given year) in a particular year as opposed to another year?  I use this figure because it is used most often to measure the health of the economy.  For example, in 1980, the year before Reagan took office, the GDP was $5,934 billion or about five times the amount of the debt.  Today, the debt is just over the GDP number or about one to two trillion dollars over the GDP.  Many find this ratio alarming.  But we have seen these rates before.  After World War II, we had a debt level quite a bit higher than the GDP level.  These kinds of comparisons are useful.  Another investigation that students can do – more of a math problem – is to see during which administration the debt, on average, increased on a monthly basis or the increase between the times that the two parties held the White House.  This latter concern can be answered in terms of a percentage basis or actual money amount basis or both.  So, in the figures above, the Republicans controlled the White House for 240 months.  Using the easier numbers for illustration purposes, during the Republican years, the total percentage increase was just under 1.5% per month, while for the Democrats, it was an increase of .5% per month over the 192 months they held the presidency (which will be the number of months – Clinton plus Obama – when Obama leaves office).  Perhaps these numbers are easier to understand.

I have previously in this blog written about comparing debt to wealth.  My message in that posting was that we can afford our debt as it is currently constituted.  Having stated that, I do want to make it clear that the debt can be a problem, especially when the servicing of debt – how much we pay in interest payments – becomes too large a number in our yearly budget.  So, all other things being equal, we should find a way to lower the debt and that means lowering our deficit rate – the amount by which the debt increases every year.  Here is where a citizen’s values come into play.  We can lower the deficit by the government spending less or we can raise revenues – a nice way of saying raise taxes.  There are portions of our citizenry that are not paying enough and some that are paying too much.  That’s my opinion reflecting my values.  You might have another view, but whatever, the question should be asked and answered:  how do we make sure we can continue to afford our debt?



[1] Mikkelson, D.  (2012)  Who increased the debt?  Snopes, retrieved from http://www.snopes.com/politics/politicians/nationaldebt.asp .

Friday, June 24, 2016

HE SAID, SHE SAID

In this blog I have argued for a federated approach to the running of schools.  I mostly have done so because in promoting federation theory as the guiding construct in choosing civics content, I feel that such a civics curriculum would be highly assisted by its being taught in a school that exemplified the concepts and principles that make up that construct.  What does that mean in terms of how the school is run?  Well, it means several things.  That is not to say that the construct’s ideas dictate a modus operandi, but it does demand that the school be run respecting certain qualities.  To understand this, let me go over some basic attributes I have shared in the past – attributes that characterize federal collectives.

A federal collective is one in which the participants in the collective have gotten together and agreed to the commitment that the collective will be united under federal principles.  That agreement, preferably in writing, states that the undersigned pledge to: a set of purposes for forming the collective, a set of principles by which the collective will be governed, the structure of the collective (including positions of authority and subordination), any added elements or relations the collective recognizes, identify any provisions for acts that diverge from the agreement (such as sanctions or other punishments), and a recognition of the solemnity of the promise to keep the provisions of the agreement.  Of course, the last part is the signatures of those agreeing to this pledge.  This type of founding agreement is called a compact.  In order for the typical public school to take such a commitment seriously or to even attempt setting one up is a demanding enterprise and one that falls outside the expected mode of operations that characterizes how the vast majority of schools is administered.  Most schools are simply entities within established school districts and they, in turn, are not federated unions, but substantially sized bureaucracies.  We citizens have allowed these bureaucracies to develop.  Why?  Mostly for the sake of efficiency.  As the famous jurist, Louis Brandeis, pointed out, a cost for republican government is the inefficiencies they entail.  In order for a public school to be federated is to grant it an anti-bureaucratic status; that is, enough leeway so that more of its policy decisions can be made at the school site.  For example, a federated school would almost out of necessity be allowed to select its assistant principals and in that context give the principal primary say as to who should be hired.  As it is, these decisions are made at the district level.  Such authority at the school level would seriously disrupt existing power relations within the vast majority of school districts.  What is being considered, therefore, would be transformational in nature.

So that is the context for what follows.  In such a federated school, certain conditions would have to be put in place; the school would have to establish and support a certain sense among the staff, especially among the teaching faculty.  They would need to generate and maintain a partnership among themselves in which, while their own individual integrity is recognized, they would expect and demand that each participant set his/her goals within the collective in such a way as to not offend the common good of the whole enterprise or within any sub- organized arrangements within the school – such as in a department (e. g., the social studies department).  Part of what is defined as the common good is to pursue actively the purposes of that collective and that might be contrary to the wishes of one or more individual teachers at any given time.  And to pull that off, the participant has to be knowledgeable, to a higher degree, about what such working arrangements demand.  This type of thinking and feeling is foreign to many, if not most, teachers who see their authority in the classroom as their domain.  And yet what he/she does in that classroom has ripple effects in the functioning of that school.  He or she has to understand that to maintain a sovereign view short-circuits any attempt at a federated approach.  The thing is that for a federated scheme to work, the staff, teachers particularly, have to want it to work, and agreeing with such an aim needs to be close to unanimous.

Where in everyday life do we come close to such a commitment?  Why, in the institution of marriage.  As I see it, the more specific the aims of a federated arrangement are – that is usually among smaller collectives – the more demanding it is to have such a commitment.  On the other end of this continuum, for example, would be the federated sense of being a citizen of the US; there, the aims are more broad and dispersed.  But in a marriage, demands are fairly specific in terms of expectations.  So it is at a worksite.  You have your roles and such factors as time, financial resources, norms, and the like, are usually spelled out.  In most work spaces, therefore, federated arrangements are not established and workers do not count on such voluntary levels of compliance and commitment.  Instead, most workplace models are based on contractual arrangements:  I do so and so and you pay me so much.  Federated arrangements have an entirely different sense and feel.  It is more of a “we” sense which is sustained among the workforce by collective goals and agreement on all of the aspects that make up the collective.  Some have described this sense as being organic in which individual cells are in congruence with all other cells.

And, as with a marriage, the interpersonal relations have to go beyond a contractual definition.  The way coworkers interact and communicate takes on a heightened importance.  And this leads me to a body of research that I think is pertinent to this whole business of federated relationships.  The research has been conducted by John Gottman.[1]  Gottman had married couples simply talk between themselves at his research locations and their back and forth sessions have been analyzed using a number code in which a researcher would write down a string of numbers, each one recorded every second and indicating what type of comment was being made.  This research was started in the 1980s and in a relatively short amount of time, these notations have allowed the researcher to predict with a high degree of accuracy whether any particular couple was going to remain married in the ensuing years.  Further research using less time of analyzed comments has shortened the amount of observation time needed in order to solicit high rates of predictability.  What that indicates is that the way couples, in this type of federated arrangement, communicate is very important in determining whether or not a particular arrangement will be successful or not.  Why?  One can only speculate, but it seems that the way we communicate reflects how we feel toward the other person and this in turn will, of course, lead to how we act and how we are motivated to act.

The research was also able to determine what types of communication are detrimental; that is, what types of messages prove to be fatal to the marriage.  As one would guess, negative messaging is involved, but some is more detrimental than others.  The research identified four types of negative messaging:  defensiveness, criticism, stonewalling, and contempt.  In the account I read, a distinction was made between criticism and contempt.  Criticism occurs, for example, when one would say the partner is selfish, or that he/she never listens to what I say.  But contempt raises the bar to a whole other level.  Contempt occurs when one spouse belittles the other in the form of an insult as in he/she is scum or a bastard.  Often, what is generally considered foul language seems to accompany such utterances.  And that, the use of contempt, is what seems to be the indicator that the marriage will not last.

But in a workplace, outside of a marriage situation, contempt verges on raw insult without the veneer of informality, at least usually.  There are stronger norms against the use of contempt.  If there is contempt among workers, one would expect that the language is more nuanced or hidden.  But I believe the Gottman research is still useful.  In any attempt to establish a federated arrangement, participants would do well to become aware of this research.  Any negative messaging, and some will always be called upon in work situations from time to time, needs to avoid any of the forms identified above, but above all, there is no place for contempt.  Negative messaging should always be related to specific behaviors or the lack of desired behaviors and with sufficient contextual content so as to communicate that the worker is not the target; the behavior or lack of it is.  If there is a question about attitude, values, motivation or other motivating factors, these should be communicated sensitively, in private between supervisor and subordinate.  Again, training for this is important because it’s not whether such communication will be needed, but when and how it will be needed and exercised.  Perhaps, if the resources are available, any large school should hire an expert in such matters to train and supervise how such communication is being conducted within the school among its staff members.

Of course, the question would be asked:  is all this worthwhile?  Why not just go for the contractual model?  I would argue that any collective would benefit from such concerns such as those relating to how fellow workers communicate, but I would also submit that this blog has given enough reasons to date to justify the effort; that is, to become more federated than they are at present.  Of course, such efforts are motivated by understanding and pursuing long-term interests and we seem to find such motivation hard to find.



[1] As reported in Gladwell, M.  (2005).  Blink:  The power of thinking without thinking.  New York, NY:  Bay Back Books.