A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Tuesday, August 2, 2022

JUDGING THE NATURAL RIGHTS VIEW, I

 

An advocate of natural rights continues his/her presentation[1] …

This first entry in supporting the natural rights view – as it would be used to guide civics curricular content – centers on William Schubert’s commonplace, subject matter.  In terms of subject matter, the natural rights/liberalism approach would transmit the following:

 

·      Teach a view of government as a subservient institution which attempts to satisfy the collective interests of individual citizens.

·      Teach the philosophical basis of government’s role as defender of individual rights.

·      Convey the legitimate needs of government to engender levels of support that maintain political stress within the political system – in the form of competitiveness – to manageable and even useful degrees.

·      Portray a realistic account of political structures, processes, and functions that allow students to internalize practical information about government to facilitate their interactions with governmental agencies and offices in pursuit of their political goals and objectives.

·      Express the technical nature of political activities with ample respect for expertise held by professional participants of the political system.

 

By accomplishing these elements, the natural rights argument claims that the subject matter advances good citizenship and natural liberty.  And liberty takes on a moral standing.

The Morality of Liberalism

          According to Jeffrey Reiman,[2] the natural rights perspective (he uses the term liberalism) is, at its core, a moral conception.  That is, the natural rights approach, in its most fundamental sense, is a standard for right and wrong behavior.  As such, Reiman explains, it is not a version or supplement to other views of governance such as promoting caring policies or community. 

Those that adopt a natural rights view advocate a moral standard that instead promotes what is required from human beings (assuming they are sane adults) to conduct themselves in such a way that maximizes the scope of everyone’s freedom.  Freedom is seen as the ability to control individuals’ lives according to their own judgment.  Any extension of their freedom that reduces the freedom of themselves or others is ruled as immoral behaviors.  This principle Reiman calls individual sovereignty.

He contends that the role of education is to prepare children and adolescents to make voluntary moral choices when they become adults.  Children and adolescents are not judged mature enough to be given the level of freedom as defined by this view.  So, a qualifier to the general argument, then, is that underaged individuals are not totally subject to this moral standard.

Another qualifier is those situations in which, because of human fallibility, people are not acting in line with their real judgments.  For example, people who are about to commit suicide in reaction to traumatic incidents or bits of information might, on reflection, choose not to kill themselves.  Reiman would allow for what he calls paternalistic coercion. 

That is, it permits as moral for people to intervene by preventing those suicides but only in obvious situations when the good judgment by the distraught person would find it extremely difficult to practice reasonable judgment.  Of course, such cases would seldom occur.

As far as government’s role under such a moral principle or standard, Reiman argues that its interference in social and economic activities is justified only in those situations when society, in the guise of government policy or otherwise, does not allow for individual freedom.  Ironically, government is to only act to advance freedom by prohibiting those actors or policies that stand in the way of such freedom.  These conditions, in turn, Reiman deems to be an empirical and measurable condition and not to be determined merely by opinion.

Further, Reiman writes,

 

Rather, the ideal of individual sovereignty is a standard against which economic systems are to be judged.  Free enterprise economics with little or no governmental involvement will only pass muster by this standard if they yield societies in which people in fact have the maximum compatible individual freedom, and this will be an empirical matter of what actually happens in such economies compared to the alternatives.[3]

 

Reiman provides a standard by which to distinguish between moral requirement and subjugation.  “To show the validity of a moral requirement, then, we must show that they are binding on people who disagree with them.  We must demonstrate their capacity to override the contrary judgments of their recipients.”[4]  Or stated another way, if moral judgments stand because they can, not because they should, they are not moral requirements, but subjugations instead.

          In such cases, the natural rights argument holds that subjugation is immoral and that subjected people are not morally bound to obey those judgments.  The only exceptions would be if people can prove beyond reasonable doubts that moral judgments are moral requirements irrespective of people’s judgments, which would be deemed impossible to do.

 

The point here is a simple one, but, I think, quite far-reaching in its implications.  Any moral requirement must be a matter of right not might.  To establish this, we must show – show, not just believe firmly – either that the requirement is true beyond a reasonable doubt, or that it is needed to restrict to a minimum the role of might in human affairs.  This shows that the liberal ideal has an advantage over all others.  Unless and until one of those others can be proven true beyond a reasonable doubt, only the liberal ideal can satisfactorily rebut the suspicion of subjugation.  It is only one that can withstand the charge of being might not right.[5]

 

          This posting will end on this note.  The next one will venture into the question as to whether people have responsibilities to others, and if they do, when would that be.  To this blogger, the basic claim of natural rights advocates is that humans have the right to do as they please if they do not interfere with others having the same right.  Short of that, there are little to no responsibilities assuming those involved, either in terms of acting upon or receiving the effects of such interactions, are adults and sane.



[1] This presentation begins with this posting.  The reader is informed that the claims made in this posting do not necessarily reflect the beliefs or knowledge of this blogger.  Instead, the posting is a representation of what an advocate of natural rights view might present.  This is done to present a dialectic position of that construct.

[2] Jeffrey Reiman, “Liberalism and Its Critics,” in The Liberalism-Communitarian Debate, edited by Cornelius F. Delaney (Lanham, MD:  Rowman and Littlefield Publisher, Inc., 1994).

[3] Ibid., 22.

[4] Ibid., 23, emphasis in the original.

[5] Ibid., 24-25, emphasis in the original.

Friday, July 29, 2022

A PROTOCOL FOR JUDGING THE NATURAL RIGHTS VIEW

 

With this posting, this blog begins an extended description, explanation, and justification for the natural rights construct as would be presented by an advocate of that view.  Each of the following postings will make a note of this attempt to give an advocated review of this perspective. This is in the tradition of presenting a dialectic argument.

          If readers are new to this blog, a short word on how that argument has historically progressed.  In the late 1940s, after years of challenging the dominant view, parochial/traditional federalism, the natural rights view was vibrant enough to overtake it.  Since then, the natural rights view has become stronger and solidified in its position of dominance.  One can get a sense of this by watching old films on TMC and comparing them to today’s films.

          Before the 1940s, those films tended to have plots in which the storyline would have characters either promoting or abusing the common good.  This wasn’t always the case, but a definite trend can be detected.  Not all films agreed about what the common good was, but one can see the concern. 

Two films from 1939 can be cited:  Gone with the Wind and Let Freedom Ring.  Each one tells a tale in which a self-centered ambitious character or entity leads to unhappy results.  In the first case, it is the self-centered ambitions of a Southern belle and in the second it is the ambitions of a corporate entity (the railroads).[1] 

Today, such plots would be considered unrealistic, and characters or entities are much more likely to be portrayed as naturally seeking self-defined goals with little to no concern for the common good.  Hopefully, readers agree.  In any event, one can search and cite other evidence, but for the purposes here, this will do.

The last posting left readers with a reminder that, as with the parochial federalist treatment, this judgment will employ the commonplaces of curriculum – identified by William Schubert[2] – to categorize its different elements.  The commonplaces of curriculum are the subject matter, teachers, learners, and milieu.[3]  Each of these divisional categories will be first introduced and generally explained and then further divided into subcategories. 

In the case of subject matter, the subcategories are the morality of liberalism, the discipline of political science, the political systems approach, the structural-functional model, the viability of the systems construct, and its methodology.  The category, the student, will be divided into the subcategories of personal student interests, student social interests, student economic interests, political student interests, and pedagogic student interests.  This “student” review will attempt to cast light on how this view affects these aspects of students’ lives.

The category, teacher, will be divided into the subcategories, teacher effectiveness and teacher knowledge.  And the category, milieu, will be divided into the subcategories, expectation of schools, school’s socioeconomic base, and youth culture.

Each of these subcategories is identified by employing an analyzing process derived from Aristotle’s categories of causation suggested by Joseph Schwab.[4]  These Aristotelean categories will be used to suggest specific questions of inquiry.  They include the state of affairs, interactions, situational insights, and the capacity to act morally. 

That is,

 

·      The state of affairs refers to the actual conditions found in schools, as opposed to abstracted or hypothesized relations between factors or variables.  Of particular concern will be dilemmas caused by adherence to one construct as opposed to another. 

·      Interactions refer to social encounters affected by the respective constructs.

·      Situational insights are interpretations of encounters gleaned from analyses of practice. 

·      Capacity to act morally will be assessments of practices judged according to good citizenship and social capital. 

 

These categories will be used freely to suggest questions for the analysis of this presentation.  The next posting will proceed with this blog’s positive presentation of the natural rights/liberalism construct.  Again, that presentation is through the opted “eyes” of one who would support that construct.



[1] Readers are reminded that the popularity of films is a very good indicator of how the American public feels about various topics since their success is dependent on regular people spending their money to watch them.  So, if a film garners a viewership, that film is very likely to reflect public sentiment in some fashion.

[2] William H. Schubert, Curriculum:  Perspective, Paradigm, and Possibility (New York, NY:  MacMillan Publishing Company, 1986).

[3] They can be defined as follows: 

·       The subject matter refers to the academic content presented in the curriculum. 

·       The teacher is the professional instructor authorized to present and supervise curricular activities within the classroom setting. 

·       Learners are defined as those individuals attending school for the purpose of acquiring the education entailed with a particular curriculum. 

·       Milieu refers to the general cultural setting and ambiance within the varied social settings found at the school site.  

[4] Schubert, Curriculum:  Perspective, Paradigm, and Possibility.

FROM PAROCIAL FEDERALISM TO NATURAL RIGHTS

 

This blog, with the last posting, completed its outline of the parochial federalist view of governance and politics.  It did so from the perspective of an advocate for that construct.  In doing so, it showed the merits of incorporating it as the central construct for the teaching of American government and civics at the secondary level.

          The emphasis has been to both explain the construct as a republican theory that reflects the commitments of the founding generation of Americans around the time of the American Revolution, and as a structural foundation, in which compacts have brought layers of governmental arrangements together in a non-centralized structure which respects the integrity of each level.

          Combined, the construct is not only interested in the factual elements of the nation’s governmental system, but also in the normative questions or responsibilities and duties that citizens are expected to accord that system.  As such, the construct is seen as directly addressing the perceived levels of disaffection and dis-attachment characterizing many of today’s youth in how they meet those responsibilities and duties.

          In addition, the blog provided a critique of that construct by this blogger that emphasizes the narrowness of its view when it comes to identity factors.  The construct, through its influence on the American public and demonstrated through the years of its dominance, contributed to dysfunctional racism and xenophobic attitudes that undermined its claims of support for equality and liberty.  Such influence proved to be very costly in terms of human life (including a heavy death toll in a civil war), property loss, and in its effects to dash human ambitions.

          This blog now transitions from the thesis of an overall dialectic argument to the antithesis – which is currently situated in a thesis position.  That would be the natural rights construct.  It will be described and explained as a current dominant view.  As with the parochial federalist view, it will be presented by a sympathetic eye – as if this reviewer is an advocate.  He will do the best he can in that endeavor.

            Its full title is natural rights/liberalism perspective and the following approach, as just indicated, will be presented as if it should be the foundational construct for the teaching of American government and civics at the secondary level.  In general terms, the reasons for this argument will be that this perspective legitimately and viably promotes the interests of good citizenship and natural liberty.  That argument employs the language of freedom often voiced by many of its advocates as a gift from God.

That is, liberty is being defined as the freedom to do what one wants to do while respecting others to have the same and being amenable or supportive of a prevailing sense of transactional interactions with others.  Within these broad parameters, schools’ curricular treatment of government and politics will promote an approach to government that leaves such determinations over duties and responsibilities to individuals.  All reasonable and legal options from which to decide will be considered legitimate and in the purview of the individual. 

Therefore, this basic curricular choice avoids any attempt, either directly or by suggestion, of any preference for political values, ideals, ideas, other than for liberty, to the individual student.  For it is up to individuals to determine the type of citizens they will seek to be, only restrained by legal boundaries.

As with the parochial federalist review, this presentation of the natural rights perspective will attempt to answer the same research questions.  Overall, the concern is:  does the natural rights view provide a legitimate and viable way to study government and politics at the secondary school level, i.e., in middle schools and in high schools?  There, the targeted courses would be civics and American government, respectively.

              This overall question leads to subsidiary questions.  They are concerned with those issues associated with the comparison between the natural rights perspective, dominant today, and the federalist perspective, which is promoted in this blog.  These views, in many ways, are at odds not only concerning how governments should be described and explained, and how politics should be conducted, but about how people should behave in accordance with that governance and in their – especially political – interactions with each other. 

With that, therefore, the following subsidiary questions are offered:

 

1.    How has the construct guided/evolved in the teaching of American government and civics?

2.    What have been the salient consequences of that development?

3.    To what social arrangements should the development of this construct lead?

4.    How can desirable social arrangements – a la the precepts of the construct – come about?

 

In addition, they steer one’s attention to how Americans should proceed into the future – the espoused aims for those upcoming years. 

Through a description of the historical development of the effects of the two opposing perspectives, a clear comparison will be attempted.  This analysis will be guided by the above subsidiary questions as they relate to the commonplaces of curriculum.

The commonplaces of curriculum were developed by William Schubert[1] and include the subject matter, teachers, learners, and milieu.[2]  Each of these commonplaces will serve as the divisional categories of the following postings in much the same way they organized this blog’s review of the parochial/federalism construct.



[1] William H. Schubert, Curriculum:  Perspective, Paradigm, and Possibility (New York, NY:  MacMillan Publishing Company, 1986).

[2] They can be defined as follows: 

·       The subject matter refers to the academic content presented in the curriculum. 

·       The teacher is the professional instructor authorized to present and supervise curricular activities within the classroom setting. 

·       Learners are defined as those individuals attending school for the purpose of acquiring the education entailed with a particular curriculum. 

·       Milieu refers to the general cultural setting and ambiance within the varied social settings found at the school site. 

 

Friday, July 22, 2022

CRITIQUE OF PAROCHIAL FEDERALISM, V

 

This blogger’s book, Toward a Federated Nation,[1] argues for an instructional approach he calls historical dialogue to action (HD-to-A).  Basically, that approach calls upon students to investigate historical documents and other historical sources (including the work of historians) to gather information relevant to some contemporary problem area.  While grounded in historical material, it is not exclusively so.

These problem areas are so designated because they, to some degree, offend federalist values.  And the aim is for students to develop their individual positions regarding these issues and be prepared to defend their positions in discussions, arguments, and debates.  Teachers are to employ a process that has students develop the knowledge and skills by which they can perform these various steps including taking some action at a local site in which the problem is being manifested.

While this whole process is very much dependent on historical material, this blogger finds the application of the parochial/traditional construct as an approach too reliant on historical materials to the exclusion of other sources.  This bias goes contrary to a great deal of both psychological and pedagogic theory that advocates diversity of instructional methods for different types of learners and for different types of substantive materials.

Here is what a current academic group has to contribute:

 

Teaching methods are the broader techniques used to help students achieve learning outcomes, while activities are the different ways of implementing these methods.  Teaching methods help students:

·      master the content of the course [and]

·      learn how to apply the content in particular contexts

Instructors should identify which teaching methods will properly support a particular learning outcome.  Its effectiveness depends on this alignment.  To make the most appropriate choice, an instructor should consider learning outcomes, student needs and the learning environment.

Consider the following example:

·      Learning outcome:  Solve a complex math equation.

·      Learning environment:  An in person, upper-level math course with 20 students.

·      Teaching method:  Guided instruction.  First, the instructor facilitates learning by modeling and scaffolding.[2]  Students take time to ask questions and receive clarifications.  Next, students practice applying these skills together and then independently.  The instructor uses formative assessment to check for understanding.

This example demonstrates alignment of what the instructor wants students to do, and how they are supported in these tasks.  If the instructor chooses a different teaching method, such as a traditional lecture, students would need to process the lecture’s content and apply principles simultaneously.  This is very difficult to do and would lead to less successful outcomes.

Choosing the appropriate teaching method brings instruction to life while encouraging students to actively engage with content and develop their knowledge and skills.[3]

 

HD-to-A was thought of with these sorts of concerns in mind.  It calls for, where appropriate, employing social scientific processes and findings, natural science processes and findings, journalistic sources, literature and other artistic sources, and any other reputable source that is relevant to the issue under study.

          This approach – a diverse and interactive one – to educational challenges has a rich history and includes the work of such scholars as Thomas L. Good and Jere Brophy,[4] Robert Slavin,[5] and Robert Solso.[6]  And when one considers what the above cite advocates, it verges on the obvious in that it respects the notion, “different strokes for different folks.” 

In addition, when social studies curriculum employs a more current, problem-solving, and relevant approach, it would be useful in encouraging lower achievers to interrelate with the substance of the material and bring it more to life.  In addition, relying on both experimental designs and then narrative based material can avoid falling into a routinized experience for students.

Parochial federalism is too committed to analyzing those historical materials, i.e., historical documents.  Yes, they contain, for example, the values and beliefs of the founding generation – useful information – but in adopting a strategy that reflects the above citation, analysis of these documents to the exclusion of other sources and modes of investigation is short-sighted.  Instead, and this would be promoted by some other construct, there should be a give-and-take between and among various sources and/or activities.

And with that call for diverse methods, this critique is set to address its final point of contention.  That would be how parochial federalism defines community.  That view, being a product of the nation’s early history with its limited technology, thought of community only in geographic terms.  Today, given online technologies (hence this blog) and transportation advancements, community can transcend physical localities. 

These broader capacities call for a broader view and that view should be incorporated into a definition of community.  Parochial/traditional federalism – as its name suggests – has an excessively local view of social/political concerns.  Yet to meet what ails the nation, any view of governance and politics needs to be proactively ensconced in what is currently the relevant setting, that being a global reality.

And with that, this blog comes to its end of how it substantively presents and critiques the parochial/traditional construct – a construct by which Americans mostly saw governance and politics from colonial days to the end of World War II.  In those years, it took on various versions of itself – the first being a covenantal view, one believed to be witnessed by God.

Through such developments as the Enlightenment, Western expansion, industrialization, the Hollywood effect, and the New Deal, that construct was not a stagnant view but evolved with the major events of the nation and with the various forms of its main challenge, the natural rights view.  But with the experiences of World War II and how profound they were, that form of federalism gave way.  This blog, with the next posting, will begin reviewing its replacement, the natural rights view.

The next posting will be short and will summarize what this blog has offered in terms of the parochial federalism construct.  It will offer some introductory commentary on what constitutes the natural rights construct and that will be in the form of an overview in the context of how it was historically situated in the late 1940s.



[1] Available through Amazon.  The book dedicates three chapters to the development of three units of study a teacher can employ in a civics or American government, secondary course.

[2] Scaffolding is merely an instructional strategy of breaking up what is to be learned into manageable segments and either giving students the tools by which to handle the segments or giving them various structures of the materials that possibly render them in a more manageable and/or understandable form.

[3] “Curriculum, Assessment and Teaching Transformation/Teaching Methods,” University of Buffalo (n.d.), accessed July 20, 2022, https://www.buffalo.edu/catt/develop/design/teaching-methods.html .

[4] Thomas L. Good and Jere Brophy, Educational Psychology:  A Realistic Approach (New York, NY:  Longman, 1990).

[5] Robert Slavin, Educational Psychology:  Theory and Practice (Boston, MA:  Allyn and Bacon, 1994).

[6] Robert Solso, Cognitive Psychology (Boston, MA:  Allyn and Bacon, 1995).

Tuesday, July 19, 2022

CRITIQUE OF PAROCHIAL FEDERALISM, IV

 

The last posting ended with the following,

 

By addressing these concerns [lack of viable local governance] … one gets at a very fundamental aspect of a parochial view of federalism as that term suggests one should have.  That would be a parochialism based on local partnerships across the nation in which a partner comes face-to-face with other partners.

 

This is not so much a call for the central, federal government not to address national concerns, but to encourage local citizens to make their local governance and governments proactive entities ready, willing, and able to address the array of challenges citizens face.  That goes from truly local concerns to such global worries as climate change.  Each level of government has not only a relevant role, but a vital one as well.

          And before leaving this local concern, one related problem should be mentioned.  Local communities are evermore becoming single-political units of advocacy.  That is, like minded people are to greater levels living near each other.  Liberals live in liberal neighborhoods or sections of towns, and conservatives also live close to like minded people.  This has political consequences. 

For example, when it comes to districting – or redistricting – Congressional or legislative districts, gerrymandered map-drawings (maps that show how the districts are designated) insure that one party dominates in each of the districts.  This makes general elections near meaningless as the choosing of representatives shifts over to primary contests.[1] 

Add to that the fact that primary elections draw the attention of only the more partisan voters and one can see that many elections do not fulfill their intended purpose.  Ideally, elections should be the time when regular citizens meaningfully involve themselves with others to determine who should represent them in developing governmental policy, yet that is, to ever increasing frequency, not happening.  By this development becoming common, it discards how democracy in a republic is supposed to work.

At the heart of this concern is how unfederated these monocultural arrangements – which they usually turn out to be – are.  Not only that, but these states of affairs are further institutionalized by the practice of gerrymandering those representative districts.  Here’s an idea:  what if a constitutional amendment was proposed and ratified in which it stated the following:

·      One, since monopolistically determined representative districts undermine the federation of a citizenry, and,

·      Two, the US Constitution is a federalist arrangement,

·      Therefore, redistricting shall honor, as much as possible, the principle of diversity as expressed by the allocation of voters within representative districts as closely as possible to the diversity of the state’s electorate as expressed in the last election.  For example, if the state’s election returns indicate 51% voted for Party X and 49% for Party Y, and then based on information garnered from voter registration distribution, each district will reflect this distribution as closely as possible.  Independent registered voters would be considered neutral in this allocation and randomly assigned according to residential addresses.

·      Claims that this mandate is not being met shall be subject to civil suits in which the courts will determine if a proposed districting plan shall be enforced.

·      This provision should not be considered an obstacle to any third-entity solutions, such as generated by commissions to set up to design districting maps, but instead serve as a standard such solutions need to meet.

 

As is probably obvious, this blogger is not a constitutional lawyer or scholar, but he feels his intent is communicated by the above bulleted list.

          In many states, given the popularity of one party over another, this “reform” would have no practical effect, but in those areas or states in which there is sufficient diversity, it could have an enormous effect.  Here is what Eilperin reported earlier in this century:

 

Political scientists and good government advocates have fretted for years about House incumbents’ reelection advantage.  Redistricting has only exacerbated an already disturbing trend.  In [recent] … congressional elections, only thirteen seats switched party control, and seven incumbents lost in the general election …  As University of Pennsylvania Law School Professor Nathaniel Persily wrote, “current rates of House turnover may equal historic rates of turnover in the Politburo [the policy making body of the old Soviet Union].[2]

 

The above listed provisions – or some such constitutional change – would encourage people of different ethnic and political standing to start talking to each other, start depending on each other, and perhaps begin interacting more often with each other. 

There is evidence that, in general, this is not so popular,[3] but it is a central attribute of federalist thought that citizens should strive to become federated with each other.  To achieve the necessary relationships so that they do so, people need to interact, especially politically.  With the above amendment or some such provision, the belief here is that a stage would be set for such interactions.

So much for that concern; now back to critiquing the parochial/traditional federalist view.  And what follows is the next element of this critique.  This element, it turns out, is somewhat related to what has just been stated.  That is, another shortcoming in the use of traditional federalism, particularly given the heterogeneity of modern societies and especially in the US, is that it takes no account of ethnic diversity; at best, it tolerates it. 

While this nation has a history of diverse European populations, with the addition of mostly the African slave population in its early days, most communities were segregated, and in the ensuing years this included whole states being established by religious/national groupings.[4]  But as time went by, communities began to intersperse, and that trend has grown extensively to the present day, particularly in urban centers.

The nation’s larger urban areas, especially, are cauldrons of diversity.  There, one finds zones of intermingling peoples.  Here is how a recent review of diversity states the situation:

 

Nearly all of the nation’s largest cities have at least one neighborhood that meets our definition as being both racially and ethnically diverse and mixed income.  Three large cities – New York, Los Angeles and San Francisco [–] account for nearly half such neighborhoods, but some smaller cities also rank high in the fraction of their population living in these diverse, mixed income neighborhoods.[5]

 

This runs counter to what this posting reports above – the prevalence of segregated areas.  That means these cities run counter to what seems to be occurring in the rest of the country.

          And in these “unusual” areas – the urban areas – there are schools with high levels of diversity.  The concern here is to merely state that such a distinguishing and influential factor should be accounted for when districting and other policies are being considered.  Surely a construct that would set the priorities of what governmental elements should be studied – as parochial/traditional federalism potentially sets out to do – and what issues will be analyzed should have a component that addresses diversity within the population. 

Not only does parochial/federalism tend to ignore these factors, but it also tends to minimize diversity, and, by its sense of priority, somehow attributes an insufficient degree of legitimacy to it and fails to entertain the sort of solutions that this posting offers – be they amateurish. So, as with the state of the nation’s politics running in two opposing directions – known as polarization – one gets a sense of how that has come about. 

On the one hand, there is segregated, representative districting and on the other hand, the higher levels of desegregated urban centers.  Parochial federalism provides Americans with little to no guidance about how they should address this current day political landscape other than claim that they should federate with each other.  Unfortunately, the times call for more guidance.

          This critique, it turns out, needs at least one more posting before it is completed.  Two more issues should be addressed.  They are related to the use of historical documents and a definitional issue – that being the definition of community.  And last, a summary statement should be added.  The next posting, hopefully, will touch all of these bases.[6]



[1] Juliet Eilperin, Fight Club Politics:  How Partisanship Is Poisoning the House of Representatives (Lanham, MD:  Rowman and Littlefield, 2007).  While a bit dated, nothing in ensuing reports in the news seems to suggest this situation has been rectified; as a matter of fact, things have gotten worse.

[2] Ibid., 112,

[3] Ibid.  This lack of popularity seemingly due to people, as conditions now stand, finding this form of interaction unattractive – it strikes many as having to deal with “them” – the other.

[4] See, for example, Tom Gjelten, “White Supremacist Ideas Have Historical Roots in U.S. Christianity.” NPR (July 1, 2020), accessed July 17, 2022, https://www.npr.org/2020/07/01/883115867/white-supremacist-ideas-have-historical-roots-in-u-s-christianity AND Mark Carnes and John A. Garraty, The American Nation:  A History of the United States (Boston, MA:  Pearson, 2015).

[5] Joe Cortright, “America’s Most Diverse Mixed Income Neighborhoods,” City Reports (June 18, 2018), accessed July 17, 2022, https://cityobservatory.org/admin/ .

[6] Afterall, tonight is MLB’s All-Star Game.