A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Friday, June 25, 2021

ANCIENT INFLUENCES

 

Past postings have made the case that two reasoned traditions affected the thinking of the founding generation of Americans especially among the educated class.  Of course, these perspectives did not just appear in 1787.  They had a history in which one of the traditions stretches all the way back to the earliest English settlers making their way across the Atlantic and the other found its beginning in Europe during the 1700s. 

The first was the Calvinist religious view that promoted a covenant principle – the origin of the federalist thinking that played such a central role in devising the American constitutional framework both at the national and state levels.  The second was the importation of Enlightenment ideas that promoted reasoned, observably based evidence in the pursuit of truth. 

It also introduced the approach summarily described as the social contract (or as Daniel Elazar calls it, social compact) theory.  That is the promotion of a choice option – as opposed to a force or accident option – in the designing and implementing of a constitutional arrangement for a new polity or polities in the case of the US federal union.

But major influences did not stop there.  One other source, according to the Pulitzer Prize winning journalist, Thomas E. Ricks,[1] was the influence from long ago, the classical writings of the ancient Greeks and Romans.  This influence can be easily detected in the writings of the founding fathers. 

One common experience among these founders was the perennialism that characterized their education.  Higher education of the time was securely defined by that curricular philosophy; a philosophy that, to this day. emphasizes the works of the classical scholars from ancient Greece such as Plato, Aristotle, and from ancient Rome such as Cicero.  Ricks begins his presently cited work with,

The classical world was far closer to the makers of the American Revolution and the founders of the United States than it is today … It was present in their lives … Colonial classicism was not just about ideas.  It was part of the culture, a way of looking at the world and a set of values.  The more one looks around early America for the influence of ancient Greek and Roman history and literature, the more one finds.[2]

The influence went beyond academic awe but verged on and surpassed a romantic attachment.

          These founders decorated their abodes with statues of ancient thinkers, designed their public buildings using classical architectural plans, and even named their cities for ancient cities or thinkers – there is Troy or Cicero, for example.

          They were especially taken with the ancient concern for the quality or word, “virtue.”  They saw it as not just what young women should preserve, but as an irreplaceable character trait for public officials to have – an unvirtuous office holder was automatically unworthy of the position and when found out should be removed from any position of trust. 

What did it, virtue, mean in this context?  Simply, that anyone entrusted with public responsibilities – which under a compact-al arrangement meant, to some degree, any citizen – had to put the common good above any private interest.  This served as the cement or some sort of lynchpin upon which a governing system held together.  It also reflects what this blog has offered as a definition for federal liberty, the right to do what one should do.

And this, Ricks claims, served as a binding sense among the founders throughout the Revolutionary period.  One piece of evidence supporting such a claim is that after reviewing some 120,000 documents of that time, – a study Ricks cites – the word “virtue” outnumbers the word “freedom” as virtue appears some six thousand times.

And as one looks closer to the classical influence, one finds by a healthy amounts of references, that the Roman effect, as opposed to the Greek effect, was found to be more practical in their recorded advice over political and governing matters.  The Greeks were not totally dismissed.  They were cited more as background and in that, Sparta took on a more privileged position than Athens.  Athenians were judged to be too factionalized, turbulent, and flighty.

Of special admiration, the founders took a liking to the Roman, Cicero.  By one measure, he was five times the hero that Aristotle was.  And that preference extended to European thinkers, especially the Scottish Enlightenment thinkers such as David Hume and was also noted among the intellectual leaders of the French Revolution.

Of special interest was the reflections American founders bestowed on the downfall of the Roman Republic during the first century BC.  That became those governing factors that the founders zeroed in on in their decisions concerning the various elements of the republican structures they were designing in the late 1700s.

Ricks in his review of that history, informs his readers of the particular names from the Roman experience upon which the founders focused.  The heroes include, of course, Cicero, but also Livy, Plutarch, Sallust, Tacitus.  As villains that one can easily cite were Catiline and Julius Caesar.  And these names were not just familiar to the elites of America but also those of Europe. 

Two English writers of that time, in the late 1700s, Thomas Gordon and John Trenchard, shared their thoughts over that ancient time in their weekly essays, collectively known as the Cato Letters (Cato was a Roman soldier and senator).  Apparently, these writers influenced the debate in America of that time as they were frequently cited by Americans concerning political principles and theory.  The Letters provided initial promotion of such rights as free speech.

At some future point, this blog will pick up on the effects classical literature had on this group of – one can safely characterize – nouveau riche Americans.  This seems relevant to how these founders came about their ideals.  Yes, they were members of that age’s elite class, but they did not inherit their standing from long established family wealth; they were surely not the product of some aristocratic class. 

According to Ricks, of the ninety-nine signers of either the Declaration of Independence or the US Constitution, only eight of them had fathers who attended college.  They, in other words, were for the most part first or second-generation men of means who owed their success to the opportunities America offered.  And in that, one can, to some degree, ascertain they had firsthand knowledge and empathy for the common American of their times.  It also gave them insights as to what truly constituted human nature.



[1] Thomas E. Ricks, First Principles:  What America’s Founders Learned from the Greeks and Romans and How That Shaped Our Country (New York, NY:  HarperCollins Publishers, 2020).

[2] Ibid., 3.

Tuesday, June 22, 2021

A PARTNERSHIP, NOT AN ORGANIC WHOLE

 

If the late 1700s through the early 1800s are known for anything it is for the political disruptions overtaking America and the European continent.  As a foretaste, the Glorious Revolution in Great Britain nearly a hundred years earlier (1688-1689) stirred the demands of non-royals/nobility to have seats at the table of national politics. 

With that, the American experience began by instituting some form of representative governance in its colonial days.  But once there, this movement took on its own steam that ended with the iconic accomplishments of first, independence, and then of a national compact formed among a national people.  This was by no means a smooth development, but one can easily detect various themes building as Americans found their way to a constitutional foundation.

          But in gaining a full appreciation of this development, one can look at the European version and understand how that experience was different.  And there, the attention shifts to France – which this blog already focused on when describing the French collectivist formula, upon which their revolution relied.  A closer look at the Jacobins, the leaders of the French effort, is necessary if one is to gauge how similar yet different the French experience was (with its effects lasting till today) from the American experience.

          As sort of a rule of thumb or a symbolic representation by which each revolution can be represented, one can – without any formality or finality – compare what custom has ascribed to the colors of their respective flags – since both boast of their same tri colors, red, white, and blue (which the French list as blue, white, and red). 

By custom, the American rendition states that red stands for hardiness and valor, white for purity and innocence, and blue for vigilance, perseverance, and justice.[1]  Each is a value or a character trait, elements that each American holds or strives to hold within him/herself.  By contrast, the French version cites that blue represents the nobility, white the clergy (the priests), and the red stands for the bourgeois (and eventually the workers and small farmers).[2] 

This writer, among many, can see that the American form reflects a national union made up of free-willed individuals agreeing to a resulting polity.  On the other hand, the French promote through their symbols, an organic whole made up of types of people who function to meet the needs of that organic whole.  This variance is profound in how each view influenced – and continues to influence – the formulation of the resulting polities.

Daniel Elazar addresses the dissimilarity.[3]  And here the role of the Jacobins is central.  Whereas, similar to the Americans, the French confronted the challenge of devising a democratic formula for governance, they rejected central assumptions Americans grabbed unto in figuring out not only how to form a national structure, but their state structures as well. 

To the French, the American solution was simply too pessimistic about human nature.  They saw the American model as undervaluing the ability of the common man and woman to avoid being corrupted.  Americans made it central to guard not only the corruption of leaders in public office, but also of the people.  For the French, a new set up needed to merely protect against autocratic despotism, but not against popular despotism.

To them, checks and balances merely subverted the “general will,” a central attribute of what they perceived as an organic unity.  They ascribed a general will to constituting the French society and that that handily trumped the relatively insignificant interests of individuals.  Being short of such guarantees for the collective whole was/is tantamount to being anti-democratic.  According to Elazar, such a view of individuals, Americans felt, was subversive of liberty.  He writes,

 

By retaining notions of the organic society, the Jacobins and their revolutionary heirs were forced to rely upon transient majorities to establish consensus or to concentrate power in the hands of an elite that claimed to do the same thing.  The first course invariably led to anarchy and the second to the kind of totalitarian democracy which has become the essence of modern dictatorship.  While the “general will” was undoubtedly a more democratic concept than the “will of the monarch,” in the last analysis it has proved to be no less despotic and usually even more subversive of liberty.[4]

 

And one can see this distinction being played out in both countries, the French went through a string of “republics” before hitting on a lasting formula.  As for the Americans, not all was smooth after the writing of the proposed constitution took place back 1787.

          Central to the argument posed by the Anti-federalists – those who opposed the new constitution in America – was the loss of power the states were to suffer if this new basic law were to be ratified.  And initially, this concern was shared by a majority of the American people.  Along with perceiving the loss of power to this central entity, Americans were concerned with higher taxes (by this far off government), potentially over-powered central government, and, therefore, a loss of liberty.

          Central to their concerns was to fight for the retention of states’ power or rights.  This was ameliorated by the election of Thomas Jefferson in 1800 but would quickly spring to the fore as the nation marched toward the Civil War sixty years later.  And that war did not end that story as the nation maintained the relative power of the states to be relatively more vibrant until the eventual prominence of the central government through the New Deal.  It took a world-wide depression to finally allow the central government to address national problems on an ongoing, institutionalized basis.

            One sign this writer cites as reflecting the basic notion of how undominant federalist values remain is how often these days he hears of states’ rights.  Currently, the principle is being heard concerning voting rights as state legislatures in “red” states have passed or are considering passing new laws to restrict their voting processes. 

The motivation, of course, varies according to the rhetoric of each side of that debate.  Those defending the new laws argue that the laws are meant to protect against unauthorized voting and those against them say they are meant to keep Democratic voters from voting or having their votes count. 

Congress is considering passing a law that would undo the effects of the new or proposed state laws, but with little hope of passing.  Consequently, those who favor the new state laws complain that the federal government is encroaching on states’ rights to run their elections.  This more recent claim has reinserted this issue after not being heard of in decades.  It was a recurring claim until the sixties by mostly southern states and had to do with civil rights – which is not too far off the current debate. 

In both cases, opposition to states exerting their “power” has been perceived as efforts by “states’ rightists” to deprive African Americans of some rights such as voting, or a set of rights of which they have been deprived.  But the point here is to state that this “federalist” argument has not been heard for some time. 

And one cannot help think that both today and in its prior use, these “federalist” arguments amount to being rationalizations utilized to defend unfederated positions.  In both cases one can see the ultimate goal is to deprive citizens of equal standing – such standing being a central federalist value.

Elazar argues that Americans seem to find their way back to true federalist policies.  The road can be long and hazardous, but the destination cannot be denied.  To some extent, this blogger agrees but ultimately in the give and take of daily politics, this nation holds federalist values in the back domains of its collective memory.  Up front, it is the transactional factors that the various players in the political arena hold prominent and bring to bear. 

And with that final thought, this blog will proceed to trace the history of this nation’s political thinking in an episodic fashion now that the reader has been led to the Constitution writing years (and even on to the election of Jefferson as the nation’s third president).  The aim will be to share the various experiences the American republic had prior to the late 1940s to test the assertion that Americans were prominently guided by a federalist view in their governance and politics.



[1] “What Do the Colors of the Flag Mean?,” The American Legion (n.d.), accessed June 21, 2021, https://www.legion.org/flag/questions-answers/91471/what-do-colors-flag-mean .

[2] “Why Is the French Flag Blue, White, Red?,” Institut Linguistque Adenet (n.d.), accessed June 21, 2021, https://www.ila-france.com/blog/why-is-the-french-flag-blue-white-red .

[3] Daniel J. Elazar, “How Federal Is the Constitution? Thoroughly,” in a booklet of readings, Readings for Classes Taught by Professor Elazar, prepared for a National Endowment for the Humanities Institute (conducted in Steamboat Springs, Colorado, 1994), 1-30.

[4] Ibid., 27.

Friday, June 18, 2021

THE COVENANTAL PRINCIPLE CHOICE

 

As the last posting establishes, the American constitutional formula was not to take a collectivist turn.  Perhaps, those Americans were already too individualistic for that sort of solution.  Frankly, this blogger believes it was not even considered as attractive or even as an alternative.  Historically, the American experience occurred before the French Revolution erupted and the French collectivist formulation was issued.  Instead, the American formulation, one that was brewing since the early 1600s, took a covenantal option; first as a religious answer, but shortly thereafter as a secular one.

          Here is how Daniel Elazar describes it,

The covenant idea [through history] passed into early Christianity only after losing its political implications.  Its political sense was restored during the Protestant reformation, particularly by the Protestant groups influenced by Calvin and the Hebrew Bible, the same groups that dominated the political revolutionary movements in Britain and America in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries.  Much of the American reliance upon the covenant principle stems from the attempt of religiously-inspired settlers on these shores to reproduce that kind of covenant in the New World and to build their commonwealths upon it.  The Yankees of New England, the Scots-Irish of the mountains and piedmont from Pennsylvania to Georgia, the Dutch of New York, the Presbyterians, and to a lesser extent, the Quakers and German Sectarians of Pennsylvania and the Middle States were all nurtured in churches constructed on the covenant principle and subscribing to the federal theology as the means for properly delineating the relationship between man and God (and, by extension, between man and man) as revealed by the Bible itself.[1]

But with the influence of the Enlightenment – especially the works of Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau – those ideals were secularized.[2]  Secularization also allowed for covenantal principles to be accepted among other Christian sects – Catholics and Anglicans.  And this Enlightenment effect deserves its own highlighting.

          In this aspect, Elazar betrays his federal roots when he calls the main idea of Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau as not a social contract, but as a social compact.  Both ideas are based on the notion that government derives its powers from the will of the people.  That the people went through some process by which that will is expressed, recorded, and agreed upon to establish a resulting polity is included in both concepts. 

But the distinction between the two terms, compact and contract, has more to do with timing.  That is, a compact is in perpetuity or until its purposes are fulfilled.  A contract is time specific and reliant on its signatories fulfilling the agreement and if one or the other does not, that eradicates the agreement, making it null and void. 

A business agreement is best served by a contract; establishing a government for a nation is best served by a compact in which no matter what an individual or group does, the agreement is still in force.[3]  And in John Locke’s version, with its provisions for natural law, it is amenable to establishing a popular government in that it more fully appreciates covenantal values.  It therefore proved applicable among Americans, relative to the other social contract theories.  Why?  Because their take of Locke’s approach, and hence Elazar’s choice of terms, took on a compact-al formulation.

He claims that the evidence is overwhelming, it describes how the American founders translated the covenant principle so as to establish a governing model for a large land mass and a diverse population.  “The word federal is derived from the Latin foedus which means covenant.”[4]  He then proceeds to provide some of that evidence beginning in 1645’s English Civil War, but here in America, the current use of the term federal, begins to be used in 1777 as the colonies were fighting for their independence.  But its ideas can be first noted in the Mayflower Compact, back 1620.

Subsequent to that with sufficient time to develop, one can find those ideas scattered throughout the founding documents of the various states including the Virginia Bill of Rights (1776), the Vermont Declaration of Independence (1777), and the Constitution of Massachusetts from the pen of John Adams (1779).  One can readily assume that all that agreement did not pop up toward the end of the 1770s without a long serious stream of thinking, discussing, debating, and agreeing over the constitutional issues that evolved among those colonies through the 1600s and 1700s.

And in those discussions one can see recurring principles:

·       Polities are developed by freely formed associations of colonists.

·       Those associations are formed by each motivated colonist with all fellow colonists creating whole entities – a colonial polity – while respecting the individual and his/her integrity within a truly vibrant governmental body.

·       In that wholeness, it is governed by self-made laws that strive to attain and maintain the common good – its ultimate value. 

·       And that that arrangement demands a law-making process by which all have equal voice and laws are impartially interpreted and administered.

These principles, it turns out, proved to have staying power as first the colonial polities were formed, then while a national polity was formed, and onward as settlers made their way to the Pacific coast taking these constitutional ideas and ideals with them.

          And in that, the evidence includes that each of the remaining thirty-seven states’ governments was formulated by a “covenant-making” process.  This general process was mirrored in the development of cities and towns.  In the private sector, at least on paper if not genuinely felt, the same basic process was adhered to in the formulation of various organizational structures that followed.

Among those organizations have been corporations, labor unions, professional organizations, scientific and reform societies – they all followed the federal model.  Even hierarchical religions at least gave/give federal organizing attributes supportive rhetoric.  It became part of the American instinct.  That is,

 

… for federalism [it] was extended into most areas of human relationship shaping American notions of individualism, human rights and obligations, Divine expectations, business organization, civic association and church structure as well as their notions of politics … At the same time, [despite some variance on interpretation of federalism] all agreed that the existence of inalienable rights was not an excuse for anarchy just as the existence of ineradicable human passions was not an excuse for tyranny.[5]

 

The next posting will address what the implications were for those who were caught up in the “Age of Revolution” that started with the American experience in seeking their independence from the British.



[1] Daniel J. Elazar, “How Federal Is the Constitution? Thoroughly,” in a booklet of readings, Readings for Classes Taught by Professor Elazar, prepared for a National Endowment for the Humanities Institute (conducted in Steamboat Springs, Colorado, 1994), 1-30, 23.

[2] Ibid.

[3] Of course, the resulting government can enact laws that punish rule breakers.

[4] Daniel J. Elazar, “How Federal Is the Constitution? Thoroughly,” 24.

[5] Ibid., 26.

Tuesday, June 15, 2021

ONE VIEW: THE “GENERAL WILL”

This posting continues this blog’s summary of Daniel Elazar’s general description of the influence that federal theory had on the founding fathers, especially as they devised the governing model that addressed the nation’s vast land mass and its diverse population.  The last posting addressed how this model, if implemented, can prove to be a source of indecision.  That is, in trying to secure the input of all, law making can easily get bogged down and result in either ineffective legislation or in no legislation for a demanding problem. 

          This posting looks at how the constitutional solution the founders devised was both something new and unique, but at the same time extended established norms and modes of governance Americans had grown to accept as preferable.  And in this, one can detect how this nation rejects traditions that were being implemented or promoted by other democratic or semi-democratic arrangements from Europe.  For example, they dismissed notions of a “general will” a la France or an “organic state” a la European monarchies, such as Great Britain.

          This debate as to what America adopted and what it rejected deserves special attention.  The main concern to which this blogger’s attention is drawn has to do with the difference between collective models or principles and federation model or principles.  Early in the history of this blog, in its attempt to describe and explain critical theory, it dedicated a series of postings to the critical theorist, Paulo Freire.  

           One of the end states that theorist aims for, in his book, Pedagogy of the Oppressed, is a condition he calls “communion” – a sort of union between the oppressed and the oppressor.  The idea is that the oppressor discovers his/her humanity by ceasing to be an oppressor.  But the question this blogger asks:  what exactly does that mean?

          This is how this blog answered that question as it relates to education back then,

 

According to Christopher Ferry, it is described or defined as a state in which teachers trust students, accepts them and their limitations as they are, while at the same time work with them to transform reality. [[1]]  In this definition, one can appreciate an overlap between Freire’s ideas and [those] of federation theory.[2]

 

But this alignment with federation theory is somewhat tentative in that it is ascribing its most communal sense to Freire’s idea.  One can easily give it a collective sense which would further classify it as a critical theory idea – a classification more in line with Freire’s general argument or tradition which his writings are judged to be.

          The importance of all this has to do with the implications of collectivist ideals and ideas.  For example, socialism is generally considered a collectivist construct.  As such it degrades the values associated with individualism.  While the “new left” claims to be more moderate on this point, certain developments among current advocates of the new left give one pause.  And here, language distinctions muddle one’s understanding, but the results demand that one has a clear understanding of this difference.

          Both federal values and critical theory values promote a repudiation of extreme individualism and perhaps the difference comes down to one of degrees, but the consequences of those degrees can be significant.  It turns out that if one ushers in high degrees of merger or union to the point individuals’ integrities are diminished, a form of mob mentality seems to take hold. 

One sees this in socialist countries – especially where democratic traditions are lacking – when their assumptions about peoples’ willingness to abandon individual ambitions and profit do not materialize.  Those efforts have, as a result, been degraded and despotic elements have been utilized to secure what regimes might deem as justice.  A form of this has recently been reported as occurring here in the US.

          Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt report that among new left advocates there has been a proclivity to shut down presentations by right wing speakers on American campuses – even claiming that such speech equates to violence.  Now, speech can lead to violence or danger, as in the famous refrain, one doesn’t have the right to yell fire in a crowded theater, but the cases Lukianoff and Haidt share seem too far from such results. 

Attorney General Merrick Garland is quoted in news reports that in America the Justice Department doesn’t investigate hate speech[3] – the exception is when violence occurs, and motivation is an issue.  This tie in with violence can be complicated and what some of these speakers say reflects policies or practices that should be prohibited.  But the readily chosen reaction of either banning of speakers or disallowing the dissemination of written works seems to reflect a collective mindset reaction that one usually associates with autocratic governments. 

And the history of such efforts goes back to the collectivist practices one associates with the various revolutions in Europe.  One being the French and the other the Russian, both in their ways instituted collectivist solutions to governance.  Here is what Elazar writes concerning the “general will” of the French,

 

Other revolutionaries in the “Age of Revolutions” that has existed since the late eighteenth century – most prominent among them the Jacobins – also sought solutions to some of the same problems of despotism that perturbed the Americans.  But, in their efforts to hurry the achievement of the millennium, they rejected what they believed to be the highly pessimistic assumptions of the American constitution-makers that unlimited political power could even corrupt “the people” and considered only the problem of autocratic despotism.  They looked upon federalism and its principles of checks and balances as subversive of the “general will,” their way of expressing a commitment to the organic unity of society, which, like their pre-modern predecessors, they saw as superior to the mere interests of individuals.  They argued that, since their “new society” was to be based on “the general will” as a more democratic principle, any element subversive of its organic unity would be, ipso facto, anti-democratic.[4]

 

The take-away is that this degree in diminishing the importance of individuals has a strong enough track record to give one concern.

That would be as to its ability to protect the rights – not just natural rights, but federal rights – of individual people.  So, for example, in France, it led to the Reign of Terror – an orgy of guillotine executions of political opponents.  Here in America, especially on college campuses, a slew of “witch hunts” that not only has disregarded the rights of free speech but has led to fear among those who would have come to the defense of targeted speakers and writers. 

That is, collectivism has a track record that frankly gives republican advocates serious concern.  The next posting will look at what federation theory’s response to this traditional “organic” problem has been.  While federation theory challenges extreme individualism, it is strongly committed to upholding and advancing the dignity of individuals. 

Their rights, in the eyes of federalists, are sacrosanct within the parameters of the common good which in turn is defined by a constitutional agreement.  And an important part of that common good is for each to feel and act in ways that reflect his/her own integrity and value as a viable, multidimensional person.  Today, there is a campaign to “police” what is taught in American history classes – an effort geared at “white-washing” the racial history of the country.  Among its offensive character, such policing undermines the socialization of vibrant citizens.



[1] See Christopher Ferry, “When the Distressed Teach the Oppressed:  Toward an Understanding of Communion and Commitment” (n.d.) accessed June 11, 2021, https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/268749403.pdf .

[2] Robert Gutierrez, “Review of Freire’s Main Ideas,” Gravitas:  A Voice for Civics Education (June 3, 2011), at present, not available in published form.

[3] For example, Meet the Press, Daily, June 15, 2021 – a news item.

[4] Daniel J. Elazar, “How Federal Is the Constitution? Thoroughly,” in a booklet of readings, Readings for Classes Taught by Professor Elazar, prepared for a National Endowment for the Humanities Institute (conducted in Steamboat Springs, Colorado, 1994), 1-30, 27.

Friday, June 11, 2021

FROM DIVISION TO INACTION

 

In continuing with the topic of the last posting, this one further shares Daniel Elazar’s review[1] of the obstacles the founding fathers faced.  That is developing a national governing model that remained true to their collective bias for republican / federalist values.  In short, the obstacles were a vast land mass and a diverse populous.  The history of such efforts seemed to always count on despotic rule to provide effective governance.

          Of any hope, at least as one studied the situation, was to either follow the model of Great Britain which was a single unified polity but that honored the diversity of the governing population or to establish a loose confederation of independent / sovereign states united only for purposes of mutual defense and foreign relations. 

The latter option was looked upon dubiously out a fear that it could degrade from inadequate rule even in terms of foreign relations.  And, as mentioned in the previous posting, the unified option – a la Napoleon and France – was popular among the military.  One of its “sons,” though, Alexander Hamilton would argue for a constitutional monarchy – a la the British model – at the Constitutional Convention.  Instead, the founders first chose the second option, the loose arrangement, by adopting the Articles of Confederation and in a few years determined that that was an unworkable model.

One thing the founders learned was that the “loose” option only led to elite factions undermining the liberties of sizable numbers within the political landscapes of the various states.  Those who represented these factions – one can by implication count Patrick Henry in Virginia – maintained their staunch support of this option.  Later, they will make up the Anti-Federalist contingency during the debate over the ratification of the federal constitution.

So, what was chosen – option one or option two?  Neither.  The founders instead invented yet another option.  They first acknowledged that a single nation had evolved in the years since the first settlers made their way to North America.  Two wars and common challenges cooked up this resulting American people. 

That meant that a sufficient common culture and way of being existed, albeit barely, to create a single polity.  But there was enough distinction among the states to not ignore the diversity that existed.  And their steadfast determination to not cater to those who advised despotism should not be underestimated in understanding what happened.

If the experiences taught them anything, it taught them that “smallness” did not guarantee a protection from despotic tendencies and even its actuality.  Smallness could be despotic just as well as bigness.  And another lesson learned was that democratic majorities can also be despotic.  Pure majorities can and had overrun the rights of individuals and minorities.  Therefore, they set out to establish a qualified majority rule arrangement.  As Elazar puts it,

 

Pure democracies, in particular, were subject to the sway of passion and hence to the promotion of injustice, and even republics were susceptible if faction was allowed to reign unchecked.  As friends of human liberty and popular government, they felt it necessary to create a political system that would protect the people from despotic governments whether they be large or small, democratic or not.[2]

 

The proposed solution was one of countervailing forces; a federalist model provided such an approach. 

How?  By allocating sufficient powers to various levels so that they could then compete in arenas of vying, opposing interests.  In this way no one faction could control what transpires as these conflicting interests work out their differences in local and national arenas.  Among the resulting balances would be the overall limits on governmental excesses and popular passion.  For example, federalism allowed for national governmental entities to compete with regional (state) governmental entities while maintaining a popular governmental model.

          In short, the founders devised a “republican remedy for republican diseases.”  Was it a centralized remedy or decentralized remedy?  It was a non-centralized one.  That is, the devised system has no central body with sole sovereign power.  Instead, an original shared sovereign approach was instituted with the resulting constitutional instrument the founders developed in 1787. 

Yes, one level, when the chips are down, has final say – that being the national government – but an honest respect for the sovereignty of each level was to be maintained – and it has been.  Students of this innovation gave it a name, “checks and balances,”[3] and civics students learn that this attribute is one of the Constitution’s principles.  And given that within each government there were divided powers, the overall polity was to be set up to deny any element within it too much power, but yet with enough power to meet those responsibilities that element was created to meet.

And this separation of power, writ large, extended to other political institutions such as political parties (with national and state organizational structures) that the founders did not even foresee.  The federal model, therefore, became culturized or institutionalized within the various political entities including private ones such as corporations.  The result is the “infiltration” of federalist principles among the diverse array of institutional elements of the civil society. 

One can look at the arrangements by which the public school system of the nation – that is, the fifty different public-school systems – and how educational policy is issued and implemented.  This does not preclude problems arising from this structure, but that it exists no one can doubt, and no one can ascribe a despotic control over the American educational system.

And the balance sought – one that Americans have frequently asked since – was between bestowing sufficient power, while at the same time ensuring that those with power seek and secure sufficient consent from the various corners of interests regarding proposed policies.  To get something big done, one needs significant consensus among the various factions that make up the American political scene. 

Currently, that is being judged as a challenge in that various problems – e.g., environmental problems – go untreated.  Unfortunately, one can at least suspect that various politicians today do not fully appreciate what is at stake, but perhaps a sufficient number of voters might resolve this inaction.  And again, the prevalence of the natural rights view seems to be an obstacle of no small consequence.

While it often, as the current headlines of today demonstrate, draws criticisms for inaction, it, the federalist arrangement, has protected the American public from a government running roughshod over the nation.  If anything, it is not majorities that seem to have undermined this federalism, but the power of a minority with excessive moneyed assets that seem to have provided a despotic character – not just today but since the development of first a national economy and now a global one.

The model that was devised, though, took significant strides toward ascribing respectful and meaningful allocation of power to the individual factions that existed at the time and since there have been meaningful accommodations to meet the growth of the economy – for example, instituting national programs that attempt to retain more local elements such as Social Security. 

This blogger sees the main threat comes more from cultural elements.  The nation no longer looks to federalist thought in its political calculations, it now looks to the transactional based view of natural rights instead.  Hence, one has the indecisive reaction one sees in how Americans react to the various political challenges of the day.



[1] Daniel J. Elazar, “How Federal Is the Constitution? Thoroughly,” in a booklet of readings, Readings for Classes Taught by Professor Elazar, prepared for a National Endowment for the Humanities Institute (conducted in Steamboat Springs, Colorado, 1994), 1-30.

[2] Ibid., 21.

[3] This blogger has been instructed that the term “balance” did not refer to a weighing scale, but to the mechanism of clocks of those times that slowed down the operations within those clocks to allow for accurate measures of time.  The analogy was just that, to slow down governmental reactions to increase the probabilities of devising prudent policies.