A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Tuesday, October 25, 2016

STEPS OF ADAPTIVE CHANGE

In my last posting, I wrote about the contributions of Jim Collins and Tom Peters to the literature of organizational leadership and change.  In this posting, I want to comment on the work of Ronald Heifetz.[1]  Along with Collins, he downplays the centrality that people tend to bestow on leaders and likes to point out that organizations are collectives and hopefully communities that are dedicated to perform and accomplish certain goals and aims.
          The immediate question many ask is whether or not businesses can afford democracy – collective decision-making – when the chips are down; when the organization is facing an important challenge.  Can a CEO take the time to solicit from those down the ranks what they think should be done?  Well, several things can be said about this. 
First, crises are usually – not always – the product of poor decisions in the past.  The reason matters get so bad as to demand quick action is that some or many adverse conditions were not taken care of in the past.  Smart thinking is geared toward, as much as possible, taking care of those conditions needing care in a timely manner.
          And that calls for many actions to occur.  Adding to the challenge of this process is that reality is becoming more and more complex.  So, gathering good information is essential.  And where does that information lie?  Well, when it comes to large organizations or communities or a society, that information is often in lower ranks or on the streets or in households.
To get at that information, those who have it need to feel trust in the system and in the leadership before they divulge it.  Trust emerges, in part, from feelings of ownership or partnership in what is going on.  This takes time and experiences that reasonably justify trust, especially if one is considering important elements of one’s life and, in turn, one’s livelihood.
          This view is counter to the one that leaders fulfill a paternalistic role; that they are there to satisfy needs and demands that people generally want someone to fix.  On the other hand, Heifetz calls for a rank and file that is disposed to wanting to tackle the problems and take a legitimate role in addressing what is confronting the collective.
And the leader?  He or she creates the environment within the collective that gets people – employees or citizens – to think and feel in those ways that encourage confidence in themselves and others.  In turn, that calls, at a minimum, for leadership to establish an environment of trust.
          Of course, nothing brings these issues to the fore more than change, especially profound change.  Heifetz makes a distinction between technical change and adaptive change.  Technical changes are those tweaks to the organization’s processes or structures that meet some shortcoming(s).  This type of change is ongoing and normal. 
What he is more interested in is adaptive change which some might call transformative change.  This type is more fundamental to how the organization sees itself and how it performs.  It generally calls for the participants to redefine themselves within the organization or how they see it.  This is difficult and time-consuming.
          Heifetz suggests a series of steps by which adaptive change occurs.  These steps have a dual purpose:  fix the problem(s) and get a workforce or citizenry to mobilize in having the changes devised and implemented.  This approach goes beyond influential leadership to a higher level of commitment on the part of leadership and follow-ship.
          The first step is identifying the challenge or problem.  Heifetz uses the term diagnosis which communicates a more thorough analysis of the component parts of the problem(s).  This calls for that in-depth search that depends on good information channels across the system.  It calls for truth-telling which can be painful, fearful, and threatening.  This occurs when the environment of trust can be indispensable.
          The second step recognizes that no matter how trustful an environment is, if the challenge calls for adaptive change, there will be stress.  This second step calls for stress management, which turns out to be a balancing act when leadership informs participants of the profundity of change, but paces it so that the system has the time and space to adjust to the changes.  In this way, those who are affected can control the stress levels that would otherwise negatively affect performance and be counterproductive.
          Third, in addition to stress – or because of it – people tend to be distracted.  Therefore, the third calls for leaders to direct participants to remain or establish a focused attention on what the change is demanding.  If workers or citizens are being asked to act differently, to acquire the new understandings and skills the changes demand, leaders will probably call for participants to be focused and to avoid distractions.
          The fourth step is for participants, in a timely way, to take on more ownership over what is being instituted.  This calls for them, in a reasonable fashion, to take on more responsibility in working out the details that the change is demanding.  This occurs when the creativity of the participants can be very important and should be encouraged.
          And to understand the fifth step, Heifetz points out a distinction; that is, in any organized arrangement, there are those who have authoritative leadership status and those who have unauthoritative leadership status.  Those with authority should protect the voices of leaders who do not have authoritative positions.  They might be the critics or supporters of what is going on, but in either case, they can provide useful input as to what is happening and what they see will be the consequences.
          Throughout this, one can detect that the leader’s main function is to create the correct environment so that the organization can get through the change successfully and be healthier at the end of the process.  As indicated, much of it entails either creating an arena or a square.
An arena – as is the case in boxing – is antagonistic and takes on the air of a zero-sum game.  One participant wins and another loses.  A square – as in a town square – promotes the image of win-win results; decisions are made in the spirit that everyone will advance his/her ultimate interests by implementing those decisions.
          Arenas encourage distrust and squares encourage trust.  One can readily see that emotions are just as or more important than any detached results analysis might discover.  These changes reflect human endeavors and human ambitions and welfare.  They are serious turns in people’s lives.



[1] Ronald Heifetz, Leadership without Easy Answers, (Cambridge, MA:  Harvard University Press, 1998).

Friday, October 21, 2016

HOW WAS THE CHICKEN?

Last night, at the Al Smith Dinner in New York, there were the two candidates for president at what traditionally has been a chance for such candidates to display their more humorous sides.  It is a competition between which side can muster up better joke writers.  It is to be a light-hearted evening.  Both candidates last night acted as if they had not gotten the memo as to the purpose of the gathering, although both admitted that they had been to prior Al Smith Dinners.
          One of the two candidates, although he began his remarks in the intended spirit, devolved into the same strident tone he exhibited in the last debate, just the night before, between the two.  The other sustained a more jovial presentation but did push her candidacy, which was not the purpose.
The usual tenor at this event is to be self-deprecating and to needle the other candidate with good natured quips.  Last night, one candidate, in trying to be self-deprecating, was more deprecating of his wife.  The other did make certain self-deprecating remarks, but nothing too profound.  She made, for example, a reference to her “deplorable” comment of some weeks ago, a comment she indicated was unfortunate.
          In short, he, Donald Trump, and she, Hillary Clinton, were worth seeing, but they did not exemplify what a “good” Al Smith Dinner is supposed to be.  For that, see the Obama-McCain or the Obama-Romney version – they were just right.  But what was more revealing last night were the opposing leadership styles each candidate exhibited.  In that, they demonstrated clashing approaches of leadership.
          The Republican candidate provides an example of the charismatic style for those who follow him and the Democratic candidate more of the low profile, humble appearing style.  I write “appearing” because in both cases, one is dealing with individuals who have had celebrity status for a long time.  As such, they have had ample opportunity to craft a style they want to portray to the public.
Therefore, one cannot be sure in either case whether what one sees is what one will get.  A person would have had to work for one of these candidates to know how he/she is when the pressure builds.  What does each fall back on when the pressure is on?  This is important because the job they are after will have a boat load of pressure.
          Let’s suppose that what one sees is what one will get come January 20th.  Based on those appearances, which is best:  a charismatic leader or a low profile, “humble” leader?  According to Michael A. Roberto,[1] there seems to be some disagreement between two gurus of organizational theory and research.  There are Jim Collins[2] and Thomas J. Peters who propose somewhat opposing opinions on this score.
          Collins sides with the low profile, humble approach.  Peters does not so much favor the charismatic approach as he prefers matching the leader and his/her dispositions to the demands of the organization at a given time.
Roberto gives the example of Rudy Giuliani, the former mayor of New York City (he was at the dinner last night scowling at Clinton and her unflattering reference to him).  When Giuliani took office, the city was suffering from high crime rates and other ailments.  He “righted the ship” and consequently enjoyed high approval ratings.  He was easily reelected.
          Then there was his second term and he tried to impose more “conservative” policies – policies that many believed were detrimental to minority populations – and his popularity plummeted.  But all that changed with the 9/11 attacks where he took charge, was highly visible and relatively transparent.  He again upped his approval ratings and left office on a high note.
          Giuliani’s example is good in that it demonstrates how, based on one person’s experience, a single personality is good in certain situations and not so good in others.  Apparently, Giuliani was good when things were extremely demanding, but lacking when things were moving along more normally.  As such, his tale seems to support Peters’ argument.
What is wrong with the Giuliani example is that it reflects a very unusual set of circumstances.  Most leaders will not be called upon to handle such extreme conditions.  So, the mayor’s effectiveness seemed to spike when the city was experiencing very difficult challenges.
          On the other hand, Collin’s argument is derived from his study about how various business enterprises that were doing poorly to mediocrely were transformed to becoming top profit-making entities – “good to great.”  In terms of leadership, he found that these companies were led by low profile, humble leaders.  These were not companies that at the time were facing drastic futures; they were not about to go bankrupt.  So, their conditions were not so imminently catastrophic.
          These more “normal” situations seem to relate to what Giuliani faced during most of his second term.  Yes, there were challenges, but established, on-going processes and policies were able to meet the demands of the day.  They could stand to improve, but that process of improvement could be more deliberate and thought out.
Although it should be pointed out that one reason Giuliani was so successful during the 9/11 attacks is that, based on an earlier attack on the World Trade Center, he had instituted appropriate planning and training to meet the challenges of another attack.  He personally supervised these efforts as they were given high priority.
          There is more that goes into successful leadership than personality traits; good sense, knowledge, temperament (which is more than just how flamboyant one is), and a host of other traits. 
I will also add that both Collins and Peters write about leaders who implement, if needed, and sustain more horizontal organizational structures where collaboration and delegation are featured.  Both write of how important it is to have a workforce that feels a sense of being federated among its members – these writers might use other language to describe this, but this is part of their message.
So, the question is, in the upcoming years, how drastic the needs will be and which of these candidates has the personality and other traits for which the place and times are calling.  I know the nation is suffering from certain problems; I’ve written about them in this blog.
But I think you would agree that they are not of the catastrophic type.  The nation is moving toward a more secure economy and there are no immediate threats from any foreign enemy.  Our biggest threat is that of terrorists and any attack from them will have limited effects.  This is serious but does not pose an existential threat.



[1] Michael A. Roberto, Transformational Leadership:  How Leaders Change Teams, Companies, and Organizations, (Chantilly, VA:  The Great Courses/The Teaching Company, 2011).

[2] Jim Collins, Good to Great:  Why Some Companies Make the Leap … and Others Don't, (New York, NY:  HarperCollins Publishers, Inc, .2001). 

Tuesday, October 18, 2016

AN INVOLVED LIFE

I went to a memorial service the other day for a former next door neighbor.  She was quite the community activist, a former state president of a well-known non-profit organization and was involved in several others.  She died in a local assisted-living facility which she had moved into a few years ago.
The service was well attended and nice things were said.  Whether she heard those things or not – or if we believe she did – is a matter of religious conviction.  What I do know is that we heard those things and it was gratifying.  The room had a glass wall so that we could overlook a forested view, very pleasant.
          I mention this because the topic of my posting today has to do with how rational or reasonable it is to be involved in civic activities.  There are different ways to think about this issue.  How one feels about whether to become involved or not is probably highly dependent on how one views government and politics.
For those of you who have been reading this blog all along, early on, I shared an extended quote from the famous political/social writer of the nineteenth century, Tocqueville.  He describes an American scene in the 1830s when people were eager and enjoyably engaged in conversations and activities that had a strong communal and civic character to them.
Here, there, and all around were people either talking or otherwise engaging in the local, community goings on with pride and a feeling that being so engaged was entertaining.  The tone portrayed a whiff of competitiveness:  who was the best citizen?
It surely was a reflection of a shared sense of duty.  And from our perspective in the twenty-first century, this scene is a source of wonder.  Why?  Why were these people so engaged?  Does it make sense?  Not from our perspective.  And here there is, in true natural rights fashion, a calculation to perform.  To see how this analysis works, let me provide an analogy.
Suppose your daily drives take you past an intersection where there is heavy traffic in every direction.  You are unfortunate on three counts.  One, you have to go through this intersection – there’s no other way to get to where you are going.  Two, there is no traffic light.  And three, your path has a stop sign staring you in the face as you approach the intersection, which causes the traffic to back up quite a bit.
This means you have to inch forward as you wait for your turn to cross the intersection.  This extra inconvenience you deem to be dangerous.  One more bit of information is that you are fairly wealthy and you can afford the cost of a traffic light. 
Should you approach the “traffic” officials and say, “Put in a traffic light; I’ll pay for the damn thing!”?  Or should you go on suffering this daily, headache inducing experience?  What is the reasonable thing to do?
You can probably think of other options, but let us leave it at that.  Here is a “community” situation, one you can improve, but will you?  Should you?  Of course, the reasonable thing is for you not to “buy” a traffic light.  That’s why government buys such things as traffic lights to begin with.  And it is also why most people don’t even get involved with political advocacy or engagement of any sort.
Let me quote Paul Burstein:
[In regard to organizing to meet some communal concern, citizens] aren’t likely to create organizations because of the collective action problem… [O]rganizations attempting to affect policy seek a collective good that will benefit every member.  Because everyone will benefit, whether or not they have done anything to win the collective good, it is rational for everyone to let others do the necessary work.  The result will be little or no collective action.  The same argument holds for individuals:  why try to influence policy when letting others do the work will produce the same benefit?[1]
So, according to this account, not only will you not buy the traffic light, but chances are you will not stir up enough organized effort to get the “traffic” officials to do what it is you think is so desperately needed.
          So what motivated my former next door neighbor to be so involved?  Assuming she didn’t have some mental abnormality – she acted “normal” in every other way – she must have developed an emotional sense that encouraged her to see engagement as either entertaining or fulfilling in some way.
Perhaps there was a religious angle or an intellectual take or some other motivating factor.  The thing is that she had something that most people don’t have.  I think she simply had a strong sense of duty, a sense that as a citizen, she just had certain responsibilities to fulfill.
          Whatever it was, I would bet it had something to do with how she grew up.  I don’t know for sure.  As an educator, I tend to believe schools do make a difference either proactively or from their inactivity in such matters.  She, I like to believe, was exposed to a more active education, one that encouraged her to care about what was happening around her and how others were being affected by the conditions of the time.
This blog has argued that there is an array of social/political problems that schools have, at a minimum, enabled by inaction by not addressing issues, especially if they have a moral aspect to them.  This neglect is caused by many reasons, one of them being that there has not been an acceptable theoretical basis by which to proceed in a more aggressive manner.  Hopefully, this blog is addressing this shortcoming.



[1] Paul Burnstein, American Public Opinion, Advocacy, and Policy in Congress:  What the Public Wants and What It Gets, (New York, NY:  Cambridge University Press, 2014), location 206.

Friday, October 14, 2016

HOW DYSFUNCTIONAL?

We have an election coming up.  Oh, you noticed.  Chances are, and I might be projecting here, you can’t wait for it to be over.  I am a political junkie and I want it to be over.  Somehow, this time around, we seem to be talking about something other than what we have grown accustomed to.
I, in this blog, called Donald Trump a “black swan.”  This was not, at the time, a derogatory term; it just referred to the fact that Trump and what he promised to represent was on no one’s radar.  He was an “unknown, unknown,” at least as a presidential candidate.
          But here we are with less than a month to go and the unfolding of events has become more and more bizarre.  At first, the bizarreness was amusing; not so much anymore.  Things have become ugly.  My personal exposure to this has been what I see on social media such as Facebook and television media.
I understand the level of “unfriending” is up significantly.  People can’t just disagree politically and leave it at that.  It has gotten to the point that one sees those with whom one disagrees as less likeable or even less human.  In my case, if I were to be of such a mind, that would include family members.  This can’t be healthy.
          And what happens after the election?  Does the bipolar nature of our politics become even more so?  Will it become even more impossible for us to congregate in order to hatch out public policy?  It seems that will happen.  To the extent it is already the case, one can determine that it is probably the chief reason the Trump phenomenon occurred in the first place.
          Our political parties, one in particular, has opted for the position that it will not compromise with the other.  Ironically, that particular party boasts that it defends the original intent of our founding fathers.  And yet central to the system our founding fathers left us is one that depends on congregating, collaborating, and compromising (the three c’s).  And it is that party, for political purposes, that has refused to even be seen as compromising, much less doing it.
          But this reflects these politicians’ political situations with their constituents.  Due to the Tea Party and others, any politician who appears soft on the issues these voters think are important is subject to being ousted by a primary challenger, one who promises he/she will not compromise.  The term, “primaried” has been coined to describe the process.  So they “cannot” compromise since their number one objective is to politically survive the next election.
          What is the result?  If one is talking about Congress being unable to arrive at policy decisions, the political system becomes dysfunctional.  By the way, such a reality is a policy in itself, one of inaction.  The problem is that that policy is not what is intended or satisfying anyone.
Early in this blog, I referenced the work of Gabriel Almond and G. Bingham Powell, Jr.[1]  They introduced a theory that described the sort of actions a political system had to accomplish in order to remain healthy and even survive.  The theory is given the name, structural-functionalism, and the things that have to be done are known as functions.  One of the functions the theory identifies is rule making and another is interest aggregation.
          When Congress does not pass laws that are perceived as needed by the electorate – or worse, an issue is not addressed, e. g., job losses due to foreign competition or non-enforcement of trade agreements – the system is not fulfilling the rule making function.  And when a portion of the electorate refuses to compromise, the interest aggregation function is also short-changed.
Here are two basic functions not being fulfilled and, a la Almond and Powell, the system seems to be in serious trouble.  This, according to the theory, can eventually lead to the system collapsing and ceasing to exist.  We’re not there yet, but does the outlook indicate healthier times ahead?  I’m afraid not.  Whoever wins, his or her party, it seems, will have to win all organs of government – the presidency and both chambers of Congress – in order to get things done.
Is it time to give up on our founding fathers’ plan and shift to another one, perhaps a parliamentary system?  If so, I, for one, would be heartbroken.  The entire federalist model, one that grew through our colonial times and was refined through the centuries – is it finally at an end?  “Say it ain’t so.” 



[1] Gabriel Almond and G. Bingham Powell, Jr., Comparative Politics: A Developmental Approach, (Boston, MA: Little, Brown, 1966).

Tuesday, October 11, 2016

A CHALLENGED SETTING

One area of concern relating to change is how national or local educational reform should be.  Since the 1980s, there has been a series of reports by various organizations.  The general gist of these reports has been to cast light on the deficiencies plaguing the nation’s schools.  A message many have taken from these revelations is that the way we are doing things in schools should change.  And one of those changes, perhaps, should be taking a more national approach to education.
What seems to be spurring these concerns are international testing results that continuously find American students not doing as well as students in other countries – countries that, by the way, generally have national educational systems with national curricula.
Of course in the US, we have over fifty educational systems, one for each state and then the territories and the District of Columbia.  The national government’s answer to this state of affairs is to have a core, national curriculum issued by the Federal Department of Education with states having the option to adopt it or ignore it.
Even this more modest level of nationalizing our educational effort has not been without controversy – one can hear the cries that Washington[1] is trying to interfere with a local matter.  It should be pointed out that education is not a delegated power of the central government and therefore, it is a reserved power of the states.  Yet given the degree to which the economy has globalized, there is a certain amount of pressure to nationalize the nation’s school system.
But this has not happened, and given the amount of antagonism any suggestion to nationalize engenders, this is not apt to happen soon.  It would call for a constitutional amendment and that is very difficult to accomplish.  Yet the problem remains.  American students still perform comparatively poorly. 
For quite a few postings, this writer has been reviewing a list of psychological and sociological issues that have an effect on education.  There are fields of study dedicated to these issues and, of course, these postings have been cursory at best.  This posting will be the last of such efforts.
It is dedicated to reviewing some of the general concerns these aforementioned national reports have brought forward as a way to familiarize the general reader as to what the major concerns facing our schools are.
This listing is highlighted by Allan C. Ornstein and Francis P. Hunkins,[2] whose work this blog has repeatedly relied on for much of the information it has brought forth regarding these related issues.  These general findings have been taken from a list of twelve reports; the two most widely noted are A Nation at Risk  and the No Child Left Behind Act.
Both of these reports were issued during conservative presidential administrations (the first, Reagan’s and the second was during George W. Bush’s time in office).  As such, they are both considered conservative documents.  Ironically, while both base their concerns on poor comparative results, they, especially the second, support local efforts and downplay the need to “nationalize” education. 
The second of these two reports is also noted for recommendations of choice and charter schools, suggestions that many see as efforts to dismantle the public school system.[3]  They also are seen as being directed against government efforts, such as in the case of public schools.  The ideological case is that private enterprise works best in providing any consumer service, and education is no exception.
Before beginning the list of issues, this writer wants to point out that he is not taking a position on any of these concerns.  He is just informing the reader that these particular issues are out there and are generating interest and advocacy either one way or the other.  If one were to attempt change in the nation’s schools, he/she would be well served to know what concerns are important to educators.
The first issue is that school curricula are drifting away from requirements that were stable fare some thirty or so years ago.  This writer sees this as evidence of what he has contended often in this blog: that over the last sixty years or so, the nation opted for the natural rights construct as its dominant view of governance and politics.
One can say a shift toward electives in schools is a way the individual can tailor his/her education to reflect personal preferences and life choices.  Instead of a core set of courses that was academic, such as foreign language, mathematics, science, English, and history, there is a slew of electives and remedial courses being offered, at least until recently. 
The experience of the writer is that while electives have been introduced, most school systems have retained four core course requirements for most years of study.  They include math, science, language arts, and social studies.  He prefers social studies to be listed first, but it usually isn’t.
Actually, in more recent years, in an attempt to address this softening, state policy has called for more testing.  Test preparation has become more prevalent and this has cut into the number of electives.  This has led to wide scale instructional plans that call for teachers teaching to the tests.  This has led to shallow, un-reflected content and teachers not being able to delve into meaningful lessons, especially on material not covered by the tests.
The second issue is grade inflation and less homework.  Grade inflation is the general trend toward handing out higher grades for proficiency levels that in the past earned lower grades.  It seems that every time a young person is mentioned in the media for doing something untoward, he/she is identified as an honor student.  The fact is that that designation is more readily handed out, at least compared to past years.
The third issue is the continued progression downward of Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) scores up to the last reported scores in 2014.[4]  For example, the scores in verbal skills dropped about 40 points between 1963 and 1988 and 20 points in mathematics.
The fourth issue is the continuing poor performance of American students compared to students of other industrial countries.  For example, in the 1970s, they ranked last among these countries on nineteen academic tests.  The comparisons have not improved much in the ensuing years.
The fifth issue is that over 20 million Americans test to be functionally illiterate.
The sixth issue is that among the 17-year old population in the US, 13% tested illiterate and those percentages jump significantly for minority students.
The seventh issue is that between the Armed Forces and colleges and universities, millions of dollars are being spent each year to provide remedial courses in basic literacy and math courses.
And the eighth issue is that all these poor indicators cannot be attributed to short-changing the nation’s students in terms of expenditures.  Compared to other countries, the US has low student-teacher ratios and the per student expenditures are second only to Switzerland’s.  More money doesn’t seem to be the answer.
These then are the dominant issues that one must deal with or, at least, be aware of if one wants to delve into instituting change at the school site.  Much of what this writer has provided in this blog tends to point to a sense that what ails American schools is not subject to “silver bullet” solutions.  The sources of these and other problems are varied.
What is needed is a holistic approach that addresses many factors and that many of those factors are cultural in nature.  If that is true, reforming education will be a slow process.  But what this writer would suggest is that that process be done with a commitment for public education.
He fears that many of the proposed solutions have a hidden agenda.  He agrees with Diane Ravitch that the efforts seem to be geared toward undermining the viability of public schools and that, in the long term, will be a de-democratization of the nation’s schools and of its governance and politics.



[1] Of course, our national capital was named for the “father” of our country and first president.  The way the city is disparaged, one wonders if the designation is an honor or not.

[2] Allan Ornstein and Francis P. Hunkins, Curriculum:  Foundations, Principles, and Issues, (Boston, MA:  Allyn and Bacon, 2004).

[3] Diane Ravitch, The Death and Life of the Great American School System:  How Testing and Choice are Undermining Education, (New York, NY:  Basic Books, 2010).

[4] “Fast Facts,” National Center for Education Statistics, accessed October 11, 2016, https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=171 .

Friday, October 7, 2016

BOOM

How does an institution such as education that is conservative by nature survive, much less thrive, in a social reality noted for enormous change?  There is little evidence of it thriving today.  There are pockets of dynamic and interesting developments and innovations but, by all accounts, this common enough institution is suffering from a general lack of successes.
We all generally feel we know this place called school; it’s an institution we deal with for a number of years during our lives – as students and parents of students.  But how well do we know these places?    If you ask the typical person why we have schools, he/she would probably respond that schools are the places we learn things, where we acquire knowledge.
  Yet knowledge is not a stagnant entity; as a matter of fact, we are in the midst of an explosion of knowledge.  There are two areas of concern where this explosion is being palpably felt:  in the fields of technology and of social relations.
          The first of these fields is readily seen.  Warren L. Ziegler makes a few observations on the pace of technological change:  the language of mathematics has added more developments to its arsenal of expressions in the last hundred years than were developed in all of history before 1900; it is anticipated that about half of what we teach engineers today will be passé in ten years, and half of what we teach students today will be no longer truthful or otherwise useful by the time they are in their forties or fifties.[1]  That is a quick turn around and reflects how much new knowledge is being produced.
          Allan C. Ornstein and Francis P. Hunkins attribute a great deal of this explosion to something called “branching.”[2]  That is, specialties are being subdivided and creating areas of study at a greater pace, and within each subspecialty, there are very bright people advancing what is known in ever greater specificity. 
Of course, this causes certain concerns.  One, the more obvious is how do we as a society, generally, and education, more specifically, deal with this increase not only overall, but in such variety?  And two, how do we assist in informing people about developments across various fields?  How do scientists, engineers, and other experts keep up with developments in other branches, much less in other disciplines, that have bearing on their work or interests?  This is daunting in itself.
Now consider what that means to education that is charged with introducing people to those various fields.  One would think that central to such introductions is giving the neophyte a good sense in which direction a particular discipline is headed.  And yet with so much branching, is there a direction?
Curriculum workers, therefore, have the challenge to select meaningfully and viably the knowledge they will include in any given field and determine how they should organize that knowledge, both in what is new and what is not so new.  The disciplines are dynamic entities.
And yet, in the midst of all this change in the one basic “commodity” that education peddles, knowledge, how does it sustain essential areas of knowledge that education must not forget, especially public school education?  It has been argued in this blog – and it is still believed – that the primary responsibility of schools is to prepare young people to be good citizens.
Given that, how do schools maintain a focus on that charge?  Any change agent must hold on and honor that basic responsibility.  And it is in this more socially oriented realm that we are experiencing the second source of great change:  the social dimension and how schooling is expressed politically.
Schools are not the traditional comfort zones they used to be.  From dealing with diversity to the handling of “inconvenient truths” such as global warming and what we now know about race, the beginnings of life, what actually happened historically in our past, all of this is part of the “boom” in knowledge.
And this could prove to be the most challenging aspect of schools as a change target for change agents.  It is in this political environment that he/she will attempt to introduce even newer ideas, goals, functions, and processes.  And yet, given the paucity of successes alluded to above, can we afford not to attempt change?  Given the effort here, one can surmise that the answer being proposed is no.  Hopefully, the reader agrees.




[1] Warren L. Ziegler, Social and Technological Developments, rev. ed., (Syracuse, NY:  Syracuse University Press, 1981).

[2] Allan Ornstein and Francis P. Hunkins, Curriculum:  Foundations, Principles, and Issues, (Boston, MA:  Allyn and Bacon, 2004).

Tuesday, October 4, 2016

P S

Would you judge a person by the size of his/her pancreas?  Silly question?  Then why do so many of us judge others by the color of their skin – just as silly.  If you were to determine what the size of each person’s pancreas was and then categorize them according to size, say three sized categories – small, medium, and large – and then correlate the sizes to other factors such as crime figures, attendance in college, Nobel prizes, etc., for each correlation one of the sized categories would correlate the highest and one would be the lowest.
Is there a cause and effect relationship among those correlations or are they just happenstance occurrences?  Most of us would say they are happenstance.  But suppose for some weird reason(s), people began believing that there was a cause and effect relationship and began treating the negatively or positively affected group in some unusual way. Would that treatment enhance the belief or assuage it?  It would probably enhance it.
So the belief is not one based on biological factors – the genetic factor(s) that cause people to have the size pancreas they have – but the social construct (the shared, made up belief) that says pancreas size (PS) leads to the behaviors one sees and with which one must deal.
          Yes, all of this is silly.  But it reflects a serious problem.  For example, the most glaring example is the historical treatment of African-Americans.  That treatment has led to the conditions that exist today, not the biological factors that cause the different shades of skin color we see.  Here, there is a people who were taken against their will from their homes and enslaved.  Then there were generations upon generations of people enslaved and deemed to be inferior in every way possible.
Upon liberation from slavery, they were subjected to horrendous social conditions and messages that continued the negative stereotypes.  And yet those people today can claim, beyond all the negative treatment, advancement.  Most African-Americans live middle class lives, just like the rest of us.  This is due to their diligence, hard work, and continued hope that things would/will get better.

          One such person made it to the highest office in the land.  But this negative social construct persists and among some, the effects can still be seen in promoting the counterproductive behaviors – on both sides of the racial divide – that further the negativity.  In a shorthand way, this brief piece is an attempt to describe what is meant by saying that race is a social construct, a social construct educators have the responsibility to set straight.