A Crucial Element of Democracy

This is a blog by Robert Gutierrez ...
While often taken for granted, civics education plays a crucial role in a democracy like ours. This Blog is dedicated to enticing its readers into taking an active role in the formulation of the civics curriculum found in their local schools. In order to do this, the Blog is offering a newer way to look at civics education, a newer construct - liberated federalism or federation theory. Daniel Elazar defines federalism as "the mode of political organization that unites separate polities within an overarching political system by distributing power among general and constituent governments in a manner designed to protect the existence and authority of both." It depends on its citizens acting in certain ways which Elazar calls federalism's processes. Federation theory, as applied to civics curriculum, has a set of aims. They are:
*Teach a view of government as a supra federated institution of society in which collective interests of the commonwealth are protected and advanced.
*Teach the philosophical basis of government's role as guardian of the grand partnership of citizens at both levels of individuals and associations of political and social intercourse.
*Convey the need of government to engender levels of support promoting a general sense of obligation and duty toward agreed upon goals and processes aimed at advancing the common betterment.
*Establish and justify a political morality which includes a process to assess whether that morality meets the needs of changing times while holding true to federalist values.
*Emphasize the integrity of the individual both in terms of liberty and equity in which each citizen is a member of a compacted arrangement and whose role is legally, politically, and socially congruent with the spirit of the Bill of Rights.
*Find a balance between a respect for national expertise and an encouragement of local, unsophisticated participation in policy decision-making and implementation.
Your input, as to the content of this Blog, is encouraged through this Blog directly or the Blog's email address: gravitascivics@gmail.com .
NOTE: This blog has led to the publication of a book. The title of that book is TOWARD A FEDERATED NATION: IMPLEMENTING NATIONAL CIVICS STANDARDS and it is available through Amazon in both ebook and paperback versions.

Friday, June 23, 2023

JUDGING LIBERATED FEDERALISM, V

 

This blog, over a great number of past postings, has been presenting a dialectic argument that traces the history of political biases in this nation.  More specifically, it has traced the common view of governance and politics among the population from an original parochial/traditional view to a natural rights view.  Added to that narrative, the blog has described a current challenge to the natural rights view, that being critical theory.  In each case, the blog has presented these views from the perspective of an advocate for each view respectively.

And now, this blogger presents a proposed synthesis, the liberated federalism view, which he promotes.  In this endeavor, it’s time to present this last construct – to describe and explain it.  But before the actual model is described, some of its elements need to be identified.  In doing so, this blog will dedicate several postings to this task, starting with this entry and the ones to follow.

The first element is the covenant or compact.  This element, for the purposes of this model, retains its meaning found in the parochial/traditional perspective,[1]  but because of the current social and political environment, which is encouraged by the natural rights perspective, certain attributes need to be emphasized.

          Unfortunately, the term, covenant, as it is currently used, has become synonymous with the word contract.  But within this model there is a significant difference between the idea of contract, and that of covenant or compact.  Contracts are agreements between or among individuals or groups over limited issues or binding clauses.  Covenant or compacts refer to obligations that:

 

… ought to be seen as more comprehensive and more binding … [It] suggests an indefeasible commitment and a continuing relationship.  The bond is relatively unconditional, relatively indissoluble …

            Covenant is more ambiguous [than contract] … The ensuing obligations are not fully specified in advance; instead, they derive from the nature and history of the relationship.  Respect for parents, nurture of children, civic virtue:  these duties and ideals are neither founded in consent nor created through negotiation [as in the case of contracts].[2]

 

And with this quote, this account will begin to describe what Philip Selznick shares with his readers concerning the various elements that this blogger relates to liberated federalism, the construct under review.[3]

The function of a covenant or compact includes making clear what the fundamental moral attributes and standards are in the union formed by those involved in agreeing to the provisions of such a document.  That is, there is an explicit or implied deference to moral determination beyond individual will, a positive view of the self that can make and keep such commitments, a genuine interest in the welfare of fellow members in the union, and a clear listing of principles for a distinguished and identifiable way of life. 

These notions of a covenant or compact run parallel to those espoused by Daniel Elazar in his writings concerning federalism.[4]  And in this, readers should take note that this rendition of what federalism is does recognize its structural elements – especially in terms of government structure – but the emphasis is more on what Elazar calls its processes – those ways of conducting business which honor the notion of being federated or of being partners with others.

Along with covenant or compact is the next element of this model, which is equality.  Equality, as identified in this nation’s basic national covenant – the Declaration of Independence – which is a foundational document.  It has a strong moral component utilizing both religious and secular thinking.  If nothing else, experience has shown the evil that follows when the moral principles of this hallowed document are disregarded, particularly in relation to ensuing travesties to human dignity and to the conceptions of personhood.

More ambitiously, equality acts to encourage, from a collective or communal state of mind, the formulation of a reflected and felt constitution – a true expression of a people since this principle assures that all need to be on equal standing within the arrangement.  And beyond equality’s role in the formulation of a constitution, the same sense and value motivate the creation and maintenance of a healthy commonwealth that is derived from that constitution.  “Moral equality is the postulate that all persons have the same intrinsic worth.”[5]

Selznick describes this element from two levels:  baseline equality and equal treatment – more on this below.  At either level, equality refers to the belief that despite inequality in talent, wealth, health or other assets, the entailed value calls for equal consideration of all persons’ well-being, that all have an equal right to maintain their dignity and integrity as individual persons.  This ascribed status is given, by this researcher, the title of constitutional integrity.

Constitutional integrity has a normative quality since it reflects a respect for being human beyond the biological aspects of that condition.  Selznick quotes Bernard Williams on this point:

 

That all men are human is, if a tautology, a useful one, serving as a reminder that those who belong anatomically to the species homo sapiens, and can speak a language, use tools, live in societies, can interbreed despite racial differences, etc. are also alike in certain other respects more likely to be forgotten.  These respects are notably the capacity to feel pain, both from immediate physical causes and from various situations represented in perception and thought; and the capacity to feel affection for others and the consequences of this, connected with frustration of this affection, loss of its objects.[6]

 

Factually, the judgment is made from the behavior of humans, that homo sapiens are equal in their ability to make moral choices.  There exist no elite standing in this regard; each is humbled by the leveling attribute; each is subject to moral discretions; each can realize fully his or her own capacities as a person.  These attributes are what lead to meaningful self-respect and a sense of empathy that allows one to reach out to others according to Selznick and, upon reflection, one’s own common sense.

Equality has certain aspects that Selznick uses to further analyze this element.  The first, as indicated above, is what he calls baseline equality.  This aspect refers to the minimal level of equality to which each person is entitled.  It is constitutionally or formally defined.  In the history of the United States, this in turn, has to do with jurisprudential development of the Fourteenth Amendment in regard to its provision of equal protection[7] and, to some degree, the due process provisions.[8]

Of particular concern are the legal entanglements of the fundamental interests of the states, the rights of individuals as they are identified in the Bill of Rights, and the corollary issue of suspect classification (when a group or class is judged to have been subject to discrimination).  That concern suggests two questions:

 

·       Do the actions of the state represent fundamental interests of that government as defined by its police powers, such as public safety, and justify any adverse treatment of individuals?

·       And how do those interests compare to the rights of individuals affected by those actions? 

 

These questions suggest that when situations are targeted against some group or person, what are the countervailing values:  usually the value of equality vs. the value of some legitimate state interest.  In addition, Selznick asks whether individuals who are adversely affected by the actions of the state are members of a group with a history of constitutional abuse being directed against them.

          That writer highlights the effects of history and the relation of individuals to their commonwealth:

 

The constitutional doctrine of equal protection does not ignore or erase differences of talent, achievement, contribution, or good fortune.  It is not a device for leveling gradations or for making society more homogeneous.  It is, however, a path to community.  Equal protection speaks above all to membership, and membership presumes that all who belong share a core identity.  This identity is wholly compatible with rich diversity so long as that diversity does not undermine equality of membership.  The most serious threat to such equality is division based on moral stigma.  Whatever its source, whether it be a certain racial or ethnic origin or level of native intelligence, the effect of moral stigma is to rank some people as intrinsically less worthy than others.  Vindication of moral equality, in the face of strong impulses toward moral hierarchy, is the primary mission of equal protection of the law.[9]

           

Within a community there is the expectation that all members can fully participate or else there can be no meaningful commonwealth.  There is not just an expectation of being protected against abuses of power, but a whole range of duties and rights attached to membership and to the protection of being members. 

While these rights and duties might be bound by limited resources and options, they are what make membership meaningful.  And this line of thought will be further pursued in the following posting as it addresses equal treatment, the other form of equality identified by Selznick.  But before leaving this notion of baseline equality, the term should be held with serious consideration and commitment among the populace of a federated union.



[1] In a few words, covenants or compacts are sacred agreements that usually set up arrangements among people.  Actually, the overall classification is compacts, of which covenants is one type.  Covenants call on God to witness the agreement and compacts, unless they are covenants, do not.  In everyday life, marriage vows are either covenants or regular compacts.  The Declaration of Independence is a covenant; the US Constitution is a compact.

[2] Philip Selznick, The Moral Commonwealth:  Social Theory and the Promise of Community (Berkeley, CA:  University of California Press, 1992), 479-480.

[3] Ibid.

[4] For example, Daniel J. Elazar, “Federal Models of (Civil) Authority,” Journal of Church and State, 33, 2 (March 1, 1991), 231-254 AND Elazar, D. J. (1994). How federal is the Constitution? Thoroughly. In a booklet of readings, Readings for Classes Taught by Professor Elazar (1994), prepared for a National Endowment for the Humanities Institute. Conducted in Steamboat Springs, Colorado, 1-30.

[5] Selznick, The Moral Commonwealth, 483.

[6] Ibid., 483-484.

[7] Mark V. Tushnet, “Equal Protection,” in The Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court, edited by Kermit L. Hall (New York, NY:  Oxford University Press, 1992), 257-259.

[8] Thomas O. Sargentich, “Due Process, Procedural,” in The Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court, edited by Kermit L. Hall (New York, NY:  Oxford University Press, 1992), 236-237 AND Peter C. Hoffer, “Due Process, Substantive,” in The Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court, edited by Kermit L. Hall (New York, NY:  Oxford University Press, 1992), 237-239.

[9] Selznick, The Moral Commonwealth, 489, emphasis in the original.

Tuesday, June 20, 2023

JUDGING LIBERATED FEDERALISM, IV

 

Inquiry suitable for secondary students in the field of political behavior needs to be concerned with the ideal domain of decision making. That would be behaviors at all levels from individuals to national groups.  That is, it needs to account for those elements of one’s thinking concerned with what should be.  The inquiry should include looking at and analyzing what the ideals are, their appropriateness, and the vibrancy in which they are held by political players.

          That study can include asking what the ideals are, why are they held, what moral messages they assume or communicate, and how powerful or transcendent are those ideals.  As such, a model of politics can and should be proposed by the political science community that incorporates ideal concerns when delving into how this domain influences the actions of political actors.

          Is political science completely disengaged from such a concern?  Here is how the discipline is introduced to prospective and new students at Northwestern University:

 

Political science is the study of politics and power from domestic, international, and comparative perspectives. It entails understanding political ideas, ideologies, institutions, policies, processes, and behavior, as well as groups, classes, government, diplomacy, law, strategy, and war. A background in political science is valuable for citizenship and political action, as well as for future careers in government, law, business, media, or public service.[1]

         

While one can detect some peripheral interest in ideals, the topic seems not to be addressed directly – perhaps political philosophy would be more disposed to addressing it.

Obviously, if political action involves the manipulation of power arrangements for the purposes of securing goals and attaining value satisfaction, then everyone is a political actor from time to time.  Such an encompassing model, one that directly and extensively addresses this concern over the ideal domain, was not found by this researcher in political science literature. 

The parochial/traditional federalist model, while concerning itself with political ideals, especially those identified as republican ideals, has been limited in its analytic efforts to describe and explain some idealistic view of what could or should be.[2]  The political systems approach, associated with the natural rights view of governance and politics – and highlighted earlier in this blog – falls short of sufficiently addressing the concerns of the ideal domain. 

Philip Selznick comes close to providing such a model (and many of his insights will be incorporated below), but the description of what he calls communitarian liberalism lacks comprehensive and isomorphic qualities in relation to what is called for here.  Again, the emphasis seems to be on what is and why that reality exists, and little attention is directed to the question revolving around the concern about what should be.

          What is offered in upcoming postings is a model of political activity not necessarily suitable for professional analysis, but viable for the study of government in the nation’s secondary classrooms.  That is, what is being sought here is not to guide the efforts of political scientists, per se, but to guide the efforts of civics educators and the claim here is that their demands significantly part ways from those of political scientists. 

Be that as it may, what this account is offering is a model this blogger calls liberated federalism and the demand here is that it should address sufficiently, if not directly, the ideal domain as well as the real and physiological domains.  Does that mean that this proposed construct can totally ignore the demands of political science study?  Of course, not; it needs to be sufficiently attuned to what that discipline holds as essential in its pursuit of political knowledge, but the ultimate aim or aims of civics educators do differ from that other professional field.

Before providing a description of the elements of a liberated federalism model and the model itself (being the topics of various postings to come), a word should be given to determining the viability of such a model.  This blog will address what conditions this model must address to be a legitimate and a viable foundation for the study of government in the nation’s schools.  Addressing this concern takes on several dimensions.  Eugene J. Meehan[3] provides criteria by which social scientists can judge constructs.

While a curriculum developer and/or implementer of curriculum have different concerns from social scientists, some of Meehan’s ideas can be incorporated into evaluating constructs for the purposes of classroom use.  The following questions suggest themselves from Meehan’s work:

 

·       Does this construct explain as many phenomena as possible as are classified under its concepts and generalizations?  (Does it have scope?)

·       Does this construct control the explanation it is presenting by being valid and complete in its component parts and in the relation between and among those parts?  (Does it have power?)

·       Does this construct specifically and precisely treat its concepts, making them clear in their use?  (Does it have precision?)

·       Does this construct have the same control over the class of situations it is explaining without changing the relations it has established?  That is, does it explain the same way time after time?  (Does it have reliability?)

·       Does the construct contain one-to-one correspondence with that portion of reality it is trying to explain?  (Does it have isomorphism?)

·       Does this construct predict conditions associated with the phenomena in question?  (Does it have predictability?)

·       Does this construct imply ways of controlling the phenomena in question?  (Does it have purpose?)

 

In other words, given the general goal of the liberated federalism model, how does its view of governance and politics match up with the realities of government and serve as a vehicle by which to present that reality, i.e., the structures, functions, and processes involved, including how it is contextualized among all relevant reality?

          But, as pointed out above, this construct is not aimed toward guiding political research by political scientists and other social scientists, but in guiding the efforts of civics teachers in secondary classrooms.  That means that in addition to the above concerns, there are exclusive pedagogic concerns as well.  That fact leads to two more questions.  They are:

 

·       Does this construct facilitate an educator to present its content at such abstraction levels amenable to students being able to comprehend the content?  (Does it have an appropriate abstraction level?)

·       Does this construct allow presentations of the material to students in such ways as to have motivating qualities in its presentation?  (Does it motivate students?)

 

A curriculum, to be viable, must sufficiently be powerful enough in relation to its subject matter[4] and be amenable enough to teenage students – students dealing with all the challenges of adolescence.  A tall order, indeed.

          What follows in the upcoming postings is a report on the way the liberated federalist construct addresses its subject matter.  Later, this blog will address pedagogic issues, but first it will “do” the subject matter.  It is argued in this synthesis that the liberated federalism approach, as will be presented, provides positive responses to the concerns posed by Meehan’s questions. 

What will follow in this blog illustrates that liberated federalism is a viable representation of governance and politics and a legitimate basis, from the demands of the subject matter, to generate the substance for an effective American government and civics curriculum.  The next posting will begin reviewing the elements of the liberated federalism model.



[1] “What Is Political Science,” Department of Political Science/Northwestern University (n.d.), accessed June 19, 2023, https://polisci.northwestern.edu/undergraduate/index.html#:~:text=It%20entails%20understanding%20political%20ideas,law%2C%20strategy%2C%20and%20war.

[2] For example see Andrew Roberts, “The State of Socialism:  A Note on Terminology,” Slavic Review, 63, 2 (Summer 2004), accessed June 18, 2023, https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/slavic-review/article/abs/state-of-socialism-a-note-on-terminology/4C742B00BE0D00ED3F0BE855097DE5F7.

[3] Eugene J. Meehan, Contemporary Political Thought:  A Critical Study (Homewood, IL:  Dorsey Press, 1967).

[4] “Difference between Subject Matter and Content,” Difference Between.net (n.d.), accessed June 17, 2023, http://www.differencebetween.net/miscellaneous/difference-between-subject-matter-and-content/#:~:text=Subject%20matter%20communicates%20ideas%20and,gaining%20from%20the%20knowledge%20imparted.  AND Ralph W. Tyler, Basic Principles of Curriculum and Instruction (Chicago, IL:  The University of Chicago Press, 1949).

Friday, June 16, 2023

JUDGING LIBERATED FEDERALISM, III

 

As of the last posting, this blog was highlighting the role that three mental domains have on decision making, i.e., the domains of the real, ideal, and physiological.  That view of decision making invites a more nuanced and complex basis by which to analyze that mental process.  That is, it is the product of more than immediate perceptions and recognized personal interests, where one engages in considerations that can be and often are quite complex. 

For instance, the choice to act in a certain way might not take place immediately before the act is done and, when the time comes, a change of heart might occur.  This might be a rare occurrence and it would usually be due to some kind of interference, such as a quick change in the situation, how one sees the situation, or an unexpected physical accident of some kind. 

What is important to the assumptions of the liberated federalism construct – what all this concern over decision making is about – is that decisions which result and reflect some ideal domain concern are as important in understanding political behavior as is the decision to act from what people see are the factual elements of a situation.[1]  As with many important aspects of life, political considerations usually carry complicating elements.

          Affecting people in that sort of situation includes several areas of concern.  For example, there has been a growing concern with morality associated with the decisions made by leaders.  First, these decisions will be highly influenced by the environment in which people find themselves.[2]  The natural rights perspective has a notion that individuals are predisposed to make these decisions based on their own analyses of the issues involved and how they affect the decision maker.  As it stands, this is a highly impractical position when the analysis is limited to those factors.

          Why?  For various reasons including the condition that before people understand the importance of making decisions along the lines of political values or social goals, they are inundated with value and goal messages with which they have grown up – their socialization.  These messaging experiences are usually presented by legitimate figures of authority (parents or teachers, for example) and, for the most part, accepted by individuals as “the way things are or should be” and often such “lessons” have staying power.[3]

          But beyond that, to think people are going to put in the time and effort to think of all the relevant factors they need to, in order to arrive at a coherent, logical, and usable decisions or, more generally, develop perspectives of politics or of social reality, irrespective of their immediate interests, is truly unrealistic.  A lot of the aforementioned messaging is stored in a mostly unconscious level of thinking.

Therefore, if the adult world, as presented by parents and teachers, does not provide a set of ideals and an overall construct of political realities (of sufficient complexity), other sources will do so to some extent.  Other sources could possibly include peer groups, in terms of political identification,[4] and mass media.[5]  Of course today there is the influence of social media which is often based on misinformation and salacious content.

          While these sources would not explicitly provide a construct about politics, they influence how people form their basic beliefs, views of reality, and their ideals that people form or accept concerning governance and politics.  That view today, as readily seen on the nightly news reports, would be an anti-intellectual, shallow, and inviable one[6] among significant if not the majority of citizens.  It would be a far cry from the federalist republicanism that characterized the beginnings of the nation.[7]

          Taking a closer look at the ideal domain and how it influences decisions, it contains those messages and desires in the form of values and goals.  They become conscious to people in the form of motivations.[8]  One can deduce from the evidence so far presented that individuals are apt to struggle within themselves as to what is the preferred priority among different desires, especially if conditions make certain optional decisions as mutually exclusive and the options represent different or even opposing desires.

          Choice might mean delaying, postponing, or canceling the quest for certain desires and delaying or eliminating choices that would offer more utility as judged by individuals, or which means fewer negative consequences as measured by standards established in the ideal domain.  Individuals might find real turmoil over deciding between or among challenging desires.  If decisions are made separately from pending realities, and there is a lack of urgency in relation to desired outcomes, then the situations allow more reflective thought.  As such, “thinking ahead” can be very beneficial.

          In less agitated circumstances – say during a classroom discussion – the choices may establish, in high priority areas of concern, more lasting commitments.  These commitments might, in turn, formulate or help develop for individuals the elements of an ideology.  Choices might reflect coherent ideal systems of values and goals.  If these choices are professed strongly by individuals, they, the choices, will be considered seriously in future action decisions.  Here, one can consider this opportunity as experienced in schools as one of schools’ main positive effects.

          These reflected choices can be affected by the socialization processes mentioned above, that people are exposed to, especially during their early years.  These are the years when one is taught the appropriate mores of one’s group.  This process is seen as inevitable.  The question is what set of values and goals people will be exposed to. And a second concern is what opportunities and encouragements they will receive in later life that prompt them to question these basic teachings, for active and engaged citizens should always be disposed to question their beliefs.

          And with that bit of reflection about what goes into decision making, especially those sessions involving decisions relating to governance or politics, that covers what this blogger wished to point out in relation to how federalist ideals and ideas should be treated in civics education.  Therefore, so much for decision making (for now); the next posting will review the main source of content for civics education, that being the discipline of political science.



[1] For readers who did not read the last posting, the reference here is that decision making is very likely to be affected by assumptions the decider makes.  Those assumptions are readily made due to mental states the decider harbors.  To analyze this process, this blog has identified the three domains of thought which potentially come to bear on any decisions made.  Those domains are the real, the ideal, and the physiological.  For more information, see the last posting, “Judging Liberated Federalism, II.”

[2] Work on this concern for moral leadership has been growing since the early 1990s.  See for example “Moral Leadership:  Meaning, Characteristics and Examples,” Harappa, November 2, 2021, accessed June 14, 2023, https://harappa.education/harappa-diaries/moral-leadership/#:~:text=Maximize%20Growth-,What%20Is%20Moral%20Leadership%3F,ethical%20system%20and%20moral%20purpose. AND more in terms to the initial scholarship in this concept, Thomas J. Sergiovanni, Moral Leadership:  Getting to the Heart of School Improvement (San Francisco, CA:  Jossey-Bass Publishers, 1992).

[3] “Influences on Moral Development,” Lumen/Adolescent Psychology (n.d.), accessed June 14, 2023, https://courses.lumenlearning.com/adolescent/chapter/influences-on-moral-development/#:~:text=Moral%20development%20is%20strongly%20influenced,%2C%20emotions%2C%20and%20even%20neurodevelopment. AND C. S. Sunai, “Influence of the Home on Social Studies,” in Handbook of Research on Social Studies Teaching and Learning, edited by James P. Shaver (New York, NY:  MacMillan Publishing Company, 1991), 290-299.

[4] Camila F. S. Campos, Shaun Hargreaves Heap, Fernanda Leite Lopez de Leon, “The Political Influence of Peer Groups:  Experimental Evidence in the Classroom,” Oxford Economic Papers, 69, 4 (October 2017), accessed June 14, 2023, https://academic.oup.com/oep/article/69/4/963/2737463.

[5] Daniel Bergan, Alan Gerber, Dean Karlan, “Effect of Media on Voting Behavior and Political Opinions in the United States,” Innovations for Poverty Action (n.d.), accessed June 14, 2023, https://poverty-action.org/node/6406/pdf.

[6] “Public Highly Critical of State of Political Discourse in the U.S.” Pew Research Center (June 19, 2019), accessed June 14, 2023, https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2019/06/19/public-highly-critical-of-state-of-political-discourse-in-the-u-s/.

[7] Gordon S. Wood, The Creation of the American Republic 1776-1787 (New York, NY: W. W. Norton and Company, 1998).

[8] Sergiovanni, Moral Leadership.

Tuesday, June 13, 2023

JUDGING LIBERATED FEDERALISM, II

 

In terms of the construct, liberated federalism, the first item of interest to this blogger is the assumptions regarding decision making – that would be decision making in the realm of governance and politics.  And in this vein, the duality mentioned in the last posting between forces that either focus political concerns or studies at local communal levels or at national levels will be highlighted shortly in an upcoming posting.  

But before addressing this duality directly, however, some contextualizing needs to be done.  Specifically, factors of decision-making processes need to be fleshed out.  While this posting will only skim the surface of this topic, one might find the path it paves a bit challenging – hopefully readers will enjoy the scenery.

This synthesis of views – which this blog is currently addressing – between natural rights and critical theory is not totally divorced from the nation’s earlier view, parochial federalism, with its more local orientation.  That orientation stands in contrast with a more nationalistic orientation that the natural rights view assumes, and which is prominent today.  Of note, the natural rights view relies heavily on assumptions posed by behavioral sciences and, with that, an important link to decision making becomes relevant. 

Within that behavioral mode of thought, it is worth noting that most decisions that people make are made to advance one’s interests on the margin and the assumption held here is that reality is more complex and that decisions are based on several cognitive domains not adequately addressed by behaviorist analysis.  Therefore, this aspect of natural rights is judged to be wanting. 

While it is beyond the purpose of this account to present a comprehensive model for decision making, the process of making decisions is seen as one in which individuals weigh several motivating factors at any given time.[1]  And so, before explaining the assumptions entailed here with this synthesis, the importance of decision making should be established and somewhat explained.

In terms of considering mental constructs that pertain to guiding how citizens view governance and politics, the question of how and why people decide to act politically as they do seems to be of central importance.  Decision making is a precursor to all actions excluding actions that are classified as reflex reactions.  That is, before people act, they decide to act, i.e., they are motivated to individually act in a certain fashion.  In turn, people’s motivations vary in terms of intensity and direction.[2] 

Therefore, to get a clear understanding of why people act the way they do, one needs to have an explanation of why they have decided to act in a particular fashion; why they have generated the motivation to act in the ways they do.  What follows is how this blogger has broken down this process – part relies heavily on psychological works of well-regarded scholars and part on self-reflection.

To assume people are merely responding to the conditions facing them in such ways as to marginally advance their interests, as crude behaviorists do, leads one to miscalculate various aspects of those decisions.  That is, it might very well underestimate how these actors weigh the values before them or the priorities these actors place on those values, not to mention the personal histories of similar situations people bring to that point in time.[3]  Granted, a lot of this happens at the subconscious level, but it happens, nonetheless.

Those who study these decision-making sessions write about these miscalculations by those who engage in the politics of various challenging situations; for example, the politics of ethnically diverse nations and how “irrational” behaviors there can and at times are judged to be.  Usually, such studies look at segments of those nations’ populations and have often judged them to be chaotic. 

In those cases, which are often like other sorts of decision-making episodes in challenging situations, the chaos originates not from what the minds read to be the facts of the situations in question.  Instead, people misread how their values are engaged and/or miscalculate the strength of their or of others’ values as they pertain to the situations at hand.

And this description of what is going on is not just the opinion of unsophisticated parties but of experts who find it excessively difficult to predict the behaviors of those populations.  What is called for are closer views and understandings both of what mental processes go into decision making and of what such decisions potentially consider; that can be, as hinted above, a large array of complicated notions, beliefs, habits, desires, fears, and complicated memories. 

It turns out, therefore, that there are numerous factors that go into these acts of deciding to act.  One, as the behaviorists argue, are the conditions of the present situation, or at least, what is perceived from the current situation or from extrinsic factors.[4]  For purposes of identification in this discussion, this set of cognitive elements can be called the real domain.  The real domain is constituted by the theories or paradigms one holds about reality, one’s memories, and one’s current perceptions. 

These elements make themselves usually known in a holistic way in that individuals attempt to create congruence among their substantive components.  Usually upon reflection, often in response to a relevant question, people think in terms of individual elements.  Short of that, the sum of these elements constitutes a holistic picture of what is.

Components or elements that do not “fit” substantively; they offend the logical wholeness of the rest and cause internal discomfort known as dissonance.[5]  In this domain there are the recognitions of all the relevant values and goals people have in life as matters of fact.  These elements – while in themselves belonging to the ideal domain (to be explained below) – add vibrance to any dissonance one might feel in each situation.  It can intensify dissonance and when it is experienced, individuals seek and usually arrive at some accommodation so that the dissonance is lessened.

How?  For one, individuals can abandon their related values or goals or rationalize the perceived inconsistencies in question if the situations allow.  Another option is that they can neglect the inconsistencies, or the affected values or goals can be diminished, if only for the time being, in importance.  This last possibility is often an important attribute of that other domain, the aforementioned ideal domain – that is, those beliefs individuals hold concerning what should or should not be.[6] 

In that other ideal mental domain, people harbor those values and goals in some order of priority which is to some degree (usually when they are fairly high in intensity or in relation to other values and goals) are readily recognized and felt by the individuals in question.[7]

Priority listings are supported by emotions and feelings, which in turn are motivating forces within the perceived mental purviews of individuals.  The substantive elements of the ideal domain are products of decisions themselves.  But unlike the decisions to act, these decisions are made without the consequences of such decisions immediately present.  One can, in a moment of reflection, decide to hold in high regard the desire to do some activity but when the opportunity arises, one can think better of that initial decision.

Ideal decision making is done upon reflection of past experiences, socialized lessons, and formed habits.  Most of the literature discusses the formulation of such ideals as those which are formed because of past rewards and punishments.  Some have commented on the role communal settings have played in the formation of ideals and often take on moralistic status and can be described as duties and obligations. 

And usually, the elements of ideals conform with the way they were developed or attained.  For example, technical values are generally acquired in technical environments; loving values tend to be attained in loving relationships.  The substance of the values and goals not only tend to be congruent with each other, but also with their formulation.

That is, they create patterns of dealing with the entailed emotions, the allegiance to sets of mores – this harkens to that delightful book, Habits of the Heart, by Robert Bellah, et al.[8] – and from the first domain, the real domain, their supportive beliefs – the “habits of the mind.”  All this is sensed not as individual components, but with a comfortable, repeatable wholeness within one’s consciousness – “this is just the way I see things,” or “this is just the way I feel about it.”

Another set of motivations or influences on the decision-making process is the physiological factors.  Here, the elements of this set of factors are not intentional on the part of people.  The elements include the genetic makeup of individuals, the changes, through aging, in the chemical compositions of people, and the social reactions to behaviors that such genetic and chemical compositions encourage. 

These factors or motivations are not chosen by individuals but are the product of given conditions that are present in either affected situations that people confront or exist more or less chronically in their biological makeups.[9]  Of course the other factor that affects this domain is accidental occurrences that have negative physical consequences – from a slip and fall to wartime injuries.  People so afflicted may have had life changing experiences that have affected how they see their worlds, which include mental effects on their real and ideal domains.

So, this account will stop here and simply state that decision making sessions are influenced by what occupies people’s minds in the form of what they “see” as the real (either in the present situations or from what they recollect from their past), what they believe should or should not be – their ideal beliefs – and what the mind recognizes are the physiological conditions or limitations that people’s bodies are experiencing. In the next posting, this account will venture into the time space in which decisions are made.



[1] For a lighthearted description of this claim, see “Critical Thinking and Decision-Making:  Why Is It So Hard to Make Decisions?” GCF Global (n.d.), accessed June 10, 2023, https://edu.gcfglobal.org/en/problem-solving-and-decision-making/why-is-it-so-hard-to-make-decisions/1/# AND for a more professional account (involving business related decisions) see Vassundhara Sawhney, “Why Do We Try to Dodge Difficult Decisions?” Ascend (August 19, 2021), accessed June 10, 2023, https://hbr.org/2021/08/why-do-we-try-to-dodge-difficult-decisions AND for a more scholarly account, a bit dated, Steven Pinker, How the Mind Works (New York, NY:  W. W. Norton and Company, 1997).

[2] Robert Slavin, Educational Psychology:  Theory and Practice (London, England:  Pearson, 2022).

[3] This has been studied from various perspectives.  For example, how others influence people’s decision making, see Vanessa K. Bohn, M. Mhdi Roghanizad, and Amy Z. Xu, “Underestimating Our Influence over Others’ Unethical Behavior and Decisions,” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 40, 3, accessed June 10, 2023, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0146167213511825 AND for a more standard account, see Daniel Patrick Moynihan, Pandaemonium:  Ethnicity in International Politics, (New York, NY:  Oxford University Press, 1993).

[4] Slavin, Educational Psychology.

[5] Ibid.

[6] Ibid.

[7] Robert L. Solso, Cognitive Psychology (8th Edition), (Boston, MA:  Allyn and Bacon, 2007).

[8] Robert N. Bellah, Richard Madsen, William M. Sullivan, Ann Swidler, and Steven M. Tipton, Habits of the Heart:  Individualism and Commitment in American Life (New York, NY:  Harper and Row, Publishers, 1985/2007).

[9] For example, Bruce Goldman, “Two Minds:  The Cognitive Differences between Men and Women,” Stanford Medicine Magazine (May 22, 2017) accessed June 10, 2023, https://www.google.com/search?q=recent+review+of+moir+and+jessel+brain+sex&rlz=1C1RXMK_enUS966US966&oq=recent+review+of+moir+and+jessel+brain+sex&aqs=chrome..69i57.20198j1j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8#ip=1 AND Anne Moir and David Jessel, Brain Sex:  The Real Difference between Men and Women (New York, NY:  Dell Publishing, 1989).