A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Friday, January 15, 2021

THE REPUTATIONAL FACTOR

 

For those new to this blog, its overall goal is to describe, explain, and promote federation theory.  That theory can be utilized to guide the development and implementation of a civics curriculum.  While this aim sounds modest, it is demanding.  The main reason for the difficulty is what is in place.  To begin with, every society has a prominent view of governance and politics in place.  The US is no exception.  It has a view this blog and others call that natural rights view and that view, in various ways, is both alluring and detrimental to a just and civil society.

          The allure stems from its basic tenet, i.e., people have the right to form their own values and attitudes and to act in ways to achieve or further those choices up to the point they do not deny anyone else the same rights.  Of course, this is a form of liberty and liberty is central to Americanism.  But as is often the case, language plays a part in all of this.

          In the history of political development there have been various definitions of liberty.  This particular one has been given a name – natural liberty.  It is probably the most permissive form of liberty.  It is named “natural” because it resembles what one attributes to animals out in the wild.  They simply do what they want to do assuming they are not constrained. 

Of course, each animal’s freedom can and does run into conflict with that of other animals.  A smaller animal’s right to live can be shorten by a larger animal’s right to eat.  And the solution to this “conflict” is settled by violence to the cost usually of the smaller animal.  To avoid the likelihood of that happening to humans, humans have qualified rights by the proviso that each needs to honor the rights of others with a general commitment to the rules and laws that govern human interactions.

The concern for governance and politics has a lot to do with what those rules and laws are and how they are enforced.  Since people do not all have the same interests in relation to those rules and laws, each – according to the natural rights view – competes with others to secure the set of provisions that benefit his/her interests.  In practical terms, for example, business owners and workers, in many ways, have opposing interests.  Which interests prevail relies to a great degree on the rules and laws pertaining to that competition.

This, in turn, leads to a view of society as a compilation of competing entities with a vague – although often strongly felt – sense of loyalty to the very system in which they compete.  One knows this view is favored by the fact that one is not surprised or that much insulted if one hears of this or that individual breaking those rules or laws to gain advantage in this system of competition.  As a matter of fact, certain rule or lawbreakers are romanticized by those who are taken by this spirit of liberty.  These examples of criminals are hoisted by a strange allegiance to a notion of “I can do what I want.”

And with this context, this posting can get at its main topic:  how do natural rights advocates promote themselves in the various competitive situations they confront?  Robert Greene wrote a book full of advice.[1]  In general, he portrays a social reality as being one of competition and the ultimate currency of that competition is power. 

Power comes in various forms.  Citing another source,[2] there are five basic forms of power:  coercive power, reward power, expert power, legitimate power, and referent power.  Money is simply a tool that can assist one or other of these different forms – e.g., it can be traded to attain a reward, or it can be withheld to administer a punishment.  And to be clear, power occurs when one gets someone else to do what he/she would not do otherwise.[3]  Obviously, this view reflects market thinking writ large.

And this leads one to an aspect of market relations that enhances one’s competitive advantage.  Instead of viewing one’s approach to how one engages others in these markets, one is apt to be more concerned with image than substance.  One competitor has an advantage if he/she convinces others of the merit of his/her product and/or of the detriment of alternative products and/or of doing without.  And here one gets a sense of where this sort of thinking leads.  It turns out, according to Greene, that reputation is more important than substance.

And a “good” reputation is not necessarily better than some sort of unsavory reputation.  Greene gives a set of examples in which military leaders, such as Rommel, were able to secure victories merely based on their reputations and not on their strength.  That is, in various situations they projected deceiving images or information that convinced an enemy that discretion would be the better part of valor.  They lied in order to win in those situations.

According to Greene, one should take those examples and apply them to the competitive arenas one confronts not only in business, but in any political confrontation in which one might engage.  That’s just prudent and a product of a natural rights’ political world.  But does one need to see politics in this way?  And beyond that, should they see politics in this way?

This is not the way federation theory suggests people see politics.  Yes, politics entails competition – that’s not controversial.  But here’s a progression that might suggest a different perspective.  It’s from reciprocity to sentiment to self-fulfillment.  Reciprocity suggests that if one does someone else a good turn, that other person is likely to return the favor.  And enough of that most likely elicits positive feelings, people liking each other and even leading to love in some cases.  And finally, enough positive experiences feelings teach people that happiness and even joy are dependent on positive social relationships.

Greene’s view doesn’t see interactions this way.  But one can say that he is writing about competition, not socializing.  But that’s part of the point.  Greene’s view promotes a social landscape in which interactions boil down to competition and one’s reputation is built not just by competitive interactions but by all interactions.  People form their judgements of others by how those others act in any interaction they might be perceived doing.  Afterall, one cannot look into someone else’s mind, but only observe his/her behavior.

Perhaps sharing a snippet of what he has to say might make his message clear.

Reputation is the cornerstone of power.  Through reputation alone you can intimidate and win; once it slips, however, you are vulnerable, and will be attacked on all sides.  Make your reputation unassailable.   Always be alert to potential attacks and thwart them before they happen.  Meanwhile, learn to destroy your enemies by opening holes in their own reputations.  Then stand aside and let public opinion hang them.[4]

What this writer finds interesting is that Greene relies heavily on military examples where confrontations are singular battles, and one does not waste time with consequences other than winning or losing.  Regular life is more continuous and human relationships evolve via day-by-day interactions.  But even in a political atmosphere, one needs alliances, and, in turn, they do not last when pending punishment hangs over those involved.  Doubt it?  Just look at the current president’s situation.



[1] Robert Greene, The 48 Laws of Power  (New York, NY:  Penguin Books, 1998).

[2] John R. P. French, Jr. and Bertram Raven, “The Bases of Power,” in Current Perspectives in Social Psychology, ed. Edwin P. Hollander and Raymond G. Hunt (New York, NY:  Oxford University Press, 1967), 504-512.

[3] Andre Munro, “Robert A. Dahl:  American Political Scientist and Educator,” Encyclopaedia  Britannica, February 1, 2020, accessed February 12, 2020. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Robert-A-Dahl .

[4] Robert Greene, The 48 Laws of Power, 37.

Tuesday, January 12, 2021

BUILT-IN POLARIZING FACTORS

 

[Note:  From time to time, this blog issues a set of postings that summarize what the blog has been emphasizing in its previous postings.  Of late, the blog has been looking at various obstacles civics educators face in teaching their subject.  It’s time to post a series of such summary accounts.  The advantage of such summaries is to introduce new readers to the blog and to provide a different context by which to review the blog’s various claims and arguments.  This and upcoming summary postings will be preceded by this message.]

 

The last posting pointed out that currently and effectively since World War II an imbalance has evolved concerning the nation’s elections.  Surely, the origins of this imbalance can be found in the arrangement the Constitution establishes by setting up winner-take-all, single representative districts for the US House of Representative and, at the state level, the respective state constitutions do likewise for their legislatures. 

This feature can be found in British derived systems such as in the US and in Canada.[1]  That posting explains how such designations hurt left of center advocates – urban, Democratic voters – and enhances right of center advocates – rural, Republican voters.  Therefore, along with right of center voters feeling threatened by demographic factors one can add how the left feels underrepresented.

          Ezra Klein points out[2] that by the year 2040, just twenty years from now, 70% of the nation will live in the 15 largest states – and this projection captures the basic problem in that, consequently in the US Senate, those people will be represented by 30 senators and the rest, 30% of the population, will be represented by 70 senators.  Add to that the effects of gerrymandering and ignoring the wishes of voters whose candidates lose in winner-take-all elections one can ascertain how frustrating politics can be for urbanites and even suburbanites. 

These factors, in effect, disenfranchise significant portions of the electorate, if not, as has often been the case, the majority of voters.  In the case of the Senate, its ability to stifle legislation, with its filibuster provision, is particularly egregious.  Rural sentiments can unduly block what the majority of Americans wish to be enacted at the national level.

To illustrate, the reader could consider polling results that indicate strong majorities wishing for various policies.  This includes such policies as paid maternity leave, government funding for childcare, boosting minimum wage, tuition free state college education, and Medicare for all.   It is telling that one can readily categorize these proposed legislation items as liberal or progressive policies.

Federation theory, which this blog supports, promotes a qualified majority rule.  It concedes that purely democratic systems – where majority rule has unrestrained power – can lead to policies that trample individual and/or minority rights.  The nation’s history can attest to that possibility; occurrences of such policies led to the ratification of the Fourteenth Amendment.  But the opposite can also be true.

          That is, the minority – read conservative advocates – can block legitimate majority wishes.  And under current conditions, the victims of such a feature are the urban, liberal states or, as within state arrangements, cities and their suburban areas.  These more congested areas can be shortchanged by what the respective legislative bodies decide policy will be. 

This reality or potential was exposed recently when rural states objected to providing urban areas, particularly in the Northeast, of assistance during the initial months of the COVID pandemic.  Red states didn’t see it useful to assist blue states (a strategy that subsequently seems to have been shortsighted).

          As for fixes, there have been various proposals.  One considered by experts of such matters, has been to abandon the winner-take-all model.  Instead, representation can adopt the European model in which representative districts are larger than those in the US and provide multi-seat allocations in which more than one representative is chosen in an election.  This enfranchises voters who did not vote for the top vote getter in that district.  It also results in legislative bodies that more accurately reflect how districts are politically constituted.

          So as things stand, the right feels threatened by the demographic changes that the country is experiencing – the shift in the population toward urban areas not to mention the increased numbers of nonwhite and non-European descendants – and the left by being disenfranchised, one can understand the polarization of the national political arena. 

These are situations that civics teachers need to address if they are to explain contemporary political realities.  Given the events that transpired in Washington this past Wednesday, a citizen needs to appreciate this background to make sense of what happened.  And unfortunately, without hyping the situation, the very existence of the republic – if we “can keep it” – seems to be at stake and demands ordinary citizens to know and substantively understand what’s happening and why it is happening.



[1] Jonathan Rodden, Why Cities Lose:  The Deep Roots of the Urban-Rural Political Divide (New York, NY:  Basic Books, 2019).

[2] Ezra Klein, Why We’re Polarized (New York, NY:  Avid Reader Press, 2020).

Friday, January 8, 2021

UNDEMOCRATIC FEATURES HURTING THE LEFT

 

[Note:  From time to time, this blog issues a set of postings that summarize what the blog has been emphasizing in its previous postings.  Of late, the blog has been looking at various obstacles civics educators face in teaching their subject.  It’s time to post a series of such summary accounts.  The advantage of such summaries is to introduce new readers to the blog and to provide a different context by which to review the blog’s various claims and arguments.  This and upcoming summary postings will be preceded by this message.]

 

The last couple of postings reviewed how the right of center advocates are facing disadvantages and how, in turn, many of these citizens’ cherished beliefs or attitudes are being, at least in their eyes, threatened.  But the right of center community is not the only faction feeling these disadvantages.  The left also finds that its positions and policy choices are not being given fair hearing.  The reasons for this are the topic of this posting and those reasons further explain what is fueling the polarized politics of today.

          Victimized by these features is the Democratic Party.  That party has suffered from undemocratic provisions of this nation’s constitutional arrangement.  These features, as a consequence, favor the Republican Party.  In addition, they undermine what the system claims to be, that is a democracy.

          When one questions such a basic attribute, one needs to define his/her terms.  By democracy this writer means a political system that exhibits two political qualities.  One, it depends ultimately on the people deciding what direction its governmental policies will take – usually through the decisions made by the people’s representatives.[1]  And two, in choosing those representatives each citizen has an equal voice or, as the old adage goes, one man/woman, one vote.

          Probably the feature that attracts the most attention is the reliance on the Electoral College to choose the nation’s president.  It becomes most relevant every four years when that selection is made.  Under the above standard of equal voice, the people would select the president in a straight popular winner-take-all voting system.  But the Electorate College, for reasons not necessary to review here (given how much press it gets), does allow for the vote-getting loser to win the election as was the case in 2000 and 2016.[2]

And since states with the highest urban populations tend to be of urban character in politics and other social realms, this structurally hurts liberally biased citizens.  But structural bias does not end with the Electoral College.  One political scientist who has looked into this is Jonathan Rodden. [3] 

His research points out that in his review of US House elections since 2012 to 2019, Democratic candidates received 1.4 million more votes than their Republican opponents, yet Democrats only secured 45% of the seats of those various Congresses.  And since 2002, this imbalanced result has happened more often than not.  As a matter of fact, for Democrats to win a Congress majority, they need to win overwhelmingly at the polls.  And this undemocratic result also happens at the state level where Democrats, on a regular basis, are underrepresented, compared to how people vote in state legislature elections.

Why?  The usual cited reason is gerrymandering.  That is the conscious drawing of representation districts so that one party, the Republican Party, is benefited over the other, the Democratic Party.  Given that Democratic support tends to be concentrated in urban areas, this factor causes Democratic voters to be “bunched” geographically.  This allows for those who control state legislatures – often Republicans – to draw district lines purposefully to maintain their advantages.  Those lines are drawn every ten years and they rely on the census data that is collected in years ending in zero, e.g., 2020.

But Rodden’s research, while acknowledging the effect of gerrymandering, points out a surprising finding.  It turns out that this undemocratic result is not unique to the US.  When surveying various democratic systems, this underrepresentation of urban areas – or over representation of rural areas – affects all British derived systems.  That is, the systems of Great Britain and all of the former colonized areas of British rule – e.g., Australia, New Zealand, Canada. 

All of these systems have majoritarian, district elections.  Those elections select one representative per district and that person is the candidate who wins the majority of votes in the respective district.  That can be compared to continental European elections where the selections of representatives are not winner-take-all affairs. 

There, the districts are larger, and voters elect a slate of representatives reflecting which of them received the most votes.  For example, if a district is to have three representatives, the top three vote getters each win a seat.  The result, therefore, is that winners represent more than just the majority of voters of a district; they represent the nation-wide majority.

This writer has thought of another solution.  That would be the creation of a fourth branch of government; one that would be charged with all aspects regarding elections in the national government – perhaps states could have the same comparable branch at their level.  The members of that branch would run elections, draw district lines, determine winners, and, to promote the democratic quality of the system, encourage participation. 

How the officials are chosen can be thought out so as to minimize partisan drives or motivations that those fourth branch officials might have.  Short of that, perhaps these functions could be assigned to the courts instead of the legislatures.  There are several problems, though, with judges making these decisions.

One, in states, judges are mostly elected and would probably have motivations to treat these functions in a more partisan way.  Two, judges are already busy enough with the law.  And three, these functions deserve their own expertise, i.e., people handling elections call for specialized knowledge having little to do with the intricacies of laws, per se.  Therefore, this overall function deserves its own independent branch along with the legislative, executive, and judicial branches.



[1] This definition is a bit informal.  A true democracy doesn’t have representatives but holds large assemblages in which all citizens are invited to attend and express their wishes over proposed policies.  Some call that a direct democracy as was the case in ancient Athens.  Once representatives are instituted, one has a republic or democratic republic.  Given the impracticality of having a direct democracy in a polity the size of nation, like the US, the term democracy is readily used to describe what the US has.

[2] Okay, a quick review:  The Electoral College, that elects the president, is made up of state delegations of “electors” that usually allocates all its votes to the candidate who wins the popular vote in the state from which the delegation emanates.  Problem is that the number of each state’s electors is made up of the total number of representatives that state has in Congress:  that’s two senators (no matter how large that state’s population is) and the number of House representatives which is based on population, but each has at least one elector (no matter how small that state’s population is). 

This provision can distort the national popular vote sufficiently in that the candidate who does not win the popular vote can win a majority in the Electoral College and with that, the White House.  It’s rare, but it has happened too often, for some.

[3] Jonathan Rodden, Why Cities Lose:  The Deep Roots of the Urban-Rural Political Divide (New York, NY:  Basic Books, 2019).  The argument and evidence shared in this posting on this issue is derived from Rodden’s book.

 

Tuesday, January 5, 2021

FURTHER DEMOGRAPHICS

 

[Note:  From time to time, this blog issues a set of postings that summarize what the blog has been emphasizing in its previous postings.  Of late, the blog has been looking at various obstacles civics educators face in teaching their subject.  It’s time to post a series of such summary accounts.  The advantage of such summaries is to introduce new readers to the blog and to provide a different context by which to review the blog’s various claims and arguments.  This and upcoming summary postings will be preceded by this message.]

 This blog in its last posting offered a hypothesis – or really a set of hypotheses – that various segments of the US populous feel and are apt to express being threatened.  Why?  Because they see how the changing demographics of the nation is causing shifts in the political sentiments and those changes are going against their beliefs and are being overwhelmed.  Here is the statement that posting shared with the reader: 

… [F]or those voters who are concerned over identity issues, the growth of more recent immigrant population – including first generation Americans – less white-based/traditional religiously affiliated people, and an increase in non-religiously affiliated people, life seems to be becoming more secular, less white, and more urban.  In 1992 the US urban population was 76% and in 2016 it was 82% (82.5% in 2019).[1]  Conservative, white, religiously prone people in the US, one can guess, are feeling more and more threatened.

 Does a review of more granulated demographic data support these general contentions?

          Along with the Pew report[2] that the previous posting utilized – published in 2016 – there is another Pew report[3] that was published in 2018 that looks in more detail at how the electorate feels about various issues in relation to a list demographic categories.  While this report was not meant to address what the previous article stated, one can make various commonsensical connections.

          This 2018 report uses the factor of community type or, as this writer refers to it, locality, to organize its findings.  The report sees locality – whether respondents to the report’s survey questions live in urban, suburban, or rural areas – as being an organizing factor about how people feel about the issues the survey addresses.  The issues are immigration, Trump (as a political figure), same-sex marriage, abortion rights, marriage (as an institution), race, and gender equity.

          Here is a listing of its findings:

 ·       Urban areas are heavily populated by Democratic or Democratic leaning people (62%), and rural areas are increasingly Republican (54%).  Suburbanites fall in between urban and rural areas, (47% Democratic or Democratic leaning vs. 45% Republican or Republican leaning) with a slight bias toward the Democratic Party.

·       61% of urban dwellers support legal abortion rights versus 41% of rural people doing so.  Locality does not affect this distribution of support or disfavor for abortion rights in that liberals support women having the right and conservatives do not across the three community types. 

·       Urban voters feel more strongly that the economic system unfairly favors the powerful, much more than rural people do.  But, again, controlling for party, the numbers breakdown with Democrats agreeing more strongly than Republicans regardless of whether the respondents live in urban or rural areas.

·       51% feel very cold toward Trump (as a political figure), 8% somewhat cool, 10% neutral, 9% somewhat warm, and 22% very warm.  Trump is seen more positively (warm or very warm) in rural areas (56%) and coolest (as in unapproachable) in urban areas (46%). 

·       In rural areas, younger respondents, at a much lower rate, judged Trump warmly than older respondents (44% vs. 66%).  In other age groups, judgements toward Trump reflected party affiliation numbers – Republicans saw him warmly, Democrats not so much.

·       In terms of the increases that non-white people represent in the population, Republicans find such a change to be negative, and Democrats are positive in comparable percentages as those relating to how people feel about Trump.  That is, those who see the President warmly see non-white population growth negatively and those who see him negatively on the warmth scale find non-white growth positively.

·       Rural Republicans tend to see same-sex marriage legalization as a bad thing (as high as 71% in rural areas); Democrats tend to see it positively (as high as 78% in suburban areas).

·       Democrats tend to see immigrants as strengthening America (as high as 81% in suburban areas) and Republicans see immigrants as threatening America (as high as 78% in rural areas).

·       51% of whites do not believe whites receive benefits that are deprived to blacks while 77% of blacks do see whites receiving them.  Locality does affect this perception; rural areas tend more to not see advantages for whites while urban areas are more prone to see them.  Consequently, Republicans don’t see these advantages (e.g., 72% in suburban areas).  Whether one does or not, numbers run consistently with conservative areas not seeing it and liberal areas seeing it.

·       Generally, across localities, younger Americans hold more liberal, Democratic Party views, older Americans hold conservative, Republican Party views.

While the two Pew reports this blog cites concerning current political divisions among Americans do not contradict each other, they are not carbon copies of each other.  The second is more detailed, but the first gives a more holistic sense of what is out there.  Neither one proves what is causing polarized politics in America today, but they do commonsensically give the reader a good sense about why and how it exists.  They do reflect a range of beliefs and attitudes one can relate to conditions leading some voters to being threatened.

That is, they find rural people to be conservative or urban voters to be on the liberal side of contested issues.  Suburban people are between but with a liberal bias.  This division indicates rural areas are Republican areas of strength, urban areas are Democratic areas of strength.  The reports give one real insights in how the nation breaks down demographically in terms of politics and those terms are changing in a threatening way to those who fall right of center.



[1] See “Urban Population (% of Total Population) – United States,”  The World Bank, n.d., accessed December 30, 2020, https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.URB.TOTL.IN.ZS?end=2019&locations=US&start=1978 .

[2] “1.  The Changing Composition of the Political Parties,”  The Pew Research Center (September 13, 2016), accessed August 31, 2020, https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2016/09/13/1-the-changing-composition-of-the-political-parties/ .

[3] Kim Parker, Juliana Menasce Horowitz, Anna Brown, Richard Fry, D’Vera Cohn, Ruth Igielnik, “2.  Urban, Suburban and Rural Residents’ Views on Key Social and Political Issues, Pew Research Center:  Social and Demographic Trends (May 22, 2018), accessed January 1, 2021, https://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2018/05/22/urban-suburban-and-rural-residents-views-on-key-social-and-political-issues/ .

Friday, January 1, 2021

HYPOTHESES IN THE MAKING

 

[Note:  From time to time, this blog issues a set of postings that summarize what the blog has been emphasizing in its previous postings.  Of late, the blog has been looking at various obstacles civics educators face in teaching their subject.  It’s time to post a series of such summary accounts.  The advantage of such summaries is to introduce new readers to the blog and to provide a different context by which to review the blog’s various claims and arguments.  This and upcoming summary postings will be preceded by this message.]

[Further Note:  Phew, it’s over.  Happy New Years!!]

Earlier in this blog,[1] this writer presented a listing of findings from a Pew Research Center report that offered demographic information comparing the electorate in 1992 and 2016.[2]  The goal was to observe changes the electorate had experienced during the intermittent years.  While that is helpful in understanding the nation’s politics in and of itself, it also suggests reasons for the polarization the nation is experiencing.

          While this posting reviews those changes in summary, the review will spur this writer to offer some hypotheses that will be tested by the information offered by another Pew publication[3] – which will serve as the topic of this blog’s next posting.  But, at minimum, this first Pew offering can stand on its own and provide the reader some insight.

          In terms of ethnicity and race (as a combined factor), the nation has gone through some changes:  non-Hispanic whites make up a smaller percentage of the electorate (by 14% points), Hispanic share has doubled (5% to 9%), blacks increased (10% to 12%), mixed-race grew (1% to 5%), and total non-whites went up (16% to 26%).  Whites’ share of the electorate fell to 60.7% and is projected to be below 50% by 2045.

          Just these limited numbers explain quite a bit and the demographic shifts spell out advantages for the Democratic Party as that party is constituted today.  That is, that party garners the bulk of non-white populations around the country.  Surprisingly, the Pew report states that the Republicans have also gained among these groups but not to the extent that Democrats have.

               In terms of age, the nation is older, and the older set has shifted from being more pro-Democratic to being more pro-Republican.  Americans are better educated and educated people who tended be Republican in ’92, tended to be Democratic in ’16.  When one mixes education with ethnicity/race an interesting change is highlighted, whites with college degrees increased as a proportion of the electorate.  And Democrats with no college dropped significantly (55% to 32%).  Bottom line, Democrats have benefited from changes in educational attainment numbers.

          Then there is the effect of religion on politics.  Those who do not consider themselves as belonging to a religion significantly went up (8% to 21%).  This change seems to have benefited Democrats.  Religious affiliation maintained its numbers among Republicans.  Summarily, Pew observes that Republicans are strong among evangelical Protestants or white Catholics during those twenty years but overall, they account for a smaller portion of the electorate.

          With the easy ability to categorize so many groups according to identity factors such as race, ethnicity, and religion – and to some degree age – with political parties and all that that represents, one can surmise that these factors add to polarization.  And that is the most prominent hypothesis one can make from this information.

          This posting ends with a statement that more specifically captures this hypothesis: 

… [F]or those voters who are concerned over identity issues, the growth of more recent immigrant population – including first generation Americans – less white-based/traditional religiously affiliated people, and an increase in non-religiously affiliated people, life seems to be becoming more secular, less white, and more urban.  In 1992 the US urban population was 76% and in 2016 it was 82% (82.5% in 2019).[4]  Conservative, white, religiously prone people in the US, one can guess, are feeling more and more threatened.

To test these hypothesized relationships, this blog, as stated above, will relate another Pew research report, “Urban, Suburban and Rural Residents’ Views on Key Social and Political Issues,” that Pew issued in 2018.  That will be the topic for the next posting of this blog.



[1] These findings are reported in the posting, “Some Demographics in Election Years,” Gravitas:  A Voice for Civics (a blog), September 1, 2020.  The reader can see the actual percentage amounts the findings here indicate.

[2] “1.  The Changing Composition of the Political Parties,”  The Pew Research Center (September 13, 2016), accessed August 31, 2020, https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2016/09/13/1-the-changing-composition-of-the-political-parties/ .

[3] Kim Parker, Juliana Menasce Horowitz, Anna Brown, Richard Fry, D’Vera Cohn, Ruth Igielnik, “2.  Urban, Suburban and Rural Residents’ Views on Key Social and Political Issues, Pew Research Center:  Social and Demographic Trends (May 22, 2018), accessed January 1, 2021, https://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2018/05/22/urban-suburban-and-rural-residents-views-on-key-social-and-political-issues/ .

[4] See “Urban Population (% of Total Population) – United States,”  The World Bank, n.d., accessed December 30, 2020, https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.URB.TOTL.IN.ZS?end=2019&locations=US&start=1978 .

Tuesday, December 29, 2020

A DIFFERENT CASE ON THE LEFT

 

[Note:  From time to time, this blog issues a set of postings that summarize what the blog has been emphasizing in its previous postings.  Of late, the blog has been looking at various obstacles civics educators face in teaching their subject.  It’s time to post a series of such summary accounts.  The advantage of such summaries is to introduce new readers to the blog and to provide a different context by which to review the blog’s various claims and arguments.  This and upcoming summary postings will be preceded by this message.] 

 To continue this blog’s look at the national polarized landscape, a Pew Research Center report provides information about the left side of that divide.  The report relates to the 2016 election and basically describes how the left relies on a journalism that has in place well-established structures and processes that guarantee its objectivity.[1]

          Of course, as this blog has just reported, this stands in counter distinction to the right-wing ecosystem that instead of utilizing long-standing protocols to bolster truth-telling, has utilized rhetorical techniques – including memes – that result in dubious news accounts.  This is further enhanced by the relatively unified set of interests its party, the Republican Party, represents.  When everyone tends to see the world through a single lens, those observations are more easily deceived and less demanding of objectivity.

The Republican Party counts on a limited set of groups – businesspeople, fundamentalist religious groups, and disaffected labor groups smarting over the loss of jobs to automation and cheap labor nations – to make up its base.  That naturally leads to allow for a singular, mostly ideological messaging to take hold and bolster existing biases among these people.

The left and its party – the Democratic Party – has instead a wide variety of groups making up its ranks.  This includes from conservative minority-religious groups, e.g., most Jews and fundamentalist blacks, to urban, professional groups such as academics and well-trained technologists.  Of course, these are tendencies, and this account is not meant to describe how all members of these groups vote. 

But to the degree this alignment exists among Democrats, given the proclivity for disagreement among such a high level of diversity, this alliance demands to a greater degree objective news sources.  Therefore, they rely on news outlets having well-established structures and protocols guaranteeing both talent and objectivity in gathering and reporting the news. 

Such an arrangement, though, does not protect those well-established newspapers – e.g., The New York Times and The Washington Post – and national TV news organizations – e.g., CBS and NBC – from being described as FAKE NEWS by the right-wing ecosystem. 

But this reliance on these news outlets allows Democrats and the left to formulate fact-based positions on the vibrant issues of the day.  That arrangement, in a more varied landscape, helps the party to avoid messaging – and accompanying proposals – that appeals to or is demanded by its more extreme members – a faction currently called progressives. 

As for the news organizations themselves, they seek to not be identified as the leftist press and seek to be considered simply the FREE PRESS.  This is backed by their protocols for gathering and reporting the news.  They rely on their audiences to be on the more centrist elements of the electorate both among left and right of center voters and these voter, in turn, make up the vast percentage of the electorate.

And associated with this avoidance of extremism, it also demands that their information sources to avoid exclusively relying on extremists.  They interview all relevant sources, but they keep those sources’ biases revealed to the readers and viewers. 

Central to those endeavors, those source must be treated objectively, and in turn, the news organizations must maintain unbiased methodologies in gathering and reporting their stories and in formulating their editorial positions.  They only revert to withholding information about their sources when those sources will tell their stories only upon being granted anonymity.  In that case, journalists have gone to jail instead of revealing who those sources are.

So, in summary, establishment journalists do not take up ideological positioning in their reporting and try to maintain a balanced perspective about how they present their stories.  On this last point, Ezra Klein describes these journalistic entities as “sources that root their identity in … being antagonistic toward political movements.”[2] 

In other words, the established press strives – not always successfully – to avoid taking sides.  The resulting, achieved balance serves the needs of the left in that that side, as described above and in previous postings, can maintain itself only with a good dose of compromise within its ranks.  Compromise is served by information sources being neutral and believable.

Some might note exceptions to this general description.  Many, mostly on the right, accuse CNN, MSNBC, The New York Times, and other outlets of being too pro-left in their reporting.  Also, there is some research by academic sources that definitely claims that there is a leftist bias among establishment sources.  One such study is by Tim Groseclose of UCLA and Jeff Milyo of the University of Chicago who published a study back in 2005 using data from the 1990-2003.[3] 

They found Fox News Special Report and The Washington Times as conservative.  They also found Newsweek, The New York Times, Time magazine, CBS Evening News, USA Today, and NBC Nightly News as having a definite leftist bias.  Balanced news outlets included ABC Good Morning America and NewsHour with Jim Lehrer.  Moderately left were CNN’s NewsNight with Aaron Brown, The Washington Post, NPR’s Morning Edition, and ABC WorldNews Tonight.  Not ranked were The Wall Street Journal and talk radio.

While this study is a bit dated and counters the thrust of what this account is claiming, the Groseclose-Milyo study is not judged as debunking the general observations this review has of the current media.  If considered in relative terms – comparing current day right-wing journalism and left-wing journalism – the general judgement expressed here is still considered justified and worthy of mention. 

And this leads one to further consider how the more balanced journalists advance in their profession.  Higher reputations belong to a relatively small number of news organizations and they provide rewards to those considered skilled at being excellent news people.  How?  By hiring them for more lucrative jobs.  One is considered to be at the top of this profession if one has secured a position at The New York Times or The Washington Post, or on one of the national news networks.

So, the basic point here is that the right – in terms of its voters – due to their distinguishing unity, is more open to disreputable sources that one finds on social media and rest of the right-wing ecosystem.  On the other hand, the left is “protected” from such journalism given the nature of the politics that diverse groups demand. 

With diversity, it is more difficult to cull a varied followship with a united rhetorical messaging that social media tends to produce.  The only exception to that difficulty is messaging based on objectified reporting that results in verifiable truth.[4]  The established press come much closer to that standard when compared to the right-wing social media, outlets such as Newsmax, and talk show hosts as Rush Limbaugh.



[1] Robert Faris, Hal Roberts, Bruce Etling, Nikki Bourassa, Ethan Zuckerman, and Yochai Benkler, “Partisanship, Propaganda, & Disinformation: Online Media & the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election,” Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society, Harvard Library (n.d.), accessed August 19, 2020, https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/76a9/3eb0bed8ff032c44186678c5279f20cc5ff8.pdf?_ga=2.230250332.1151241653.1597869609-1463880478.1597869609 .

[2] Ezra Klein, Why We’re Polarized (New York, NY:  Avid Reader Press, 2020), 236.

[3] Robert J. Barro, “The Liberal Media:  It’s No Myth,” Business Week/Online, June 14, 2004, accessed December 29, 2020, https://scholar.harvard.edu/barro/files/04_0614_liberalmedia_bw.pdf .  Of note, Barro is a founding member of the movement, new classical macroeconomics, that began as a response to the condition of stagflation in the 1970s and is currently an editor-in-chief at Quarterly Journal of Economics, the scholarly journal that published the Groseclose-Milyo study.

[4] This reference to objectified methods should not be confused with the reductionism a scientist practices in a scientific study.  In this form, journalism more resembles responsible historical study by reputable historians.  Journalism is often described informally as the first stab at history.