A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Friday, December 20, 2013

UNDEMOCRATIC MAP DRAWINGS

What is the purpose of Congress or, for that matter, of any legislative body such as a state legislature? The legislative body makes the laws. And what is a law in terms of this function? Law is the authoritative policy pronouncement of what the government will do. The legislature decides what the government will do. The executive – the President at the federal level – does what the legislature has decided. Are these legislatures legitimate in fulfilling this function? In our system, the legitimacy of the legislature, be it Congress, state legislature, county commission, or city council, is based on the fact that the members are voted to their positions by us, the citizens of the respective jurisdiction. The members represent us and, by and large, if they want to keep their jobs, they will roughly decide in such a way that reflects the wishes of most of the voters who sent them to their positions. I am probably not conveying anything that you don't already know, but I go over this elementary civics material to draw a context for what follows.

In the voting process, the assumption is that all citizens have equal voice in determining who will be chosen to represent a certain jurisdiction. Let me focus on the House of Representatives at the federal government level, although much of what follows also pertains to state legislatures. Each state is divided into Congressional districts and each district is represented by one representative. On average, there are about 700,000 citizens per district. So each representative represents about 700,000, although this number varies from district to district. The Constitution provides for each state to have at least one representative even if the population of the state is less than 700,000. And, of course, the actual numbers of each district will vary in order to accommodate the demographic realities of the state. Besides, the exact population of any state is not exactly divisible by 700,000, so the math of distributing population among the number of districts a state has will, by necessity, cause the 700K number to vary. Be that as it may, let us assume, for the point I am making in this posting, that each district has 700K. And with that ratio, 1 representative to 700,000 citizens, let us imagine a fictitious situation.

The situation has to do with a made up state that has exactly 2,100,000 people. Simple division tells us the state, therefore, has three Congressional districts with each district having within its boundaries 700,000 citizens. We will call the fictitious state South Huma. With only 2.1 million people, the state is considered small. The only urban center exists in Congressional District One. In the last Congressional election, 2012, District One voted 90% for the Democratic candidate and 10% for the Republican candidate. District Two voted 49% Democratic and 51% Republican. And District Three voted 49% Democratic and 51% Republican. Across the entire state, the Democrats won roughly 62.7% of the vote and the Republicans won 37.3% of the vote, yet the Republicans won 2 seats and the Democrats won only one seat. While my example exaggerates what actually took place, the idea is that if you draw Congressional districts just so – a process known as gerrymandering – a party can lose at the ballot box in terms of actual votes of citizens and win a majority of seats available. In principle, that is why in the last Congressional election, the Democrats received one million more votes nationwide than the Republicans and yet did not gain control (win a majority of the seats) in the House of Representatives.

How are the district lines drawn? Well that task – some might say, “opportunity” – falls to the respective state legislatures and they use primarily the national census figures that are reported every ten years. That is, every ten years, each state legislature goes about figuring out how the Congressional district boundaries should be designated. This is a highly politicized process since where those lines are drawn will determine the fate of individual politicians – will he or she have to run in a district that is favorable to his/her re-election chances? Also, the ability of a political party to advance its policy positions will be dependent on how many members of the respective legislative body belong within its ranks. So, the party in the majority of any given legislature will use its numbers to insure that the boundary lines will be drawn favorably. They will be lines that help insure that their members will be re-elected and, perhaps, be able to defeat members who belong to the opposition party. Both parties, when given the opportunity, have done this. Since the Republicans won big in the 2010 elections, they got to draw the lines that resulted from the 2010 census figures in twenty-seven of the states (a figure that jumped to twenty-eight in 2012 as the process concluded). That is the number of states in which the Republicans controlled both chambers of the legislature. Some argue that the practice has become too skewed in favor of the Republicans. They go on to say that districts are so biased, creating such secure Republican districts, that that party does not have to worry about losing control of the House of Representatives. But how does this practice affect the quality of our democracy?

The case of South Huma illustrates a fundamental problem, one that undermines the very democratic nature of the system. After all, when people vote, their votes should be equal and the result should reflect the will of the majority. And yet, the current composition of the House – “the people's House” – does not reflect the majority. A lot of the gridlock in Congress today can be attributed to that fact. Yet there are efforts in various states to address this undemocratic aspect of how we choose our representatives.

In Florida, for example, the state constitution has a provision that drawing of district lines will not reflect political aims and that, specifically, lines should not be drawn in order to insure or protect an individual or party winning a particular seat. The League of Women Voters brought suit against the Florida Legislature claiming that the Republicans violated that provision and they want to question members in court about their actions during the reapportionment process that ended in 2012. The Legislature countered that it is immune from such questioning. Such questioning would place a “chilling” effect on legislators in the performance of their duty and, as such, the courts ordering them to testify would amount to a violation of the separation of powers between the Legislature and the courts. In an opinion just issued, the state's supreme court decided in favor of the League. The Court agreed that forcing members to testify would have a chilling effect, but that that was the very idea of the constitutional provision. Therefore, the members will have to go before a court and, under oath, explain their motivations and actions in drawing the lines as they did.1 Will this make the process more responsive to the democratic wishes of the people? We will see. As it is, the voice of many urban voters, as illustrated in my fictitious state, are being silenced and rendered as wasted.

When one's vote is rendered useless due to where one happens to live and it is done as a result of a systemic condition, the very constitutional integrity of those voters comes into question. For federalists, constitutional integrity is a central procedural value and, therefore, a civics class that uses the federalist construct to guide its content would be well within its purview to study this current anomaly.

1Farrington, B. (2013). Supreme Court: Lawmakers must testify on new maps. Tallahassee Democrat, December 14, p. 3A.

Monday, December 16, 2013

AN IMPORTANT MODERATION

In viewing the significant developments of American democracy, one development that receives limited interest and focus is the transfer of American federalist thought from one based on a religious foundation to one that became secular. Before expounding on this theme, let me share what caused me to think of it. On the 60 Minutes broadcast of December 15th there was the story of the Copts of Egypt. This Eastern Orthodox religion has survived in a nation that is predominately inhabited by Muslims, for over 1,000 years and an overall history of about 2,000 years. The Coptic followers have been practicing their religion since the earliest days of Christianity. The name Copt originally meant people of the area that is now Egypt. They even claim to have initiated the ceremony that eventually became the mass, a central ritual of the Catholic Church and of other Christian denominations. Today they account for about 10 % of the Egyptian population and are the largest Christian sect in the Middle East. Recently, due to their backing of the Egyptian military's coup in overthrowing the Muslim Brotherhood supported Morsi government, followers of the Brotherhood launched massive attacks on 40 Coptic places of worship causing extensive damage. This was an event that happened in the midst of other episodes in which the Copts have been the targets of abuse either from Muslim extremists (for example, the Nag Hammadi massacre in which eight Copts were killed on January 7, 2010) or another massacre that was instigated by the Egyptian military on Copt protesters in the city of Maspero on October 9, 2011. This last attack killed 27 Copts. As Americans view such reports, we might ask: why are we in the US not like that? What is it about American politics that allows a level of tolerance so that our cases of religious attacks have been held to a limited number? Of course, the Egyptian example might be extreme and there are other nations along with the US that enjoy religious harmony. Each nation has its story to tell in this area of concern, but what is our story?

These questions need to be asked while keeping a very important historical fact in mind; that is, the origins of the American society were highly influenced by religious beliefs. We should remember that early settlements were established by highly religious English men and women. The earliest settlements were small and were mostly inhabited by like-minded individuals. As the settlements grew, eventually folks who did not share in the predominant beliefs began to be part of these communities and this eventually led to conflicts including those motivated by religion. Early examples of religious strife took many forms. There were cases of discrimination against members of non-preferred religions, violent confrontations, lynchings, destruction of property, and the like. But these episodes did not characterize the typical relations between citizens of differing religions. They were more often the exceptions. There might be, in our early days, state sponsored religions but, by and large, as populations began to grow to substantial levels, there developed a general understood sense of “live and let live” among people of differing faiths.

I am sure there were many reasons for this general development. But I believe that one such reason is the historical development in which Americans began seeing our basic national agreements – our constitutions – as no longer being covenants, but instead being compacts. To remind you of the distinction: a covenant is a binding agreement among a people in which each member promises, in the most solemn fashion, to abide by spelled out provisions in the agreement. The promise is so binding that it is to be kept no matter what any one party does – at least that is how this type of commitment was defined. This could be a marriage vow, an agreement to engage in a collective activity such as the founding of a church, or the formulation of a government. The promise is further “sanctified” by calling on God as a witness to the promise. The origins of covenants, way before they made their way to American shores, date back to prehistoric times, but Western traditions surrounding this binding process are probably mostly influenced by the Judeo tradition (the Sinai or Mosaic Covenant, 11th century BCE). A compact is the same as a covenant only without calling on God as a witness. This is a significant secular turn and one that reflects a basic evolution of the attitudes on the part of Americans, a turn that reflected attitudinal changes and then promoted them.

At the time of the American Revolution, there were two views concerning the adoption of binding agreements: one supportive of covenants and the other supportive of compacts. If we look at the language of the Declaration of Independence, 1776, that document is a covenant. If we then look at the language of the US Constitution, that document is a compact. I believe that this was an emblematic change of perspective; that is, that the years between the writing and adoption of these two documents coincided with a significant change in the opinions of Americans – change that, at least when it came to forming a government, covenants were no longer needed to bind parties. Instead, a preference for compacts took hold. One should remember that these years were focused on these types of issues since we were not only forming an national government, but also highly involved in forming state governmental structures as well.

One aspect of these types of agreements, that pertains to both, refers to how such an agreement is either changed or terminated. One might roughly measure how serious one views either type of agreement by how easily the agreement can be done away with or how easily it can be changed. For example, can a covenant or compact be dismissed or voided by the parties that agree to such a change? An answer to that question must include the notion that voiding or changing the agreement needs to be difficult – very difficult. Short of that, the commitment does not have the binding quality that is needed to allow the parties involved to become invested in either the process or the final product. Consider the process by which our constitution, a compact, is amended. Without going over all of the possible steps, the bottom line is that the change has to be overwhelmingly supported by the American people – at least that is what the process is supposed to guarantee. In short, both in the case of a covenant or a compact, the idea is that the agreement is supposed to be made in perpetuity or until the conditions that led to the agreement still exist. Some might consider that given the fact that it has become relatively easy to obtain a divorce, the marriage agreement has lost its status of being a covenant or a compact and, in fact, common parlance has started calling the agreement the “marriage contract.” Also, the argument has been made that state constitutions have become too easily amended by public initiatives and that the integrity of many of them has been compromised by the addition of non-constitutional provisions such as whether or not the state should support rapid transit.

According to the scholar, Daniel J. Elazar,1 one of the contextual developments of forming our national union under the provisions of the 1787 constitution was the acceptance by the nation of the Federalist2 view. That is, in terms of our sense of political morality and all that that entails, we needed to place in lesser priority local orthodoxy about such matters – and that included strong religious biases – and accept a notion of tolerance. If we were to consider ourselves a single people, then we needed to restrain ourselves from insisting that all see religion from the same “lenses” of our particular religious bent. We needed, instead, a more secular view of our political commitments and that began by defining our basic constitutional agreement in those secular terms, at least as that view pertained to the national arena of politics and governance. I don't know how conscious the average American was over such a shift in our perspective, but once it was, in effect, codified in our constitution, including the First Amendment, the process began to change our national sense of what was legitimate in these concerns. The formulation of a governing agreement changed from one of being “higher, higher” law to one being “middle higher” law. The view of governing was seen more as being a human endeavor than an expression of God's will on earth.3

On a more practical level, our governmental perspective became less a form of religious expression and more of one that described our overall civic relation as a partnership. And as such, politics in a federalist sense became an expression of sharing. Ironically, secular sharing placed the emphasis in traditional federalism back on the local level and shied away from central authority and power. This, then, is a compromise. On the one hand, the shift emphasizes the transcending values that made up the American ethos: liberty, equality, self-reliance, communal membership, and the like. On the other hand, social and political focus would remain with local conditions and institutions in which more parochial concerns could be more readily expressed, but in a moderate way. The newer outlook could be expressed as: “I can dislike you and avoid being social with you if you don't see the Almighty in the same way as I do, but you do have your right to be wrong.” This compromise gave the early Americans a way to find the mid-point between religious fervor and secular demands to accommodate the diversity that was becoming ever more a characterization of American life. It has been proven, through our development, that we have evolved from this initial reluctant form of tolerance to one in which many take on an embracing posture of those who believe differently. Our constitutional way of life, to this day, is replete with institutional structures and processes that reflect that compromise and has allowed us to avoid the ugly possibilities that exemplify the sectarian relations in many countries such as Egypt. Through the years, we have become more and more inclusive and even tend to define what it means to be American by incorporating a positive and accepting view of others' beliefs. That process is still taking place.

1As with the previous posting, the ideas expressed in this explanation of the distinction between covenants and compacts reflect the insights of Daniel J. Elazar (1934-1999).

2By Federalist, I am referring to the ideas advocated by those who supported the new national constitution.

3In terms of this debate, the work of Thomas Jefferson cannot be overstated. For example, his Bill for Religious Freedom in Virginia had enormous influence on the minds of Americans.

Friday, December 13, 2013

A DUALIST JEFFERSON

One of the anecdotes about Nelson Mandela that I found particularly telling was that he invited his jailer to a front row seat at his inauguration for the presidency of South Africa. I repeat it to point out how “federalist” President Mandela was. The reason I characterize this gesture with this moniker is because central to federalist thinking is the principle that good governance is advanced by bringing into political play as many parties or interests as possible.

In the first of the Federalist Papers,1 Alexander Hamilton divides all polities into three types: those based on force, those based on accident, and those based on choice. We associate different institutional structures with each type. Those based on force are noted for concentrated power in the fashion of a king or dictator. Those based on accident are noted for power of the elites – an aristocracy or plutocracy. And those based on choice are noted for power of varied interests that make up the political landscape of a nation. The last sees no limitation on the number of interests that should participate in the formulation of public policy. The implementation of this principle has further structural and procedural implications.

First, a polity of choice holds as most important its foundational constitution – the covenant or compact – that spells out the agreement by which those who have chosen to formulate the polity do so. The constitution sets out to form a structural grid of offices, levels of authority, agencies, and even, in some cases, divided sovereignty designations. Yes, it's complex. It is a structure that can lend itself to suffering through politicians who continuously defray responsibility, but it is also a structure that opens opportunities for more to become involved and also opportunities for citizens to find those government officials who are apt to be favorable to any given demand. As a citizen, if you don't like the response in office A, then you can go to office B or office C and so on. In principle, this approach to governance tends to avoid extremely hierarchical tendencies. As with any form of polity, there is a significant danger associated with its approach. That is, polities based on force are in danger of becoming tyrannies; polities based on accident are in danger of becoming cabals of oligarchs, and polities based on choice are in danger of becoming chaotic or anarchistic. When analyzing each of these types, a student is wise to keep the respective dangers in mind and expect that its development, at a fundamental level, fuels many of its more significant political issues.2

Of course, the US exemplifies a polity based on choice. For one, it is a federation which is a subtype of “choice” polities. The US has its matrix structure with bifurcated sovereignty, sovereignty that resides both with the central government and with the state governments. And I see that through its history, to varying degrees, that there has been a particular view of politics which has provided a source of instability. I can trace the manifestation of this challenge from its very beginning as a national polity. That is, the natural rights construct, with its emphasis on the individual and, to some, unrestrained liberty, has been the source for chaotic, anarchistic developments. And no founding “father” was more responsible for this construct's initial influence than the prime author of our Declaration of Independence, Thomas Jefferson. Yet, such a designation should not be made without some qualifying explanations. What makes his contribution along these lines so nebulous is that his association with natural rights thought was due more to isolated comments and written passages than to any well thought-out exposition of ideas. His natural rights assertions, I believe, were motivated by his admiration of John Locke. Locke wrote of individuals giving up a limited amount of liberty in order to form a polity. The British philosopher contextualized his comments with the devising of a fictional origin to societal arrangements – that they emerged from a state of nature. Humans formulated such arrangements by being willing to surrender only those liberties that made societal formation possible. This, to a generation of political thinkers who were fighting the overwhelming level of repression that was the product of a long history of elitist governance, sounded liberalizing. Between the king and the nobles, the history of British rule might have been leading the world into opening up political opportunities, but it still represented a stronghold as to what an individual could and could not do. To men like Jefferson, that history represented stifling horizons and they wanted to change this whole basic political arrangement. Natural rights ideas provided the theoretical arguments by which to attack this legacy. The Declaration is an excellent example of what this fight was all about. But how far down this theoretical path was Jefferson traveling?

To begin, Jefferson was not an abstract theoretician. His proclivities were more of a practical bent. According to Richard Hofstadter, Jefferson was more at home studying and sharing his wisdom about the practical concerns of agriculture. Yet, he was no slouch concerning political thought. And his thoughts did have their influence among Americans of the late 1700s and early 1800s, an influence that was substantial and long lasting. Yes, he did talk of how revolution was the useful “manure” for the tree of liberty, but these were populist assertions that were not backed by any mature thinking. Instead, he spoke more convincingly and importantly when he reacted to the work and efforts of his fellow founders. He supported the structural selection, by the founders, of a balanced constitution in which the several classes were represented. “It is not by the consolidation, or concentration of powers, but by their distribution that good government is effected.”3 That is why the Constitution creates the structural matrix our governmental system exemplifies. Structurally, according to federalist principles, government should not limit the number of interests that can participate. With these interests comes the diversity of opinions, principles, and passions that are present within the polity at any given time and that should be considered by policymakers. This holds a dual challenge: the inclusion of all interests and the safeguard of each (even of each individual) against the potential tyranny of the majority. Jefferson was sensitive to this danger: “One hundred and seventy-three despots would surely be as oppressive as one … As little will it avail us as that they are chosen by ourselves.”4 This is Jefferson's support, similar to that of James Madison, of an expanded republic. It is a view that expresses a version of federalist principles. So while one can trace an initial argument for natural rights from this founder, one would be wise to make this overall judgment with a healthy dose of restraint.
 
1One should remember this title in considering the content of that historically important collection of essays.
 
2Many of the ideas contained in this description are attributable to the insights of the late, eminent scholar, Daniel J. Elazar.

3Hofstadter, R. (1948). The American political tradition. New York, NY: Vintage Books. Quotation on p. 29.

4Ibid.

Monday, December 9, 2013

REALISTIC REASONS TO PLAY ALONG

I have a story line to share. It's fiction, but I think its ins and outs can be telling of our political system and its processes. Let us say the president is a woman – that a woman won the presidential sweepstakes back in 2008. She has a plan for a national healthcare program. It is one in which the national government copies a plan that already exists in one of the fifty states. That program calls on uninsured people to sign up for a health insurance plan by going online and seeing what private insurance programs have to offer. For people who can't afford any of the plans, there will be a subsidy provided by the federal government to help them pay their premiums. Adding to the appeal of this program is that it has been in effect for several years and works swimmingly well with the citizens of that state loving it. Also, the state plan was initially passed by a Democratically controlled legislature and signed into law by a Republican governor. That gives this program something very rare in our political environment: bipartisan backing. The fictional president, though, has several obstacles in nationalizing this state plan.

The first obstacle is from members of her own party. Her base support – that is, the support of her most committed backers – want a more government-controlled program. They want to extend, in effect, the existing national old age program (Medicare) so that it will be provided to the whole population. That is a program in which the government basically pays for all medical expenses (100% of hospital costs and 80% of doctors' fees) beyond minimal co-payments. It also mandates that all citizens must pay a healthcare tax that corresponds roughly to a modest insurance payment. This puts into the actuary pool people of all ages. By doing this, the pool will include people who are healthy, who happen to be the vast majority of the population. The resulting pool will, therefore, have enough money so that the expenses of the not so healthy can be covered. This is acceptable to the healthy because no one knows when one will change from being a healthy person to an ill person. By the way, this is the principle behind any health insurance program, private or public. This type of program relegates the middle men, the insurance companies, to a much reduced role and cuts back the fees they can charge. Therefore, for this and other reasons, healthcare becomes cheaper. The main objection to this program, though, is that this expands the intrusiveness of government in our healthcare system. At least, that is the concern of conservatives.

Short of this alternative is a mix between what the fictional president wants and what her base supporters want. That would be a program that mirrors the state program but offers, among the provided insurance choices, a “public option.” That is, the basic structure of the program is in line with what the president wants, but, in addition to all the private options, a person can choose a public option similar to the old age program. Again, this would probably be a program with fewer costs since it eliminates the private insurance companies when a person selects the public option. With fewer costs, the public option will have lower premiums and this would provide significant competition to the private options and, therefore, lower the overall costs of healthcare.

Up to now, this story sounds like what happened when Congress was considering healthcare a few years ago. At least, in its broad outline, it is what Representative Luis Gutierrez (D, IL) described the other day as being what was considered by President Obama.1 But to return to my story line, there are three stated alternative approaches to reforming healthcare: private choices option (what the president wants and is aiming to have become law), the public option (what is a mix between what the president wants and what the president's party base wants), and single government payer option (what the president's party base wants). Our fictional president wants the private choice mainly because she knows there is a high degree of skepticism over the other two alternatives. The opposition party has been very successful in convincing people that any extensive role by government will have government determining what medical services will be available to people if either of these two options were to be put into effect. But beyond this obstacle, the president has another one. That is, she has an extremely hostile opposition party in Congress that, even though they don't have a majority in either chamber of Congress, they can still deny the president any ability to capture bipartisan support for any effort the president might attempt. Since this is such an important area of legislation, the president feels she must secure some opposition party votes in favor of any bill that would pass Congress.

So, and now we will vary from what actually happened; after consulting with her advisers, the president decides on the following strategy. The president will first, with much public fanfare, announce the administration's supposed healthcare position which is a single government payer plan. While this is not true – she is not aiming to get this plan through Congress – she makes the public argument for this option. She secures the support from key members of Congress who belong to the president's party. To some of these members, whom the president really trusts, she confides in them what the true strategy is and is about to be implemented. The president then calls a much publicized meeting which includes leaders from both parties to work out a national healthcare program. The opposition party members protest, but agree to attend. Since Americans want their government to address the fact that there are about 40 million Americans who can't afford health insurance and it is bad form to reject a presidential invitation, they agree to attend the meeting. There is also the added fact that everyone's health costs are being pushed higher than they should be since hospitals are passing on to other patients the costs of treatment for those who can't pay. These passed-on costs, on average, are costing the Americans an extra thousand dollars a year. In back rooms, the president's negotiators are able to talk a few key opposition members into supporting a plan that resembles the bipartisan program already existing in the one state mentioned above. They agree because the ideas for this program were initiated by conservatives and rely on private insurance companies competing for the uninsured people's business. But first, they are to propose and publicly insist that the administration adopt a set of provisions that are geared to lower health costs. One such provision would be to shift insurance markets from being organized at the state level to being organized at the national level. This would increase, they claim, more competition and lower insurance premiums.2 When they do this, the administration balks, but states that instead of supporting the government payer plan, the president is willing to adopt the public option alternative. The opposition again publicly rejects that offer and holds that the administration should now adopt the existing state model in which private options are offered to people. All of these moves have been previously planned as public give and take between a few members of Congress from both parties and the president. The president agrees to this last offer and, in effect, gets what she initially wanted. While the president wins, she does so in such a way that everyone walks away with the ability to claim a victory. The nation has a national healthcare program, but it is a program that is based on ideas initially offered by conservative sources.

I hope you don't find the above story line as being too rambling a tale. The point is to illustrate an important aspect of our political processes and one that is probably part and parcel of any democratic system. That is, politics is made up of a lot of perceptions. I believe that one reason President Barack Obama has met with such opposition to his healthcare law has been the fact that it was passed with all Democratic votes in Congress. One can claim that the opposition, the Republicans, is mostly responsible for Democrats having to count on only their members to get a healthcare program. But from the Republican perspective, the President came up with the program and mostly jammed it down their throats. But if the President could have followed a scenario more in line with my storyline, then perhaps there could have been some Republican votes and those Republicans could have shared in some of the credit in passing legislation that finally provided healthcare to millions of Americans. Instead, Obama and the Democrats in Congress went it alone.

Some of you might be saying, he doesn't know what actually happened in the passing of healthcare – that there was a lot more involved with the actual events that led to the Affordable Care Act. Maybe I don't know all that went into that particular legislative process. After all, all negotiations do not happen in public. Perhaps what actually happened is the best we could have expected. I provide this story not so much to criticize the administration as to provide an alternative approach to policy making – one that illustrates potential give and take (even if staged) that can provide positive results for all involved. This might include some grandstanding, some staging, or some other manipulations to achieve what is politically possible. Is it an ideal scenario? Of course not, but it is a view that takes into account some less than ideal realities. As it is, while the Republicans ended up with a form of healthcare that reflected many of their stated principles, the way the law came about offered them few to no opportunities to claim credit. After all, they are in the business of selling themselves to the electorate as being worthy of credit and when that is deprived, they have no transactional reason to play along. And while it is common for people to expect a higher motivation on the part of their leaders, history tells us that on this account, they will probably be disappointed.

1The Representative gave this description during a meeting of the Judiciary Committee.

2It would also provide an incentive to all insurance companies to set up shop in the lowest regulated states.

Friday, December 6, 2013

INSTRUCTIONAL “MYTHS”

In this blog, I usually address content issues in the curricular field of civics. I find from time to time that content issues border on instructional concerns. That's the case with this posting. We have the President to thank for that. President Barack Obama gave civics teachers a good suggestion for a set of lessons during his speech this past Wednesday on the expanding gap in income and wealth distribution between the rich and the not so rich. In his speech, he identified what he called three myths regarding this issue. Let me paraphrase: one, low income is a problem of minority populations such as African-Americans, Hispanics, or some other ethnic groups; two, policies that are aimed at securing equality in income or wealth are detrimental to economic growth; and three, efforts by government to ameliorate or solve lower income or wealth rates do not accomplish their aims and, therefore, are not useful. What civics or other social studies teachers can do is look at these claimed myths as hypotheses and have students test them to see whether these claims are true or whether they are, in fact, myths.

The first of these “myths” seems fairly easy to test. One can readily gather demographic information that identifies those portions of the population that earn near or below poverty rates and then see what percentage of those people are non-Hispanic whites, blacks, Latinos/as, Asians, or any other nationality or ethnic grouping the teacher would want to identify for the lesson. For example, CBS news reports that “[f]our out of 5 U. S. adults struggle with joblessness, near-poverty or reliance on welfare for at least parts of their lives, a sign of deteriorating economic security and an elusive American dream.”1 While non-whites are becoming a majority in the population, one can mathematically determine that if the four out of 5 figure is correct, many of those who make up disadvantaged segments of the population are non-Hispanic whites. As a matter of fact, survey results show that “[p]essimism among that racial group [non-Hispanic whites] about their families' economic futures has climbed to the highest point since at least 1987. In the most recent AP-GfK poll, 63 percent of whites called the economy 'poor.'"2 This type of information is readily available from what are considered objective sources. US Census and IRS information sources can be highly helpful.

In terms of the second “myth,” policy aimed at promoting equality counteracts economic growth, one can view historical efforts historians consider serious efforts at promoting equality. I would include in that list the Progressive efforts of the early twentieth century, the New Deal initiative of the 1930s, and the War on Poverty/Great Society programs of the 1960s. One can see what the resultant economic indicators show governmental efforts had on income and wealth distribution as well as the overall economy. One can also look at efforts to undo those “progressive” initiatives such as during the 1920s during the administrations of Harding, Coolidge, and Hoover and of that of Ronald Reagan's administration and see what resulted from those efforts. Did income and wealth distribution gaps increase, decrease, or stay the same? I believe the most telling statistic that gives a quick view on how evenly distributed income is is the median wage; that is, the wage level at which half of the incomes of households fall below that mark and half fall above that mark. If the median wage increases during a segment of time when the GDP is growing, one can say that the economy is growing and that that growth is somewhat more evenly distributed than is the case if the median wage were going down. Another telling statistic is the percentage of the population living below the poverty rate. Of course, if the poverty rate is going up, one can say, unless there is a drastic lowering of GDP, that the lower classes are not benefiting from economic growth. A more sophisticated study can trace income levels of the five quintile3 groups – the division of the workforce according to twenty percent groupings of the population from the lowest income earning group to the highest – over time. These income levels or poverty rates can be matched to prevailing economic policies, particularly those that are aimed at shrinking the distribution gap. A warning needs to be stated: this type of analysis can be misleading in that it is difficult to determine when policies take effect and have any meaningful influence on economic conditions. But what one can easily determine is whether policies that are aimed at equality have a meaningful, negative effect on economic growth. Does one see, for example, a drastic downturn in the GDP or in the median income in the years during and immediately after the onset of the Great Society programs? Students can do such calculations.

Closely related to myth number two is myth number three. To study this hypothesis, that government cannot help conditions of inequality, a teacher can have students do case studies of particular government programs that were designed to ease or solve some condition of inequality. For example, did Medicare solve the problem of the elderly not being able to afford healthcare? Or, does raising the minimum wage assist lower income people in securing living wage employment? In this type of instruction, the teacher should take care as to how he or she poses the question to be studied. So, in the case of the minimum wage issue, asking whether raising it results in higher income, the question misses an important element in the debate over the minimum wage. Many argue that raising the minimum wage will result in fewer jobs since employers will cut back on this factor of production due to its higher cost. By asking about the policy change in terms of securing employment, as I suggest above, the number of jobs employers are willing to offer is taken into account. Well-stated questions can have students test how effective government programs can be.

These three “myths” or hypotheses reflect important issues. The American people usually indicate that their most important issue at any given time is the economy, at least according to their responses on surveys. As such, politicians of all stripes manipulate their language to advance their economically related positions in order to make what they say more amenable to interested voters. I heard a politician today say that the minimum wage should not be raised because this would discourage businesses to hire teenagers, even though vast majority of the jobs in question are held by people 20 years and older. This type of manipulation can be combated by students doing the type of studies I reviewed above. And civics teachers, if they choose to take advantage of the recent help provided by the President, should offer, if only under their breath, a “thanks” to – what should we call him? – Instructor-in-Chief.

2Ibid.

3According to the Free Dictionary, “[s]tatistics the portion of a frequency distribution containing one fifth of the total sample.”

Monday, December 2, 2013

“CONSTITUTIVE CONCEPTION”

What can we expect of an individual who claims to be part of an association – a federal union? What seems reasonable, even if we are asking in terms of an ideal? One can start such an inquiry by considering a person who has normal ambitions in life. There is a line in the HBO series, Boardwalk Empire, that goes something like this: all of a man's [woman's] problems stems from his [her] inability to live contently sitting in his [her] room. We all want more out of life. So we go about dreaming, planning, training, sacrificing, risking, sometimes conniving to achieve the “better” life. Yet none of this can be accomplished alone. We are all dependent on others so that those kinds of activities can take place. I just heard of a study that links the incidence of lower crime rates to the prevalence of abortions. It seems that lower incidence of unwanted children being born has eventually resulted in fewer people wanting to commit crimes. I don't offer this relationship as an argument or a justification for abortions – many unintended positive consequences begin from either immoral acts or, at least, less than desirable acts – but it does hint at the importance of a nurturing home. A good and loving family, a caring community, good schools, and enriching environments in general all increase the probability that children will grow up to be productive, law abiding, and, at a minimum, contented citizens. And yet, this whole amalgamation of factors is provided by others: parents, teachers, neighbors, priests or ministers, relatives, and public officials.

So, a civics curriculum, I believe, should address this reality. It should take on what Michael Sandel calls a strong view of community. What is that? Let me attempt to describe a “strong” view by first reviewing what a “weak” view is. A weak view sees community or a sense of community as either being instrumental – a view of community as a field of opportunity to advance one's interests – or being sentimental – a view of community as one composed of a compilation of people who have shared, final ends. Instead, a strong view is one that has other characteristics. One, the community is seen and felt as being a part of who one is. “It is a part of me.” Two, as such, the community or a sense of a community is not something one chooses – as is the case when one sees community instrumentally or attaches oneself to it to seek mutual ends with others – but instead is something one discovers as one understands who one is. It is one of an array of items that helps determine the essence of one's identity, but is not so obvious as other essential characteristics such as religion or nationality. Sandel refers to this view of community as part of a person's “constitutive conception” of community.1

Here is what Sandel means. He believes that community ideally should become a part of a person and, as such, is not dependent on a person having a sense of obligation or seeing community in terms of gains or losses, advantages or disadvantages. This is a view that is dependent on a higher degree of self-knowledge or understanding. It takes the dependency I describe above – of family, neighbors, etc. – and internalizes it within a person who can appreciate how constitutive of his or her being that reality is. If a person doesn't appreciate the constitutive role that community plays in whom he or she is, perhaps he or she can feel it when considering his/her family. Or perhaps a person can transcend the community and extend such a view to the region or even the nation within which he/she lives, because a lot of what a community can do is, in turn, dependent on the factors that exist in its environment.

A telling response which indicates whether a person has such a constitutive conception would be his/her answer to the question: what keeps you from breaking the law or keeps your behavior within the boundaries of legitimate social norms? Is it fear of detection, being arrested, being beaten up, or being ostracized? Or is it a logical choice in which you see your interests served by supporting a system of rewards that is dependent on some minimum level of cooperation? The first reason is one that is based on coercion and the second is one based on predictable and reliable rewards. The first reason, if universally or extensively held, is expensive for a society and the second is too dependent on many whimsical factors. In either case, the health of the society is not well-served if these are the bases for the prominent motivations in citizens obeying the law or otherwise cooperating with essential social activities. Where there exists a close psychological relationship, however, between what one wants and what a community is trying to achieve, there is no need for excessive coercive measures or an unrealistic reward system that is unsustainable.

So how does one see his or her community, state, or nation with a strong view of community? He or she, in simple terms, strives to see other citizens as partners. He or she understands that his or her interests, if not in immediate terms, then in long range terms, are linked. Therefore, he or she should conduct his/her business in such a way that any resulting advancement should be for all. This idea begins with one understanding how dependent one's self reality is unalterably linked to one's community and to the efforts exerted by the community on one's behalf. And even in our competitive environment, which is a product of our capitalist system, this idea or view can be sustained. If I produce and bring to market a useful product and do all I can to lower my costs, yet treat my employees fairly – which does not mean extravagantly – and treat my customers honestly and fairly, then I am helping everyone's interests, including my competitors', not just my own. As Robert Reich says on TV, while promoting his recent documentary film, if businesses pay their workers a fair wage and treat their workers fairly, everyone will do better than if they don't. He applies this principle by comparing Walmart to Henry Ford2 and also by his analysis of the effects of the Affordable Care Act:
[As a result of the ACA] everyone does come out ahead in the long term: Even the best-off will gain from a healthier and more productive workforce, and will save money from preventive care that reduces the number of destitute people using emergency rooms when they become seriously ill.3
But such an analysis, while helpful in promoting positive images of community, gets us back to seeing community and society as a transactional arena and offering our allegiances for instrumental reasons instead of reasons based on a constitutive conception that Sandel would like us to adopt when viewing our community. Perhaps encouraging a transactional view is a good place to start with students. When this reality is well understood and accepted, then students can start inquiring into how integral community and society are in determining who we are.

1See Dagger, R. (1997). Civic virtue: Rights, citizenship, and republican liberalism. New York, NY: Oxford, pages 48-50. The reference to Sandel can be found in Sandel, M. J. (1992). Liberalism and the limits of justice. New York: Cambridge University Press.

2Henry Ford is historically remembered for his business philosophy which held that businesses should pay their workers well so that they in turn can be good consumers of his products.

Friday, November 29, 2013

HAIR'S BREADTH

Being able to buy public policy affects a polity in many ways. It tends to make policy reflect the short term interests of those who can make the purchase at the expense of others. It affects trust levels since even if the policy is aimed at the common good, the citizenry will suspect the motives behind the decisions that generate any policy. Once the belief that policy choices are up for bidding, then the job of governance by those in positions of power will be that more difficult, and reliance on coercive means will tend to become more the mode of ruling. So, with this in mind: What constitutes bribery? And is bribery different from political donations? Some claim the difference is miniscule – a hair's breadth of difference. I want to address this difference in upcoming postings. I want to describe how such a small difference has allowed people of means to have what some describe as undue influence over those who determine public policy. And while there is influence directed by those with money over those with political authority, those who have political authority also engage in practices that at times can exert undue influence over those who make political donations. Here, in this posting, I want to more or less introduce this topic.

Let me begin by stating what to many has become obvious: money, always the lubricant of politics, has become even more of an issue as the gap between the rich and the not so rich has grown over the last several decades or so. Dave Meslin, in a Ted Talks production,1 addresses the belief that citizens of prosperous democracies tend to become selfish, stupid, and lazy. He rejects this belief and points out that the reason many citizens choose to be uninvolved in the political processes of the nation or even of the locality in which they live is because prevailing practices by governments or other political entities set up obstacles to such involvement. He lists seven obstacles and explains them. I want to focus on the second one he mentions and labels “public space.” Here, the point is that in order to be able to engage in meaningful political speech, speech that can compete with speech of those who can purchase large quantities of public space, in the form, for example, of advertising space, one needs a significant number of financial resources. In addition, this obstacle takes the form of having direct access to political decision-makers, in the form of lobbying efforts, which also call for enormous amounts of money. This, in effect, results in regular folks, as they attempt to compete against monied interests, having almost insurmountable disadvantages systemically placed against them.

So, due to this imbalance, a system has evolved in our nation, not by necessarily evil people, but by engaged people who have definite political goals and who also have the use of big bankrolls to pursue those goals. This system entails a definite process, not one of “bribing” public officials, per se, but of well-heeled political participants making political donations to those politicians or political parties that “see” things as they do.

Again, none of this is new. Probably the most famous effort to overcome this obstacle occurred during the Progressive period. During the beginning of the twentieth century, due to the enormous wealth of industrial corporations, public policy developed not to advance the interests of the people, but to almost solely advance that of the monied class – the industrialists. The citizenry became so disgusted that it began electing into office, from local to national, politicians that became known as Progressives. Probably the most famous was the Republican, Theodore Roosevelt, although the Progressives came from both major parties – Democrat Woodrow Wilson was also a Progressive – and from a variety of interest groups. “Yet,” as Lawrence Lessig writes of that time, “one common thread that united these different strands of reform was the recognition that democratic government in America had been captured.”2 Today, as if on cue with the conditions of almost exactly a century ago, we again face the challenge of tackling a form of widespread corruption – a corruption born of a mutual, reciprocating relationship between those with money or access to money and policymakers.

There are differences today. To begin with, the nature of the public space has changed. That change has been the product of technology, as in the case of mass media and social media. As a result, monied interests have far reaching means to get their speech out there. They have the resources to make sure their speech is professionally produced and, as a result, more convincing and effective. And, in addition, we have a degree of banality on two levels: one, a certain enabling by the citizenry that has allowed an economy of dependency between the monied and the politicians to form – perhaps as a result of the changes during the last century – and, two, the nature of the goals many of the monied players seek. That is, they seek to have policy that gives them increased income they cannot attain under market conditions – for example, as in the case of special tax loopholes or subsidies. We call these attempts “seeking rents.”

This corruption – and it is a form of corruption – is mostly legal.3 There is no, for the most part, concrete quid pro quo: something, money, for something else, favorable votes in a legislature, for example. Instead, the system at work operates from understandings between the givers and the receivers. These understandings take the form of, to various degrees, vague expectations and tend to be created, nurtured, and maintained over time. It is a gift economy that has evolved. It is made up of no specific demands, but a relational understanding that is dependent on continued support by policy decisions that are favorable to those who furnish the resources.

All this is usually quite legal. Yes, it is a hair's breadth of difference between this practice and out and out bribery, but it is a difference nonetheless – of significant importance.

2Lessig, L. (2011). Republic lost: How money corrupts Congress – and a plan to stop it. New York, NY: Twelve, Hatchette Book Group. Quotation on p. 5. Many of the ideas in this posting originate with Lessig's work.

3Sometimes it is illegal as some participants have crossed the line. People have gone to prison.