A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Tuesday, December 29, 2015

BORN TO LEAD?

An age old concern with leadership is whether leaders are born or made.  Is it a matter of being born to the right parents genetically or into the right nurturing environment?  My exposure to that literature indicates that there is a bias toward believing they are made.  This has the democratic quality which leads one to believe that anyone can become an effective leader.  A pioneer in the field of transformative leadership, James MacGregor Burns,[1] assumes that whatever the source of the related skills, they center on a perspective leader being able to initiate change through the example of his/her behavior.  And further, that dynamic reflects not an assigned set of behaviors, ones the person can turn on and off depending on the circumstances, but actions emanating from the leader’s personality.  So, whether such a trait is a product of genetic makeup or one that is acquired through training, what a transforming leader has to project is just him/herself.  Through these skills, the leader communicates that he/she is dedicated to enhancing a higher level of motivation and morality.  The leader cannot do this if he/she is “buying” or threatening in order to solicit compliance on the part of the followers.  Burns saw transactional efforts – those based on reward or punishment – as counterproductive given the goals of a transforming leader.

In terms of exemplifying that which is sought after, the leader is promoting an espoused theory openly and definitively.  In cases when a theory-in-use varies from what is espoused – and reality will sooner or later demand some level of variance – a transforming leader is as honest as the situation allows in whatever decisions and actions he/she takes.  But even in these situations, the leader, in order to keep the mantle of a transforming leader, decides and acts in such a way as to advance the interests of the collective, be it a school, some other workplace, a community, or some politically defined jurisdiction.  This form of leadership is, in my opinion, necessary in order to institute a normative-re-educative change strategy.

My only concern with Burns’ argument is that he does not apply a moral test to the aims and goals of a transforming leader.  In his theorizing, he disconnects the methodology of a transforming leader and what he/she is trying to accomplish.  Under Burns’ perspective, Mao Zedong and Martin Luther King both are considered equally effective transforming leaders.  I understand Burns’ thinking on this, but as an advocate of federation theory, I judge Zedong to have been a despicable leader who accomplished some good, was conscientiously motivated but, given the levels of suffering and damage he and his leadership caused, would not be at the pinnacle of transforming leaders.

Picking up the work of Burns was Bernard M. Bass.[2]  He introduced the term transformational to replace transforming (I use each interchangeably).  Bass was concerned with the psychological mechanisms that operate in order to allow transforming leadership to succeed.  Particularly, he introduced a means of measuring this form of leadership.  That is, since transforming leadership relies on the acceptance and reactions of followers (the planned-for), Bass identified a list of indicators of such acceptance.  This included levels of trust, loyalty, admiration, and respect.  Of course, since all of these are not directly observable, being that they are states of mind, one can only speculate as to their existence and strength by what followers say and do.  But usually, these reactions and their accompanying behaviors are the results of followers observing the level of effort and dedication the leader exhibits.  This is beyond what the followers expect.  In addition, the leader not only talks and acts to advance the self-interests of those involved, but also is able to communicate a transcending endgame that has some inspiring and emotional laden accomplishment or mission.  This, in turn, provides an identity to the follower such as I’m a civil rights worker or I’m a union man.  So what might be considered here is a leader who instills an idealized influence which could be observed as charisma.  This is in addition to motivating followers to become intellectually stimulated and to seek, on their own, newer ways of doing things to help guarantee overall success in achieving the change being sought.  Unlike Burns, Bass was willing to accommodate transactional strategies in a transformational effort.

Coming up, I will look in more depth at the various transforming attributes, strategies, and distinguishing characteristics.



[1] Burns, J. M.  (2003).  Transforming leadership.  New York, NY:  Grove Press AND Burns, J. M.  (1978).  Leadership.  New York, NY:  Harper and Row, Publisher.

Friday, December 25, 2015

SOME TRANSFORMING CHARACTER DIMENTIONS

Note:  Merry Christmas everyone!!

As advertised, this posting will continue with my view of transformational leadership.  The purpose is to extend some themes associated with change, such as changing a school’s content in one of its core subject offerings.  This blog has been dedicated to convincing those in charge of choosing the content for civics courses at the secondary level to shift from the use of the natural rights construct to a federation theory construct.  Naturally, a lot has been presented in this blog describing and explaining each of these constructs.  The above introductory remarks (the ones seen above this posting) give an overview of what constitutes the federation theory construct.  The natural rights construct is what currently prevails in our nation’s civics classrooms.  Of late, in order to facilitate the adoption of a federalist approach, I have been addressing some elements of change theory, hoping to assist anyone who is disposed to work toward making this curricular shift.  I have shared some ideas concerning what goes into an individual making choices – a person’s demeanor, mode of political behavior, options, and tenor – and what constitutes the environmental space in which the change is being planned and implemented.  With the last posting, I introduced the last topic I will write about concerning change: that of leadership.

I have already established that in order to be successful in changing an entire orientation in a given subject area, one needs to utilize a change strategy known as normative-re-educative.  This strategy type is geared to changing the normative stance a person holds toward something so that that person adopts a different stance.  Since normative views are made up of attitudes and values – with their accompanying emotions – changing them can be very challenging.  If one takes on the goal of adopting a newer construct for civics, one is probably going to step on some toes in the effort – change of this sort is calling on teachers to change extensively how they see and do their jobs.  For example, a federation theory view of civics is going to challenge some strongly held feelings concerning liberty.  Federation theory, while cherishing liberty, does not hold this value as its trump value.  While the effort would not directly command teachers and their students to give up their beliefs and values concerning liberty, it would present information and situations that would question the prudence of holding liberty as the dominant value.  This might strike teachers and students as frustrating and somehow challenging.  Let me give you a specific example:  should you be forced to pay into health insurance?  By having a national pool of health insurance payers – a pool consisting of all age groups – the price of such insurance for any one person is much less, so much less that everyone can be insured at reasonable prices.  But the question is:  doesn’t a person, under the provisions of liberty, have the right not to pay; not to participate in such a national program?  Isn’t this a liberty issue?  It is these kinds of questions that would be highlighted under a federation theory guided civics lesson.  The point is not that a natural rights guided lesson would avoid such a question; it is a matter that in classes where federation theory is the source of the content, this type of questioning would be more central and occur more often.  Why?  A federation theory guided content would zero in on those commonly held dispositions that people are apt to hold and that are contradictive to federalist values.[1]  And again, this is likely to question not only the beliefs of students, but also those of teachers and administrators as well.

And this takes us back to leadership.  In order to have those involved with such change, a leader has to be knowledgeable enough and talented enough to shepherd such a change toward a successful implementation.  And the trick is, in order to approach such a change, the leader will not be able to simply mandate it.  As a matter of fact, he/she cannot spell out what the change will exactly be.  The leader has to manage a series of phases in which those involved take an active part in the problem identification, planning, testing, implementation, and evaluation of whatever is strategized.  As I indicated in the last posting, the leader is going to have to convince those whom he/she is leading that the change is more prudent, more legitimate, and/or something that will bring each of them closer to those they want to be closer to due to some dimension (such as friendship).  What is called for is transformational leadership.  That is,
… a style of leadership where the leader collaborates with employees to identify the needed change, creating a vision to guide the change through inspiration, and executing the change in tandem with committed members of the group.[2]
In order to pull off this type of leadership, there are certain mechanisms.

These mechanisms are many and varied.  A trained change agent is familiar with them.  Most schools, though, cannot afford the services of a change agent, but even if they could, a corps of teachers, those perhaps with graduate degrees and a rudimentary understanding of change theory and techniques, could provide the necessary leadership.  Most high schools these days have an assistant principal in charge of curriculum; this person would also be key to any extensive curricular change effort.  But leading all of this is, of course, the principal.  Ideally, among those who identify the need for this type of change, would be the principal.  That person, more than any other, sets the tone for the school.  This is true regardless of how gifted or ungifted the person is.  These blog entries addressing change are geared toward teachers and parents, but any of these identified personnel, I believe, can benefit from understanding this subject matter.

Let me end this posting with an overview of the mechanism change that leaders can adopt in ushering in the type of change proposed.  One, a change worker (referred to earlier in this blog as the planner) would benefit from getting those who are to change (referred to earlier in this blog as the planned-for) to make the proposed change as an extension of their identity and self.  In my proposed change, that would entail the planned-for to see and feel federalist ideals as their espoused theory and a theory they want to implement in how they act – their theory-in-use.  And this identity factor is not contained within the individuals, but becomes a collective identity of the school – “we are a federalist school.”  Two, the leader is a role model for change and encourages the other planners to be role models also.  He/she and other planners live out federalist ideals.  This includes such personality traits as being inclusive, open to dialogue and collaboration, and an infectious spirit of unity that he/she can infuse among the planners and planned-for.  Three, the leader should have the ability to instill ownership of what is being attempted and what has been accomplished – both of the positive and negative.  Such a leader is a transformational leader and one that can at least have a shot at instituting a federalist posture in his/her school.




[1] You might question how a mandated national health program reflects a federalist issue.  I hold that health care, given its relation to survival concerns at the individual level, reflects an inequality of opportunity reality.  If a portion of the population is deprived of a basic, survival service, those who belong to that segment of the population are being deprived of enjoying a basic element of opportunity to live a reasonable, secure life in a society that is wealthy enough to provide it.

Tuesday, December 22, 2015

DO AS I AM

I want to continue my look at change theory with one more related issue: leadership.  As I indicated a while back, to institute the type of curricular change I have been advocating in this blog – that is, changing the content of our civics instruction from one guided by the natural rights construct to one guided by liberated federalism – the needed type of strategy to institute that change would be the normative-re-educative type.  A strategy that would fall under this type would be one that seeks to not only solicit outward compliance to some change mandate, but also would further strive to have those involved willing to participate in the planning and implementation of that change.  If one is after a profound change that is pervasive in its effects, then one needs to get at not only the related behaviors, but also the related knowledge, attitudes, norms, and values.  This level of change encompasses not only changed procedures, but changed procedures over time and therefore demands those involved to see and feel differently.  Serious change has the knack of bringing up emotional challenges and if one is expected to adopt another way of doing something, in order to have the necessary discipline to adopt a new way, one has to want to do it.  The change, therefore, is transformational – as opposed to transactional change.

If you are unfamiliar with this distinction, let me describe it.  When one does something at the behest of someone else in anticipation that one is to be rewarded or relieved of some punishment by so acting, we are talking about transactional change, a tit-for-tat arrangement or an “I’ll scratch your back if you scratch mine” agreement.  If we apply the concept of power to these types of changes, this relates to, in the first case, reward power or, in the second case, coercive power.  Each of these, in turn, has corresponding types of change strategies:  reward relates to empirical-rational strategies and coercion relates to power-coercive strategies (I’ve written of these in previous postings).  For most changes, one of these can fit the bill.  But most changes are not extensive; most take on a style that usually can be voiced as “wouldn’t it be better to do this before that” or something along those lines.  But from time to time, an organization will want to initiate a new way that something important is done; for example, teaching a civics content that has different priorities and moral perspective from what has been taught to date.  You can try to reward people to teach a different content or you might try to threaten some punishment if they don’t teach this other content, but if you want a teacher who is believable in what he/she teaches and is motivated to do a good job, then you need one who believes in what he/she is teaching.  Further, if that teacher and the other teachers involved with the shift in content are not of that frame of mind initially, then you are attempting transformational change – change that gets not only at behavior, but also at this level of priorities and motivations the new way entails.  One, then, is concerned with the normative aspects of how the person views the process, aims, and goals of the endeavor.

Now what convinces a person to want to change?  There are a few categories of such motivating forces.  These occur when, one, a person perceives the change as morally or otherwise legitimate; two, a person perceives the change as prudent – the more intelligent thing to do; or three, a person perceives the change as soliciting the positive response from someone with whom that person wants to be associated.  This last category can be motivated by love, friendship, envy, loyalty, or any emotion that leads the person to establish or maintain a close relationship with the targeted subject.


For each type of change, transactional based on reward power, transactional based on coercion, or transformational, one needs a different style of leadership.  In the upcoming postings, I want to address transformational leadership.  I will attempt to share ideas concerning its elements and attributes.  But to give you a sense of what is to come, let me just mention a couple of reputed transformational leaders as examples from our history:  FDR and Martin Luther King.

Friday, December 18, 2015

ADDRESSING A REFUGEE PROBLEM

In the last posting, I left you with an assignment.  I suggested a situation in which you are teaching in a school that has been designated to accept a number of Syrian refugee students.  Now this has not happened, to my knowledge, but it can happen in the future.  Why a particular school district and school is chosen for such a designation is beyond the concerns of the assignment, but let us say the school is noted for being located in a tolerant and liberal community.  Yet the situation, as I presented it, does pose a challenge.  Before addressing the problem directly, let me focus on a few factors that are contained in the situation as I presented it, but need further emphasis.

One important factor in this scenario that bears special note is that the change I described is not emanating from an in-house observation of a problem.  The change is coming from the district and reflects an up-down decision.  Perhaps the district has been ordered to accept the refugee children by state authorities, but that in itself is not relevant to the conditions the school community faces.  The point is that the school has been given this challenge by legally designated authorities and whether such authority should or should not be able to issue such mandates is a subject for another posting.  Before you dismiss this factor as something I am making up, I will tell you that all of the major change efforts I experienced in a twenty-five year teaching career came from the district – some originated at the district level; some originated from the state.  So, for purposes of this assignment, let us accept that the school is going to get the refugees and now it is up to the school personnel to make the best of it.

As I described the situation, one can assume the principal is disposed to be inclusive in her decision-making.  She called the teacher-parent meeting in order to hear from the community.  The meeting, she feels, also allows members of the community to have some say – or, at least, feel they have some say.  It is at that meeting when a parent stood up and voiced the following (paraphrased):  who is doing all the bombing?  It’s not the Christians; it’s not the Jews.  It’s the Muslims.  Then the man looked at the assembled group and asked: did you get that, sport?  In what he said, one could easily see that he was speaking for a sizable minority of the audience as they, in turn, voiced, loudly, their approval not only for the content of his concern, but for the tone in which he voiced it.  There is “attitude” behind this objection.

Your assignment, if you chose to accept it, was to recommend to the principal what she should do next.  In doing so, I invited you to apply the change strategy elements I have described and explained over the last series of postings.  I didn’t expect you to sit down and write the principal an email, but perhaps you could have given this challenge some thought.  I promised that I would, in this posting, give you my take on this situation – here goes.

First, the situation to this point calls for defining and thinking of what I, as a teacher, and possibly the principal, don’t know.  For example, are these new students going to be here for a transition period or are they to become a regular part of the student body?  What are the language requirements of these refugees?  What is the employability status of these children’s parents?  What are their living accommodations?  In other words, what is the scope of the challenge before this school and community?  Then there is the extent of the opposition.  Does the voiced opposition represent negative beliefs in the community or is it contained within the group who showed up to the meeting?  How deep-seated are these misgivings and how apt are those who harbor negative feelings willing to act on them?  In other words, while these negative notions reflect an espoused theory, is it strong enough to generate an active theory-in-use?  And if it is that strong, how much congruence will there be between their espoused theory and their theory-in-use?  Are there within these people, contradicting espoused theories?  Are their assumptions firmly imbedded in their beliefs?  There is obviously a need to talk with those members of the community who are put out by the idea of accepting these students.

Now this is not an exhaustive list of things to consider, concerning this situation.  What I am presenting is a notion of how the factors of successful change can be used.  What I just described relates to the environmental factors of the situation; there is also the individual level concerns.  Let me add some questions that can be asked of the individuals involved, both in the community and in the staff.  By the way, one should not assume that everyone on staff is on board with this change.  A lot of what the principal needs to deal with will be obstacles presented by staff members.  An important difference with this latter group is that due to their employment status, these individuals might not be so open and honest about their feelings, but can be even more undermining of an attempt to implement a successful strategy.

Of course, when knowing about those with whom you work, this comes in handy.  That knowledge, on the part of an administrator, should be one he/she actively seeks on an ongoing basis.  For a school principal, this is not only a concern for those who work under his/her authority, but also for the leaders of the community.  Why?  So when a challenge as the one I am posing arises, and they do, the principal and the other administrators don’t have to start from scratch.  All schools, like any social entity, have to accommodate change.  This often calls on affected people changing their behavior and that usually means, at least to some minimal degree, changes in their beliefs, feelings, attitudes, and values.  So, a smart administrator seeks these types of information about those he/she is in charge of and those with whom he/she has to interact.  Hopefully, that is the case of our principal.  Be that as it may, here are some questions she might ask of those involved:
·        Does this person exhibit a reaction to problems which can be described as being idealistic, realistic, or visceral?
·        Does the person tend to maintain an even keel over problematic situations or does he/she tend to become emotional?  (Of course, this is a matter of degree, so the principal might want to gauge this observation.)
·        Does this person tend to be demanding of the school and its staff or does he/she offer support for what the school is doing?  (Again, this is a matter of degree.)
·        In the choices to act, does this person see his/her self-interests in a short term perspective or take more of a long term perspective?  And are those interests sought after by acting in isolation or is the person an organizer or joiner of collective action?
·        What tenor does this person adopt in expressing his/her knowledge, attitudes, values, plans?  That is, does this person offer an authoritative, a reasonable, or an overemotional tenor?
And, in terms of this particular situation:
·        For those agreeing with the protesting parent:  how truly are the expressed objections to the refugee children a concern over safety issues (bombings and killings) or how much are they a reflection of cultural biases against this particular minority?

With clear answers to these questions, our principal can go about devising a strategy.  Given the long-term nature of the situation – these students are going to be around for a long time – this principal would be wise to have good information regarding these factors.  This might prove difficult, but the more information she can acquire, the better off she will be in meeting this challenge.  She would also be assisted if she could count on a supportive faculty and other staff members who are equally prone to being subjected to the factors these questions reflect.  One last thing, in all of this: our principal would be well-served in being as honest in what she is doing as possible.  And this is my take on the assignment.

Tuesday, December 15, 2015

A SHORT ASSIGNMENT

We all, from time to time, say something we don’t really mean.  Perhaps someone does something or says something that ticks us off or maybe makes us exceptionally happy and we blurt out some words that are an overreaction to the occasion.  I’ve been there; not often, but I have had my moments.  There have been, of late, certain events that have made most of us angry, perhaps a bit scared, disgusted, sad, and a host of other emotions.  Of course, I am referring to the terrorist attacks both in Paris and here in San Bernardino, California.  Rightly so, the media has dedicated quite a bit of air time and print to report and comment on these attacks.  Currently, the President’s poll numbers have taken a hit.  One is taken with how sorrowful these events are.  Part of the news coverage has tried to report some of this emotional response.  People have been asked the “how does this make you feel” question.  One particular response to this type of question has stuck with me.  It was from a middle aged man; he looked as if he was either in a suburban or rural area.  He had an accent, but I was not able to place it.  It was American, but I’m not sure from which area of the country.  This is what he had to say (paraphrased):  who is doing all the bombing?  It’s not the Christians; it’s not the Jews.  It’s the Muslims.  Then the man looked into the camera and asked: did you get that, sport?


I have been, in this blog, reviewing some ideas about change.  I have an assignment for you, if you want to take part.  Apply what I have had to share concerning change to a change project.  Let us say that you are working in a school that has agreed to accept a certain number of Syrian refugees.  This has not been universally accepted in the school’s community.  The principal, in trying to ease the process and before the youngsters arrive, calls a teacher-parent meeting in the school’s auditorium.  The principal, after a few introductory remarks, opens the proceedings up to questions.  Hands are raised and the first parent called upon says what the above man said.  As he expresses his opinion, others – not all, but a significant number – audibly express approval of what the recognized parent is saying.  Assuming that these sentiments are shared by a sizable minority of the parents, analyze the situation and make recommendations to the principal as to how he/she should react to the challenge this response represents.  I will, in my next posting, give you my take.

Friday, December 11, 2015

THE IDEAL SELF, THE PRACTICAL SELF, AND OTHER GUY

I have of late been reviewing some ideas concerning change theory.  My reason for this has been to address the challenge of introducing and having schools adopt federation theory as the source of content in their civics’ classrooms.  You are invited to take a look at the last ten postings or so in which I have looked at change from the perspective of the individual and, more recently, from the vantage point of a change environment.  As I have ventured into the dynamics of change, I have looked at how the individual, a change operator, relates to that environment.  I have written about how those involved with change are motivated by what they want to accomplish – espoused theory – and how, once such a theory is formulated to any degree, they will go about developing a theory-in-use which describes and explains how the sought-after change is to be accomplished.  Together, espoused theories and theories-in-use are known as action theories. 

Action theories are what those who want to implement change hold to guide their behavior.  To the extent the individual is able to instigate change, he/she creates a behavioral world – the environment in which the efforts of change occur.  In this posting, I want to address three realms within that environment:  one, the realm in which the theory-in-use is applied, two, the perceived behavioral world the change actor creates, and three, the ongoing dynamic environment perceived by others.  These realms are what the change operator deals with as he/she attempts to accomplish his/her goal(s).

In previous postings, I have described how Chris Argyris and Donald A. Shon[1] advise us that, in order to promote successful change, one should have consistency within a particular action theory and congruence between an espoused theory and a theory-in-use when attempting to implement change.  This is difficult, and I address incongruence between an espoused theory and a theory-in-use below.  Now, I want to draw your attention to the interaction between the identified realms above. 

To do this, let me first quote Argyris and Shon:
Theories of action are theories that can be expressed as follows:  In situation S, if you intend consequence C, do A, given assumptions a1 . . . an .  Theories of action exist as espoused theories and as theories-in-use, which govern actual behavior.
A person who is trying to institute change does not get to that point spontaneously.  He/she first sees and/or feels that something needs changing.  In this blog, I, for example, have argued that federation theory should replace the natural rights construct as the predominate source of content for our civics curriculum.  That statement emanates from an espoused theory I harbor in my mind.  It motivates me to think:  how does that change in curriculum happen?  As in most cases in which change depends on public policy, there has to be a certain amount of public support.  There are other things that have to happen, but let me limit my comments to the function of action theories.  In order to proceed toward accomplishing this aim, I need a strategy.  That strategy needs to account for the practical realities – as I see them – in the environment.  These, even in the simplest and most modest occasions, are probably many and complex.  I recently, in this blog described how a family wants to improve its relationship with the maternal grandfather and how complex that sort of change can be. 

Therefore, a new theory develops and, at minimum, outlines a strategy in order to accomplish what I want to achieve.  As Argyris and Shon denote above, I develop a theory-in-use which contains my strategy.  There are times when perceived realities force or, at least, encourage a devised theory-in-use to diverge from an espoused theory.  I described this eventuality, in a previous posting, as “sinning.”  I used this term to point out that the individual who does diverge in this way is betraying what he/she has espoused as his/her beliefs.  The word hypocrisy comes to mind, but practicalities cannot be dismissed so easily.  To accomplish any level of success, one might need to compromise on the demands of an espoused theory.  But one should be warned that he/she who diverges from stated beliefs must face consequences either in terms of falling short of initial goals or sacrificing some aspect of what motivated the relevant change behavior in the first place.

Let me return to the above, identified realms.  Overt behaviors reflect, first of all, the first realm:  application of a theory-in-use.  In my example, my theory-in-use called for me to identify a platform by which I could communicate – espouse – my theory of what I believe should change in terms of civics curriculum.  That theory identifies writing a blog as a behavior I can carry out which would communicate a rationale and a promotion for what my espoused theory holds as something worthwhile.  The assumptions include that public policy, which includes our public schools’ curricular choices, is encouraged by public support for a particular policy choice.  But part of my theory-in-use has little to do with this public-spirited, espoused theory.  In addition, it has to do with my having an interesting and entertaining pastime in my retirement years.  That part of the theory is backed up by another espoused theory, one that promotes a healthy approach to retirement.  The point is that in order to be successful, one needs to have sufficient consistency within theories of action and congruence among the theories that are relevant to a particular change effort.  I am not making unwarranted claims here; I understand that success relies on talent, resources, and timing, but essential to any change effort is clear thinking and motivations guiding that effort. 

Experiences, as one goes about implementing a theory-in-use, generate evaluative information which, in turn, communicates to oneself how the espoused theory and the theory-in-use functions in the real world.  But in reality, when one judges the effects of implementing theory, one needs to remember that that judgement is one’s perception of that reality.  That is the second realm I identify above.  Often, when change is attempted, those involved fail to hold their perceptions, attitudes, and even values in a sufficiently critical perspective.  In the second realm above, the one in which the change operator functions, he/she needs to be able to objectify what he or she sees, hears and otherwise senses is happening.  Self-criticism in this effort is a skill which a change operator should seriously develop.

The last realm in a change environment is the social dynamic that ensues once the change process begins.  These social interactions occur for the change operator within his/her behavioral world.  This realm opens up an entire other set of factors which affect how successful the change effort will be.  For example, if I am a civics teacher in a school and become sold on the idea (i.e., it becomes part of my espoused theory) to adopt federation theory as my source for content, I would probably begin using federalist content under the overall structure used in my school’s civics curriculum.  This might compromise the “purity” of that content, but it would be a way of easing its adoption.  Up to this point, the important “others’ perspectives” I would be concerned with those views of my students, their parents, and possibly school site administrators overseeing the curricular issues of the school.  Their feedback – which reflect their perceptions – would provide me important information about the change I am implementing.  If some minimum level of success is met which is enough to convince me that my effort is worthwhile, I might deem it wise to attempt to broaden my effort and convince other civics teachers to join me.  This would broaden those perceptions that become essential sources of information in assisting my efforts.  Again, I would be well-served to remember that that information reflects perceived reality, not necessarily the complete reality.  Each participant brings his/her own demeanors, filters, modes, options, and tenor.  Each is a participant reflecting complex factors that will affect how he/she interacts with the change process and its demands.

For a teacher so motivated, this can be both exciting and frustrating.  One obstacle to change is expectations.  Students who enter a course have preconceived notions as to what the course is about.  Not meeting those expectations, especially when changes are associated with challenging tasks, can be questioned in terms of the effort’s legitimacy.  Therefore, the perceptions of others become very important.  Pre-explanations and a bit of selling might be needed.  One should not shy from such preparations.  If nothing else, having to explain yourself to others aids in grasping the substance of one’s change effort in a more thorough way.



[1] Argyris, C. and Schon, D. A. (1985). Evaluating theories in action. In W. G. Bennis, K. D. Benne, and R. Chin (Eds.), The planning of change, Fourth edition, (pp. 108-117). New York, NY: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.

Tuesday, December 8, 2015

PROBLEMS WITH TESTING THEORIES

I try to have each of the postings of this blog stand alone, but I am making an exception with this one.  This posting will refer to the previous one, Here We Go Loopty-Loop.  In that posting, I used a made up anecdotal story about Jane’s family in which the relations between the family and Jane’s parents are somewhat strained.  Jane, the mother in our family, has taken it upon herself to bolster that relationship and has chosen to begin a change process by calling a family “kitchen table” meeting in which the family, together, can come up with a plan to achieve the aforementioned aim.  I am using this narrative to illustrate some organizational change principles in a simplified setting because I want you to gather, at the least, some appreciation of what is called for if our school districts were to adopt a new curricular approach to civics education.  This blog is dedicated to advancing a different perspective to civics, a perspective I have entitled federation theory.  By using a simpler environment, because a family involves significantly fewer participants, I hope to make the change principles more understandable.

I am advocating, much in the spirit of federation theory, a change strategy that falls under a more general strategy type called normative-re-educative strategies.  In this type, there is less than total reliance on either rational argument (although rational arguments can be utilized) or coercive measures (although in portions of a strategy, limited coercive measures might be needed).  Instead, the overall aim of normative-re-educative strategies is to change not only what change subjects know, but also what these subjects feel and possibly what they hold as their related values, norms, and emotions.  Such a change goes beyond changing processes and, possibly, structures.  Not only are we talking about a change of mind, but a change of heart.


To date, in my review of change theory, I have introduced the terminology of Chris Argyris and Donald A. Shon[1] which includes the following:  theories of action, theories-in-use, espoused theories, single loop learning, double loop learning, and governing variables.  You are invited to go back and take a look at the last few postings as I introduced these terms and defined them.[2]  But for this posting, I want to continue with the general concern of the way one finds out how effective a particular theory-in-use is.  In the last posting, I introduced the procedural stage of testing a theory.  Testing is what one can do to see if a theory, or more likely a part of a theory, is confirmed or disconfirmed; whether the theory leads to desired change or not.

In reviewing testing, I will define some of these terms again, perhaps giving those definitions a slightly different emphasis.  Starting with theories of action, which includes both espoused theories and theories-in-use, I remind you that they are mental representations of what a person, desiring change, holds as what should be done or what will be done.  In terms of desiring change, these theories are formulated so that the person seeking the change can gain control.  We have comparable theories when building a bridge, treating mental illness, applying a new technique in growing crops, or in any planned change endeavor.  In each case, testing theories are prudent and are generally part of the change process. 

In my anecdote, I have Jane test her theory of action by calling that meeting.  When more formal organizations attempt change, they test theories by using more formal means.  In effect, what is being tested is the predictive power of the theory or theories.  But the entire process of testing is plagued with problems and being aware of them, the tester(s) can account for them and possibly handle any deleterious consequences which would result from any deficiencies in testing.  Right away, there are three types of problems when dealing with testing theories that are aimed at normative change.

The first problem occurs when one is dealing with the feelings of people – when feelings affect what one wants to believe about the participants of the change – this will have consequences as the social dynamics unfold.  Let me illustrate.  In our family example, the kids have formed fairly established view of the type of man their maternal grandfather is.  To them, he is a relic of some highly disciplined, unyielding past with a serious lack of human concern.  This is demonstrated by the mean comments he spouts from time to time as he criticizes just about everything they do.  They belittle the older man behind his back and generally treat him with guarded tolerance and little to no warmth.  This adds to the grandfather’s view of the family and further antagonizes them although he tries to express some affection.  What we have are self- fulfilling prophecy dynamics going in both directions.  One way is bad enough – as when a teacher believes his/her students are stupid and treats them accordingly and they respond in kind. But when the cycle operates in both directions, testing becomes very challenging.

There is also a problem with testing in general in that it calls on opposite emotional postures.  On the one hand, to be successful under many change challenges (or any challenge, for that matter), a subject is well served by being decisive, committed, and confident.  But under testing conditions, one needs to be experimental, skeptical, and critical.  This is a bit of a paradox that plagues just about any environment in which theories of action is being tested.

A third concern occurs when one is testing a value.  Remember, what one is after when proposing changes in curricular content is changes in values.  The question becomes:  how do you test a value?  For example, how do you test the value, as a value,  of grandparents being revered? 

Let me address each of these problems and I will start with this last problem of testing a value.  Of course, one cannot test a value directly.  Whether one values something or not is not a testable sort of statement.  I value love or trust or loyalty or honesty; how does one even think of testing any one of these notions?  Either you hold a value to any degree or you don’t.  Perhaps you value dishonesty.  If you do, one can only speculate as to the consequences of acting on such a value, not on the value itself – it just doesn’t make sense to do so or even try to do so.  What one can do, though, is to look at those consequences and state such a connection with an if/then proposition.  I believe, along with Argyris and Schon, that seeing the testing of value propositions from this approach provides some sort of test.  For example, I could value talking out disagreements – let’s say between grandparent and grandchild.  If so, one can ask why and propose an answer.  If we talk out our disagreements, then we can discover areas of agreement and, in turn, have a basis for building cooperation or caring or a basis for further talk that can lead to a plan for fostering reconciliation.  What happens is that assumptions upon which disagreements were based can come out or be made explicit.  Better still, if what is being highlighted by the if/then statement refers to a norm, then over time the questionable norm can begin to be addressed.  Any norm which is institutionalized will not be given up readily.  Instead, by testing, one begins a process in which the norm is challenged.  A norm, such as the accepted notion that grandfather is a seriously flawed individual, can be identified, considered, tested, and reevaluated.  It, in short, can be tested over time.  There is always the possibility that the norm or judgement proves unyielding to review and that trying to avoid its veracity is causing problems within the family.  Then other opposing norms and values might come into play (e.g., it is good to have stable relations within the immediate family to have a peaceful homestead); then another test might have to be made.  If attempts to generate warmer relations with granddad are pursued, then disruptive and divisive interactions in the family will result.  In turn, this might lead to testing the congruence between espoused theory and theory-in-use or testing the consistency within an espoused theory or within a theory-in-use might be necessary.  These kinds of testing are long-term and are not accomplished so readily after one or two incidences of testing.

In testing theories, the next problem, self-fulling prophecy problem, can and often does arise.  Again, this occurs when a tester holds some judgement about another participant and because of it can see only evidence that confirms that judgement.  The person who sees others in a certain, unquestionable way and is unable to cast a critical eye on a resulting judgement is said to have a “self-sealing” perspective.  This demands a change in the theory that person holds and this will more likely call on some outside force or event to bring an unavoidable view of the judgement as being an erroneous conclusion.  Let’s take the grand kids’ view of their grandfather.  It is based on a great deal of interaction with the older man.  Remember, their relationship with their paternal grandparents is very positive, but not so with their maternal grandparents, especially mom’s dad.  What if they were “forced” to see this man from the perspective of his professional life (I established in the story that both maternal grandparents are highly respected professionals in their respected fields)?  Perhaps the kids could come face to face with the people gramps has helped through his career and are exposed to the warmth and appreciation they feel for him?  Would this be of such a nature that the grandkids might start questioning their own negative feelings toward him?  Perhaps so.  This outside “force” might cause their theory-in-use to fail, at least in how it pertains to gramps.  The event providing this force is political in that it forces the kids to give up repressing information about their grandfather – to see another side of the older man.  Repressed information does not occur from some sinister agent; it just evolves from experiences.  To undo them, though, usually takes a concerted effort by some third party – perhaps mom in our story.  Again, we are talking about time consuming processes and in the case of some professional organization, the efforts of trained and skilled change agents or administrators are then likely needed.

The last problem addressed in this posting has to do with the opposing postures change testing involves:  between the need to be psychologically certain about what one is doing and the intellectual demand for uncertainty when it comes to testing.  This problem is heightened if the change environment is unstable – e.g., what if in our story mom and dad were having marital problems?  In such situations, the participants can be overwhelmed with information.  The participants would then cease to be guided by information, but instead make decisions based on norms – often non-reflected ones.  Norms provide a sense of certainty when certainty is seriously lacking.  At such times, though difficult, one needs to make norms hypothetical.  That is, if one can see that under current conditions one is not succeeding, one might begin to question the norms that in turn are providing support for a theory in action.  At these times, the participant has to see that the here-and-now, sustained problem(s), is more important than the theory.  He/she has to buy into the notion that things are not working out.  The challenge is to sharpen one’s view of reality and identify how that reality is counter to some or all of the elements in the theory-in-use.  If placing what is currently real as a priority is successful done, then one is free to test and have less need to have here-and-now certainty.  This is a daunting challenge indeed and one that probably demands professional change agent assistance if the organization is of any size and complexity.  Even some family situations might call for professional therapy to meet this demand.

These are but some of the problems change agents encounter, especially during the testing phases of the change process.  Participants in change have to develop functional theories – either in terms of what they want to occur or in how they go about getting it.  Effectiveness means control, and control leads to planned change.



[1] Argyris, C. and Schon, D. A. (1985). Evaluating theories in action. In W. G. Bennis, K. D. Benne, and R. Chin (Eds.), The planning of change, Fourth edition, (pp. 108-117). New York, NY: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.

[2] A good Internet site that reviews the work of Chris Argyris and provides definitions for these terms is provided by Infed.  See http://infed.org/mobi/chris-argyris-theories-of-action-double-loop-learning-and-organizational-learning/ .